Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Keswick Guardian

Article from the Keswick Guardian, 23rd January 1897


The Fatal Accident at Threlkeld Quarry

An inquest was held at the Court Buildings, Keswick, on Saturday afternoon by Mr. Gordon Falcon, corner, touching the death of John Gill, which was caused at Threlkeld Granite Quarry on the Thursday morning previous.

The jury was composed as follows:— Messrs. J. F. Hope (foreman), J. Peascod, R. Musgrave, J. Robinson, M. Sanderson, Jon. Scott, E. Bowden, R. Lawrence, J. Rigg, D. Melvin, J. Wilson, J. S. Allinson, T. Reed. Mr. I. Lowthian, solicitor, was present on behalf of the widow of the deceased, and Mr. Musgrave appeared in the interests of the Threlkeld Granite Company, Limited. Mr. Oswald, Government Inspector, Carlisle, was also present.

Charles Macintosh, 22, Gotha-street, Leicester, gave the formal evidence of identification. The deceased was his brother-in-law and was 44 years of age.

The witness was answering a question put by Mr. Lowthian, when the Coroner intimated that they had better have that evidence from an expert. — The witness added that he was brought up a miner and had some knowledge of places of the sort. — Mr. Musgrave objected. — The Coroner said he had merely called witness to identify the body. He however, would allow him to be recalled later, if it should be thought necessary.

Daniel Tyson, labourer, Threlkeld, deposed that he had worked at the quarry for ten months, and he had had previous experience. He was working with John Gill on Thursday. They were making a cutting for a tramway. The cutting might be about 12ft. deep where they were working, removing soil from the bottom. A fall of stuff came from the side. The stone which came with it was about 7ft. up. Witness had not worked in the cutting all the time; he had been there but two days. Gill had been working there before, and he was immediately underneath the stone when it fell. Nobody had touched the stone. Witness did not know that it was loose. The stone was smooth on the side next to them, facing the cutting. Mr. Noon, the foreman, had been in the cutting twice that morning, had examined the place and sounded it on both occasions with a pick. He was sure he saw Mr. Noon sounded the place where the fall came from. Witness was not present on Wednesday when the Government Inspector was there. Nothing had been done under the stone while witness was there, and nobody but Gill and himself worked there on Thursday. Witness was about 6ft. from Gill when the fall took place. It gave no warning before it came away. A quantity of earth came before the stone. Gill moved once after he had been got out. Nobody but the foreman had visited them that morning. The width of the cutting was about 4ft. at the bottom; they were preparing for props to be put in.

By Mr. R. Musgrave: Witness was about 6ft. from Gill and 6 or 7 yards in. If there had been any warning there was room to get away.

By Mr. Bowden: The fall took place about an hour after Mr. Noon had last sounded the place.

By the Government Inspector: The ground did not trickle. They could only see the face of the stone. The accident occurred about 11-30. Witness was in the cutting from starting work up to the time of the accident.

By Mr. Lowthian: Noon sounded the stone which fell; he did not try to move it. Witness did not hear Noon make any remark about it. The cutting is open at each end. They were going to put in some props for the bridge which crosses the cutting above the place where the stone fell. The bridge is used to run bogies over. There had been bogies over that day. He did not notice how long it was after the last bogey had passed that the fall occurred. The bogies come one at a time. There was no shaking; he did not think the bogies had anything to do with the accident. The stone was nearly underneath the bridge. The top of it was covered with "sill," and it rested on clay. The stone was a cobble. He had not seen that the place was dangerous, and he had not heard anything said that it was. He never heard Gill say anything about it. Mr. Noon gave them no further orders than that he wanted the bottom out so that props might be got in.

Mr. Lowthian asked if there were not some rules.

Mr. Oswald said the Quarry Act was in force, but there were no special rules. The rules were up but had not yet been certified.

In reply to Mr. E. Musgrave, witness said he would not have worked there if he had thought the place dangerous. Gill was not very active in his movements. Witness did not think he could have got out of the way, as the stone came down too suddenly.

In reply to Mr. Oswald, he said he did not know where the stone struck Gill, whether on the back or side; he was in a stooping position.

Henry Noon, foreman, Keswick, deposed that he visited the cutting twice — first between 8-30 and 9 a.m., and again about 10-30 on the day of the accident.

He examined the place. The fall occurred on the left-hand side looking towards the quarry, and was 6 or 7 yards in. The depth of the cutting to the platform was from 18 to 19 feet. He had not noticed the stone particularly, nor had he sounded the place either time. The stone had been bared from about Tuesday. He did not see it was necessary to make any sounding. He had been foreman for about nine years. There was not the slightest appearance of danger, and he would have had no hesitation working there. He stood beside the place both times he was in the cutting. He did not think the bogies passing over would shake the stone; it was too far down. He did not know the exact size of the stone; it might be 3ft. across in the widest part, by 2ft. 6in. It was a boulder as far as he could see, and it had apparently crushed itself out. He considered the sides of the cutting were sufficiently sloping.

The stone was plumb with the edge of the cutting. Gill had not worked in the place all the time; he might have been in a week. It was a labourer's job all through.

By Mr. Oswald: If he had sounded he did not think he could have told it was bad. It looked to be all right.

Mr. Oswald: But you are a practical quarryman. If you did not examine by striking you could not tell whether it was bad or good.

Witness said, as the stone was not very high he did not think it unsafe.

Mr. Oswald: You cannot tell, unless you examine it properly, whether ground is good or bad.

Witness: I was perfectly satisfied the ground was solid.

Mr. Oswald: But you could not be unless you examined it properly.

Witness: I was satisfied.

By Mr. Lowthian: It was quite possible that the frost of the previous night had a little effect upon it. He did not think there was anything risky; it seemed perfectly sound and right to him. He had not heard Gill or anybody else say anything about it. Some boulder stones did slip away easily; but that had had good hold of the bank. They could only just see a piece of 6 or 7 inches of the face of it. The soil had not been dug away from under it.

By Mr. E. Musgrave: There was nothing to show that the stone was likely to come down. He had worked in quarries since he was eleven years of age, and he would have had no hesitation working there. He considered he made a sufficient inspection.

By Mr. Bowden: He did not tap the stone.

Mr. R. Musgrave: You could not tell, with a boulder, if it was loose.

Witness: If it had "given" in any way they would have seen by the crack. He thought the inner part of the stone had been the thicker.

William Dixon, labourer, Threlkeld, said he was working in the place up to Tuesday. They had got it to its present depth. He had not noticed the stone until it was down. He did not know there was anything about the cutting more dangerous than ordinary, and he had not asked to be put on another job. He was called in after the fall. The stone was lying on Gill and it took about five minutes to get it off him. Gill, who was dead, was crouching a little, with his breast on the earth on the opposite side of the cutting. When he was working there Noon visited them several times a day as a rule.

By the Foreman: The stone would be between 30 cwt. and 2 tons.

By Mr. Lowthian: He had not noticed any trembling of the ground when bogies passed over the bridge; it could not. There was always a certain amount of danger in quarry work; they had to keep their eyes about them. He had not heard anything about that place; a man was supposed to watch. It was right enough when he was there. He was ordered to another job when he left the place.

George Henry Bragg, Keswick, manager of the quarry, said he had made an examination since the accident. He was in the cutting the day previous, along with foreman Noon. There was nothing visible of the stone. If they had seen it protruding it would have been removed. He went in with Noon to consult about putting in trestles. They went round the whole cutting, and everything seemed to be safe. The stone that slipped was resting on slate shale. He thought the action of the weather upon the newly-exposed stone had something to do with the accident. The air would dry the earth and cause to leave the stone. He was at the cutting with Mr. Oswald on Wednesday. No alteration had been made to the slope. The bottom was simply being taken up; it was a regular labourer's job. He was of opinion if Gill had been a more active man he would have got out of the way; there was nothing in the way to prevent him.

By Mr. Lowthian: The men were shovelling the bottom out to others who took the material away. The bogies passed over the bridge one at a time. The stone rested on solid shale and there was not the least vibration. The shale is alumina, soft rock, and, as far as they could see 20ft., thick — quite capable of turning water. The stone was embedded in the shale. The thin end of the stone faced into the cutting. Every possible care had been taken as far as could be seen. He did not see any risk. There was sufficient slope to hold any weight of stone; it was, he thought, at an angle of fifty degrees.

Mr. Lowthian: Other witnesses seemed to think the sides perpendicular.

In reply to Mr. Lowthian, the witness said he had not heard the slightest apprehension of danger.

The Coroner asked if Mr. Lowthian wished to call any evidence.

Mr. Lowthian replied that it might be well, perhaps, to call Mr. Macintosh, who had some experience.

Mr. Macintosh said he went on Friday to look at the place where the accident happened. Mr. Bragg and Mr. Noon were there. From what he could see the ground where the boulder had been was rotten. He went to the top and looked into the cutting and he thought that the stone must have projected.

The Coroner: That is your conclusion?

Witness: I looked at the stone.

Mr. E. Musgrave objected to this kind of evidence.

Witness repeated that he saw the stone, and he thought the place had been a very unfit one for a man to work in; and he thought the jury would think the same if they saw the place.

Mr. Lowthian added that he might say on behalf of his client that it would be more satisfactory if the jury saw it.

The Coroner said the jury might do so if they wished. To him it seemed a perfectly simple matter. They were driving a way to get the bogies into the quarry. The cutting was about 18ft. deep; and the sides sloped at an angle of 50 degrees. He had asked Mr. Oswald if that was so, and he said it was. There was the evidence of Dixon who had worked in the place, of Noon who had inspected the place twice, and of the deceased's fellow workman, who all swore that the stone did not project, and he thought the jury could not but accept that as conclusive. In all operations there is a certain amount of danger and slips will occasionally take place. Personally he would have preferred that examinations were made in the manner adopted in coal and metalliferous mines. The foreman might have got a sound. But he thought the true solution was the effect of the weather after the stone had been bared.

The jury deliberated a few minutes in private and then returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed." They gave their fees for the benefit of the widow.

The remains of the deceased were interred in St. John's Churchyard on Sunday afternoon. The service was conducted by Messrs. J. H. Williams and C. Greenwood, the deceased having been connected with the High-street Meeting Room. A very large concourse attended the funeral, and among the crowd were many of the workmen at the quarry.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Allinson, J. S.    Juror  
Bowden, E.    Juror  
Bragg, George Henry    Manager  
Dixon, William    Labourer  
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Gill, John   44   Deceased, Individual Page
Greenwood, C.      
Hope, J. F.    Jury Foreman  
Lawrence, R.    Juror  
Lowthian, I.    Solicitor  
Macintosh, Charles      Brother-in-Law
Melvin, D.    Juror  
Musgrave, —    Solicitor  
Musgrave, R.    Juror  
Noon, Henry    Foreman  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Peascod, J.    Juror  
Reed, T.    Juror  
Rigg, J.    Juror  
Robinson, J.    Juror  
Sanderson, M.    Juror  
Scott, Jonathan    Juror  
Tyson, Daniel    Labourer  
Williams, J. H.      
Wilson, J.    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Threlkeld Quarry (Granite)  Threlkeld Quarry (Granite)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print