|
20th November 1902 The Egremont Mining FatalityResumed InquestThe inquest on the body of William Scott, who was killed at the Falcon Pit last week, was resumed at the Police Station on Monday afternoon, by Mr. Coroner Falcon and the jury, of which Mr. J. J. Wilson was foreman. There were also present: Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. J. Flynn (secretary of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Association), who was present on behalf of the relatives of deceased; Messers. J. B. and H. Adair, engineers of the Wyndham Mining Co.; and Mr. T. H. Brockbank, solicitor, who watched the proceedings on behalf of the Company. Chas. McCarten was the first witness called, and said he resided at No. 5 Rafferty-street, and was a miner engaged under the Wyndham Mining Co. And where is the Falcon Pit? — Witness: At Egremont, the back side of the town. And were you working there on Monday last in company with deceased? — Yes. And who else? — Witness: Thomas Singleton. But there were three of you. Had you a labourer? — Witness: Yes, and there were three other men of us. And is there any particular name for this gang? — Witness: Yes, No. 19. What time did you go down last Monday? — Witness: Six o'clock. The four of you I suppose? — Witness: Yes What time did the accident happen? — Witness: As near as I can say about 12.30 p.m. Then what were you doing at the time? — Witness: I was dressing the place down. How long before had you fired a shot? — Witness: About ten minutes Was that the first shot that morning? — Witness: No, the second. What height is the pillar? — Witness: About fourteen feet What had you on the other side? Was the other side loose? — Witness: Yes How far across might it be from the pillar to the stone side? — Witness: As near as I could say about nine feet. How long has this stone been standing? For some time, has it not? — Witness: Yes. Was it about fourteen feet? — Witness: One foot short of that may be. Was there anything in front of it. Anything to protect it? — Witness: Yes, there were props. How were the props set? They would prop up the roof I suppose? — Witness: Yes. Was there anything against the side? — Witness: There was a lot of loose stone walled up. That is stuff you put in I suppose? — Witness: Yes. How long had the rock where the fall came from been standing? — Witness: As near as I could say a month. Do you do any examining when you go to see if the place is safe? — Witness: We examine every morning. Had there been any fall before? — Witness: Yes, about five weeks since. There had been a slip there before has there? — Witness: Yes. Did that make you examine the place more particularly since? — Witness: We kept an eye on it. Have you any overman to come to see you? — Witness: Yes. Was he in the morning of the accident? — Witness: Yes. He was there about eight o'clock I think. Did he examine around? — Witness: Yes, Scott told me that he had examined all round. I was down below. You say you fired a shot about ten minutes before? — Witness: Yes, on the right hand side. Then do you suppose the shot could effect the other side? — Witness: Yes. Was it a very heavy shot? — Witness: Yes. We used fifteen dynamites. Me and deceased fired the shot. And did you go back? — Witness: Yes, all three of us. Did you get any warning? — Witness: Not the least. It came very suddenly. At that particular time what were you doing? — Witness: Dressing down the right hand side. Where was Scott standing? — Witness: He was standing watching me. He wasn't doing anything then? — Witness: No. Then what first attracted your attention to it? — Witness: I heard a little bit of a knock, and I shouted "Look up." I first looked over my shoulder, and saw deceased fall. How were you able to get away and not him? — Witness: He was standing more under it. What was it that came away, the rock itself? — Witness: Yes, rock. And it struck deceased and he was killed instantly? — Witness: Yes, I believe so. Was it a big fall? — Witness: Not very big. What do you call a big fall? — Witness: It would be about a ton weight. There were two smaller bits came first, and a big lump of rock after. Did it come away by the roof or it was purely side? — Witness: It knocked the prop right out. There was a good roof above our head. You talk about some props supporting the roof. I suppose they supported both the roof and the side? — Witness: Yes. Have you been a miner all your life? — Witness: Yes. Was Scott too? — Witness: Yes. Was there any way you could suggest that a place could have been found out to be bad? — Witness: Not in the least. Was everything done for you, timber and everything? — Witness: We had everything we wanted. I mean so far as you working were concerned. You could not find out any means when this place could have been found out? — Witness: No. Don't you set your own wood? — Witness: Yes. Mr. Leck: I think I understood you to say that you were not in when the overman was in? — Witness: I was down below. Did your mate tell you any instructions he had been given? — Witness: He said he would like the right side nicely in. Is it a custom for the overman to come in every day? — Witness: Yes. Now there was an expression used which the jury will not understand perhaps. You say the stuff came from the back side of the fall? — Witness: Yes, the back side of the fall. The Coroner: Then this prop was apparently not touching the roof? — Witness: It was not. How many props were there knocked out? — Witness: There were two. What kept the prop standing? — Witness: It was fastened at the bottom by stones. What had you for your roof? — Witness: Stone. Mr. Leck: Are all the props touching the rock? — Witness: These two are touching metal. What had you behind the props? — Witness: Check. How much space is there between the top and the pole? — Witness: Four feet. Then I understand from what you say the pieces which came away came from behind? — Witness: It rolled down and knocked the prop out. So that the ground forming the roof is still remaining? — Witness: Yes. Was there anything to keep the props in position? — Witness: We had a wall. There was no stretcher from the top of the prop to the solid side? — Witness: No. Have the props immediately behind you come out? — Witness: No, they are left standing yet. How long have you been working in the kind of ground? — Witness: Backwards and forwards a good bit now. And deceased would have been done quite as much, if not longer? — Witness: Yes. Mr. Flynn: How did you examine this piece of ground? — Witness: We went over it every morning. Did you examine this particular place where the fall took place? — Witness: We could not do so very well. Where the fall took place had never been examined for some time then? — Witness: It would not have been safe. How would it not have been safe? — It is all falling ground behind. Have you no head boards or packing? — Witness: It is packed. You say you could not examine the place where the fall came from? — Witness: We could get up a ladder and look back. But you can't sound it? — Witness: Not very well. Then did the rock come from the fall or from a fault? — Witness: It came from the old fall. He thought the rock would have crushed through. It was a place you could not reach or tell anything about? — Witness: Yes. What distance was it from the fall? — Witness: Eighteen or nineteen feet. If the props had been properly standing and fixed, would it have stopped the rush? A tone is not a great amount? — Witness: I could not really say. If the propping and backing had been sufficient do you think it would have prevented this fall? It would not have had the room to fall? — Witness replied that he could not say. How long have you been working in this place? — Witness: Ten years. Not in this particular working? — Witness: No. How long have you been in this working? — Witness: About nine months. Has a fall ever taken place before? — Witness: About a month ago. Of course the roof was not come in at once? — Witness: No, it's left standing yet. Mr. Leck said it seemed from the witness's statement that the stuff was expected to roll right down and settle there, but in that case it had not done so but had rushed and knocked the prop out. If the props had been up to the top you could have packed it up safely? — Witness: Yes. Mr. Flynn: There is one thing. The witness says you could have averted it had you anticipated any danger, by building the place up? — Witness: We never expected anything. Mr. Leck: Had the fall "chocked" itself up in the top? — Witness: No, not quite. It is not the object of the workings to allow the stuff behind to roll and fill the fall up? — Witness: Yes. It is expected to fall quietly? — Witness: Yes. You were in on the morning when the deputy went down? — Witness: No. You only heard what deceased said? — Witness: Yes. Did none of the other men say anything to you? — Witness: No. We put 15 dynamites in. On the solid side? — Witness: Yes. The Coroner: You had four feet left on the top. You expected it to fall then but not your way? — Witness: Yes. They could not have examined this place without climbing up ladders? Mr. Leck: You are not expected to look behind? — The only point was to make it so that nothing could come forward and rush the workings. Isaac Parker said he was the men's captain under the Wyndham Mining Co., and had been in their employ eleven or twelve years. And you know No. 19 workings? — Witness: Yes. Are you in the habit of going down there daily? — Witness: Yes. Do you go before the men come to work or when they are at work — Witness: When the men are at work? Were you there last Monday? — Witness: Yes, I went down about eight o'clock in the morning. McCarten appears not to have been present when you went down? — Witness: No. Singleton was there. What did you do when you got into the place? — Witness: I told Scott to examine the roof, and he did so. He found there was a piece of bad wood in the roof, and I ordered him to replace it with a good piece. You would not examine the place where the fall took place? — Witness: No I could not. Did you consider leaving four feet space a prudent thing? — Witness: I thought it was quite sufficient from where they were. Have they to pack the place themselves? — Witness: Yes, by themselves. If you had not considered they had enough it was your duty to insist upon more? — Witness: Yes, certainly. I would have made them do it if I thought it required doing. Mr. Leck: All the stuff came from behind? — Witness: Yes, that is the only explanation I can give. The roof is good. Then you have been expecting the stuff to settle down? — Witness: No, not then. I thought it was sufficiently strong to stand, and to keep anything from coming into the workings. The Foreman: Was this the result of the fall a month ago? — Witness: On, no. Mr. Leck: The place referred to before was it blown in or brought in? — Witness: Brought in. Suppose you had any suspicion of any rush what would you have done? — Witness: I should have blown it, and filled up behind. Does anybody examine the place in the morning? — Witness: Two men go down during the night shift, and examine the place. Was Scott what you call a steady, competent workman? — Witness: Yes. Did you call him the leading man in the company? — Witness: Yes. Mr. Flynn: Do you think it would be possible to have prevented this accident by packing the place? — Witness: No. Did you know that there was any danger? — Witness: I never anticipated that there was any danger. It was not possible to examine this place? — Witness: I did not think it necessary. I thought it would fill up in the ordinary way. — The witness said there had been a fall previously. Do you think the present accident was due to that? — Witness replied that he did no think it had anything to do with it. I suppose they had a sufficient supply of timber if they wish? — Witness: Everything they want can be had at a moment's notice. Mr. Leck: When the men go round during night shift have they a method of indicating to the men whether anything wants doing? — Witness: At the entrance to each working there are notice boards on which the men write what is required to be done. Mr. Leck: It would be no use men examining unless the men knew whether the place was safe when they went in the following morning. Mr. Flynn: Have you advocated the use of stays? — Witness: Not at this particular pit. We have them at other places. Mr. Flynn remarked that the majority of accidents seemed to have occurred from side slips, and there seemed to have been an absence of stays in the whole of these cases. If the top of the props in this case was loose, and if the bottom of it was only resting on loose stone, that would not be sufficient to prevent a side rush. Had the props been tested to see if they were properly fastened his idea was that it would have held a ton of ore or a ton of stone. If it had come from a long distance it would have been sufficient but in that particular case it had proved that it had not been. You could have timbered it up if you suspected any danger? — Witness: Yes. But as far as your opinion went everything was perfectly secure? Thomas Singleton stated that he was working in the Falcon Pit, at the time of the accident. And when Parker came in did you see what he did? — Witness: He tapped the roof and said it was all right. Did you see him giving any orders to Scott? — Witness: No, I was filling a bogey at the time. The Coroner, summing up, remarked that they were more accustomed to that kind of thing than himself, but it seemed to him if the cavity had been absolutely filled up to the top, the accident would not have occurred. It could have been averted no doubt for if they had anticipated any danger they would have brought the place down. The manager evidently thought the place was quite safe. It seemed to him to be one of those unforeseen accidents in mining, which seemed very frequently to occur. They seemed to have done everything which could reasonably be expected to be done, and the only verdict would be "Accidental death." The jury returned a verdict accordingly.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||