Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th August 1899

The Southam Pit Fire

Finished Inquest

Important Intimation To Miners

On Monday, Mr. Webster, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, resumed the inquiry into the circumstances attending to the death of Richard Nichol, of Moor Row; David Taylor, St. Bees; and Phillip Burns, Cleator Moor, who met their death on Friday, the 7th July, at the Southam Hematite Company's mine near Bigrigg.

Mr. J. Hedley, Newcastle-on-Tyne, H.M. Inspector of coal and metalliferous mines; and Mr. Wm. Leck, Cleator Moor, H.M. Assistant-Inspector, were again present during the inquiry.

Mr. T. Brown and Mr. W. H. Chapman appeared on behalf of the Southam Company; Mr. Atter appeared for the relatives of Taylor; and Mr. J. Flynn appeared on behalf of relatives of Burns.

James Nicholls deposed: I live at Moor Row. I am underground manager in the employment of the Southam Company. I was off work on the 7th of July last. I had been off since the 14th June, being ill. My duty as underground manager was to see that the pit was in safe working order. It was my duty to inspect and see that the pumps, including Nos. 1 and 2, which were worked by compressed air, were in order. I had two deputies who worked under me: one was John Newby and the other John Barry. We had special rules relating to this mine. Supposing there was any fire or fall, or anything of that kind in the mine, it would have to be reported to me or to one of the deputies. I know the place where No. 1 pump was. I have examined the place and know how the woodwork was placed. I last inspected it before the accident, on the 13th June last, the day before I was taken ill. It was our pumpman who first suggested a lamp to keep down the ice in the pump; and John Tolson, our fitter, made a lamp especially for the purpose. The first one we used was a cast-iron lamp. That was a much larger lamp than the one used at the time of the accident. That lamp would be made about a month before I was taken ill. On the 13th June, the pump and the lamp connected with it were in good order. We continued using this big lamp for maybe about three weeks altogether: I cannot tell to a day or two. We knocked off the big lamp because we thought it was making rather too much smoke. Complaints were made about the big lamp by the men. I don't remember the names of any men in particular who complained, but I found myself that it was very disagreeable. I have never seen these lamps used in other places: I never saw one before the pumpman recommended it. When the smaller lamp was substituted for the big lamp, I never heard any further complaint. I never heard tell of any fire caused by either of the lamps until the accident. I never saw any traces of fire on any of the timber in the place where No. 1 pump was. Supposing there had been traces I would have been sure to have seen them.

By Mr. Atter: I have been under ground manager for ten years with the Southam Company, except that I was absent about five years ago for two and a half years. I don't keep a book in which reports made to me of things having gone wrong are entered. When a complaint was made of anything being wrong, we went and put the thing right at once, or as soon as we could. I returned to work after my illness on the 12th July; but I did not go down the pit for about nine days after that. I first inspected No. 1 pump after the accident on the 27th July, being the day before Mr. Hedley went down. The place is thickly wooded at No. 1 pump. There is a good deal of wood at No. 2. When we first worked those pumps we used steam, and we had men in charge of them. When we changed to compressed air there was not so much work to do, and I consider it was safe and proper to have one boy in charge of the two.

By Mr. Flynn: I engaged Parker. Parker had been employed about a fortnight firing a boiler- that was the only experience he had. The height from the sole to the roof of the place where the pump was was about 6ft. I examined the timber before the accident, but saw no appearance of fire. A fire was never reported to me, nor did I ever hear that the men had been called out to ride the shaft on account of a fire at No. 1 pump station. I never heard of men having giving in their notices to leave because they thought the pit was not safe. A man of the name of Smith did not leave my employ and say it was on account of the pit not being safe owing to a fire having taken place. If he gave notice to the deputy it should have been reported to me by the deputy. No report was made to me whilst I was ill, nor was any word conveyed to me of a fire at No. 1 pump station. No report about anything was taken to me before the accident, while I was ill. The deputies had no power to dismiss any person when I am there; they might have dismissed men when I was ill. No rumour of a fire that was put out by buckets of water ever reached my ear. I have had no conversation with the boys as to the evidence they were to give at the inquest.

Mr. Hedley said that he would like that it should be well known that if men had complaints to make about their work in respect of any danger or suspicion of danger, he would welcome information on the point. Any communication that was made to him or to Mr. Leck would be perfectly confidential. He would like to get the information through Mr. Flynn; but whether any communication was signed or anonymous it would receive attention and would be treated as confidential.

Mr. Flynn: Anything that comes through me will have my name on it.

Mr. Brown: Wouldn't that introduce a condition of things, which would be dangerous to both men and employers? — that a man, instead of reporting to his employers any irregularity or danger in the pit is invited by the Inspector of Mines to inform him either anonymously or privately, and the owners of the pit have to be kept in ignorance.

Mr. Hedley: No I don't imply that for a moment. I say that these complaints ought to be made to me: it is done all over the district.

Mr. Brown: That may be. But I think that the mine owners ought to have the information the inspector has.

The Coroner pointed out that by the rules of the Southam Pit men were required to report to the manager any supposed defect or danger. Mr. Hedley asked the men also to give him notice; but that did not absolve them from their obligation to report to the manager.

Mr. Hedley repeated that it was done all over the district.

Mr. Atter: It is a great pity there is not a report book kept.

Mr. Hedley: There ought to be.

The Coroner: There has been a great deal of discussion between myself and Mr. Hedley on this point; and we are agreed that there should be the same regulations as in coalmines.

Mr. Brown: That is rather a question for legislation than for application to one particular mine.

The Coroner: But we have got many people to do things merely on the suggestion of Her Majesty's Inspector; and it has done good.

Mr. Leck: And which they are not compelled to do.

The Coroner: Which they are not compelled to do. For instance, examining working places before men go to work. That is now generally adopted

Mr. Flynn: Of course, as Mr. Brown says, it would be better if things were embodied in an Act of Parliament. Ever since I have been in the district I have seen the necessity for a Metalliferous Mines Act.

Mr. Brown said that what appeared to him was that such observations made at an inquiry like this emphasized the matter with regard to one particular mine.

Mr. Hedley: That is not so. It is only a suggestion that complaints were made and were not attended to by the mine manager; and I say if complaints are made and they are not attended to, then send the complaint to me.

Mr. Flynn: We have remained stationary without legislation for the last 50 years; and the mines are getting old and worn out, and I think we should have something done in this respect.

Mr. Hedley: Well, I hope you understand that I already get these complaints every now and then from other parts of the district; and I wish it to be understood that all such complaints of danger from fire or the like will be attended to, and I will treat them confidentially.

Mr. Flynn: There is one reason, perhaps, why complaints are not made to the managers. In cases were the deputy, because the miners have brought some complaints — they have had to leave, and lost their positions, they are very shy about reporting.

The Coroner: They should report to Her Majesty's Inspector, if they cannot get redress.

Mr. Hedley: That is what I am suggesting. I don't wish to cast any reflection upon Mr. Nichol; but I gather from Mr. Flynn's remarks that complaints have been made and that some of the men have left because they were afraid to report.

Mr. Brown: We have no evidence of that at all.

The Coroner: Mr. Flynn asked whether a man had not given notice on account of a previous fire, and he gave the name of the man as Smith. (To Mr.Flynn): I don't know whether you are going to call Smith.

Mr. Flynn: I dare say he will be here if he is wanted.

Cross-examination of the witness was then continued.

By Mr.Brown: The place where the No. 1 pump is placed is 6ft. by 6ft. The pump is about 4ft. long by 14 inches wide and 18 inches high. I have been about 50 years employed as a miner. It is impossible that the wood could be scorched by fire without it being evident to inspection. There could have been no charring, or I would have noticed it. When No. 1 and 2 pumps were put down they were worked by steam, and two men were employed to attend to them. There were three shifts in the 24 hours, and there were three men one for each shift. When we changed to compressed air we put a boy on in place of each man — one boy for each shift. The boys put to this work were already in our employment. We had a similar compressed air pump on the top, at which the boys had to turn the air off and on. So the boys were not ignorant of this class of work when they were sent below. Before the boys took charge of the pumps in the pit, they had two days` practice with the No. 1 and No. 2 pumps. Some one was sent with them to teach them. John Jackson was on with Stabler; Paddy Hillon, the pumpman, instructed Conkey; and Stabler and Conkey were down a fortnight before Parker went down, and Conkey instructed Parker. The lamp has no wick to it, and what takes fire is the paraffin vapour. We had water buckets in No. 1 and No. 2 stations before the compressed air was put on, and after the compressed air was put on. The buckets were used for priming. When we used steam we did not use a lamp: we did not require it. When we substituted compressed air we did not consider a torch lamp would be safe, so we got a lamp specially made.

By Mr. Hedley: When we were using steam, the pump stations were lighted by candles. When we used compressed air we depended on the lamp for light. I have seen when inspecting that lighted candles were stuck on the legs in the pump station — a time or two, but not often. The candles are sometimes fixed up with a bit of clay. I have never had difficulty with the lamp in keeping down the ice. I have never been known of oil being poured on waste or on either of the two engines to set it on fire as to free the pump from ice. I have heard of that being done on No. 1 pump, but that was only since the accident. No report was made to him before the accident, and he never heard of it being done.

Mr. Hedley said as a matter of fact he knew that it had been done, because there were twenty men killed in Lancashire from the fumes.

Witness continued to answer Mr. Hedley: I never heard from my son, who was employed in the pit, that there had been a fire.

By the Jury: When we used steam the bucket at No. 1 pump was not kept standing full of water.

Mr. J. M. Main, recalled by the Coroner, asked by Mr. Atter what in his opinion was the cause of the accident, said he would prefer to hear all the evidence before replying to that question. Asked to express an opinion on the evidence he had already heard, Mr. Main said: All I have to say, Mr. Coroner, is that the lamp of itself would certainly not have caused the fire that occurred, and there has not yet been sufficient evidence given to enable me to form any reliable theory as to the cause of the fire. I am prepared, to show, however, that there could not possibly have been a fire of any extent previous to the fire on the 7th July.

Notwithstanding your investigation as manager of this mine; you can form no theory as to the cause of this accident? No reliable theory.

What would, in your opinion, be the cause of it, whether that opinion be reliable or unreliable? Well, I am not prepared to say. The lamp of itself is not sufficient; there must be some other element.

What is that element?

The Coroner: What is the value of any theory that he considers not reliable? It is of no value. I will only ask him this — can you give a reliable theory?

Witness: No sir.

Mr. Atter: No one can form a reliable theory: it is only theory. I suggest that he leave out the word "reliable." From your investigations as manager and from the evidence which you have heard at this inquest can you form any opinion what was the cause of the accident on the 7th July?

Witness: Well no, I can't. I may have theories, but each of those theories may be wrong

Mr. Chapman: I take it what Mr. Main means is that any opinion must be purely hypothetical.

Witness: That is so.

Mr. Atter: Do I take it that you cannot form any opinions as to the cause of the accident?

Witness: My answer is as at first that I cannot form any reliable opinion.

Mr. Atter said he would not waste further time, if the manager could not form any opinion as to the cause of the accident.

By Mr. Flynn: No person reported any previous fire or complained of anything — not one; and I never heard a word of anything of the kind. If a lighted candle had fallen on the two handful's of waste Parker had been using on the day of the accident, that would not have been sufficient to have accounted for the fire on the 7th July.

By Mr. Brown: If there had been any fire in No. 1 station previous to the fire of 7th July, there would have been distinct indications on or about the pump of the fire having taken place. On the end of the cylinder — that is the casing in which the piston works there are two lubricators, and the top part of one of these is inland filled with fusible metal, which will melt at a comparatively low temperature; and if there had been a fire to a very slight extent, that metal could not fail to have been fused. Then there is another point. There are the Joints of the cylinder, which are of India rubber, and these joints must also have been affected by a fire. We are prepared to prove that no fusing of that metal took place, nor were the joints affected, previous to the 17th July.

By Mr. Flynn: It would require 500 degrees to fuse the white metal. The lubricators were made of brass. If you will allow me I will show you a piece of that white metal, which can be melted by a match.

By Mr. Hedley: These fusible plugs were fused after the fire of the 7th.

Mr. Flynn: But that was a very different fire to the first.

Witness: Supposing there had been a fire previously, the lubricators would be the first thing that the fire would reach.

Mr. Flynn: We don't know whether it worked the day after or not.

By Mr. Hedley: As to the oil blown on to the cylinders, if this joint on the top was not perfectly tight, there might be a little spurting of oil, caused by the compressed air, of course, when the oil was being run into the cylinder, if the cover of the lubricator was not sufficiently close.

Could it be blown out in sufficient quantity to constitute a danger? Certainly not. The lubricator contains only a wine glass full, and it would burn only very slowly. We buy engine oil, and they mix a little paraffin with it, but in very small proportion.

Supposing the road by which the men had escaped had been closed, was there any other road to get to the surface? There were two roads.

Have you two outlets from the bottom of No. 1 dip? Yes certainly.

The main dip and another one? Yes.

There are two outlets from the bottom on No. 1 dip? Yes.

That is No. 3 and No. 1- the old pit? Yes, and there is an air course between the two.

And you could travel between No. 3 to No. 1? You can. You cannot walk erect, but you can get through.

There is a road through? Yes, there is a tramway.

There is a road through to the surface? Yes.

Of course you are not bound to have two outlets. Had you any means of getting the men up if they had got to the bottom of No. 1 pit? Oh yes, we have a ladder way down and stages.

Mr. Hedley: I just wish to show that there was another means of escape if they had been able to do it.

Mr. Flynn: It is not a very good travelling way.

Mr. Brown: It is a great deal better than some Cornish mines.

Mr. Hedley: I have no means of compelling them to have two outlets at all.

The Coroner (to Mr. Main): Is there any probability of Curwen's body being found shortly? Within what time?

Within a week? It might be.

Mr. Hedley: What is being done is this, sir. They have got No. 1 pump to work. That will keep the regular supply of water down; and they are using another pump to clear out No. 2 dip, where it is probable the man is lying. But there are falls there, and it will take them some little time before they can get in. But that is where the man's body is lying.

The Forman of the jury asked Mr. Main if the lamp would have been safer if there had been a tap to regulate the oil flow.

Witness said there was gauze in the pipe for that purpose, and in addition to that there was a regulator on the burner.

The Foreman: No, but an additional tap?

Mr. Hedley: I am afraid that would stop the flow.

A juryman: No; Well's lamps have a tap.

Witness: This gauze answers the same purpose.

John Laidler Hedley, H. M. Inspector of Mines, in charge of the Newcastle district of which this forms part, deposed: On Saturday, the 8th July, about mid-day, I was informed that had occurred at Southam Pit. I came over from Newcastle by the earliest available train. I went up to the mine the same night. I found it closed. Mr. Leck accompanied me, and examined what had been done up to that time. We returned to the mine the following morning, and met Mr. Main, who explained what he has already given in evidence. As soon as ever there was an opportunity — and Mr. Leck watched the mine almost day by day, I may say — as soon as there was an opportunity of inspecting the site of the fire it was done; and I am in the same way of thinking as Mr. Main. I am as wise as I was before, and I am unable to say from what cause the fire arose. There are four theories that I have in my mind, the question of the lamp being the most prominent, I think. It is not suggested there was any defect in the lamp, but there might have been, and oil may have been spilled; but I can't see how the lamp could have set fire to the legs, as it was in the same position when found after the fire; and had it been hanging in the position the witness told us it was it could not have set fire to the head tree. Another theory is about oil being put on the engine in order to heat it. That is simply a matter of surmise. I know no more than the jury; but I know that such a thing has been done elsewhere with most disastrous result. If that had been done then the head trees might have been set on fire. The other theory is that candles might have been left on the legs and so caused the fire. We have it in evidence from Mr. Nichol that he has seen candles; and it would not be the first time a fire has been caused in that way. The fourth theory is as to the waste. If there was an accumulation of waste there might have been spontaneous combustion. Those are the four theories that suggest themselves; but as I said in the first instance I cannot come to any definite suggestion. That the fire commenced at No. 1 station I am certain. I had had no complaints from this mine previously with regard to fires.

Thomas Toomey deposed: I am a labourer in the employment of the Southam Mining Company. I knew the three deceased men. I went to work at two o'clock in the afternoon on the 7th inst. It was the afternoon shift. All went right until between eight and nine o'clock at night. I was working in No. 8 working and I came down to shift some sill from the rise bottom, and I went for a bogie and come back and waited until a man had filled his bogie half full. Then I got my bogie in and had got it half full when young Parker came into No. 2 rise and told me that the pump was on fire, and he could not put it out. I shouted up to John Newby. He was on the rise top. I knew he was there, and I shouted up what the boy told me. Then I threw my shovel down and ran out to the dip bottom to see if I could put it out. I got a bucket, but it was no use; it choked me before I could get to it. I could not get near enough to throw water on to it. I threw the bucket down, and went back the same road as I had come, and met the other men. I don't know all who were there, although I saw a lot of them, but there were some I never saw before. We went by No. 2 road to get out by the eye. We met some men, and they said it was no use going that way, as they were driven back. So then we all came back, as far as I know, down the same place again, near the dip bottom. (Mr. Main said they would be about ten fathoms from No. 1 pump) Ned Crears said, "Here goes," and I said, "Go on, Ned, and I will follow you." We went up the dip. Others followed. I was the fifth up, I believe. When I got to the top and had partly recovered, I knew that several men were left in the dip; and I went back for David Parker, and succeeded in reaching him. I did not rescue anybody else. I just pulled him into good air, and left him there. I was very sick, and vomiting, and there were lots of things passing that I did not know about. I remember having hold of the coats of some men, pulling them to the top, after I had got over the sickness. I worked at the pit before Parker. I had nothing to do with the pump and had no occasion to go near it, and I don't know much about it. I never had heard of a fire there before.

By Mr. Atter: When I passed No. 1 pump with the bogie I did not notice any candle burning. I did not notice that the lamp was smoking or jumping. Parker was always going back and forward from one pump to the other. I could not say more about how he did his work

By Mr. Flynn: I have heard "crack" among the men that there had been a afire before; but I could not say whether it was true. It was just rambling talk that I heard. I could not say that it was oftener than once. I could not say whether I have heard of men riding the shaft because they were afraid of the engine going on fire; no, I don't think I have. I have heard it rumoured once or twice that the engine has been on fire. I never heard anyone say that they would not work in the pit because they did not consider it safe, on account of these fires. I think it would be more than a fortnight before the accident that I heard that there had been a fire. The lamp had been on fire. I don't know that the men would have to go to the shaft for that. I had heard in the pit that the lamp had been on fire, but I never heard anything else.

By the Coroner: I mean by the lamp being "on fire" that it was flaming more than usual.

Mr. Brown: That was what Parker said.

Mr. Atter: No; indeed he did not. Parker's evidence was most emphatic.

Mr. Chapman said he understood that this witness meant the flaring up of the lamp — not anything apart from the lamp.

The Coroner said that was so.

By Mr. Flynn: Witness never had occasion to go out of the pit on account of any fires before the 7th. Parker did not say anything as to how the fire occurred. We all thought we could get round by the eye, but when we found we were choked there we were frightened. I did not hear any of the men say "Well, this is nothing; we have had this before."

By Mr. Leck: When Crears said "Here goes for the dip, we had lights." When we set off I threw my light down. I saw that it could not burn. It had been put out before when I went to the pit bottom. Parker was on the tram, nearly at the top when I rescued him. When I first went to see whether I could put the fire out, I saw a small flame, but I don't know whether it was from the lamp; the place was full of smoke.

James Southward deposed: I am a miner at the Parkside iron-ore mines. On the 7th July last I was working at the Southam iron ore mine, in the dip working, along with the shiftmen. I first became aware there was a fire in the pit between eight and nine o'clock that night. David Parker said to me, "Jim, the pump's on fire." I went round to where the pump was working. The place was all in a blaze when I got there. I got hold of the signalling wire and knocked an empty tram away in order to get at the water in the pump. I then threw a few buckets of water at the fire. I saw that it was not doing any good with the fire. Parker had gone away at this time, I think, but you could not see for smoke. I first went a few steps up the dip. I could have got out then without any difficulty; but I turned back in order to warn the other men. I saw John Newby, and told him, and he went towards the fire while I went on to warn the men. I came out of these dip workings by the No. 3 road. I cannot say what men I saw, except that I saw a man named Slone, who was saved.

By Mr. Atter: I had worked for Southam pit for six weeks, and had not seen a fire at No. 1 pump.

By Mr. Flynn: One afternoon before the accident of the 7th, I heard talk of a fire at No. 1 pump. I could not tell who I heard it from, or who was talking about it. We had not to come out of our workings on that day in consequence of the fire that was talked about.

By Mr. Brown: About ten minutes before Parker shouted that the pump was on fire. I had been at No. 1 station. I had been working with the shift men. The station was alright then, as far as I know. I saw nothing unusual: if there had been anything unusual I would be likely to see it. I saw some of the men on my way out. Some of them told me I could not manage to go the way I did, by No. 3 road. No one went with me that I saw, but I know that Slone set off with me, and I know that he got out.

By Mr: Chapman: When I went to fetch the bogie, ten minutes before Parker shouted "fire." I noticed Parker going to No. 2 pump.

By Mr. Leck: After I had heard there was a fire I saw there was a blaze, but I could not see any lamp. I don't know why the men told me that I could not get out by No. 3 road, except that it was low ground, right over the place where the fire was. Before I got into the thick smoke my light went out. The men I spoke to were Graham, Magan, Roan, and Nicholl, all of whom got out except Nicholl. When I got out I went to two men at the shaft, and they came back with me to the dip top. I was out of the dip before Crears. I would be one of the first out. I don't know whether Richard Nicholl attempted to follow me or not. I don't think they had heard of the fire before I passed them. I don't know, but I don't think so.

Edward Crears deposed: I am in the employment of the Southam Company, as an iron-ore miner. I was in the pit on the 7th July. A man named Taylor told me there was a fire. I went right up to No. 1pump and found nothing but a stench there of smoke. I asked Parker if he had a bucket, and he got me a bucket. I filled it full of water and attempted to go into the pump, but I could not face it. We then all came back from the pump, and someone spoke up and said he could get out by No. 3 road. We went there and found we could not do it. Thereupon we all came back to No. 1 dip and found the smoke had advanced two or three yards further in. I said, "Well, here goes for the dip top," and I put my hand on my nose and mouth and made a rush forward through the smoke. When I got to the top I found James Foy was there before me. Paddy Hillon and Francis Cronin picked me up when I got to the dip top. They just clicked us out as they saw us coming through the smoke.

By Mr. Leck: Foy, Taylor, and I were in the same company. They did not leave at the same time as me. After being at the fire, I went back to warn my mates, and heard a voice there warning us to "come out." Five or six or seven minutes after I got out I knew that all were out except four. The smoke was then standing like a cloud at the dip top, and nothing could be done to rescue any who were still in. I have been at No. 1 pump station many a time, and saw the lamp hanging on a leg or upright prop. The lamp was used to warm the cylinder. I never saw it hanging from a head-tree. It was hanging down the side on a leg. I have been working at the pit nearly two years. I never saw a fire there before, and never heard any complaints of fire. Taylor never told me that there had been a fire before.

John Barry deposed: I was a deputy overman in Southam Pit. I was not in the pit at the time of the accident. I was at home, in bed. I never heard of the accident till half-past four next morning. I then went to the pit. We succeeded in finding the body of Richard Nicholl that morning. It was found just below No. 3 flatsheets. We have never had any fires in the pit before. I am quite certain. I have never heard that there was a fire in the pit before. I know Parker. Parker had buckets at the two pump stations. They were for the purpose of priming the pumps. They were not kept there for the purpose of extinguishing fire, as Parker said.

By Mr. Atter: Parker has not worked at the pit since the fire, nor has any of the other lads Wm. Conkie and Stables. I cannot tell you why they have not been working since. Paddy Hillon, the pumpman, is on now. I could not tell you whether more experienced men are now employed at the pumps. There are three men now at the pumps. One of the boys is now employed at some other work in the pit. No. 1 pump has been working since last Thursday. There is no lamp at all now. Nothing is used in place of the lamp. I could not say whether both of those changes are in the way of safety. It stands to reason that experienced men are safer than lads, and it is safer without the lamp. I don't know anything about the cause of the accident; I wasn't there. I have never seen the lamps jumping. I never saw anything wrong with either of them. We had to prime the buckets when we used steam. I am not aware that any change was made afterwards. There never was any water kept in the buckets so far as I know.

By the Coroner: You could get water out of the sump at any time.

By Mr. Flynn: I have made no statement of my evidence to any one since last Wednesday. I never remember any fire or any rumour of a fire of any kind. I have never made a statement to anyone, and no one has made a statement to me about previous fires. Both pumps require priming. Any time I ever saw the lamp it burned steadily and bright. I saw it about twice a day.

By Mr. Brown: I inspected No. 1 pumping station at one p.m. on the 7th, and everything was satisfactory. It was my duty to inspect everything right from the shaft in. I inspected it on the morning of the 7th to see that everything was safe. I think if the legs of the trees had been burnt by fire I would have noticed them. I could not have gone two days without seeing them. It was not possible for me to have been inspecting there day after day for weeks without seeing signs of fire if there had been any. A few days before the fire I told Newby there were some repairs to be done to the woodwork of the pump. These repairs would be 20 inches at the furthest from the pump. I saw that that woodwork wanted repairing, but I did not see any signs of fire. The legs would be about a yard distant from these repairs. The repairs were done after a careful inspection of No. 1 station. Neither Stables nor Conkie reported that there had been a fire; neither did Taylor, one of the deceased, tell me.

By Mr. Chapman: It is not true that I said to Parker "Keep a bucket of water in case of fire."

By Mr. Leck: There was no old waste lying about the pumping station. I gave no instructions what they were to do with the old waste. I never gave the boys any instructions what they were to do in the performance of their duties; they knew what they had to do, and always did it satisfactorily.

Mr. Brown said Mr. Main would like to explain why men instead of boys were now employed at the pumps.

The Coroner said it was not necessary.

John Chorley deposed: I am a banker at Southam pit, and was there on the 7th July. I heard that an accident had occurred, and I alarmed the engine driver, and then sent for the nearest doctor. By the time the doctor came the main part of the men were up. In the meantime I waited for the men coming up. About nine of them were "gassed." They were treated by men coming on the night shift — ambulance men, some of them. We adopted artificial respiration and so forth, and that did good, until the doctor came.

This concluded the evidence, and the Coroner then addressed the jury.

Parker was re-called, and in answer to the Coroner, said one morning when he had no water in the buckets, Barry told him that he had to keep a bucket of water in the station for fear it took fire. The other bucket of water was for No. 2 pump. No. 1 pump would want priming when the buckets were taken off or changed. This took place every four days. They had to prime No. 2 pump often — it did not go very well; it lost its water.

By Mr. Leck: One of the buckets was at No. 1 when he came. The other bucket had come about a fortnight after. It was a fortnight or three weeks after he started that Barry told him to keep the bucket full of water.

By Mr. Main: Both pumps were not working when he went down first. They used the bucket of water for washing and for putting the fires out. The deputies had seen the fires.

Mr. Main said this was ridiculous.

The Coroner said Mr. Main should not use this language. It might be ridiculous from his point of view, but it was very singular evidence. He could not conceive why the lad should make such a story up.

Mr. Main said it was singular that none of these fires had been reported.

The Coroner said he agreed with Mr. Main on that point.

In answer to Mr. Main, witness said the timber was about two feet and a half from the burner of the lamp.

John Barry was also re-called and questioned by the Coroner: You see this lad Parker? — Yes.

He says that you told him to keep a bucket of water up on the pump so that he might put out any fire that might occur? — I did not tell him any such thing.

Mr. Leck: What instructions did you give him about the buckets? — I did not give him any instructions at all.

By the coroner: Do you mean to say that this boy is romancing, and making up this story out of his own head? — Witness said he could not say.

In answer to the Coroner, Parker said he was not afraid when the fires occurred to mention the matter.

Mr. Main asked the lad a question, and

Mr. Flynn he considered it a shame to try to shake the lad.

The Foreman: As the foreman of the jury I object to Mr. Main asking the lad such questions.

The Coroner said the lad had given straightforward evidence, and as good as any other men.

The Coroner then continued his summing up, after which the jury expressed a wish to consider their verdict in private.

After a deliberation of about half-an-hour, the Coroner was called into the room, and shortly afterwards he read the verdict, as follows :— "That the said Richard Nicholl was accidentally, casually, and by misfortune poisoned by carbon monoxide gas, which was given off by certain burning wood near the station No. 1 in the Southam Pit in the parish of Egremont, on the 7th day of July. 1899"

The jury also wished to record their opinion that the evidence given by the boy David Parker was most trustworthy.

The Coroner: I am also of the same opinion. I think it only right to say this.

The same verdict was returned in the cases of David Taylor and Philip Burns.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Solicitor  
Barry, John    Deputy  
Brown, T.    Solicitor  
Burns, Philip   40 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Chapman, W. H.    Solicitor  
Chorley, John    Deputy  
Conkey, William    Miner  
Crears, Edward    Miner  
Cullen, Patrick   45 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Flynn, J.    Solicitor  
Hedley, John Laidler    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hillon, Paddy    Pumpman  
Jackson, John    Miner  
Leck, William    H.M. Assistant Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Main, John McKellar    Manager  Whos Who Page
Newby, John    Miner  
Newby, John    Deputy  
Nichol, Richard   18 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Nicholls, James    Underground Manager  
Parker, David    Miner  
Slone, —    Miner  
Southward, James    Miner  
Stabler, —    Miner  
Taylor, David   19 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Tolson, John    Fitter  
Toomey, Thomas    Labourer  
Webster, John    Coroner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Southam (Iron Ore)  Southam (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jul 1899  Pit On Fire At Bigrigg, Narrow Escape Of Ten Others (Whitehaven News)
20 Jul 1899  The Southam Mine Disaster, Inquest Further Adjourned (Whitehaven News)
03 Aug 1899  The Bigrigg Fatality, Another Body Discovered (Whitehaven News)
10 Aug 1899  News (Whitehaven News)
10 Aug 1899  The Southam Pit Fire, The Inquest, Yesterday (Whitehaven News)
17 Aug 1899  The Southam Pit Fire, Finished Inquest, Important Intimation To Miners (Whitehaven News)
31 Aug 1899  The Bigrigg Mining Disaster (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Southam
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print