Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

February 1897

Monthly Circular


No. 14.     February.     1897.

 

To The Members.

Gentlemen,

The trade and state of the comity are about as they were when I wrote in January. Towards the end of February we were slightly affected by the strike on the N.E. Railway. Happily, however, a truce was arranged and work resumed, which, it is to be hoped, will eventually lead to a just settlement of all the matters in dispute. All that is needed is a full recognition of what is right. Neither party should want more. Nor should there be an unwillingness (even if the position warranted) to give less. The effect on the general trade of the district indicates how closely we are related to each other, how in the formation of our commercial system, the chain of interdependence links us vitally together, and how careful any man should be, lest his action should tend to dislocate the harmonious working of any part of it.

The Railway Strike.

There is not a single man who will not be glad that the strike on the N.E. Railway is ended ; as there was not a single member, in our Union, who did not sympathise with the men, in their entrance upon, what at first appeared a struggle of a most serious nature. This is all that I or any one else outside the ranks of railwaymen need say. We should not be justified in saying more. Much harm has been done in the past in trades, where strikes were taking place, by men who knew nothing of the merits, rushing upon the scene, and by inflammatory speeches and contorted views, irritating the feeling, widening the breach between employer and workmen, and preventing a settlement of the matters in dispute. This is as I see it. In every organisation there are men at the head whose duty is to watch the relations of the trade, guard the rights of the members, and to give such advice as the occasion and circumstances may require. It is presumption on the part of any man to step in with condemnation or counsel, in the presence and face of these leaders. There are, however, men wise enough in their own conceits, ready at all times to offer gratuitous advice, and censure, and say vile things about those who refuse to take it.

The railwaymen felt they were aggrieved, not only in the matters, which were the primary cause of the stop, but in others. They said they had reached the verge of endurance and the spirit of revolt broke out. Their leaders took up the cause, and, after a few days, advised a return to work, preparatory to a discussion of the matters complained of. Into the merits of the case I enter not; but I do, without the smallest reservation, give the men my word of praise for their acceptance of the advice given by Mr. Harford, and I hope they will place full reliance in him, and trust him to carry out the future stages of the negotiations to their just advantage. I have the honour of knowing Mr. Harford very intimately, and I have had some opportunities of judging of his ability, and I am confident the railwaymen have in him a leader worthy of their trust.

The National Free Labour Association.

There are many paradoxes in these modern times; but none more glaring than this Association, with its loud sounding name and long manifestoes. We have seen non-union men, but it does seem more than a little contradictious in men who denounce trades unions, calling themselves an Association, and issuing their literature from a district office. They call upon their fellow-workmen "to return to work, and refuse to be any longer the catspaws of unscrupulous and self-seeking agitators who live and fatten on the misery of the working classes, and the dislocation of our national trade." The best answer that can be given to that is, the benefits which have come to the railway men. We are not left in doubt as to the intentions of the A.S.R.A., nor the sources of its income, but we are in no little doubt as to why the Free Labour Association was formed, and how its machinery is kept going. We can only speak from indications (and as men as well as trees are known by their fruits), we are forced to conclude that it exists for the purpose of assisting the employers when a dispute takes place. If this be not the aim, for what end is it carried on ? Would it not be more in accord with their action, if the name were changed to "The Employers' Auxiliary Association?" Its first object being to find men to take the places of the workmen who come out on strike against oppressive treatment, or reduction in wages, or to seek for better conditions or higher payment in any trade whatever. The sign above the door of their office would be appropriate if it read "Blacklegs of every grade furnished on the shortest notice, wherever a strike takes place, and the society will guarantee a manifesto of the most insulting nature, while the employer waits." In what does the freedom consist, except it be the freedom to do mischief? It is not a freedom from contributions, for they have offices and officers to maintain, and we are bound to assume that all the income will be gathered from the Free Labourers, and none from any other source.

Employers' Liability Bill.

I casually mentioned in finishing the circular for January, that the Queen's Speech contained one matter of very great importance to the workers of Great Britain, viz., the Employers' Liability Bill. It is placed in a prominent position, and no doubt 'will receive attention during the present Session. There is not a question within the probabilities of legislation which so vitally affects our interest as it does. So far as I have been able to gather, the Government measure of this year will be vastly different from either the present Act of Parliament, or any Bill that has been proposed, to amend it. Whatever form it may take, it will bear the impress of Mr. Chamberlain's mind, if it be not in his hands to pilot through the House of Commons. We may hear the voice of the Home Secretary, but we shall certainly realise that the spirit of West Birmingham is in it. It will be a very safe anticipation to say, that there will be a provision made for all accidents, except such as are considered to be of a trivial or minor nature. Some time of duration being fixed as a test of their eligibility to be included within the scope of the measure.

If this be a proper forecast, then it will be seen that while a money payment may accrue for all accidents which continue beyond a certain time, yet there will be no liability to appear before a court of inquiry for negligence in management, or for the use of defective machinery. Contracting out will reign supreme. This aspect of the case is far more important than the monetary view. It starts a very important question, and one which claims precedence over all other considerations of this subject. What bearing will contracting out — or only being liable to render pecuniary compensation — (say through an insurance company) have upon the list of maimed, or the death roll of the industrial army ? Will this removal of direct liability from the shoulders of the employers to some insurance fund, weaken the sense of responsibility on the part of the employer ? If it can be shown that such an arrangement will give a larger compensation (and if we will, a more certain one), still that is but a secondary consideration, if the result were found to be a greater loss of life, or of injuries to the workers. This is the great fear that exists in the minds of the Labour Members, and, strange to say, it received very strong corroboration from an expression made by Mr. J. Collings, while the Engine and Boilers' Bill was under discussion. In that Bill it is sought to provide certificates for men having charge of steam engines and boilers, and especially those at the winding engines of our mines. Mr. Collings, speaking for the Government, and against certificates and examinations, said if the certificates of competency were granted to the workmen, it would take the responsibility from the shoulders of the employer; and, as a consequence, there would be an increase of accidents. That absolute statement he afterwards sought to soften by saying "Accidents might increase," Take it in any way we like, it shows that in the mind of the Under Secretary for the Home Office, there is a suspicion that to remove responsibility from the employer will not lessen, but may increase the number of accidents. That is the very fear which prompts the great bulk of the working people to object to the contracting out clause, or the passing of an Act which makes provision for all accidents, which is simply contracting out on a larger scale.

How will the employer, who needs the law, to make him feel his responsibility be reached, if he becomes careless when the fear and pressure of the law be taken off? He will be shielded from the scrutiny of the court by the compensatory arrangement, and he will save himself from the monetary aspects of the case by insuring his works, as men insure their property against fire or burglars, or other sources of damage. Already this is in the air. I have heard more than one conversation and calculation as to what the cost will be of such an insurance. Whether it induces greater carelessness or not; the spirit of it is too cold and calculating to be acceptable. These men, in their calculation, feel confident that the Bill will be carried. It may be so, but if it be in conformity with the desires and arrangements of the employers, it will not be acceptable to the working class community. From the very first they have been in opposition to any Act which involved contracting out. That opposition is not any weaker than it was; neither will this newer and more alluring form do anything to soften it. Mr. Chamberlain gave a forecast of his intention in the discussions on the Bill introduced by the Liberal Government. Since that time there have been three Trades Union Congresses, and in each of them, with the greatest unanimity, the proposal has been repudiated. It will be serviceable, at this juncture, if I quote the resolution of the Trades Union Congress for 1895 :—

"That in order to place the law relating to Employers' Liability on a more equitable basis, and to make it more Conducive to safety, this Congress calls upon the Government to so amend the existing Act, that amongst other things, the responsibility may rest upon the employer for the acts of all his employees, or of those of any sub-contractor; and irrespective of the acquiescence of the person killed or injured, that its provisions may apply to the workers in all industries on land or sea, in private or State, or municipal employment; and that contracting out of the Act be illegal, with other alterations, such as the extension of the period of notice, and the removal of the maximum limit of compensation; the Parliamentary Committee to be instructed to draft a measure on these lines, and secure its introduction into the House of Commons as early as possible."

There are indications, clear and explicit, of the mind of the great body of Trades Unionists in that resolution. Their contention has been safety of life and limb, and not money compensation, and they are not to be drawn aside by this or any offer of any money bait. There may be employers such as I have indicated above, whom Mr. J. Collings meant, who will welcome such a chance of shielding themselves, but if I were an employer of labour, with pure intentions, and carrying on my works with proper care, I should, object strongly to having this charge thrown upon me. There are calamities that arise against which we cannot provide, and out of which no blame comes to any one. If an employer is chargeable with this burden, is there not implied guilt ? But we are told it will save litigation, with its consequent expense and irritation. To effect either of these is a great benefit ; but is there not a rather serious and curious doctrine laid down in that statement ? Why was the Employers' Liability Act passed in the first place? Was it not to punish a wrong ? If so, have we to compromise a wrong, or condone an offence ? If this were followed to its logical conclusion, where would it land us ? Litigation might be saved in many ways. Robberies, and injuries to person, and burgularies, mean litigation and expense, but who dreams of compounding with these ? Is it any less a crime to take life, or injury a limb, if not deprive of it altogether, because it results from carelessness in management, or the use of defective machinery ?

But, suppose, a universal scheme of compensation for all accidents established, and as easily as water flowing down a hill, we received the amount arranged by the State for the class of accident Ave had received, whence comes the money ? The ready, but incorrect answer, will be, no doubt, from the employer. It will come no more from him than the water we drink comes from the tap or pipe it runs out of. It may run out of the tap, but it must first have come from the spring or other source. So the money paid will come from the spring of the employer's wealth, the labour of the workman. The employers are alive to that simple truth of political economy. In conversation with one large employer, he admitted that, and it cannot be successfully controverted. It may be denied, but not refuted.

Who is asking for this mode of compensation ? The workmen are not. That I have clearly shown. It is a game of going one better on the part of the Conservative party. It is generally understood that the House of Commons should be a reflex of the opinion of the nation. In this case, however, the order will be reversed. The great question is How does this conform to the wishes of the electorate? If this were submitted to the vote of the electors, it would be rejected by an overwhelming majority, and the Government told that the country was against having these arrangements imported from Germany, marked as English made, and put forward as one of the English wants.

I observe that certain employers are asking for such an arrangement in preference (from their point of view) to having the direct responsibility thrown upon them. The ship-owners of Glasgow have re-issued a circular they sent in 1893 to Mr. Asquith, who, you will remember, at that time, was Secretary for the Home Department. The Liberal Bill sought to include for the first time the sailors. These ship-owners placed their views before Mr. Asquith, and urged upon him an exemption of the sailors. They set forth a long catalogue of reasons why this exemption should take place. The last one being that, in their opinion, "the pressure for this change does not come from the sailors. It is the agitator and the promoter of unions who seek to magnify their office." And then they conclude, — "For all these reasons we venture strongly to urge upon you not to add this new responsibility to the ship-owners. The direction which the provisions for accident should take, should rather be by a general accident or aliment, and might form part of a scheme such as that which Mr. Chamberlain advocates." The lesson which comes from that quotation is plain, and full of warning. The ship-owners are willing to pay money for which they can insure themselves, but their great desire is to avoid an inquiry into the causes of the injuries and deaths. To that we demur, and shall demur. For that which is unpreventable, no agitator can make them responsible, for that which is preventable, no law should shield them from the real consequences, nor hide them from the real penalty.

The Truck Act and Engine and Boilers' Bill.

I must leave these interesting subjects over until next month. Time is proving clearly the effect of the former upon the position of the workers, in the shape of deductions which are being posted on railways, and at many works in the kingdom. The latter of the two has been under discussion in the House, and it will be necessary that the changes it seeks, and the opposition it received, should be set forth fully, in order that we, about the mines in Durham, should (as workmen ought everywhere to) know the true intention of many politicians, as regards the desire of the great body of working people of every class and occupation.

I am, yours,

J. Wilson.

Durham. — 1897


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Asquith, —    M.P.  
Chamberlain, —    M.P.  
Collings, Jesse    Under Secretary of State for the Home Department  
Harford, —      
Wilson, John    Secretary, Durham Miners' Association  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
Jan 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 19 Mar 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print