Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

July 1896

Monthly Circular


No. 7.     July.     1896.

 

To The Members.

Gentlemen,

My first word must be a note of sorrow. July to us, as regards the agency, has been a fatal month. In it we lost Crawford, and now Patterson has joined the great majority. This is the common lot of all. Happy is the man who leaves this world for the next without regret, feeling that his life has been of some service to his kind, and that the people amongst whom he has lived, express their recognition of his worth by their sorrow and appreciation of his labours. Such was our friend. If we, who stood by his bed-side in the last moments of the final struggle, could have been cognisant of his thoughts, there would have been no regret; for W. H. Patterson was the enemy of no living man, but the friend of all. We were not so privileged, but we were glad to see the large crowd of people who gathered to pay a tribute to his memory. The gathering was diversified in its character, spontaneous in its gathering, and truly sympathetic in its manner and spirit.

But from our regret for his loss, let us turn to the influence of his life. The true test of a man is his work. Our friend stood the test. The real measure of a man's life is its actions; he was full measure. He was not showy, but solid; and as such, being dead, yet speaketh. Speaks in no uncertain sounds; let us turn no indifferent ear. The main work of his life, in conjunction with others, was the inception, promotion, and solidifying of our organisation. It will be the most real expression of our sorrow if we do our best to carry forward that upon which he set his mind, and which he endeavoured on all occasions to enforce. Would it not be sham sorrow and unreal regret on the part of a son, who on the death of a father — a father who by the toil and care of his life had made a position — if he was careless of that work, and had regard only to self-indulgence. Little as we may think of it, indifferent as we may be in our appreciation of it, there has a fortune come to this generation, and a position gained for it by the labours of our friend and others which cannot be estimated in money. We are apt to test every thing by a monetary standard; but in this case the test fails. Within the life of Mr. Patterson, there have been affected changes which lie outside the range of wages, but which are none the less valuable to us. These are only known to those whose working life commenced anterior to thirty years ago. There are many who have not the experience, and who cannot, therefore, realize to the full, the contrast. Lightly as these may be inclined to look upon the changed conditions, and think because these conditions exist now, they have always existed, there are numbers who know, and who are able to compare, and rejoice in the change made.

I would not say that all is attributable to the labours of our lost friend. No man would have protested more strongly against such an idea than himself, but he did what he could. He never devolved his share of the work upon others. He was earnest and determined at the foundation of the society, and anxious for its welfare during the whole course of our existence. We shall best show our respect to his memory by doing what we can to preserve and perfect the institution.

The Gala.

We were favoured with a very fine day for our yearly gathering. The weather on these occasions is a matter of great anxiety not only to us who are in the office, or to you who are in the county, but to the general public. Our demonstration is one of the institutions of the county. It is a very useful one to the Railway Company and the people of Durham. Our gathering means more than a merry meeting, or an opportunity for hearing a set of speeches; and, therefore, a fine day is the desire in many quarters.

The day was all we could have wished. Fine, without too much sun, and one of the largest gatherings we have had. It was not merely a crowd of sightseers and pleasure-seekers, but the platforms were as well (if not better) attended as on any previous gala. It is a healthy mixture to blend sound information with solid pleasure, which our demonstrations affords facility for doing. It will be of immense benefit if the lessons taught are remembered and practiced. The main plank of the platform was (as it was bound to be) unity. This is the primary doctrine in our creed. By it, and from it, all else receives inspiration and impulse. It is cheering to find that as the years roll by, and the list of galas is being extended, the idea is becoming more firmly accepted and practiced than ever before. In numbers we were never stronger, and there was never more of the spirit of allegiance to the organisation than at present. There are a few who allow themselves to run in arrears, or out altogether. I hope that before next Gala these will have realised their duty, and have straightened up or identified as their respective positions may require.

Justice Grantham again.

This partisan judge, who, some time ago, at our Assizes in Durham, showed the bias of his mind, and his scant knowledge of the people, by maligning the Miners of Durham, has again been giving indications of his unfitness for the high and dignified position to which he has been elevated. He has been called upon to try a case arising out of a Trade Union dispute, and he has not hesitated to say, that the joining of an organisation has changed those who before were decent and respectable men, to brute beasts, and stripped them of their reasoning powers. These remarks were made during his summing up in the case — when instead of venting his spleen, and showing the bitter bias of his feelings, he should have laid down the law for the guidance of the jury.

What hope is there of justice being done to the workmen, when the judge cannot hold an even balance ? To whom do the jury look for the interpretation of the law, but to him ? How can he or anyone else give correct enlightenment with a mind warped such as his appeal's to be, for he cannot try an ordinary case but he must snarl and snap and use scurrilous language ?

What was the case that was being tried before him, and what was there in it to call for such remarks ? It was a case of picketting. The employers, who were the plaintiffs, said, they had been seriously injured in their business as a result of the picket. All the workmen did was to tell others who might be seeking work, the nature of the dispute. There can be nothing criminal in an action like that. So long as no violence is used, nor intimidating words expressed, in what respect have the workmen on strike in the smallest degree violated the Decalogue ? The men and their witnesses denied that ever they tried to persuade men from seeking work, but this Justice Grantham would not believe, or did not appear to believe, and set himself to prejudice the case by discoursing upon the evils of Trades Union. All that he had to do, and all he should have done, would have been to have allowed the jury to have gathered the facts for themselves, and have given them the law as to intimidation, and have left the verdict to them.

Such exhibitions of prejudice against whole classes of people, as he has shown here in Durham, and now on this occasion, ought not to be seen on the Bench. A judge should know no class, and should clothe himself with impartiality. The lofty position he holds is not for a partisan of any description whatever. It is a good thing that there are not many Justice Granthams, if it were so, the entire system of justice would be involved in an atmosphere of well-earned censure and doubt. The old school of magistrates, who acting on their game-loving feelings and propensities, hated a poacher, and who revelled in uttering vile denunciations whenever such a prisoner was brought before them — and who find their type in Fielding's Squire Western — will see themselves embodied in this modern example of their spirit, although in a more elevated sphere. This should be remembered, that while no social status is too low, or dress to rough to hide the dignity of a man ; so no position, however high or lofty, can add that feature to him. The behaviour, and having due regard to the fitness and duties of the office, ennobles workmen or judge. All else is tinsel and dressing, through which, as in his case, coarseness and brutality and prejudice will break.

An Important Blue Book.

Among the many Blue Books which have been issued during this year, none is more important to the miner than one upon the "Causes of Death in colliery explosions and underground fires," with special reference to the explosions at Tylorstown, Brancepeth, and Micklefield. It is the result of investigations by Mr. John Haldane, M.P. Those who were at Brancepeth during the first two or three days will remember Mr. Haldane, who came to the colliery with the view of going down the pit, to make enquiries into the real cause of death. He, however, had to be satisfied with viewing the bodies, as they were brought to bank. Perhaps it might have been more conducive to the interests of science and life-saving if he had been allowed a closer enquiry.

Dr. Haldane was appointed by the Home Office not to make enquiries into the causes of explosions, and the action of coal dust or gas, but into the causes of death. It would occupy too much space if I were to set forth in the scientific terms he uses (and which are indispensable in the work he had on hand) the whole of his investigations. His findings must suffice. At Tylorstown there were fifty-seven lives lost. Fifty-two of those were attributable to after-damp. At Brancepeth there were twenty men killed in the explosion. Nineteen had been poisoned by carbon-monoxide, and one by violence. Of those who died from carbon-monoxide poisoning, one had received fatal injuries, of which he would have died even if rescued immediately after the explosion.

His conclusion as to the cause of death clearly establishes "beyond doubt, that the explosions themselves kill only a few men: that the poison produced by the explosion is the fatal agent: that this poison acts as a rule slowly, and in the presence of oxygen to support life; and finally we have the vital fact, that men may be reduced to helplessness, but not to death, after the poison wave has passed over them, or in the presence of such a slight percentage as to admit of continued respiration."

But from these enquiries, Dr. Haldane turns to suggestions as to the saving of life after explosions. Any endeavour in that direction should have our appreciation by whomsoever made. Who can tell how soon, or where, such may be needed. We labour in jeopardy every hour. The first matter to attend to is, get fresh air into the pit as soon as possible; but the great obstacle in the way is the fact, that the air-crossings and stoppings will have been blown out, and therefore the fresh air makes its way into the return airways at the first stopping or crossing which has been destroyed, and so up the upcast. There should, therefore, be a fan at every upcast, and not a furnace. Regard should be had to the fan-drift to prevent disarrangement. The communications between intakes and returns should be driven narrow, behind the stoppings should be solidly "stowed," and the air-crossings especially near the shaft should be in the solid. These are not new ideas. They will have been forced upon any man who has had anything to do in exploring. The brick stopping is put in across a place four or five yards wide. The place in which it is put is nearly free from any material. At the first blast away it goes, and the whole system of ventilation is upset. If there be a number of these, the danger to the explorers is increased, and the chances of safety to the men who are being sought for are lessened.

There are not only these suggestions, but there are recommendations to those who are in the mine at the time when the explosion occurs. Some of these run counter to the accepted ideas and methods. I will quote in extenso one of those recommendations :—

"The saving of life after an explosion depends, not merely on the action of rescuers, but still more on that of the men in the pit themselves. At the least warning of approaching flame or disturbance a man should at once fall flat. In this way both burning and violence may be partly or completely avoided. Moreover the air along the floor will be cooler and contain less after-damp, and when fresh air comes it will come first along the floor. Any exertion will (by causing the respirations to become quicker and deeper) hasten the action of the after-damp.

"For a man near the shaft, the best plan would probably be to lie still. For a man in a road, far in, the most hopeful way of escape, if consciousness remained, would be towards a return air-way, or towards the face.

"Those at the face, or on roads not traversed by the explosion, should on no account hurry towards the shaft by the haulage roads. To do so will entail almost certain death if the explosion has traversed any part of the road towards the shaft, and even, if this has not been the case, after-damp may have been blown by the force of the explosion into some part of this road. Any attempts to reach the shaft should, therefore, be made with the utmost caution, and when after-damp is met the only safe course is to retire again into fresh air. The after-damp can be detected by its smell and its irritating effect upon the eyes, and any mistiness or unusual warmth in the air should be regarded as a sign of its presence. It should be remembered that the more time can be gained by retiring before the after-damp, the greater chance there will be of its clearing away, or becoming so dilute as to be harmless. There is no doubt that hundreds of men have lost their lives by hurrying blindly towards the shaft, or by not retiring towards the face when they met the after-damp."

There are other portions worthy of reference, but these must be omitted. I will conclude by quoting a part of a letter I have received from Mr. A. L. Steavenson, Holywell Hall, one of the best of our mining engineers. Anything he says on mining matters has a claim upon us. I received a letter from that gentleman, anent Dr. Haldane's report, and the portion I quote has special relation to the above quotation :—

"His advice for workmen to remain at or near the face is good, but so much depends upon the nerve and self-possession of men under such circumstances that probably not more than one man out of a hundred will be found to act on it.

"I think that the Report should be read by every one connected with a mine, whether as manager or workmen."

J. Wilson.

Durham. — 1896


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Crawford, William    D.M.A.  Whos Who Page
Grantham, —, Justice    Judge  
Haldane, John, Dr.      
Patterson, William Hammond    Corresponding Secretary, Durham Miners' Association  Deceased , Whos Who Page
Steavenson, Addison Langhorne    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Wilson, John    Secretary, Durham Miners' Association  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Brancepeth Colliery  Brancepeth Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
Jan 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 23 Feb 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print