|
23rd August 1900 Fatality At William Pit, WhitehavenMr. Gordon Falcon, the coroner concluded his inquiry at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, on Tuesday afternoon, into the circumstances attending the death of Patrick Murray, aged 14, a boy employed at one of the pits of the Whitehaven Colliery, who met his death last Friday. Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared on behalf of the Colliery Company; and Mr. Turner (manager of William Pit), Mr. A. D. Nicholson (H.M. Inspector of coal and metalliferous mines, Carlisle), and Mr. T. P. Martin (secretary of the Cumberland Coalowners' Association) were also present. Mr. Pettigrew, surveyor, put in a plan showing the locality of the accident, in the underground workings of William Pit. The accident, it appears, occurred on an incline down which trains of tubs were sent to the main road to the shaft. To the top of the incline the tubs were brought by horse, and while standing there they were supposed to be securely sprigged to prevent them running down the incline. The deceased was at the bottom of the incline, and was killed by two full tubs that ran away down the brake. The only questions that arose were as to the sufficient spragging of the tubs standing at the top of the brake, and as to the efficiency of a "burr" that was placed in front of the standing tubs. Thomas Cannon, 6, Bransty Villas, Bransty, said he was deputy overman at William Pit, and the high south brake in the Countess District was in his district. He made the usual inspection at three o'clock in the morning, on the day of the accident, and found everything right. He saw Murray about half past five. Murray was a lamp carrier and assistant driver. Witness did not see Murray till the accident happened. Murray was then lying near the corner at the bottom of the brake. He was not conscious. Witness saw two full tubs on end, close by. The road was all right. These full tubs should not have come down the brake without the rope. Standing at the top of the brake, the wheels of the wagons should be sprigged, and have a burr in front of the wheel; and if that was done it was impossible for them to get away. The drivers brought them to the top of the brow with ponies, and then, when they got the sett made up, they let them down with a rope. The brow was between 90 and 100 yards in length, and there would be seven or eight yards at the top, on the flat, and the incline above that was very little. Murray as far as witness knew, had only been working there about three weeks. The other young man, Woodman, had been working there some time, and was accustomed to this kind of work. Witness always insisted on the sprigging of the wagons, when he was there. By a Juryman: The burr was an efficient one. It was a piece of wood set in front of the wagon, with one end against a sleeper. By the Inspector: For several weeks they had been using a loose piece of wood as a burr. On the other set of rails there was cross bar used, which was more of a fixture. The bar on the other rails had got out of order, and they tried a piece of wood, and found it effective. The Inspector said it might have been effective when the wagon was close up to it, but it was evident it had not been effective in this case. The Coroner said if the wagon was at a little distance from it, and something drove the wagon suddenly forward, unless the wood was set exactly at a proper angle, it would be knocked out and would fail to stop the wagon. The Inspector asked witness if he did not think such a burr was a very primitive arrangement? Witness said it had been often tried, and it answered the purpose. The Inspector said it was no use unless the tubs were lowered down against it. In the other case, the fixed burr could be put across before the tubs were lowered down. A Juryman said the lowering down was left in the hands of the lad. Thomas Woodman, 14, Plumblands Lane, said that on the morning of the accident he was driver in the high south brake in the Countess District. That was not his regular place; but he had been there seven or eight times. He went there at midnight before the accident, and all the time he was bringing out tubs to the brake top. He had a boy named McGuiness with him. They had one horse, and there were the two of them to do this job. One sett of twelve tubs had been sent down the brake that morning, before the accident. After that he brought two tubs to the brake top. Matthew McCourt was there, too; he had gone to assist to put a tub on that had got off the rails. McCourt was there when witness and McGuiness put the two full tubs at the brake top. Witness scotched the tubs up and put a plate in the fore wheel. McCourt put the burr in. Witness saw him do it. The front tub was not chocked up to the burr. It was about a yard off it. The Coroner: Why, if the tubs went up against it, it would not prevent them moving? Witness: Well it did not do so that night. The two wagons were coupled up. Witness then brought two more tubs out. He eased the lockings and let them down about a horse length to the other two tubs. The rails were quite dry at the place. When he let them go they shunted against the other two, and the other two knocked the burr out and went down the brake. The first two went on, but the other two, witness was able to stop. McCourt was with him. McGuiness was at the bottom, to put on the empties. Murray had gone with McGuiness. Witness had never sent any wagons in that way before — not at that brake. The tubs went away with the sprags in. The sprags might be smashed as the tubs went down. There were three sprags and an iron plate in the two that were standing, and the burr waiting within a yard. A Juryman: You must have given them an awful "dunch." By another Juryman: There were six sprags in altogether, in the four tubs. When he let down the last two tubs he loosed the sprags, and they came rather with a bump against the others. The Inspector said that he had tried experiments with tubs on the top of the brake. They took a full tub and set it six yards back, and then let it run down itself. That tub would go at a greater speed than tubs with lockings in, and yet it only moved two standing tubs half a yard. They afterwards tried two lockings in the first tub and none in the second. From the result of the experiments he thought it looked as if the lockings had not been in these four tubs. The Coroner (to witness): When you are only going to have a short sett, don't you leave them further back and not put any lockings in at all? Witness: Oh, no, sir, we always put lockings in. Matthew McCourt said he lived at 33, High Mount Pleasant. He was a collier at the pit. On Friday morning he was called to help get a tub on the line. He set the burr for the first two tubs brought to the top of the brake. He did not put any sprags into the other tubs. The burr was about a yard in front of the tubs. He saw the driver, Woodman, put some sprags in, but he could not say how many. There might be one or two, or more; he did not know how many. He saw him put a plate in, from the left hand side going up. Witness was helping when Woodman brought the other two down. He stopped the horse, and the tubs stood, and witness heard the first two tubs running. Witness took the horse, and Woodman checked the tubs. They went rather fast, but only had about two yards to go before they hit the other two. They were as close up as they could get with the horse. By a juryman: Woodman put his back to the last two tubs and shoved them. Witness did not see him ease the lockings, and could not say how Woodman could push the tubs; he thought Woodman must have eased them. By the Inspector: These two tubs must have had sprags in, or else they would have followed the others. By a Juryman: The boys below could not see the tubs coming. He could not say whether they could hear them. William James Brannan said he lived in Duke Street, and was a miner. He was in his working place in the high south brake district when the accident happened, and one of the lads came in for him. He went to where the two tubs were at the bottom of the road. One end of the tubs was up, but the fore wheels were on the road. Murray was then underneath them. Witness saw an iron plate in the hinder wheel of the second tub. It was in such a position that it would lock the two hind wheels. That would not prevent the tubs travelling. That was the only evidence of scotching that witness saw. Mr. Turner said the gradient was about one in eleven, and with only one wheel sprigged the tubs would travel. Witness, in answer to the Coroner, said he did not see any smashed sprags on the incline. The Coroner said it seemed rather strange that these tubs should have gone away as they did, if they were sprigged in the manner described by Woodman. There could be no question whatever that the iron plate was put in, because it was found, but whether anything else was put in they could not say. They had only the statement of Woodman. One could hardly think that the sprags were put in. If they had been in and had broken when the tubs were coming down the incline, some one would very likely have noticed them. As regards the burr, it seemed to be a very primitive way, indeed, of stopping tubs. If the burr was not placed to a nicety as regards the proper angle, the tub when it came against it must either knock it in or out, one would think; and unless the tub was set straight up against a burr of this description he should think that the odds were that the burr would be more likely to go than to stop the tubs. It might have been that Woodman, having a light sett, did not sprag so heavily as he would have done if he had had a heavy sett. However, there was only Woodman's evidence as to what did take place, and he thoroughly understood his duties. The jury found a verdict of "Accidental death," but thought there should have been a proper burr at the brake top. The Inspector: Mr. Turner intends making alterations. Mr. Turner said this method of stopping tubs was rather primitive, but it had been the custom throughout the colliery. However, he had assured the Inspector on Monday that the method employed in the Midlands would be adopted here forthwith. The Coroner: You will adopt the other principle. Mr. Turner: We will adopt the other principle — yes.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||