|
15th March 1902, Page: 3, Column: 7 Blaenavon Cage DisasterThe InquestOn Saturday Mr. J. B. Walford, coroner, opened the inquiry into the circumstances attending the deaths of the five workmen killed in the cage accident on Tuesday at the Melfraen Colliery, near Blaenavon. He was accompanied by Mr. R. H. A. Davies, coroner of the Crickhowell division, two of the bodies having been conveved to their homes in that district. Mr. E. Coulman, Newport, represented the Blaenavon Company ; Mr. T. S. Edwards, Newport, the relatives of the deceased men and Mr. Smillie, Scotland, one of the deputation from the Miners' Federation of Great Britain, was selected to watch the case for the workmen of the colliery. There were also present Messrs J. S. Martin, H.M. inspector ; Thomas Richards, general secretary South Wales Miners' Federation ; D. H. Hughes, North Wales, deputy from the Federation of Great Britain ; W. Hopkins, Enginemen's Association, Merthyr and J. Manning, miners' agent, Blaina. Mr. P. Williams, general manager of the Blaenavon Company, was also present ; Mr. H. C. Steel, agent, and Superintendent Davies. Mr. Leonard Nicholls was appointed foreman of the jury. Mr. Coulman, at the outset, on behalf of the company, expressed their extreme regret at the occurrence of the lamentable accident, and sincere sympathy with the relatives of the men who had unfortunately lost their lives. The five men killed are Elias T. Griffiths (48), Elias James Griffiths (14), his son, Llanelly ; Edward Stollard (55), and William Stollard (16), father and son and David Phillips (36), of Blaenavon. In the course of evidence of identification, Thomas John Ellis and Edward Fisher stated that the elder Stollard was subject to fainting fits and cramps, the former coming on upon the slightest agitation. Mrs Griffiths, the widow of Elias Griffiths, on going into the witness-box to give evidence, fainted and had to be carried from the court. After the other bodies had been identified, Caradog Davies, certificated manager, said the guide ropes were still in position, and coal had been raised ever since the accident without alteration of the ropes, The square of the cage had been slightly altered at the top corner. There was no indication of the cage having struck anything with the exception that a cramp holding the troughing in the shaft had apparently been struck upwards, and another a few feet higher up had been struck and the brickwork injured. The men who descended in the other cage at the time said there was a slight shaking. So far as witness knew, Stollard was in a good state of health. The wood on the top of the cage was found broken, and splinters were found at the bottom of the shaft. Coroner Walford said there was now evidence that the cage had received a very severe blow. Coroner Davies : How do you account for the wood being broken? — Witness: It must have struck this cramp. In further cross-evamination by Mr. Martin, witness said all the machinery connected with the colliery was working well, and this shaft was only one entrance to the colliery, which was also approached by slopes. In cross-examination by Mr. Smillie, witness said the planking splintered was about an inch and a half thick, and there must have been a vibration of 24in. if the cage struck the cramp as suggested. Christmas James, smith, stated that the ropes, chains, and cages were safe up to the day prior to the accident, and the guide-ropes had not been altered since the accident. By Mr. Martin: The cramp was found turned up after the accident. He could not account for the cage colliding. The cage was only a little out of the square, and there were no marks on the cage. There were no marks in the shaft as of the cage having been frequently striking. He had not known of it striking previously. Isaac Davies, examiner, said he only found one cramp shifted, and there was an abrasion of the brickwork. He could swing the cage himself. At this stage Henry Stollard, son of one of the deceased men, stated that his father suffered from fits, but it was several months since he had been seized last. Caradog Davies, the manager, was recalled. Mr. Martin: Was it easy to swing the cage ? Witness: Not without considerable strain. Say one or two men struggling or causing commotion. Mr. Martin: But we had no commotion yesterday when we swung it. Edwin Rudge, collier, stated that about 2.20 p.m. on Tuesday he and Benjamin Harris, William Young, and John Powell went on the down-cage. Shortly after starting the cage began to swing, and the first unusual occurrence was that he heard something fall. They were travelling down at the ordinary rate, and the cage began to swing more than usual, and went against the side. The cage was stopped before it reached the bottom. Witness had never experienced anything wrong with the cage going up or down, and it did not swing very much. By Mr. Edwards: Witness said the stage struck against the side a few times. By the Coroner: Witness saw no indication of the cages having fouled. Samuel Hughes, hitcher at the bottom, saw the five men killed get into the cage, and the first indication of anything wrong was something falling into the sump, which proved to be the men. Wood also fell into the water. William Cecil, banksman, said that the shaking of the rope at the top attracted his attention. He signalled to the engineman to stop. This was done promptly. Witness thought there was something unusual. It was then discovered what had happened, and the men were drawn up again, and the empty bond went down. Joseph Moore, engineman, said that after the bonds had passed the middle of the shaft he noticed a vibration, and Charles Richards, examiner, gave further evidence of examination of the shaft, whilst Samuel West, fitter, said he had never known any catching or vibration of the cage. The Coroner, in summing up, referred to the suggestions that there was some larking, or that one of the men was taken ill, but they would never know what actually happened on the cage. The jury retired, and upon returning into court Coroner Walford said that they had decided that these five persons met their death by misadventure, and found that the cage by some means collided with the cramp and byat, and subsequently with the shaft, but that there was not sufficient evidence to enable them to find how that was caused. They desired to add a rider by way of a recommendation to officials and others that consideration should be given as to the desirability of having movable gates at each of the openings of the cage, as a safeguard against the men falling out. There were four practical colliers on the jury, and the recommendation which came from them would no doubt have due consideration in the proper quarter. The Funerals The remains of the deceased men were interred on Saturday evening — Edward Stollard and his son Willie at Blaenavon Cemetery ; David Phillips at Blaenavon Churchyard and Elias Griffiths and his son, of Llanelly-hill, near Brynmawr, at Llanelly Parish Churchyard. Large numbers of workmen employed at the Blaenavon Company's collieries attended, and every mark of respect was shown throughout the district.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||