6th April 1901, Page: 7, Column: 3
Board Of Trade Prosecution at Blyth
The Carriage Of Pit Timber
At a special meeting of the Blyth Justices, on
Monday, Jorgen Emil Jensen, master of the
Danish sailing ship Pallesen, was charged before
Mr. J. Nixon and Mr. J. H. Nicholson with
having unlawfully carried a deck cargo of heavy
wood goods in an uncovered space on deck.
Mr. Burton (of Watson, Dendy, and Burton), was
for the prosecution, and Mr. Charlton, Blyth,
was for the defence.
Mr. Burton stated that he appeared to prosecute
on behalf of the Board of Trade, under
Section 451 of the Merchant Shipping Act, 1894.
The sailing ship Palesen left New Fairwater on
the 7th March, and arrived at Blyth on the 17th
March. On the following day the vessel was
seen by the surveyor, and, on the report made
by the Customs to the effect that there was a
deck cargo on board, the surveyor went and
examined the deck cargo, and found it consisted
of beech wood. It was made up of 3,050 pieces,
or chocks, and measured 1 foot 10 inches in
length, by 8 inch section. The aggregate of the
pieces was 1,390 cubic feet. The point was that
beech was a heavy wood. The section stipulated
"pitch pine, oak, teak, or any other heavy wood
whatever." Although beech was not mentioned,
it came within the description of a heavy wood,
because the specific weight of beech was in
excess of both pitch pine, mahogany, and teak.
If the Bench decided against him he should have
to ask them to state a case.
Mr. Charlton. Don't terrorise the Bench.
(Laughter.)
William McGregor, Board of Trade Surveyor,
bore out the opening statement.
Mr. Charlton: Do you know that it is common
to allow the carriage of pit wood on deck.
Witness: Light pit wood of certain dimensions
is allowed.
Mr. Charlton: Or uncertain dimensions?
Witness: Pit props of light wood are allowed.
Mr. Charlton: These chocks are sued for pit
props. Do you suggest that there is any danger
in carrying these chocks on deck?
Witness: It is prohibited by Act of Parliament.
The Clerk (Mr. C. Alderson): What is the
use of going into that? It is not for the magistrates
to say whether or not it is a dangerous
cargo.
Witness: In my opinion all deck cargoes are
dangerous.
Mr. Charlton: As compared with pit props,
do you say this is an unsafe cargo?
Witness: You, in my opinion it is.
Mr. Charlton: Is it more dangerous than long
pit props?
Witness: The only point I considered was
that it was prohibited. They were laid along
the deck in three tiers, and the average height
from the deck was 18 inches.
Mr. Charlton: Assuming that the chocks had
been made of pitch pine instead of beech, would
the captain have been within his rights?
Witness: If it had been light wood he would.
Mr. Charlton, for the defence, stated that the
actual value of the freight was £12, and the
penalty to which he was liable was £60. Heavy
woods, he pointed out, were usually received in
large logs, and cut up in the country. Light
wood goods were generally put up abroad, and
brought in this way to the market. The object
of the Act was to protect ships and seamen, and
in considering this case they must take the
spirit of the Act which was intended to apply to
cargoes such as this one, which could be easily
jettisoned in case of danger.
The Bench found there had been an offence
committed, and imposed a fine of 5s for each 100
cubic feet — in all £3 10s, and 12s costs.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Alderson, C. | | Clerk | |
| Burton, — | | Solicitor | |
| Charlton, — | | Solicitor | |
| Dendy, — | | Solicitor | |
| Jensen, Jorgen Emil | | Ship Captain | |
| McGregor, William | | Board of Trade Surveyor | |
| Nicholson, J. H. | | Magistrate | |
| Nixon, J. | | Magistrate | |
| Watson, — | | Solicitor | |