|
7th April 1898 CorrespondenceThe Recent Prosecution At Croft Pit[To The Editor Of The Whitehaven News.] Sir, — In justice to Mr. Redshaw, the manager of Croft Pit, who was advised to plead guilty to the charges preferred by the Inspector of Mines against him, at the Whitehaven Police-court on Thursday last. I think something might be added to the extenuating circumstances adduced by Mr. Chapman, his solicitor, by one who has a more practical acquaintance with the subject. Having had an intimate knowledge of the underground workings at Croft Pit for many years, including the St. Bees main band district, where the breaches of the Mines Act took place. I may fairly claim to write with some little authority on the subject of this letter. In doing so, I purposely refrain from saying anything with the regard to the prosecution by the Inspector and the subsequent conviction by the Bench, but confine myself to the aspect of Mr. Redshaw's position in the case, from a practical point of view. According to sections 50 and 51 of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1887, the manager of the mine is held responsible for any contraventions by any person whomsoever. "Unless he proves that he has taken all reasonable means by publishing and to the best of his power enforcing" the provisions of the Act. No colliery manager, as Mr. Chapman stated, could have done more than Mr. Redshaw had done to carry out the provisions of the Mines Act, and it was never alleged by the prosecution that he was personally culpable of the infractions of the law for which, acting under advice, he admitted responsibility. As Mr. Chapman explained, Mr. Redshaw published at the pit top a printed copy of the regulations for the safe working of the mine; he gave his officials and all workpeople who applied to him a copy of these regulations in pamphlet form; and he appointed overmen and deputy-overmen to see these regulations duly observed, to make daily inspections of the working places, and to make reports of such inspections in books which he specially provided for the purpose, and to send him duplicates of these reports daily. It is simply impossible for any manager unaided to inspect daily every cranny and nook of an extensive mine like Croft Pit, which has been at work for the past 120 years. Indeed, the special rules framed under the Act and officially approved by the Inspector, recognise this fact, for they provide for the appointment of the two classes of subordinate underground officials above named. Stated briefly, the charges made against Mr. Redshaw were (1) for having gas in Marratty's working on certain days (including February 25) contrary to No. 1 General Rule, and (2) for not having a record (of the presence of this gas) in the report book — a non-observance of No. 4 General Rule. The first series of charges may be described as those of commission, and the second as those of omission. The origin of both was the act of taking out the brattice, which carried the air up to the forehead of Marratty's working. This, it transpired, was done by the late Thomas Williams, a deputy-overman, and a responsible official, on the 16th of February. It may here be explained that Marratty's working was a "pointing" or "end" in the Main Band coal, rising at a gradient of 1 in 5, and that, approaching it and destined to hole into it at right angles, was a level working or "board" also in the same seam. Marratty's working had been stopped until this "board" holed into it, where the air was intended to be brought down Marratty's place instead of carrying it up by brattice, which would then be dispensed with. Probably. Williams thought that the "board" was so near holing that he might venture, on his own responsibility, to take out the brattice in Marratty's place, and use it elsewhere for his own convenience. At any rate he did so, without any orders from either Mr. Redshaw or the overman. The effect of the removal of the brattice was to stop the circulation of air in Marratty's place, thereby allowing the gas to collect in the forehead and to gradually descend the hill as it accumulated. It is only fair to Williams to say that at the same time he took out the brattice he fenced Marratty's place off the full width at the bottom or entrance to it, and chalked the words "No Road" on the fence, thus preventing anyone from straying into the working. Fenced off like this Marratty's working was not a danger; and, had the gas been allowed to accumulate until it came to the bottom of that place, it would have there encountered the full current of air undiminished by the leakage of the brattice. If no fence had been erected, and some unsuspecting workman had strayed into the gas and lost his life, then a serious breach of the Act would have been committed, but the fatality that befell Williams on the 25th of February was due to his climbing over the fence he himself had put up, disregarding his own warning to others, and going into an atmosphere of pure gas, leaving his extinguished lamp behind him. No doubt the poor fellow was anxious to ascertain from the sound of the men working in the "board" how far it was off holing into Maratty's Place, and thought he was incurring no risk by going in the dark to the forehead. Mr. Falcon, for the prosecution, very properly asked the bench, not to take into account Williams's death in arriving at their decision: but had not Williams met his end in the unfortunate way in which he did, it is probable that Mr. Redshaw would never have known that there was gas in the working, and it is almost certain that the inspector would not, for a holing was soon affected after the accident and the gas all cleared away. With regard to the second series of charges, — for omitting the record in the report book the presence of gas in Maratty's working, it was the duty, not of Mr. Redshaw, but of the overmen and deputy overmen to do so. Truly, Mr. Redshaw was responsible for their sins of omission. But, when it is taken into consideration that these officials were making daily written reports on the state of the mine, and mentioning anything of an exceptional character, Mr. Redshaw, or any other manager, may be excused for not knowing that there had been any omission. The question naturally arises, why did the overmen and deputy overmen omit to report the gas when it is admitted that they were aware of its presence? It seems that many underground officials including those in the St. Bees district, were under the impression that they were not bound to make written reports of the presence of gas in disused workings that were fenced off. And, really, there was some excuse for their so thinking. A working that is fenced off is barricaded by the officials with planks across the full width at the entrance to it, and the words "No Road" are chalked on the fence. No miner would think of disregarding such a warning when it will be admitted it is far more affected to miners than a report in a book, which at any colliery is seldom, if ever, consulted by the workmen. The report books kept at Croft Pit prove that Maratty's working was fenced off on the 16th of February: and the prevalent idea that is was not obligatory to report gas in a disused fenced-off working accounts for the omission on the part of the overmen and deputy-overmen to report in the books the presence of gas, even when it was known by them to be there subsequently. From these remarks, I think the public will come to the conclusion that although, in the eye of the law, Mr. Redshaw, as manager of the pit, was responsible for the breaches of the General Rules to which he was advised to plead guilty, he was persnally not to blame and is deserving of public sympathy in having to bear the penalty that was imposed on him by the magistrates on Thursday last. Yours faithfully, R. W. Moore.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||