Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th March 1899

The Fatality At A Frizington Mine

Mine On The Creep

An Error Of Judgment

The adjourned inquest touching the death of Thos. Lowden, miner, of 103, Ennerdale Road, Cleator Moor, who was killed by falling from a cage down the shaft at Dalmellington Pit, Frizington, on the 23rd ult., was held at the New Crown Inn, Cleator Moor, on Friday, by Mr. Webster, coroner for the lordship of Egremont, and a jury, of which Mr. J. Flynn was foreman. Messrs. W. Leck and A. D. Nicholson, H.M. Inspectors of Mines, attended the inquiry, and Mr. Gordon Falcon, Workington, was present on behalf of the widow of deceased.

Wm. Brady, Main Street, Frizington, a banksman at Dalmellington Pit, said on Wednesday, February 22nd, he went on duty at 4-30 in the afternoon. He saw deceased about half an hour before he went down the pit. He descended the shaft about ten o'clock with Wm. Stables, and Thomas Powell, and his shift should have continued until six o'clock next morning. Shortly after ten o'clock John Martin and John Thompson were lowered down the shaft for the purpose of doing some repairs. They took wood with them, and the cage remained where these men were working, and did not come up the shaft again until they ascended with it about midnight. They then came up for some more wood, which they got, and then went back again. They continued their work in the shaft for another two hours, when they returned to the surface to get something to eat, and went into the hut for that purpose. The cage remained at the surface, and about a quarter of an hour Thompson and Martin came up the last time the engineman shouted to witness and the others who were having their bait to come round. Martin and Thompson then got on their clothes to go down the shaft. They were then lowered to the bottom of the pit to pick Lowden up.

J. H. Woolcock, engineer, produced a tracing of a plan he had made of the shaft. It was a double shaft, and two cages were run in it. Witness, replying to Mr. Leck, said the shaft had been, under repair for some considerable time during the afternoon and night shifts. They always kept a banksman on the pit, top during repairs. Witness had not given the banksman special instructions, but he had done so to the overman to the effect that every precaution was to be taken, and that no one was to ride in the shaft during work of repairing. The overman in question was John Rowe. In the event, of an accident taking place, in the pit, the men at the bottom could get out by going into an adjoining pit, belonging to the Parkside Mining Company. The witness Brady now resumed his evidence. By Mr. Falcon: His duty was to receive signals and warn the engineman. He shouted to the engineman that the men (Martin and Thompson) were clear, and that they (witness included) were going to have their bait, and he replied "All right." The place where witness and the two men went was so situated that witness could not hear signals or give signals back. At the time he went to get his bait he was aware there were three men working down the mine. He could not hear the engine running.

By the Foreman: The noise of the pumping engine prevented them hearing this in the hut.

By Mr. Falcon: When he told the engineman they were going to get their bait, the engineman did not ask if the shaft was clear.

By the Foreman: There was a direct signal from the bottom of the pit to the engine house. Witness had no signal for the engineman. The only means of signalling that witness had was by shouting to him, and he could hear him plainly. The engine house was only about ten yards away from witness's place.

By Mr. Leck: When witness shouted to the engineman that all was clear he, meant that the two men had left the shaft; that did not mean that he was at liberty to raise or lower the cage. He should not do so without a signal from witness. Witness did not ask Martin and Thompson when they came up for their bait whether the shaft was clear.

By the Foreman: There were no catches to hold the cage when it came to the pit top.

Wm. Stables, 89, Ennerdale Road, Cleator Moor, miner, in the employ of the Dalmellington Company, said he went to the pit on the night of the 22nd ult., and descended the shaft, shortly after ten o'clock with Lowden and Thos. Powell, to follow their usual employment on the night shift. They went down in the south cage, and continued their work until about two o'clock next morning, when they sat down to get their bait. While doing so they heard some falls overhead, and the place around them began to be uneasy. Consequently witness and his two companions got up and came nearer to the shaft, and while they were standing there more falls took place. They moved still further towards the shaft, and witness and Powell stood while Lowden walked to the bottom of the shaft. Shortly afterwards he returned to them, and as the place was still on the creep, witness said, "I doubt we are not going to get anything more done to-night," and they made towards the shaft to leave the pit. They were most anxious to get out of the danger from the falling roof, and deceased knocked rather sharply. The cage then came down to the level of the platform. They ultimately got on to the cage. Witness got on first, and then Powell said "You get on, Lowden," but deceased replied, "No, you go on, you have better clothes on than me." Powell then went to the same side as witness, and deceased afterward knocked, and got on to the cage himself. They then commenced the ascent, and when they had gone about three parts of the way up the shaft there was a crash and witness received a knock on the head. He exclaimed. "Oh, Lord, what's that?" and Powell answered "Oh, Bill, I'm done." Witness put out his hand to see if he could feel him, and failing to do so he put his foot out to see if he could find his feet or legs. He touched Powell's feet with his clog, and found he was all right, and he had better look out for himself, for poor Lowden was down. Witness continued to keep hold of Powell, until they got to the surface, and then helped him to get off the cage. He did not see the banksman, Brady, on the pit top when they arrived. The engineman was in the engine house and witness shouted to him "Jimmy, come here." He came, and witness asked him what had fallen down the shaft. He said, "Oh Bill, what's up?" Witness replied, "Nothing, nothing, here, but Lowden is down the shaft." The engineman then went to fetch Thompson and Martin who were in the cabin having their bait and they, with Brady, came round to the surface. Witness asked Brady if he knew what had fallen down the shaft, and he answered "Nothing that I know of." Thompson then said, "It must have been a stage plank that we had in the shaft." Immediately after Thompson, Martin, and witness descended the shaft in the south cage. They went down for about 40 fathoms and then stopped. At that point they found a piece of the stage plank sticking in the shaft. They placed the plank on the wall-plate beside the shaft, and continued the descent as far as the "eye," where they found the remainder of the plank. Thompson got off and placed it by the side, and they afterwards descended to within about four feet from the bottom of the pit. Martin then called out that-deceased was there, and they had the cage stopped. Martin jumped out on to the flat sheets, and witness and Thompson followed, and they found deceased quite dead in the southern division of the shaft.

He was in a sitting position. They thereupon got on the cage again and ascended the shaft for the purpose of getting something to wrap the body in. They afterwards descended again and brought up the body.

By the Coroner: All these rappings which they had given were made in the ordinary way. The men working in the shaft were not in the habit of leaving the stage planks in the shaft. They could have been removed and placed on the wall-plates without being dangerous.

By Mr. Falcon: They were the only three men working in the lower part of the pit that night, and the drift they were driving was through a fall. It was dangerous work. No deputy or overman came to consult with them that night, and they were left to their own resources. They were therefore bound to use their own discretion. The signals used in the pit between workmen and the engineman and surface, were as follows :— Two knocked meant lower the cage, three knocks informed the engineman that men desired to ride the shaft, and the lifting and lowering of the cage which followed meant that all was right. There was nothing else to show that it was all right. The bell had been altered since. The lifting and lowering of the cage showed that the engineman had accepted the signals and they could ride. They then gave one knock to signify that they were ready to go, and accordingly they went up the shaft without any warning whatever from anyone. There was a good deal of water coming down this shaft, and owing to that there was some difficulty in holding on to the cage. They did not care to use the cross-bar on account of the wet running down their sleeves.

The Court, at this stage, adjourned for an hour.

On resumption, Stables, in reply to Mr. Leck, said the covers on the cage top were down in the proper way. They had no light with them at the time. They heard no signal back from the hammer in reply to their signal of three knocks. The answer was the moving up and down of the cage, which they took to mean that all was right for their going up.

The engineman, James Black, was called, and warned by the Coroner that the evidence so far was of such a nature as tended to criminate him. He could give evidence if he desired. Black declined to give evidence.

John Thompson, landlord of the "New Crown", who was one of the men engaged in repairing the shaft, was similarly warned by the Coroner. He said he would give evidence. During the night they had to go up several times to get wood. They took no staging planks down with them, as far as he could recollect. They were already in the shaft and were lying on the side bars. When they began working they put these planks across the shaft. They came up for breakfast shortly after two o'clock on the 23rd, and before doing so they moved the staging a little so that the rope would not run against it. There was only one staging plank there then, as they had taken the other two they were using up the shaft earlier in the evening. This did not leave sufficient room for the cage to travel up and down. They were aware at that time that there were men in the pit and Martin also knew.

Could you have put the plank so as to have left sufficient room for the cage to travel? — No.

Could you not have taken it out? — Yes, but we did not do so because we wanted to come back to work.

By Mr. Falcon: Their work in the shaft was about 40 fathoms from the top, and there were about another 100 fathoms, to the bottom. There were just two of them in the shaft that night, and not three. A third man had been working with them other nights. His name was Wm. Rowe. Rowe was not a banksman, but was assisting Brady to bring the timber to the shaft. It was too heavy for Brady to bring himself. Witness and Martin took two pieces of timber down the shaft during the night. The last piece of wood went down about twenty-five minutes to two.

Mr. Falcon: Did you know whether any men would come up? — We did not expect anyone to come up the shaft until six o'clock on the morning of the 23rd. I did not make any report to Brady or the engineman about leaving the shaft obstructed.

The Coroner: Why did you not do that? — We don't do that until the time is up for us to leave. Then we do it.

By the Foreman: The three men in the pit were aware that we were repairing the shaft.

The engineman, James Black, of Queen Street, Cleator Moor, again called into the room, now said he was willing to give evidence. He was in charge of the engine for lowering and raising the cages. On the morning of the 23rd he received a signal from the bottom of the pit to lower the cage. He did not act upon this at once, and shortly after he received another signal to lower which he responded to. When the cage got on the bottom he received a signal that some men wanted to come up. He answered it by moving the cage for them, and they answered back by knocking one, upon which he lifted them away until they reached the surface. They then called to him to come to them and told him they had lost one of their number out of the cage. Upon that witness went and informed Thompson, Martin and Brady what had happened, and he asked them if they had left any obstruction. Thompson replied that there was a plank, but it would do no damage. Witness then told him that it had done damage as there was a man off the cage. They then went to the shaft and the body of the deceased was ultimately brought up.

The Coroner: What induced you to answer the signal and bring up those men from the bottom? — Because they wanted to come.

Did you in any way satisfy yourself that the shaft was clear? — Yes, previously to receiving the signal to bring up the south cage. I received a signal that the shaft was clear. I received this signal from William Brady. He just shouted "Clear."

Brady, re-examined by the Coroner; said that when he signalled to the engineman he shouted "The men are clear." He did not say the shaft was clear, because he did not know.

The Coroner said the main question the jury had to consider was as to whether they thought there was anybody responsible for the death of this unfortunate man. There seemed to be a dispute between the two persons mostly interested in the matter — the engineman and the banksman. The engineman said he received the signal from Brady, who shouted "clear" to him, and this gave him the impression that the shaft was clear. But Brady had told them that when he shouted to the engineman that "all was clear" he meant this to apply to the two shaftsmen who had just come up to get their bait. The question was could the jury reconcile this, or did they think Brady had made a mistake by saying "clear," when the shaft was not clear, or, on the other hand, did they think the engineman had been mistaken in supposing the banksman said it was clear? Unfortunately the two shaftsmen could not recollect when they came up at two o'clock hearing Brady give any signal. The question, therefore, was whether the jury considered Black or Brady or the two men working in the shaft guilty of such negligence as to make them criminally responsible for what happened to Lowden, or whether on the other hand they had committed an error of judgement.

The jury, after deliberating by themselves for about fifteen minutes, returned a verdict of "Accidental death," and added that they were of opinion that there had been an error of judgment on the part of one or whole of the four workmen — James Black, William Brady, John Thompson, and John Martin.

The inquiry lasted nearly five hours.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Black, James    Engineman  
Brady, William    Banksman  
Falcon, Gordon    Solicitor  
Flynn, J.    Jury Foreman  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lowden, Thomas   38 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Martin, John    Miner  
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Powell, Thomas    Miner  
Rowe, John    Overman  
Rowe, William    Miner  
Stables, William    Miner  
Thompson, John    Miner  
Webster, John    Coroner  
Woolcock, Joseph H.    Engineer  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Holebeck (Iron Ore)  Holebeck (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
02 Mar 1899  Falling Down A Pit Shaft (Whitehaven News)
09 Mar 1899  The Fatality At A Frizington Mine, Mine On The Creep, An Error Of Judgment (Cumberland Pacquet)
02 May 1899  Shocking Fatality At Frizington (Cumberland Pacquet)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Holebeck (Metalliferous)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print