|
23rd February 1899 The Cumberland Iron Ore DepositsThe following article, from the pen of Mr. W. Wilson Barnes, mining engineer, appears in Saturday's issue of the "iron and steel trades journal." Excepting Hodbarrow mines, on the estuary of the river Duddon, in South Cumberland — the Duddon divides Cumberland and Lancashire — and Knockmurton (in the skiddaw slates), the known or proved ore field of west Cumberland (in the carboniferous limestone), is only some 11 square miles. The present position is that in Cleator, Frizington, and Lamplugh, where the oldest mines are, there is know prospect of increased raisings. Many of the older mines are now, and have for sometime past been engaged in getting all they can preparatory to closing, and, as a matter of course must cease working at an early date. In the immediate neighbourhood, other than Whinnah, in the Lamplugh district, there is little or no chance of new discoveries in the old mining field. Statements were made sometime ago that in a certain mine ore had been found in the slate, i.e., to say that the ore deposits worked in the limestone were found to run into the slate lying immediately below. Such statements are incorrect, as there has not been found any deposits of ore in any mine in Cumberland that has continued after the slate has been reached. It is fully recognised in the district at the time of putting down boreholes to test the ground that should ore not be found before the chisel cuts into the slate (Skiddaw), there is know chance of getting ore, and the hole is immediately stopped and the trial regarded as a failure. With the exception of the Egremont district and along the foreshore near Hodbarrow, where the Hodbarrow Mining Company, limited, are boring below high water mark, in front of their sea wall, built some 12 years ago, there is no new discovery. The Hodbarrow Company are now engaged in building a second sea wall in front of the existing one, i.e., a wall more seawards, so as to enable them to win the ore known to lie under the sea. At the Roan head Hematite Mines, on the Lancashire side of the estuary — of the river Duddon, a large body of ore has recently been got, and it suggest the possibilities of the run of ore existing under the estuary being continuous from Hodbarrow on the Cumberland side to Roanhead on the Lancashire borders. Not long ago proposals were made to build a dam between Hodbarrow and Roanhead so as to enable the area between Cumberland and Lancashire, in the neighbourhood of Duddon, to be bored for iron ore with a view of seeing whether there was a continuing run of ore between the points named, and also with a view of reducing the mileage of the Furness Railways. This would mean closing the Duddon as a shipping port, and the costs would run into millions of pounds, and it is not "desirable to construct a dam across the estuary of the Duddon" as had been advocated. Indeed, considering the Duddon rushes up the estuary at a speed of over 10 miles an hour, and the immense volume of water that would be diverted by the building of the dam - if it be possible, which the writer much doubts - it would mean flooding the area of low lying lands on both sides, more particular Cumberland. Without interfering with shipments at Borwick Rails Harbour, or without closing the port, the Duddon estuary could be narrowed, and by training walls, embankments, and lochs, arranged so as to reclaim a large acreage. The engineering difficulties are pretty stiff, but the chief thing is to be assured the deposits of ore are there, to warrant he outlay. The area of the mountain limestone that is now ore-yielding in West Cumberland has been tested to its boundary, or nearly so, and in the attempt to find ore, a borehole over 200 fms deep has ended in the limestone (i.e., the limestone that not been passed through by the chisel at 200 fms), yet it is probable enough that by still deeper borings the hole might cut ore, if not in the limestone between the limestone and the Skiddaw slate. The decline in production of local ores is due to two cause's lessened area of search near the older mines and many years of bad times. The exaction's of Lords of Manors have repeatedly been set up as the great drawbacks to more extended search and mining, but when competing mine owners bid one over the other for royalties, it is hardly likely manorial owners will do Quixotic enough to lease at lower terms. Indeed the matter simply resolves into a question of supply and demand. Repeatedly the inequalities of railway rates — particularly upon coke to Cumberland — as compared with other district smelters, have been put before the railway companies. Temporary rebates only have been obtained in depressed markets, but with advance in values they are withdrawn. The West Coast smelter cannot get competitive rates with the East Coast, and under the monopolies held by the railway companies it can scarcely be expected that they will give away a material proportion of receipts. Looking geologically upon the Cleator, Frizington, Egremont ore fields of West Cumberland, the Hodbarrow, which are mines of the southern portion of the country, Dalton and Lindal and district of Furness, it will be seen that these (the three ore raising districts that are so far the only known or proved places of material deposit of mines that can depend upon for supply in the carboniferous limestone) are upon or near the faulted lines, and where such limestone is fringing and is immediately under laid by the Skiddaw slate. There seems only one sound theory — only a single argument of any value to assist, or to be of use towards looking for a new field as likely to contain ore, and it is that many years ago propounded by the great chemist, Bischoff. His replacement theory, carefully followed up and thoughtfully looked into, brings home the fallacies of all other theories, as to the Haematite origins and depositions, and not only this but more importantly and commercially, it may influence, as it offers a prospect of entirely new sources of supply; indeed it does more than this, it suggests that where ore is found in one section of Cumberland under certain geological conditions, systematic search only is needed to very probably develop other fields. In his well-known work "The Iron-ore fields of Great Britain and Ireland," Mr. J. D. Kendall has ably enlarged upon Bischoff‘s theory. But perhaps, there may be something even of greater moment, commercially, in what Mr. Kendall says it is "and seeing that the earths crust would be thinner at those points where the Skiddaw slate was on the surface than at other points where it was covered by rocks of a later age, an also that at the former points the uplifting action was greatest, and therefore the fractures and dislocations would be greatest, it follows that there the volcanic emanations would be most abundant." In other words, this suggests the nearer to the fringe of the carboniferous limestone — resting upon the Skiddaw slate - so is the prospect of there being iron ore. The known fields are so situated. This prompts a view of other parts of the country — a systematic examination with the object of seeing whether such other parts have similar geogical conditions as have the area where ore is now, and has for years being raised. Found at other parts of the country, an area having its rocks similarly in geological order, and accepting the Bischoff-Kendall theory of both origin and replacement — deposition — systematic search only seems needed to bring into being new ore fields. Many authorities have not been wanting in freely expressing themselves that the "prospects of new discoveries of hematite iron ore are very unlikely outside the known fields, and that the West Coast must in a short time be nearly wholly dependent on foreign ores! With all modesty, yet confidentially the writer differs from such views, and ventures saying that the prospects of entirely new discoveries of hematite iron ore in other parts of the country are more than probable, and not only this, but acreage favourable to hematite iron ore bearing is many times greater than the now known fields! For Eaglesfield, Plumbland, Bothell, Threapland, Bolton, Nedale, Heskett, New market, Hutton Hoof and southwards are of the carboniferous formations, and have the limestone, as in Cleator district. To the North is the Whitehaven and other sandstones and shales, to South, several volcano rocks along with the skiddaw slates. At several points when cutting foundations by outcrops in old limestone quarries, and in beds of streams, hematite iron ore has been found. It is not intended to assert that workable bodies of ore will be got, or are a sequence of every surface indication! The great features in favour of deposits of ore are the similarity of the geological order of the country. The relative positions of volcanic and sedimentary rocks to the known fields. Given these no forcible reason can be brought forward to say there are improbabilities of ore, but to the very contrary. Search of hematite iron ore by borehole is at best hit or miss. Within an area where the several formations are in the order common to hematite iron ore bearing, there is no certainty that ore may or may not be found until the chisel cuts into the skiddaw slate, when it would be folly to go deeper. Hematite iron ore is found upon the limestone, between the limestone, below the limestone and resting upon Skiddaw slate when such slate has been overlaid by carboniferous limestone during the period of replacement deposition (in natures laboratory) valuable deposits of ore are found at Knockmurton, Kelton fell in true vein form, that are in the slate, but in such cases the slate is to the surface, and was to the surface during the age when replacement, depositions was in process; towards — or growing into, as it may be termed — the condition now presented by the ore. Had the carboniferous limestone extended to Knockmurton (i.e., overlaid at this point the Skiddaw slate), the ore now being mined at Knockmurton would have conditionally been in the limestone and not in the slates. The prospect of successful mining of hematite in Cumberland, for iron ores in granites and volcanic rocks are that no other workable bodies can be found. The very prodigality of surface indications simply means no continuing body. The excessive washes detached boulders and numerous strings of ore scattered over a wide area in the granitic ash rocks prohibited a workable body of ore being found. For any other mineral than hematite iron ore, conditionally the granites and altered ash-rocks may be favourable, but for hematite ores they should be fought shy of in Cumberland, and the more attractive looking they may seem at the surface the more hopeless they are as mines. Apart from hematite's, Cumberland is at yet merely surfaced scratched as to its other Metalliferous mines and the writer ventures saying that had scientific and practical methods ruled in the place of the slip shod, wasteful, and unskilful work so common years ago, the country's metalliferous mining would have, even during the depressing and low prices and foreign competition, have been materially different to what it is at present. There are many valuable properties in copper, manganese, &c., needing only capital and judicious management to yield handsome returns, and if a little of the cash invested by speculative public in many wildcat schemes of foreign mines had been directed to Cumberland, benefit would have resulted. At no period of the country's history has its industrial position been so sound and prosperous as at present, as to iron ore and coal mining, iron and steel making, and given freedom labour disputes there seems many fat years to come. There is, however, no question for the need of some greater energy, indeed boldness, as to getting increased wet dock accommodation. The Cumberland capitalist is credited with being "slow and safe" but if the industrial position has to be maintained he must go with the demand for cheaper freightage and increased railway facilities. If, in the words of Mr. Fletcher, Cumberland "has to be made secured against all competitors for every kind of steel manufactures" she must at once set about finding new iron ore fields, and not only thus equip herself with an enlarged wet dock and increase her railway accommodation so that vessels up to 5,000 tons or more can in all states of the tide load. The foreign imports of ores and exports of steel rails are handicapped seriously through want of a deep-water dock for large vessels. With an up to date dock there would be attracted to the coast sites, new and varied industries. One of the greatest wants of the local smelter is an increased local consumption of pig iron during the time of low prices and keen competion, when his geographical position handicaps him in the home market. Nothing is more calculated to lead to this than the much needed wet dock for Workington. The raw material — pig and steel — is at hand for iron and steel plates, tin plates, pipes, wire, wire rope, mining tools and some bold and concerted effort is at once needed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||