|
7th February 1900 The Explosion Of Gas In Oatlands PitHow The Explosion OccurredEvidence Of The Injured Man, HindOn Friday afternoon last, Mr. Gordon Falcon, coroner for West Cumberland, held the adjourned inquiry at the Whitehaven Infirmary, touching the death of Thomas Kavanagh, who was injured by an explosion of gas at Oatlands Pit, on the 3rd of December last. The inquiry had been four times adjourned. Mr. Hedley, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines; Mr. Nicholson, H.M. assistant Inspector, were present. Mr. W. H. Chapman represented the Moresby Coal Company; Mr. Thom, manager for the Company, was also present. Mr. J. Waugh was foeman of the jury. A witness called MacDonald was called and his evidence already reported, was read over to him by the Coroner, which the witness stated to be correct. By Mr. Hedley: Where did you find the gas? — We did not find any gas, sir. I mean some time before? — It was there about a fortnight before as near as I can tell you, just in where we put a brick arch up. It was my first shift in the working when they put the arch there. Was this in the same place as the accident happened? — In the same drift but a bit further forward. Can you tell us how often you have seen gas there? — I never saw any gas there but that night. Were you working with safety lamps or what? — With safety lamps. Had you seen the place just before the shot was fired? — Yes, Hind sent me away with a tub of metal, and deceased went for the charge. And he charged it with what? — Dynamite was the explosive they used. Can you say what explosive was being used at he time? — No, sir. I was not there at the time. But they used dynamite? — Yes; they had never anything else in their boxes. I can say that. If I have to suggest to you gelatine — is it called by that name? — I cannot answer that question. I have had no experience with these things. From the time you went away from these men how much time would have elapsed — how long do you think you would have been gone before they set to work to fire this shot? — From ten minutes to a quarter of an hour. How far were you off when the accident happened? — Somewhere about 100 yards. That would be in the drift itself? — All on one pitch. Did you feel any effects from this explosion? — Nothing particular. There might be a little extra explosion, but nothing on what they could pass any remarks. Well we take it that you felt something had gone wrong? — I could not say that it did. Was everything done in the ordinary course, and had the usual practice been carried out in this affair? — Yes, sir. You are an experienced miner? — No, sir. By Mr. Chapman: About this seeing gas a fortnight before? Did you use the expression a very little bit? — Yes. At the time this very little bit of gas was noticed, had shots been fired just before? — No, sir. But were shots fired just after? — Yes, sir. And it was too small to be reported? — Yes, sir. Archibald Thom jun., produced a plan of the working, showing the scene of the accident. Michael Hugo said he was a deputy at Oatlands Pit. He remembered the deceased and others coming to work on the 3rd of December about midnight. Shortly before midnight he was in the working place and examined it. He knew that Kavanagh, MacDonald, and a boy were going in, and he examined it perhaps about a quarter or twenty minutes past ten, as near as he could say. Deceased and the others followed on a previous shift, and there was a hole ready bored in the right-hand side, ready for a shot. This hole was bored by those on the previous shift. When he got into the working the previous shiftmen had left the working, and he examined the place with a lamp for gas, but he could find any traces of gas in the place whatever. If the men had not fired the shot and did anything to disturb the place, there was nothing to let the gas there, until some feeder was let loose, or there might have been some stuff that fell before the shot was fired and this released some of the gas. A piece had fallen off the right hand side when he was there. In answer to Mr. Hedley, witness said it was an irregular roof. Continuing, witness said when the men went into the working, he told them there was a "head" to set, and he told Hind that everything was alright. He was told of the accident about half-past eleven. He never had any call to ask the deceased or Hind if they had met any gas. After the accident both Hind and the deceased had told witness that there was no gas, and that all was as clear as crystal. Matthew Hind was the contractor. By Mr. Hedley: About the position of this shot hole. Did you see the hole? — Yes, sir. Before the accident, or after it? — Before the accident. And what position was it placed in? — It was placed in the stone on the right-hand side. Had you any opportunity of judging in what position the hole was? How was it that you noticed they had it like that? — Because in the previous shift there was always a mark left near the hole. And did you see the hole in the previous shift? — Yes, in the shift I was coming on with. I first saw the hole about a quarter past ten. And the shot was fired when? — From my leaving and when I heard of the accident at half-past eleven. Are you certain that was the same hole that was fired at the time the accident is supposed to have taken place? — Yes. Did you examine that hole yourself? — Yes. Did you stem the hole or that it was stemmed? — No, sir. I was not there to fire it. When the accident happened did you examine the hole, or what was left of it? — Yes, about half-past four in the morning. And did you notice in what condition the place was in — had the shot down its work or had it been blown out? — It had done its work, and there was some stuff which had fallen. When you examined that shot the night before, or rather the same night after 10 o'clock, did you consider that that shot had been placed in a proper position? — Yes. You are satisfied that the shot was right? — Yes. When you went in at four o'clock in the morning you examined the place all round? Did you find any gas there? — No, sir. Have you got any gas reported? — Yes, but not before the accident. You have had some since then, I take it? — Yes, when the accident occurred. If you have the gas reported there how did you know it was there when you told us that the gas was not there beforehand? — Because now there was nothing to stop it; the brick partition was now down, and they had no return from the heading. That would show that the seam does make a little bit of gas, and when you got the partition up again the gas was cleared away? — Yes, sir. Since the partition was put up again they have not seen any gas. Have you ever seen gas in any other part of the mine? — Yes a little, but it was not in the same district at all. Joseph Hind stated that he lived at Pica, and worked at Oatland's Pit. On the 3rd of December last, he and Kavanagh, MacDonald, and a boy, were in a drift working up to a higher seam. They went down about 10 o'clock, and on their way to the working place, they met Hugo. He examined their lamps and told them they were all right. Hugo also examined the working place and said this was all right. When they went in the first thing they did was to set some timber. Witness was the shot firer for his company. When they went in there was a hole bored which had been done by the previous shift. Witness stemmed the hole himself. He charged the hole with gelatine, putting in four cartridges and a half. This would be about nine ounces. Sometimes they put nine or ten cartridges in — it depended on what work they had to do. The hole was in the right-hand side, and it was driven up. They had only put the "head" in. They examined the place before they charged the hole, and after it was charged. Their lamps were hanging seven feet up in the air all the time, and they never saw any signs of gas. He fired the shot with a piece of touch and a piece of wire. They had been doing this all along. By Mr. Hedley: Did you try over the timbers for gas? — Yes. Everywhere where we could get. If there had been any collection of gas it would have been further down than where they fired. The ventilation was pretty good where they were. Witness, continuing, said when he was ready to fire the shot he told McDonald and the boy not to come back. Witness and deceased always kept together when they fired the shot. He could remember that an explosion took place. After the shot went off, it knocked both deceased and witness over. There was a quantity of stuff fell off during the time of lighting, the shot and going back. Before the explosion about half-a-ton of stuff fell out of the roof. He was quite sure this fall took place between the time the shot should have been fired and lighting it. By Mr. Ellwood: It is a strange thing that there has been no gas seen since in this place. Mr. Hedley said it was not an unusual circumstances for gas to come off under conditions such as the witness has told us, and the very fact of gas being there was the result of the fall, which was caused by the pressure of the gas. Continuing, Mr. Hedley said he did not wish to ask the witness any questions. He had given his evidence in a very lucid manner, and had given it straightforward. He had given a very fair explanation, and they could not get any further. He would, however, ask the witness how far he was from the working place when the explosion happened? — Perhaps 30 or 40 yards. Can you say whether you were injured by the explosion of gas and not by the direct effect of the shot — a blown-out shot or anything of that sort? — Gas must have come from some place and the shot went off. Were you struck by anything that you remember? — No. You were burned? — Just burned. Mr. Chapman said he agreed with Mr. Hedley that this witness's evidence cleared up the whole affair. Mr. Hedley said gas coming off unexpectedly like this was one of those things which could not be avoided. The Coroner, in summing up, said it was unfortunate that this fall should have taken place just as the shot was going to be fired. The Foreman: They seem to have taken every care. The Coroner: Yes, it seems so. A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||