Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

31st July 1902

Fatal Mining Accident At Egremont

The Adjourned Inquest

On Friday afternoon last the adjourned inquest was held at the Albert Hotel, St. Bees, touching the death of Thomas Richard Ashburner, aged 25, sinker, who was killed while at work at a new pit at Orgill, Egremont, on Thursday the 17th inst. Mr. Gordon Falcon was the coroner.

Mr. Leck, Government Inspector, was present; and Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared for the Wyndham Mining Company.

John S. Noland, examined by the Coroner, said that he was a miner employed by the Wyndham Company and was in the pit at the time of the accident. The kibble was filled by shovelling and generally they put pieces on the top with their hands. They filled the kibble about three inches from the top. Before sending the kibble up he gave a signal to the engineman - he shouted to the banksman, and the banksman gave orders to the engineman. Deceased was standing about two feet on one side of the kibble, and Noland was standing at the other side, perhaps three feet from the kibble. [A plan of the scene of the accident was handed in by Mr. Hubert Adair, engineer for the Wyndham Mining Company.] Deceased was standing immediately under the kibble, during the time it was ascending; he was standing there unconscious of any danger in so standing. If deceased had looked up the shaft he would have seen that he was in danger; in fact, witness had told deceased and the other men that they should not stand under the kibble when it was ascending. They could not hear the kibble travelling at night, but they could see its shadow, during the day time, at the bottom of the pit. Witness had travelled on this kibble when leaving work. The kibble was always examined when it went up, and it was examined before going up on this occasion. He saw nothing until a piece splashed in the water; it did not seem to be very big by the splash it made; it seemed to be about the size of a man's hand. There were a good many pieces of stone in the water. Witness had never seen anything come down the shaft before. The shaft was in as good order as he would wish to see. He had never seen anything sticking to the kibble bottom, but he had seen at other places a sort of fire-clay sticking to. The accident occurred about 11.30 p.m., and deceased died before he was removed from the pit, about 12.30. The casement at the bottom of the pumping-shaft was not broken. After they fired, the place was examined by the man in charge and another man, to see if the slides or anything had been broken. Witness last saw deceased standing with his back to the side of the pit, and deceased was struck on the head by the stone.

In reply to a question by the Inspector, witness said there was a banksman and lad and the engine-driver on the surface. The latter would be in the engine-house; but witness did not think that they could, any of them knock anything down the shaft.

The Inspector: At that time of night you would not have seen anybody loafing around the pit?

Witness said he had not seen anyone. He had seen no tramps, nor anybody else; and he did not know where the stone would come from. Witness was one of the men who escaped at the accident at Ladysmith Pit, Whitehaven. He had been in a few shafts in Africa, and this was the third he had been in since he came back.

The Inspector: You have had considerable experience in sinking?

Witness: Yes. He did not allow the men to stand at the bottom of the shaft. Deceased started work about six weeks ago, and about a fortnight ago he had blood-poisoning in one of his fingers. He went off the club on the day of the accident.

William Little, one of the sinkers, said he was at the bottom of the shaft on Thursday night, the 17th. He went down with the last witness and the deceased. He helped to fill the kibble. It was about four or five inches away in the usual way, and examined to see if anything was on the bottom. A man named John Mellon looked at it before it went up the shaft. Deceased was standing partly under the kibble as it ascended. He heard something go into the water first, and looked up and saw deceased tumbling back. It did not seem to be a big piece. When they loaded the kibble, shovelling, they partly filled it with pieces as big as their hands, that just come in their way. Sometimes they took pieces off, if they thought they were too high. They did not take anything off the top of that particular kibble.

By the Inspector: The last witness was telling them every day that they were not to stand under the kibble. Witness never saw any pieces come down the shaft.

By the Coroner: Seven or eight kibbles had ascended full of water, and nearly as many full of stone. If there had been anything in the shaft, one would have thought it would have been knocked down before.

Edward Glare said he lived at 17, Smithfield, Egremont. He was one of the men employed at the new shaft, and was on duty there as banksman at the time of the accident. He remembered this particular kibble. He always had the doors partly open. This kibble did not come right to the top. He did not hear any jerk or anything. Nothing touched the doors, he was certain of that. There was nothing went down from the top. Before the kibble stopped he heard then shout below. The rope was going at the ordinary rate.

The Coroner: If the rope was going fast and come to a sudden stop it would shake the kibble?

Witness said he did not think it would, because the kibble worked well in the shaft - there was not much room for it to shake. He had no idea how far the rope would be down when he heard the shouts.

By the Inspector: The enginemen took signals from witness; he had to shout to him. He heard them shout from the bottom, and he shouted to the engineman to bend up. When he heard them shout, the kibble was coming up the shaft. When he shouted to the engineman, he meant him to bend up slowly. The engineman stopped the engine. The engine was not stopped before witness shouted "Bend up" a second time. When the kibble was ready, they shouted "Away." Witness shouted "Away" to the engineman. He then heard another shout, and he shouted to the engineman and said "Bend up easy." The engine was stopped, and he saw the engineman looking at his engine, but he did not come out of the engine house. Witness shouted again for him to bend up, and he brought the kibble up easy and it came all right. It was about two or three inches off being filled level with the top. There were pieces somewhat similar to the size of his hand on the top. When he emptied the kibble, he heard that there was a man lamed. When he shouted to the engineman the second time he heard that there was a man lamed below. They put the big pieces in the middle of the kibble, and pieces as big as their hands at the sides.

The Coroner: You would not tell the engineman to bend up easy when the rope was running?

Witness said he often heard then shout, "Bend up easy."

Isaac Hunter, the engine man, said that in regard to this particular kibble, the first signal he got was from the men shouting at the bottom of the shaft. The banksman told him to bend up a little bit. That was his first signal from the banksman. The meaning of that was to give them an opportunity of examining the kibble and steadying it. The next signal was to wind up. He stopped the kibble five feet from the doors. He could not hear anything before he stopped the engine. He reduced the speed of the engine as it approached the top, knowing where it was by an indicator. He could not get the speed off as he expected. He found it easier to stop the engine than to graduate the speed. It was going about three miles an hour. He never before had any occasion to stop the engine. He could not get the speed off the engine as he ought to have done. The same engine was running yet, and there was nothing wrong with it. After he stopped the engine, the banksman shouted to him to bend up. Witness could hear them shout at the bottom before he lifted the kibble. There was no one else about the pit top except the banksman and the young lad who was among the waggons, and John Hellon. These were the only persons about that he saw.

Dr. Calderwood said he saw deceased between eleven and twelve o'clock. His skull was smashed. He must have had a tremendous knock, and the stone must have travelled some distance down the pit.

The Coroner said there was the satisfaction once could tell by the evidence that everything had been done by the Company and every precaution seemed to have been taken. It was quite clear that there was only one place that a man could possibly be injured; and no man should stand under the kibble when the rope was running, and it was the only place where the piece of stone could come from. It must have come down the shaft when the rope was running and the kibble ascending. The question was "How did it fall out?" He must say that he could not believe the banksman, as he was going out of the way as to what he said about the engine. The man said he heard a shout from the bottom when the rope was running. He said he shouted to the engineman, "Bend up." There could not be no "bend up." If the man shouted "Bend up" it was when the kibble was at the bottom. He would never say "bend up" after it was running, and the engineman told them that. The banker said he heard the shouts, and said "bend up" when the ropes were running. It was mere conjecture to think that he heard the shouts before the kibble stopped. It would have made it impossible that the stone had fallen before the engine stopped. The banksman was not correct in saying that he heard shouts before the kibble stopped. It was the only time that the engine had stopped, and the indicator showed the engineman that he was clear at the pit top. At any rate, he knew from the indicator that he was clear from the surface, and not far to shut off his steam. On that particular night the steam would not shut off. The loose kibble, hanging by a chain, would shake when the engine stopped, and the stone drop from the kibble. There was no one who would know the speed the rope was running except the engineman. The stone might come from near the edge. It was quite clear to his (the Coroner's) mind that the stone dropped from the kibble, and what caused it to come from the kibble? There was an excellent need for it to run in.

The jury after a few minutes deliberation returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed by a stone falling down the shaft."

The Coroner: You do not say from the kibble or the shaft?

Mr. Hartley (the foreman): We cannot give any reason why it should have fallen from the kibble, but the jury are quite under the impression that it has fallen from the kibble.

The Coroner: But what caused it to fall you are not able to say.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adair, Hubert    Engineer  
Ashburner, Thomas Richard   25 Sinker  Deceased, Individual Page
Brockbank, T. H.    Solicitor  
Calderwood, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Glare, Edward    Banksman  
Hartley, —    Jury Foreman  
Hunter, Isaac    Engineman  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Little, William    Sinker  
Mellon, John    Miner  
Noland, John S.    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Wyndham (Iron Ore)  Wyndham (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print