|
10th August 1899 The Southam Pit FireThe Inquest, YesterdayYesterday (Wednesday), at the Board Schoolroom, Bigrigg, before Mr. J. Webster, coroner, and a jury, the adjourned inquest was held, touching the death of Richard Nichol, Moor Row; David Taylor, St. Bees; and Phillip Burns, Cleator Moor, three of the four miners who met their deaths by the firing of the Southam Hematite Iron Company's mine, near Bigrigg, on the 7th July. The Coroner said he had had a conversation with Mr. Adam Byers, the foreman appointed by the jury when first they assembled to inquire into these deaths. It was not necessary to say what those remarks were, but the result was that, Mr. Byers thought it would be a proper thing for him to retire from the jury. It would therefore be necessary that the jury should elect a fresh foreman. Mr. Byers said he would prefer not to sit on the jury at all. The Coroner said he quite commended Mr. Byers for coming to that conclusion, because it prevented any question arising hereafter as to whether there was any interest or anything of that kind. They would have thirteen jurymen without him. The jury having been sworn, Mr. John Bell was then chosen as foreman of the jury in place of Mr. Byers. The Coroner said that before calling witnesses he thought it desirable to give the jury a warning. There had been a considerable amount of comment on this case both in the public press and by private individuals, and he asked them to dismiss all that from their minds and consider only the evidence here, which would be tested by cross - examining all the parties concerned. Mr. Atter, solicitor, said he appeared on behalf of relatives of the deceased man Taylor; Mr. T. Brown and Mr. W. H. Chapman, solicitors, said they appeared on behalf of the Southam Hematite Mining Company; Mr. J. Flynn, miners' agent, said he appeared on behalf of relatives of the deceased man Burns. Mr. Hedley and Mr. Leck, Government Inspectors, were present during the inquiry. John McKellar Main, the first witness called, produced original working plan of the mine, and also plans and sections of the particular workings where the accident occurred, showing the position of the pump used for pumping the water out of the dip workings. He proceeded: I have been employed as engineer to the Southam Mining Company for three years. Previous to that I was for six years in partnership with Mr. Kendall, as engineers. The Company is a limited company. I was responsible for putting in the compressed air apparatus for pumping. Mr. James Nicholl was sorting under me. I gave him instructions as to the management of the mine, and the practical working was left to himself. He has two overmen. The depth of the pit shaft was 74 fathoms, and the distance from the shaft to where the air pump was placed was 63 fathoms. It was a main road from the shaft to the pump - on the level for a distance of 45 fathoms from the shaft to the dip top, and from the dip top to the pump about 16 fathoms. The gradient from the dip top to No.1 pump is about one in two and a half - a steep gradient. The length of No.1 dip is 95 feet. The way to the dip and workings is almost due magnetic north. We did not buy the water pump. We had it by us. We placed it near the bottom of No.1 dip. It was worked by compressed air. That was for the purpose of relieving the dip workings from water. The sudden expansion of the compressed air in the exhaust produces intense cold, and the moisture in the air is frozen, adhering to the sides. If this is permitted it impedes the action of the pump very materially, where the pump has the water to lift for a considerable distance; in lower lifts there would be no ice formed. The lift in this case was such as to form ice. To prevent the formation of ice we use a Well's burner and oil lamp, to impart a gentle heat, so that the ice would readily come away. The burner was placed under the pump cylinder. The pump rested on a wooden sole - tree. The lamp might be 2 ½ feet from the larch timber. It would only be eight or nine inches from the wooden sole - tree, but that was protected by a piece of sheet iron. The lamp hung from a hook, but the wood work in which the hook was burnt. We have recovered the lamp and also the hock. Mr. Nicholl will be better able to say what was the distance from the lamp to the nearest woodwork. I was not in the pit on the day of the accident; it might be two or three days before when I was last in before the accident. There was a lad for the purpose of attending to the lamp. Mr. Nicholl appointed him. The number of men in the dip workings of the pit at the time of the accident was eighteen, including the pump boy. Fourteen of these were rescued from the pit after the fire commenced. The bodies of three of the other four have since been recovered, and one is still in the pit. I arrived at the pit close on midnight of the 7th July, after the accident. No steps were then taken to close the pit. In the afternoon of the following day I ordered stoppings to be put in the main drift, and we closed up No.1 old shaft, and Mr. Kitchin, of the Pallaflat mines, put in a stopping in that mine, which had connection with the other. That was to smother the fire, by preventing access of air to it from any direction. It was done with the sanction of Mr. Leck, one of H.M. Inspectors, and with the sanction also of two of the directors of the Company. On Sunday, the 19th, we opened No.1 shaft and found it quite clear. We then put on the water blast on No.3 pit to insure good air to the first stopping; and Mr. Hedley, Mr. Leck, myself, and others then went down and took that stopping out. The air was found to be very good inside. We then proceeded to the second stopping and took that out, and found we could make our way to the dip top. There was a smell of burnt wood, but the water blast was playing all the time, and the air was forced in the direction of the pump. The blasts were intermittent. Whilst we were sitting on the flat sheets at the dip top we noticed one or two sparks fall from the roof about half - way down the dip. It was therefore quite evident that the fire had not been altogether extinguished. The blasts of air had a tendency to fan it into flame. We did not see it flame up, but we saw the smoke produced. When we saw we had not been successful in stopping the air, we came to the conclusion in consultation to flood the mine. We first sent to get a hose pipe, to fix on the end of the airpipe, down which we sent water, and we intended to use the hose for the purpose of trying to extinguish the fire. But we could not get down the dip, because the smoke was coming up so thickly that we could not get near enough to the seat of the fire to play upon it. We then came to the conclusion that the only course to put the fire out was to put sufficient water down the pit into the dips workings to drown them. From what I have seen since I think that was the only way to deal with the fire. By Mr. Atter: We have special printed rules. During the time I have been manager I never had a report of fire in the dips workings. I am not prepared to say whether any oil dropped from the lamp. There may have been a few drops. All the reports I had about the lamp were satisfactory. James Mitchell, the mine manager, had been off work on account of illness two or three weeks previous to the accident, and he was off work on the day of the accident. In his absence at the time of the accident John Newby, overman, was in charge of the pit. In my opinion, the lamp itself could not possibly have produced the fire. I can't offer any opinion as to what was the cause of the accident. Having heard what has happened, as an expert, --------. Mr. Hedley said he thought the jury should have the evidence of fact first, and then if they wished from expert afterwards, that might be given, and Mr. Main might be re-called. Mr. Brown said he thought the question was a very proper one, but not at this stage. Further cross-examination of the witness was then deferred until he should be recalled. John Newby deposed: I live at Brisco - road, Egremont, and am a deputy at the Southam mine. On the 7th July I went to my work at the mine at two o'clock in the afternoon. I went down the mine, and went through all the working places all over the mine. I found the mine as usual, in safe good working order. About ten minutes or a quarter to nine a fire took place at No.1 pump. I was told this by one of the men. Someone shouted; I could not exactly say who it was. As soon as I heard this I went up to No.1 pump engine. I found I could do nothing to extinguish the fire; I could not get near it. I then went back and warned the men. There were one or two men with me. I think Crears was, and Thomas Toomey. There were 18 men in the dip workings at the time, including myself. I warned them all. They said "All right," and came right away with me. We came down on the bottom road, to the bottom of No.1 dip, about two fathoms from No.1 pump. I did not count the men then, and don't know how many I had around me. We saw we could not get up No.1 dip. We therefore went back again up to No.3 road. Our intention was to get there before the smoke arrived there; but we found the smoke there before us, and we had to retreat to No.1 dip again. We would be perhaps a minute and a half before we got back again. There was then nothing to be done but face the smoke. There was a great talk and confusion about what we should do, and we made a rush through the smoke to try to save our lives. Some of the men fell; I myself fell. I was rescued from the top. I have been deputy at this pit for six months, and I have been an iron ore miner for 38 years. It was my duty in the pit to make inspection and see that all was right. That included looking after the No.1 pump. That pump was placed in position after I became deputy. I fixed it according to the orders of Mr. James Nicholl. The pump was worked by compressed air. The air was compressed on the pit top, and conveyed to the pump by means of iron pipes. The air about the exhaust of the pump was so cold as to form ice, and we had a metal lamp in which we burnt paraffin oil, for the purpose of keeping down the ice. When I went down that afternoon I saw the lamp at No.1 pump at four o'clock. The lamp was hanging up by a crook fastened in a head - tree. When the lamp was suspended it would be about three feet six inches or four feet from the head tree. The lamp had a burner, and the oil was carried along from the reservoir to the burner, through an iron pipe. At four o'clock when I saw it the lamp was in good order and condition. Parker was attending to it. That lamp has been found, and I now produce it. Mr. Flynn: Has that a new stem? Witness: I don't know. It has a similar stem, but I don't know whether it is the same. I was there when the lamp was found, and it had a pipe attached to it the same as that produced. If the lamp has been altered I expect it would be by John Tolson, who is one of the witnesses present. The reservoir I am very nearly sure is the same. It is exactly the same. We left the lamp until after Mr. Hedley and Mr. Leck saw it, and then it was removed. When we found it the burner was off the pipe. The burner on the lamp produced is not off. I don't know by whose orders the burner would be put on. After the inspectors had been down and examined the place, they gave Tolson orders to remove the lamp. When I examined the place at four o'clock there was no other light than from the lamp. The lamp of No.1 pump was usually cleaned with waste and water. It was usually lighted with a candle. Mr. Tolson used to clean the burner - not the boy. The waste was required to be put into a bogie and sent up the shaft. I have heard that the burner of the lamp has "taken fire," but I never saw it. The cause would be that the oil has come through in greater quantity than usual, and caused a flame larger than usual. I never saw Parker smoking. He would not be carrying a candle about from place to place; but he was supplied by the Company with candles, to light when required. He could light his candles at the burner of the lamp. By Mr. Atter: We had had the lamp and a similar burner for three or four months. The waste after use was supposed to be put in a bogie; but the waste before being used was kept on a shelf distant about three or four feet from the burner. There is not much heat from the burner. It would not affect the clean waste. I never saw any of the oily waste dropped underneath the lamp. Supposing the lamp dropped oil into such waste I don't know whether that would cause it to take fire. No one reported the previous flaming up of the burner. I only heard of it. That was about two months before. I never thought anything about it, and I did not report it. Whether it was true or not I can't tell. I could not tell what caused the fire on this occasion. I can not offer any opinion. You would not feel as safe with that lamp now as you did before? Well, I could not say that, sir. You have no idea what caused the fire? I have no idea, sir. By Mr. Flynn: I saw all the men when I went to warn them. I can't say that I saw any of the deceased men particularly; but we were altogether. I never saw the boy lift the lamp down for any purpose. There was a bottle containing paraffin near to No.1 pump. It was not known to me that the boy sometimes poured paraffin on waste and set fire to it for the purpose of thawing the ice; I never heard tell of him doing so. The reservoir of the lamp was generally filled at the pump station, No.1. If there was any oil left it would be left in the bottle. The boy Parker filled the lamp. The place where the lamp was hanging was very dry. There were no chips, no paper, no waste, lying about. I produce two vessels used for holding oil. One is a tin in which we brought the oil from the pit top to No.1 pump. The other is a large lamp reservoir, into which the oil out of the tin vessel was put if any was left after the lamp in use was filled; it was used to store the oil. The witness explained how the oil was put in and taken out of the reservoir, which was a heavy and clumsy thing. It might be possible to spill oil in pouring it in and out of these vessels. Supposing oil were spilled on to waste it would be possible for the fire to have been caused in that way; but I never saw anything of that sort. We formerly had two men to attend to the two pumps. At the time of the accident we had one boy to attend to the two pumps. I don't know the age of the boy exactly. He will be about 16 or 17 years of age. I have heard as I have said of one fire before. I have not heard that a bucket of water put out a fire before. I have heard that Parker on this occasion attempted to put out the fire by means of a bucket of water. Never any of the men had complained that it was not safe to work below with only a boy in charge of the lamp. By Mr. Brown: When I say I have heard of a fire, I mean I have heard of the burner being afire - that is, giving out a bigger flame than usual. I don't mean that there ever was anything else on fire about the place. By Mr. Hedley: When I passed the lamp on the afternoon of the accident, I went into the pump station. I would not pass before that time. When I went into No.1 pump, the boy Parker was at No.2 pump, which was about 40 feet from No.1. I am certain there was then no other light in No.1 than the light from the lamp. The lamp was hanging by a crook attached to the head-tree. Nails were knocked into the legs about that place for the purpose of hanging things on. I have never seen the lamp hanging on to one of these legs. The lamp gives a good light, and there is no necessity for any other light about the place, excepting what the boy uses in going away to the other pump. He would not be likely to have a candle burning in one place and another burning in the other. He would carry a candle. The floor of No.1 pumping station is metal. The place is rather damp - not wet, but moist. I don't know that that would kill any oil that was spilled. For the pump we use engine oil, which was kept in a bottle. The new waste was on a shelf about four feet from the lamp, and on a level with the pump; but there was not very much of it. We don't use much waste. We threw it, when done, into any bogey that was going out; we did not keep a bogey for it. I don't know when the oil supply was last renewed. I have never seen the lamp produced at any other place than at the exhaust. In exploring since the fire, I saw the greatest indication of fire at No.3 flat sheets, about 44 feet from No.1 pump, nearer the pit shaft. So that if the fire originated at No.1 pump it must have been travelling against the air, in the direction of the shaft. There were three sets of fire burnt down at No.1 station. I have seen no indications whatever of fire on the in by side of No.1 pump. So that the fire was thus located somewhere between No.1 pump and No.3 flat sheets. By the foreman: When I heard the report of fire I went right away to see that there was a fire, and seeing I could do nothing I went to warn the men. The Court adjourned at 1.20, for an hour. On resuming. Dr. Braithwaite, of Egremont, was called. He said: I examined the body of David Taylor, on the 31st of July, at Southam Pit. Examining it as well as I could from the state the body was in I came to the conclusion that he died from gas poisoning - carbonic oxide poisoning. There were no marks of violence or of burning. By Mr. Atter: The gas would be from the burning timber; carbon monoxide some people call it. That is a much more deadly poison that carbonic acid gas, and a very small percentage of it is deadly. The burning of the paraffin oil would not give off this gas. They could not possibly have any time; and it is a perfectly painless death. By Mr. Hedley: In my opinion the men were not suffocated by drowning. Death by drowning is suffocation; but death by carbon monoxide is poisoning, not suffocation. Mr. Hedley: The reason I ask is to satisfy the relatives that when the water was turned into the pit the deceased men were already dead. Witness: I am satisfied that within ten minutes of the last man taken out of the pit alive, the remainder of the men in the pit would be dead. I examined the body of Phillip Burns on the following Friday, the 4th of August, and I repeat the same statement in respect of his death. There were no marks of violence or of burning, so far as the body was capable of being examined. I think the same evidence will apply to the other men who were in the pit. David Parker deposed: I live at St. Bees. I was employed by the Southam Company, on the 7th of July last. I was 16 years of age on the 2nd June last. I have been employed by the Southam Company about ten weeks. I was employed at first firing one of the boilers at the surface. After that I was employed attending to the two Tangye pumps in the pit. Those pumps were used for pumping water. On the 7th July, I went down the pit at two o'clock in the afternoon. I found No.1 pump all right. I relieved Wm. Conkie. I had to oil the pumps. That was the first thing I did when I got to them. I used engine oil. I also cleaned the lamp at No.1 station. I cleaned the lamp with a bit of wire. The lamp has no wick in; but I cleaned the lamp burner with a bit of wire to make it burn brighter. (Mr. Hedley explained that the lamp burned the vapour of the oil, similarly to the naphtha lamps that are used at the fairs by showmen.) I then watched the pumps, and kept the water down. Just before bait time, I put some more paraffin oil in the lamp. Bait time was six o'clock. I put the oil into the smaller of the lamps now produced. (The lamp that was burning at the time of the accident.) I know the lamp by its burner. It was about three hours after that that something else happened. I cleaned the lamp again during those three hours, to see if I could get it to burn brighter. I cleaned it once. The paraffin oil I put into the lamp I got in a tin bottle at the surface, before I went down. The bottle was full when I got it. The lamp into which I had poured the oil did not take the whole bottle - full. I put the tin containing the remainder on to a shelf, near the pump - about a yard and a half from the pump. When going from one part of the pit to another I had candles, which were supplied to me by the Company. No.1 pump was the main pump we had to stop at, but I was going backwards and forwards between No.1 and No.2 pumps. I was using a candle to light me. I had four candles when I went on duty, and I burnt three. I had no matches, and lighted the candles at the lamp. There was waste on a shelf at No.1 pump, and I used it to clean the pump. After I had used the waste, I put it down beside the pump. I had no special orders as to what I was to do with the waste after using it. There was not a large quantity of waste lying about. The boy who went before me had just taken a lot of waste out that morning. We made a heap, and then cleared it away; and it had had been cleared away that morning. I just used two little handful. The pump did not go wrong that morning. About twenty - five minutes to nine, I was down No.2 dip, seeing if the water was all right. I found it right. I put the No.2 pump on rather slower action, and then came up the dip to No.1 pump. As I approached it, I observed a fire at the pump, high up. I got a bucket of water and threw it on. The fire was at the top of the pump - it was blazing right up the pump. Was the flames coming from the burner, or what was it coming from? I could not say, sir. The water I threw on made the fire worse. I threw only one bucket of water. I then went and warned the men. I first warned Tommy Toomey, at the bottom of No.8 rise. He shouted to John Newby, who came down the rise and came out to No.5 flat sheets and then went back to warn the other men who were higher up. In the meantime Tommy Toomey got the bucket, but put it down again when he found he could do nothing with the fire. Then he went to warn the other men, and I went to the bottom of No.8 rise. I had not long to stay until the men came - two or three minutes. Then we all tried to get out through the smoke, by No.1 dip. Then we went to No.8 rise and tried to get out there, but were prevented by the smoke. We then returned to No.1 dip and we found smoke there. Edward Crears said "Here goes for the dip," and he set off, and we followed him. I got as far as the tram, which was not quite the top of the dip. I could go no further. I fell, and lost consciousness; but before doing so I shouted, and when I came to myself Tommy Toomey had hold of my hand when I got to the flatsheets on the dip top. I have since heard that Mr. Bell brought me round by artificial respiration. By Mr. Atter: I was engaged about eight weeks at the pumps. I had had no previous experience at any other pit. I saw John Newby somewhere between two and six o'clock. I did not see Newby make any inspection of the pumps. I have seen fire at the pumps before this one. There's been a fire twice before with me. I did not report those fires to anyone. I did not say a word about it to anyone. Why did you not? Was the wood fired the same as on the 7th of July? Yes, the wood was fired on one occasion, and the pump on the other. If the pump was burning, it must have been oil burning on the pump? Yes, we had to mix the engine oil with paraffin. How had the oil got there? It had blown through the cocks. Which was the first of those two fires? The woodwork. Did you do anything to put out that fire? Yes; I threw water on it and put it out. How long did that fire last? About five minutes. When did the fire occur? Within a fortnight of my going to work down the pit. Who helped you to put the fire out? David Taylor, one of the men who has been killed. Who was the overman that shift? John Newby. You never named this to him? No, sir. But he would see it, wouldn't he, if it was five minutes burning? No, sir; he was higher up and knew nothing about it. When did the second fire take place? About three weeks before the 7th of July. The fire was then on the pumps. How long did it burn? Oh, I catched it in time, sir. But how long was it burning? Two or three minutes, and I threw a bucket of water on it and put it out. How much water did you put on the first fire? Half a dozen buckets. David Taylor handed me them up from the sump. We never reported that. What caused the fire in the woodwork. Could not say, sir. What caused the fire on the pump? The oil on it. Sometimes the lamp jumped, and burning oil dropped from it. Was there sometimes old waste below on which the burning oil might fall? No, sir; and it was over wet to burn if it had caught it. You say the fire was at the top of the pump, high up, on the 7th July. Was that the woodwork that you saw on fire? Yes, the woodwork was burning; both the woodwork and the oil on the pump was burning. How long had you been away from No.1 pump before you saw the fire? About ten minutes. Can you see No.1 pump when you are at No.2? No, sir. Was the lamp at No.1 where you had left it? It was hanging up as I had left it. Had you a bottle of paraffin at all that night? Yes, on the shelf. How near to the pump? About a yard and a half. When had you last used paraffin out of the bottle? That afternoon. Was that a small glass bottle? No, it was a tin bottle. There was another tin containing the oil for the pump. They would be a yard and a half from the lamp. What had caused this fire on the 7th? I could not say, sir. Do you know what caused the fire on either of the other occasions? It was by the oil on the pump firing, on the second fire. And how did it catch fire? By the lamp "lowing" up. Did you see that, or do you only suppose it was? I saw it lowing up, sir. The Coroner: If the pump had been properly cleaned there ought not to have been any oil on it? It was from the cocks blowing the oil out. By Mr. Atter: Whose duty was it to clean the lamps? It was my duty. Because we have been told it was Tolson's duty? Yes, sir. I sent Tolson the burner up that day. Mr. Hedley said Tolson was responsible for the lamp, and this lad had simply to trim it. Witness said he last sent the burner of the big lamp up to Tolson to clean about five weeks before the fire on the 7th July. They were using the big lamp at No.1 at that time; and the other lamp they had not at all, then - they had not yet got it. It was Tolson's duty to clean the lamp burner. By Mr. Brown: When the lamp burner required cleaning it was sent up to Tolson. When cleaning the burner with a bit of wire, I simply knocked the soot off; that was all I had to do. It burned better then. And burnt steadier? No, it jumped a little bit after taking the fluff off. Did you see Southward just before you went down to No. 2 dip? No, but I saw him when I returned. How was it you did not report the first fire, when David Taylor helped you to put it out? No reply. Question repeated? (After further hesitation) I did not know whether it was any use telling him or not. During the first three weeks we used the big lamp, and I sent it up to Tolson three times to clean. The small lamp that we used afterwards made a much smaller flame. I don't know whether it was new, but it was new to us. When the first fire took place we had the little one. When I left No. 1 pump to go to No. 2, on the 7th July, the lamp was not burning very well - it was smoking, and the flame was jumping up. It had been that way since after bait time. He had been down that shift, once. I never said anything to him about having those two fires. Why? No answer. The Coroner: You really must answer the question. Witness: I did not think it was necessary to report it. I don't know whether there are special rules for the pit. The Coroner read the special rule showing that the witness ought to have reported the fire, and asked if he really thought it was not necessary to report a fire that was jeopardizing the lives of the men in the pit? Witness said he thought he could get the fire out. The Coroner: Where you frightened to go and tell? No, sir. Mr. Brown said there was a man in the pit who appeared to have known of it, and did not report it. Mr. Atter: We have known of it before, and we did not get it from this lad. The Coroner: It is a most singular thing that lad did not go and report it. Were you afraid to tell? Witness: No. Mr. Flynn: There is another way of looking at it. It might be a common occurrence. Mr. Brown: I don't think you have any right to say so. Mr. Flynn: Well, he had only been there ten weeks, and had tow fires before. Mr. Brown: I think we have to deal with the evidence, and not with what isn't evidence. Mr. Hedley said the point that was of importance was that there might be others like witness, who did not know what the rules required; and they should understand that where they become aware of any source of danger in the pit it was their duty to report it to some of their superiors. Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman, the witness said the legs that were on fire the first time were distant about two yards for the burner of the lamp, which was hardly so high as the two feet. He had very often spilled paraffin oil in filling the lamp; nearly every time they poured it the spilled some of it. By Mr. Flynn: In case of the exhaust pipes being frozen I have never teemed oil on waste and set fire to it to thaw it. I have never heard of others doing that. I did not continue to throw on water on July 7th because I could not stand the smoke. There was more flame than there was on the occasion of the first fire when we put six bucketfuls on. No one ever asked me, all the time I was there, the reason of the scorched legs. Newby never asked me how it had occurred. I have heard of fire occurring on the other boys' shifts during the ten weeks I have been employed there. Hartley Stables told me that he had reported a fire at No. 1 pump. He lives at the Marsh, St. Bees. He is not here today. He did not tell me what the deputy said when he told him. The Coroner said what the deputy told him would scarcely be admissible. Mr. Flynn said if the deputy made light of it when he reported if and told him to take it to — — -, it would be of importance that that should be known. By Mr. Hedley: I never had any experience before I took charge of these pumps. Wm. Conkie, the pump lad who was on before me, gave me instructions what to do - just how to oil it and set it on. Did he tell you what to do in case the exhaust got frozen up? Yes, he showed me how to put the burner so that less oil would come through. Where was the burner? Against the side of the pump. Had you any difficulty about the ice at any time? When the lamp would not burn right the engine would not work. Did he tell you how to get it to work again in a case of that sort? Yes. Take a screw key and knock the ice out of it. Did he tell you to mix the oil with paraffin, put it on the cylinder, and light it up? No, sir. I think you told Mr. Flynn you have not done that yourself. Have you seen anybody else do it? No, sir. You are sure about that? Yes, sir. Is the floor of the No.1 engine house wet or dry? It is wet. All the legs wet - the side timbers? No; just a bit at the bottom. What sized heaps of old waste did you have before you cleared it out? I have had about a bucket and a half. What became of it? I don't know; but I think it would go up the pit on a bogey. One of my mates sent it up. What had you the buckets for? We kept a bucket in No. 1 engine house filled with water and one in No. 2, in order to put out any fire that took place. But you had no lamp at No. 2. What did you want with a bucket of water there? To prime the pump. Does No. 1 not want priming? No, sir. And do you mean that you are so afraid of fire at No. 1 that you keep a bucket of water there? We are told to keep it there. Who told you to keep it there, and for what purpose? Jock Barry told me to keep a bucket of water at No. 1 in case of fire. He did not tell me about No. 2. We keep No. 1 bucket full, but the other we fill as we want it, form the dip. When knocking off the fluff from the burner have you ever seen the fluff flare up after it has reached the ground? No, sir; I have seen the lamp flare up. Had you trimmed this lamp immediately before you went to No. 2 on this day of the accident? Yes. How long after you trimmed the lamp did you go away to No. 2? About three-quarters of an hour. You have told us about two previous fires. Did the pump stop at the first fire you know of, when the timber got alight? No, sir. Are you sure about that? Yes, sir. Were you in the place at the time it occurred? No, sir. Where were you? Down in the other dip. I found the lamp up against the pump in its ordinary position whilst that fire was going on. John Tolson deposed: I live at Moor Row, and am a blacksmith and a fitter in the employment of the Southam Mining Company. I was at the pit on the 7th July. My duties at the mine are those of blacksmith and fitter. I know No. 1 pump and the lamp that was used at No. 1 pit. My duties with regard to these were to fix the pumps and see that they were kept in working order. As to the lamp, I don't know that I had any duties, after first making the fountain and fixing the burner into the stem and testing it and seeing that it gave satisfaction. The smaller lamp was never through my hands afterwards; but the burner was brought to me - I recollect once, but I cannot recollect any more - in order to have the burner cleaned. It seems through the heat the lamp the oil leaves a sediment in the passage, and that has to be bored out; the burner passage had got stopped up. I put it right. There could be no leak from the fountain or stem, unless they were damaged. I have examined the lamp since the accident, and I found it damaged. I produce the damaged tube. The burner was broken off and part of it was in the tube. I found the burner on what is called the muck bank - the bank of debris thrown out from the mine. The burner was damaged, too. I put the burner on to a new tube, and put that tube into the lam, as it now appears. The tube now in the lamp is three inches linger that the broken tube. As this stage, half-past five, the inquest was further adjourned till 10.20 on Monday morning next.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 12 Mar 2023
|
Search |
|
|||