|
1st November 1900 The Fatal Explosion At Mowbray PitAn Error Of JudgmentThe adjourned inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of Thomas Haffie, miner, of Frizington, who was killed at the Mowbray mine, on Friday last, the 19th inst., was held at the Parkside Hotel, Frizington, on Friday morning by Mr. Webster (coroner for the Lordship of Egremont). There were present: Mr. Leck (H.M. Inspector of Mines), Mr. Flynn (secretary of the Miners' Union for the relatives of the deceased), and Mr. F. Hall (for Chas. Cammell & Company). John Magen, miner, who resides at Birks-road, Cleator Moor, said he was employed by Messer's. Cammell & Co., at the Mowbray pit. On Friday last he was in No. 14 working, in company with Thomas Haffie, Thomas Lindsay, and David Bell. They were engaged getting metal. They started at six a.m., and worked until half-past one, when the accident occurred. They charged three holes with dynamite. Lindsay was the head of the working. About a quarter past one Bell and he charged two holes. Haffie had charged a hole in the roof before that time. They said they would fire and Bell went out with some jumpers. Witness told him he need not come back as he would light his hole. Haffie got his lighting stick, and put it up to the fuse, but it would not light. Deceased said "Jack you had better light your two holes as thy're wet, they might miss. Then we will come back and run this one." Witness lit the two holes as directed and they went out, and the two holes exploded. They came right back to the working place and deceased brought the lighting stick with him. He held it up, with the candle at the end of it, but the fuse would not burn. Deceased then got on a stage and told witness to hand him a "swab" stick. Witness did so, and the deceased put his candle on the end of it, to light the fuse. Witness got the lighting stick and held out the fuse to him. Deceased put the candle to the fuse but he could not get it to run. Haffie said "To — with this, Jack, we'll go and get the ladder." They then left the working, and witness was taking the ladder down while deceased lit a fresh candle. They returned to the working, and just as they were putting the ladder onto the ledge where the fuse was, the hole exploded, causing injuries to the deceased from which he died soon afterwards. By Mr. Flynn: The holes which deceased had to light were fourteen or fifteen feet from the sole of the working. One of the holes witness had to light was about six feet from the ground, and another at the bottom. These holes were quite handy to get to. While lighting it, deceased would have a good view of the fuse. The lighting stick which deceased used was long enough to reach the hole. It was their opinion at the time that the fuse had not taken fire, and they were not breaking any rules when they went back. He had tested the fuse at times and it was very good. The reason why the fuse did not go off at the first was because, he thought, it had got damp, with the water running down. It had been in the hole for about an hour. Deceased had charged the hole himself. He was an experienced miner. In reply to Mr. Leck, witness said the working would be about fourteen feet wide by sixteen or seventeen high. A tracing showing the scene of the accident was produced by Mr. J. H. Woolcock, civil and mining engineer. The examination of Magen by the Inspector was continued. It was a solid working and did not require timber in the forebreast. They had planks in the stemples to dress the working. It was on this wood that deceased stood when he tried to light the hole with the swab stick, which was about a yard in length. Their first idea was to light the three holes together. Water was running down the face of the working over the fuse. When deceased gave up trying to light the hole witness saw no signs of fire at the fuse. A dry hole was one that points upwards or is dead level. At that time witness had not lit his holes. There was a special rule for the miners that in case of misfiring they shall not return to the working until at least twenty minutes had elapsed. They did not consider this a misfire. They stayed out of the working perhaps over five minutes until the other two holes exploded. Deceased tried about ten minutes to light the hole before they went for the ladder. There was a red glow on the fuse, but it was just like a bit of brown paper burning, and it faded away, so they went for the ladder. They were away for five or six minutes and on returning it exploded. It must have lighted whilst they were out for the ladder, and he thought the fuse had taken fire from the spark which he saw. He made no remark about the spark which he saw, because the fuse did not run while deceased had his candle to it. Haffie was nearer the fuse that witness. Witness did not think that the spark would light the fuse because it was damp. He had been a miner for thirteen years, and Haffie was formerly a deputy at one of Messrs. Cammell's mines. He left that employment to go to Africa. Witness thought him a competent and careful man. The hole was dry but water was running down, making the end of the fuse damp. They had complained of the fuse to the overman, who told them to do so when the fuse was bad. Haffie made no remark about the spark. Once you attempt to light the hole and fail to do so, then it becomes a misfire? — Witness did not agree with this. The Coroner: What do you call a misfire? — When the fuse has split and doesn't explode. Mr. Hall: If the hole wasn't lit, it can't be a misfire. Mr. Leck: When you came up the first time did Haffie take the candle from the hole? — Yes. If they had left the candle near the fuse they would have retired from the working and not returned for twenty minutes or half an hour. Deceased and witness were alone in the working at the time. By the jury (Mr. Telford): They had a foot of fuse out of the hole. They could tell it was damp when the candle was underneath. David Bell, miner, said he was working with the deceased. He left the before the shots were let off. He saw deceased in the working after the accident. He was lying besides the ladder, unconscious. He heard the three shots go off. Deceased was not bleeding much, and died on the way home. In summing up, the Coroner said Magen had given his evidence in a very clear and intelligent manner. He thought it was much to be regretted that the rule referred to above with respect to misfires had not been attended to than appeared to have been the case. There had evidently been an error of judgment on the part of the men. The jury found a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||