Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

5th April 1900

Shocking Fatality at Walkmill Colliery

Boy Kiled And His Father Injured

On Thursday morning, about 6 o'clock, Michael Quinn and Nicholas Quinn proceeded to their work at Walkmill Colliery, the property of the Moresby Colliery Co. They were working together when about 10:30 a.m. a fall of roof took place, partly covering Michael Quinn. He shouted to his son to go for assistance. The son was about to go, when a large stone, 15 feet long, fell from the roof upon him. The father shouted for assistance, knowing that a man named Daniel Christian was in the next working. After calling "Danny" several times, he was answered by another workman named James Johns, who as quickly as possible got the father out and conveyed him to a place of safety. Johns then got further assistance and returned to where the son was covered up, but it was not until half-past one in the afternoon that the large stone was removed. It was then found that the boy, who was 16 years of age, was quite dead, and his body was greatly crushed, his neck and right leg having been broken and his chest stove in. Immediately after the sad occurrence Dr. Castles was in attendance and the father was placed under his care. He also examined the body of the son on it's being recovered, and pronounced life extinct.

The Inquest

Importance Of Systematic Timbering

The inquest on the body of the deceased was held at the Mission Room, Moresby Parks, on Friday morning, by Mr. Webster (coroner for the lordship of Egremont) and a jury, of which Mr. M. Kendall was elected foreman. There were also present:— Mr. Nicholson, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. P. Martin, secretary to the Cumberland Coal Owners Association; and Mr. A. Thom, manager of the colliery.

Michael Quinn, father of the deceased, and whose evidence was taken in his home, said he was a coal hewer, and went to work on Thursday morning, accompanied by his son Nicholas. When they arrived, they saw Henry Lobb, the deputy, who, after looking at their lamps, said the working place required wooding, and said he would send some six-inch wood. That would be about half-past six. Witness and deceased then went to the working place and started to make ready for putting in the wood. Deceased was with him all the time until he went to help bring the wood. Between nine and ten o'clock the wood came down. Witness had two or three tubs of coal lying in the working and deceased proceeded to put the coal into the tubs. Witness was cutting some notches on the side of the coal to get the wood in, when the roof came away together. It knocked witness down first, and also two or three sets of wood. Deceased then ran to the other side of the tub, and witness did not see him after. There were three shifts in that working. Witness had the day shift, P. McCarten the second, and Whiteside the third. Witness followed Whiteside's shift on Thursday morning. Witness had a conversation with him. Whiteside told him that the roof was getting worse, and that he put in a set of wood just before he came out. When witness examined the roof he did not think it was bad. He sounded it all over, except the sides. There was a good deal of pressure on the sole, or bottom, and it heaved a good bit. The working was about twelve feet by six. No fall of roof had taken place before. The working was about sixteen yards from the main road. Witness had been a coalminer for 16 to 17 years, and was well experienced in the work. — By Mr. Cape (a juryman): Between the time of his leaving the deputy and the accident no deputy visited the working. The roof was all stone. There were three sets of four-inch wood in the working when he went down, and three or four sets of six-inch wood came down afterwards. The headtrees were twelve feet long. The headtrees were notched onto the side of the working.

Daniel Christian, a miner employed at the Walkmill Colliery, identified the body. Deceased was a nephew of his. He was a labourer at the pit. The first time witness heard of the accident was about 10:40, and he ran to the working of the deceased. James Jones, witness's mate, told him about it. When they got to the place they found Michael Quinn. He had been removed from the forebreast, and apparently had been crushed. They then looked for the boy and found him under a big stone, which seemed to have come from the roof. Witness sent for assistance to have the body removed. By Mr. Nicholson: Witness's working would be about 15 yards from the working of deceased.

James Jones who said he was a "tradesman miner," said he was working near to the deceased and his father, when he heard Michael Quinn call out "Danny, Danny." Witness went into the working and asked "Michael, where are you at?" and he answered, "Is that you, Jimmy? Come on fast." Witness went to the man and lifted the stone off his shoulder and arms. When witness got him clear, he took Quinn to a place of safety, and ran for Christian. They both returned to the working and looked for the lad. Christian saw the boy's head, and witness went for more assistance. He afterwards returned, and then got deceased free. He was quite dead then. Witness had had been a miner for 18 years. He had only seen the working of the deceased twice. It seemed a decent, safe sort of working. — By the jury: He saw one lot of timber broken. — By Mr. Nicholson: The timber had been broken by the fall of stone.

Henry Lobb, deputy overman at Walkmill Colliery, said on Wednesday night, he went to work, at ten o'clock. He visited the working of the deceased on Thursday morning, between four and five o'clock. He had previously spoken to James Milner, another deputy, but he had only mentioned about putting up a bit of brattice. When he examined the working place, he found the roof strong. He sounded it with a hammer. He noticed that at one end there was a "nick" coming in at the side, and witness insisted on the man who was working there putting some timber up. When that was properly done, witness left the working. About half-an-hour later he saw Michael Quinn, and witness told him he was not to take out much coal until he put another headtree up. Two or three tubs would be sufficient to take out before a headtree was put in. Witness visited the working last night, and found that the headtree he had been put up and the one beside it had been knocked down by the fall. The headtree witness put in was broken about the middle, and the other was broken in a similar manner. There would be a distance of about 3ft. 6in. between the headtree witness put in and the other one. Michael Quinn had not succeeded in putting a headtree up. The headtree was tight up to the roof. The stone, which fell, had a slape side where it came from the roof. He considered the working place was safe, provided the men did what he advised. Quinn was a steady, sober, and industrious man. — By Mr. Nicholson: The wood he was using was about 4½ inches thick. He considered it was strong enough to keep the stone up, but afterwards he got six-inch wood for it. Formerly the roof was bad, and they timbered it closely, but they considered that the roof had grown stronger. There were no props for a space of seventeen feet under the stone, which was considered safe.

Mr. Nicholson: That is the best illustration I have had yet, showing the importance of using timber systematically. In this case the roof was bad, and they had plenty of bars in right across the place. As soon as the roof gets a little better, they relax that caution, and down comes the stone. You could not have a better example of the importance of systematically timbering a working. In this case the man relies on is judgement in "jarling" the stone, and he has been taken in, as anyone else would have been taken in.

The Coroner: The roof may be unsound and very safe, notwithstanding that you get a good sound.

Mr. Nicholson said that was just what they wanted to guard against by putting timber in systematically. Ninety per cent of these falls were in connection with slips.

By Mr. Martin: Witness said as soon as he noticed the slip he put the bar across.

The Coroner: I am really glad Mr. Nicholson has made the remarks he has.

Mr. Martin replied that systematic timbering was not enforced.

The Coroner: But for your own sake and the sake of the men, you can see how necessary it is.

Mr. Martin: What I want to show is that every precaution is taken.

The Coroner: Apparently the deputy depended entirely upon his hearing, which is treacherous, to say the least of it.

Mr. Martin: He was trusting to his judgment.

The Coroner: Supposing the inspector had been there it would not have happened.

Mr. Martin: I don't know about that. I think it would.

The Coroner: He says you can't depend on the roof being sound by simply "jarling." If the wood had been continual from the inlet to the working up to the forebreast, the probability is that the accident would not have occurred.

Mr. Martin: But what I want to show is that there was no indication whatever of it being a dangerous place.

The Coroner: You must guard against contingencies.

Mr. Martin: We did.

The Coroner: I can't agree with you, but I agree with the inspector.

Mr. Martin: What I want to ask the witness is "Was there any indication of danger?"

The Coroner: He says not. There was none, because he did not put the prop in.

Witness: I never saw any slip except what I have said.

The Coroner: Supposing the place had been wooded from the entrance to the working place to the forebreast, would the accident have happened?

Witness: Probably not.

The Coroner said that, unfortunately, the deceased's father had not time to get the props in. He did what he was told; so don't let that reflect upon him.

Mr. Martin: Of course it is very easy to be wise after the event.

The Coroner: Yes, but the inspector thinks the timbering ought to have been done first.

Mr. Nicholson asked witness if he thought all precautions were taken, when he let a space of 17 feet go without a prop.

Witness: I think so.

This was all the evidence called, and the Coroner summed up. He said that the stone came away, while Quinn was obeying the orders given by the deputy, from the very place the overman suspected was dangerous. Quinn himself escaped with not very much injury, but his son was killed. The deputy was of opinion that the roof was sound, hard, and good, but that only showed how men were apt to neglect precautions, which would, in many instances prevent accidents. They had heard what the Inspector had said, and the probability was that if this part of the working had been timbered in the same way as the entrance to the working, the accident would not have occurred. However, there was no doubt that the deputy had acted to the best of his judgment and knowledge, and he ought not to be found blameable because is judgement was not good. He did not think there was any such neglect on the part of the officials of the mine to come to the conclusion that there was any criminal negligence on their part. No man should be blamed for an error of judgement, and the deputy had given his evidence in a very straightforward manner, indeed.

The jury found a verdict of "Accidental death," but recommended that in the future more use should be made of timber in cases of this description.

The Coroner said Mr. Nicholson had been in communication with the Home Office on the subject of systematic timbering, but they could not divulge anything. He had no doubt that Mr. Thom, the manager of the pit, would appreciate all that had been said.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Cape, —    Juror  
Castles, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Christian, Daniel    Miner  
Jones, James    Miner  
Kendall, M.    Jury Foreman  
Lobb, Henry    Deputy  
Martin, Thomas Pattinson    Cumberland Coal Owners Association  Whos Who Page
McCarten, P.    Miner  
Milner, James    Deputy  
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Quinn, Michael    Miner  Father
Quinn, Nicholas   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Thom, Archibald    Manager  Whos Who Page
Webster, John    Coroner  
Whiteside, —    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Walkmill Colliery  Walkmill Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
Mar 1900  A Sad Fatality at Walk Mill Colliery, Son Killed and Father Injured (Whitehaven News)
19 Mar 1900  A Sad Fatality At Walk Mill Colliery, Son Killed And Father Injured (Whitehaven News)
05 Apr 1900  Shocking Fatality at Walkmill Colliery, Boy Kiled And His Father Injured (Cumberland Pacquet)
05 Apr 1900  Son Killed And Father Injured (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Walkmill
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print