|
2nd January 1902 Inquest On A Millom MinerDeath Results From An Explosion Of DynamiteDelaying Too Long After Firing The HoleOn Friday, an inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital, Millom, touching the death of William James, who on Christmas Day, succumbed to an accident which he met with at the mines, on the 17th inst. Mr. W. T. Lawrence, deputy coroner, attended, there being also present Mr. W. Leck, Government Inspector of Mines. The jurymen were :— Messrs G. Hill (foreman), J. Fawcett, A. H. Taylor, J. Atkinson, E. Dixon, W. Coady, J. Bennett, P. Gregson, E. Griffin, W. Crump, W. Atkinson, and W. Stephenson. The first witness called was Edwin James, brother of the deceased, who said he was an iron ore miner, engaged at the Hodbarrow Mines. The deceased was 31 years of age, and was a married man, with five children, and had been employed as an iron ore miner at Hodbarrow. On the Tuesday, 17th December, witness, his brother, and Charles Batten were working, blowing out some old wood near No. 6 shaft. They were all following their occupation as miners. They had been working three and a half hours, when about 20 minutes to two in the morning, they were engaged in firing five holes, which were charged with dynamite for the purpose of blasting. Two of the holes were on the left hand side, and three on the right hand of the drift. Batten lit two holes and deceased two, one being left to witness. Batten lit the two on the left. Deceased had a bit of difficulty with the second one, but at the time the others had not exploded. Witness could not tell what the matter was. Batten said "Let us clear, Bill," witness and deceased being then close by the fuses. With that they went away as fast as they could. The deceased had to go up a straight drift to get away, and witness and Batten had a corner to turn. The explosion followed after they got about three fathoms away. They only heard three reports, and they went immediately to see deceased, as one of the holes went off sooner than they expected. They found him lying inside a carrier, about 20ft from the hole. He was lying down and he asked to be left alone for a minute or two. They left him, and shortly after went and lifted him up. They asked him if there was anything broke, and he said no. They carried him towards the ladder, leading up out of the pit. He asked for a drink, which was given to him. The deceased said he was not badly hurt, and he would be all right again, and witness did not think that he was badly hurt. With the assistance of others they examined him and found a wound on the right thigh. He was then taken to the top, and to the hospital straight away. Dr. Stoney was sent for about three o'clock, and had been in attendance since. Witness had some conversation with his brother after the accident, but he made no allusion to the cause of the accident in any way. The charges were put in the holes in the ordinary way, such as is usually done in the mine. He was not aware of any printed rules, as he was only a young hand. He had been under his brother's care in the mines for 15 months. His brother took the leading part in the drift. Witness did not take any active part in the charging of the holes. If there were any printed directions deceased would have got them and not witness. He, at all events, had not heard of them. So far as witness could say every care was taken, that is usually done to prevent an accident. Witness was 20 years of age. Cross-examined by Mr. Leck: All the five shots were in timber, there being 17 inches to 18 inches of fuse in each. Deceased and Batten charged the holes. The depth of the holes were 4 inches or 5 inches. They were drilled with an auger in the legs. The fuses were lit with a candle, which was held to it till they spit, and then another one was lit. Before Batten said "We had better clear out," four of the fuses had spit, but he could not speak for the fifth. Witness had about 3ft to go to get round a corner, but the deceased had about 18ft to go. If he had got a couple of yards further than where he was found he would have been safe round the corner. Deceased was bleeding a good deal, but there was no one who understood ambulance about at the time, and the bleeding was not stopped till he was taken to the hospital. Mr. Leck: There are a good many ambulance men at Hodbarrow, but it is evident that more are wanted. Witness said the doctor was in attendance when witness came to the hospital, but that was two hours after. Though only three holes had gone off, they had passed them to get to the deceased. They found that the explosion had blown out some of the fuses. Mr. Leck alluded to a very good rule in the mines, though it was not requisite according to an Act of Parliament, viz., that in case of an accident a companion of the injured man had to immediately proceed for a doctor. The Foreman: Why did not the deceased get quicker into a place of safety? Mr. Leck explained that the rule was for each man to go a different direction to prevent others coming near the explosion. Charles Batten (42) said he had worked at the Hodbarrow Mines nearly 20 years. The deceased was one of witness's workmates. They had been working together in the same places for 18 months. The deceased had been in the mines ever since a boy, but he could not say how many years. He used to take the lead of the drift. There were strict rules in the mine with regard to charging holes, &c., which had been strictly enforced. The Captain usually came down, and told them what to do, though he thought there were also printed rules. There were different ways in lighting the fuse. On the 17th December, they were boring some holes in some old forks about two o'clock or a little after in the morning. The first thing they agreed to do was to shoot five forks out, and put new ones in. Before they shot them, however, they had to put a middle fork in to keep the headtree up. Witness bored four holes, and the deceased came in, and under his directions he bored a hole in a fifth fork. The middle fork was then put in by the deceased and his brother, and witness went and prepared his charges, the deceased charging three holes and witness two. When everything was ready the deceased asked witness if he was ready for firing, and on getting answered in the affirmative he said "Fire away." They all started firing together, the deceased lighting two fuses, witness lighting two, and Edwin James one. Deceased's first hole caught all right, but he had some difficulty with the second one, and witness thought they had been there long enough, as his two holes and Edwin James's had caught all right. After the lapse of ten seconds witness said "Willy, clear out," and with that they all went away together. The deceased went down a straight drift in order to prevent anyone coming that way. He was just on the point of turning round a corner when he was caught. The explosion happened in a few seconds after they left the holes. They heard only three shots, but sometimes in wood shooting, two holes explode together like one report. When they heard nothing of the deceased they went round another way to see if he had a light, and then called out to him. They found him lying down under the carrier, and they gave him a drink of cold tea then and there, and then they got a couple of spiles, and made a pillow of some jackets and laid him down. In reply to a question he said there was no bone broken, but on examination a wound was found in his thigh, and witness suggested that he should be removed to the hospital. They sent a man to fetch a doctor, whilst they were removing him to the hospital, that being the rules of the mines. The doctor was at the hospital soon after they got him up. Cross-examined by Mr. Leck: Five or six holes are at times lit together where there are plenty of men. In fact, one man could do them all. This was the safest method to proceed in loose ground, such as they were shooting, in preference to shooting two holes at a time. The length of the fuse used would be 19½ inches. Deceased had a light when he left. Witness could not say if deceased stumbled or fell, as he was moving away from the holes. He would have to stoop in passing through the drift. It would be half an hour before they went back to the holes. He did not think that there were any ambulance men around. Witness did not see any serious bleeding, and did not think he was seriously injured. They took the deceased out of the mines on an improvised stretcher. Cross-examined by the Foreman: They were not stinted for any length of fuse. They had charged holes in the same place at the commencement of the shift. In reply to a juror, the Inspector said that there was a sufficient length of fuse, but it seemed that they had stopped too long in the place. In reply to another Juror, witness considered that lighting the fuse with candles was the safest method they could employ. Dr. Stoney stated he was called to see the deceased between three and four o'clock on the morning of the 17th. He found the deceased in bed, and on examination of the injuries showed that there were marks above the hip on the right side. The wounds were full of rotten pieces of wood, but none of them were serious except the one above the hip, which was about the size of a five shilling piece, and extended under the flesh five or six inches in either direction. A considerable quantity of rotten wood was taken from the wound, and the deceased complained a good deal of the pain. Witness never liked the look of it after the first 48 hours. It looked very unhealthy, there being a foetid discharge. On the Sunday night he began to complain of symptoms of tetanus, spasms of the muscles of the jaw, sore throat, &c. These symptoms developed, and died from tetanus about 2.30 p.m., on Christmas day. Witness believed that the wound was poisoned by the dirty wood, saturated with dynamite. There was no hope for him after the symptoms of tetanus set in. In fact, witness had little hope for him from the first, especially after the first 48 hours. The deceased had also been seen by Dr. Hudson and Dr. Anderson. In reply to a question from a juryman, Dr. Stoney said that the rendering of first aid by an ambulance man would not have made any difference. Captain Joseph Rich gave evidence on the methods adopted in lighting fuses in the mines, and considered what had been done in this case to be safe. There were rules posted up at the mines with regard to the charging of holes, &c. In summing up, the Coroner said that the evidence had been taken as some considerable length, and they also had the assistance of Mr. Leck, the Inspector of Mines, and he thought they would have as good a grasp of the facts as they could get, and nothing he could say would help to elucidate it. The only thing that struck him when he heard the evidence was that these men made the unfortunate mistake on this occasion of staying too long in the presence of danger. That lost this young man his life. With regard to the place of the accident it seemed that every facility was given for the men to get away, if they used reasonable precaution. It seemed, that in this case, it was simply an accidental occurrence. The jury, after retiring for a short time, returned a verdict of "Accidental death," the Foreman intimating that the jury had come to the unanimous conclusion that this young man met his death by misadventure by remaining in the drift after the fuses had been lit, and this had caused his death, which was purely accidental.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||