|
23rd June 1899, Page: 5, Column: 6 Fatal Accident In Goathland Whinstone MinesCoroner's InquestYesterday (Thursday) afternoon, at the Esk Valley Reading-room, before Mr. W. L. Carrick, coroner for the Stokesley district, an inquiry was held into the circumstances relative to the death of John Edward Porritt, 19 years of age, of Esk Valley, who died on Wednesday noon from the results of an accident, sustained whilst following his employment in the Goathland whinstone mines, some nine weeks ago. Mr. John Plummer (inspector of mines) watched the case on behalf of the Home Office. Mr. Thompson Foster Porritt, whinstone miner, of Esk Valley, identified the body the jury had just seen as being that of his brother. He received an injury at Goathland Whinstone Mines, on the 21st April, to his leg, below the knee, and had been confined to the house ever since. On Wednesday, two doctors performed an operation, and deceased died shortly after. Mr. John Harland, whinstone quarryman, living at Grosmont, deposed that he was working with deceased on the 21st April, at Goathland quarry. On that day the deceased was shoving a wagon in the mine down to the main road. He had his back to it; and the roof came down and caught one of his legs. The roof was not propped at this place. About half-a-ton would come down altogether, and, to his knowledge, it all went on to his leg. When they lifted him out he talked all right, though he appeared to have been unconscious. He and a man named Harrison helped to bring him out of the mine. No one was working there at the time; it had never been worked through at that place for about two years. He had worked with the deceased for a short time, and he appeared to be quite healthy. He had never known any stone going bad at that place, nor yet had he known of a fall. Dr. W. G. Dreaper, medical officer for the Egton district, said about noon on the 21st April he was called to see the deceased, who, he had been told, had been injured at the quarry. When he went to the house he found him on a shutter, and suffering severely from the shock of the accident. Upon examination, he found there was a very bad compound cominuted fracture of both bones of the leg. about five inches above the ankle. He removed several large pieces of bone, which were lying quite lose. He had to decide as to whether he should take the limb off directly, or whether he should try to save it, but he eventually decided to endeavour to save it, leaving the alternative to a later date. He got the leg into a good position, taking into consideration the severity of the accident, and it went on comparatively favourably for six weeks. At the end of that period he had to change the splints on account of trouble in the sole of the foot and heel. A few days afterwards, owing to the fresh position of the foot, it was evident that the bones had not united, and he then decided to perform an operation, and it was during the operation that the death occurred. He asked Dr. English, of Sleights, to give chloroform whilst he amputated the leg. For the last fortnight, the deceased had been rapidly losing ground, due to profuse suppuration of the wounds. Had he not taken the leg off, the deceased would have wasted away — death must have resulted. He had practically completed the operation when deceased expired. Dr. English drew his attention to the fact that deceased's pulse had stopped. They tried artificial respiration for some time, but without success. He obtained deceased's permission to amputate the leg, and, though he was weak, he certainly thought he could safely give him chloroform. His opinion of the cause of death was the result of two causes — shock from the operation, and the depressing effects of chloroform upon the heart. Dr. T. H. English, of Sleights, said he was asked on the Wednesday to give an anaesthetic to the deceased. He saw him about eleven o'clock, and he then looked very weak and bloodless. They both recognised the risk of the operation and anaesthetic, and prepared for it. He gave deceased chloroform, which he took very easily, but in the middle of the operation his pulse suddenly got weak. However, it pulled up again. That made him (witness) anxious about him, and he gave very little more chloroform. Dr. Dreaper was approaching the completion of the operation, when the patient became sick, and he asked if he could discontinue the aanesthetic. He gave over for about three minutes and the pupil of the eye showed he was coming to himself again, but, suddenly the heart failed. They tried the ordinary method to get him round, but their efforts were unavailing. It was perfectly necessary to save life to perform an operation, and he should have performed it if he had been similar circumstanced to Dr. Dreaper. The jury, over whom Mr. R. Hay was foreman, returned a verdict in accordance with the medical testimony — "That death resulted from the shock of the operation and the depressing effect of chloroform upon the heart."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||