Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th May 1896

Claims Against The Wyndham Mining Co.

Moffat and others v. Wyndham Mining Co., Ltd. — This was a case in which James Moffat sued the Wyndham Mining Co., Ltd., to recover £50 damages alleged to have been caused to his house, 18, East road, Egremont, by the mining operations of the defendant company; Jos. Wear also sued for £50 for injury alleged to have been done to his house, 16, East-road; Walker Preston for £45 for injury alleged to have been done to his house, 17, East-road; and Wm. Moffat for £48 for injury alleged to have been done to his house, 19, East-road.

Mr. Langton (instructed by Mr. Nelson, Egremont) was for the plaintiffs and Mr. Jordan (instructed by Messrs. Brockbank, Helder, & Co.) for the defendants.

His Honour said that he had had a view of the houses that morning, and he thought the first case would decide the question of liability as regards the whole four, for of course the damage to each house would have to be considered separately, and he would suggest that counsel agree on a gentleman to assess the damages.

Mr. Jordan said he did not object to the course suggested by His Honour.

His Honour: We'll try the liability first and that decided, we'll discuss the other points.

Wear's case was taken to decide the question of liability, and Mr. Langton, in opening, said the question to be decided was one of fact, whether the mining operations of the defendant company had caused such subsidence as had led to the injury of the houses. The cottages, Nos. 16, 17, 18, and 19 in this row, were built in 1878. The first two houses built were 18 and 19, the two furthest away from the mine, and therefore the least subject to the effects of any subsidence that had taken place. The date of the lease of the plot of land on which No. 16 was built was 20th July, 1878, and the mine had been worked from the year 1871, and the workings of which they complained were worked to 1887. It was these workings that had caused the "drag" of the ground which they alleged had caused the injury to the houses. After 1887, when these workings were closed, the first fifteen houses in the row began to show serious signs of cracking, and in that year negotiations took place with the mine owners, which eventually resulted in 1889 in the purchase by the Mining Company of these houses in order to prevent any litigation and the question being raised of the damage caused by the subsidence. These houses were, he contended, purchased by the Company because of the damage done to them by the subsidence, and the question was whether the subsidence had extended as far as the houses they were concerned with, and his contention was that it had. Between 1887 and 1889 there were slight cracks in the houses with which they were dealing. These cracks were, however, so slight that no attention was paid to them at the time. Between 1889 and 1894 the cracks gradually opened, and in 1894 the first claims were made. The workings of the mine ran north-east and south-west, and the furthermost portion of the mine was just under the corner of the cottage, and the contention of the plaintiffs was this, that over these workings was a bed of gravel, that when the mine collapsed the gravel fell into the mine, and then there was a tendency of the ground to slip and "drag" towards the mine, and this caused the slight subsidence that had caused the cracks, in the houses. Upon one point there was a dispute between his learned friend and himself. Certain plans had been placed at the disposal of the plaintiffs by the defendant Company, but these plans did not correspond with those obtained by the plaintiffs. One of the plans the plaintiffs had was supplied by Mr. Russell, Geological Surveyor for the Government, but the plans placed at their disposal by the Mining Company did not correspond with this, nor with the plans supplied by the owners of the royalty. The plans showed far less of the iron stone worked than had been, and also showed a limestone roof. There was no better roof for a mine than an iron stone roof, but the evidence he should call would show there was no such thing. The topmost end of the workings was under the last cottage, which showed unmistakeable signs of subsidence, the whole of the gable wall being cracked, and if the roof of the mine had been of limestone it was almost incredible that the cottage should have given way as it had done, and their evidence was that the limestone was to the west and that ironstone cropped right up into the gravel. Again a shale slate fault, that was given on the plans as perfectly perpendicular, but their evidence would go show that it sloped at an angle of about 45 degrees, and thus rendered the slip of the gravel easy. The learned counsel went on to read a letter from the defendant Company, declining to furnish the plaintiff's solicitor with certain plans he had asked for, as not being of interest to his clients. That was to say, continued Mr. Langton, they had asked for information, which was refused. He might also say that Messrs. Walker and Thomas had gone down the workings, and wished to see the plans of the roads and workings, and to see where the excavations were made, but the defendant Company refused.

Jos. Weir, 16, East-road, Egremont, painter, said he purchased the plot on which his house stands from Mr. Hartley in 1878. He began to build in the same year and finished the house. It was considered a well-finished house, with 18in. walls, and the side wall 12 inches, with chimney breasts. It was a very good foundation, built upon what the miners called red "pinnel." Prior to 1887 he noticed no cracks to speak of. He painted the lobby and staircase in that year, and he found some small cracks, but only such as might appear in plaster. But in 1890, 1891, and 1892 the cracks gradually grew bigger, and new cracks appeared. The level of the road had not been altered since the house was built.

Cross-examined: Mr. Hewetson built the house, Mr. Renny being the architect. He was not an architect, but a builder. The house cost something like £300, the land costing £21 10s. His house was No. 16, and No. 17 was built at the same time. Nos. 18 and 19 were built then, but not 15. Before the house was put there the ground sloped pretty steeply down towards the river. He saw the foundations taken out, and knew it was solid pinnel. He did not know how far the pinnel went down, as they had enough to do to get the top off it, but he knew it extended to the end of his house. He remembered very well that the foundation was pinnel, because he had a good deal to do with the building of the house.

Mr. Jordan: You had an experienced gentleman doing it for you. Could you not trust him? Scarcely. (Laughter.) When a tree was planted over the pinnel it only lived a year or two.

Mr. Jordan: That is when you pick out the pinnel. (Laughter.)

No. 15 was built, he thought, a year after his. He first noticed the cracks in 1887, in the Jubilee year. Nos. 3 and 4 had suffered cracks, and the Mining Company had come to an arrangement with the owners.

Mr. Jordan: And as soon as they succeeded the chap a little higher up in No. 5 had a go at them. (Laughter.) It kept extending higher up, as one succeeded the next man had a go, until it came to your turn. (Laughter.)

Witness: There were only two lots.

Mr. Jordan: In your front room there is a lot of paper pulled off?

Mr. Langton: Mr. Jordan, do you surest that His Honour could see through the paper? (Laughter.)

Mr. Jordan: I am not asking for your suggestions.

Witness: You sent several people to see them and they could not see them. (Laughter.)

Mr. Jordan: So you pulled a good bit off to have no mistake. (Laughter.) Mr. Jordan went on to say that the pulling off of the papers gave the cracks a wide appearance until they got near it.

His Honour said he had seen.

Mr. Jordan: When did you think the time had arrived for you to have a go at them. (Laughter.) Witness said he thought he would have to watch them about four years ago. He was very sorry for the Wyndham Mining Co., that it should come to such a thing. None were more sorry than Joe Wear. (Laughter.)

Mr. Jordan: You are not so sorry that the time has come to have your action. (Laughter.)

Witness: I am as sorry for them as ever I was.

Mr. Jordan: You are having a go at them? (Laughter.) I am having a go at them. If you had put all your money into a house and had a wife and children?

Mr. Jordan: It is a very nice house, Mr. Wear.

Witness further said he had never seen houses cracked like this unless there had been iron ore mining.

James Moffat, No. 18, builder, said he had his house built for him. When it was being built, the window sill of the back kitchen was cracked, and there was also a crack in a wall. He had a dispute with his neighbour as to what caused it, and they finally came to an understanding that it was his neighbour's cellar building that had done it, and witness was paid about £6 for the damage.

Mr. Jordan: You are the gentleman who has the canaries? (Laughter.) Yes.

Mr. Jordan: I remember them. Is it what most people do when building there to underpin their neighbours? No.

Re-examined: None of the other houses were underpinned.

John Smith, builder and contractor, Egremont, said he had been over the houses with His Honour that morning. He had had his attention called to the houses in 1894, when he went over them, and claimed £25 on behalf of Mr. Wear. In March of this year he went over the houses again, and found the cracks more in number. The cracks were mostly vertical. They could almost trace the cracks from the bottom to the top, but sometimes a stone broke the continuation. The cracks got worse towards the top. No. 16 had the worst cracks, and No. 19, the farthest away, had the least. In Mr. Wear's house in the top rooms the cracks were wide enough to let the smoke through from next door. — Cross-examined: If a crack appeared in a house it did not follow it would extend.

If the ground settled a little bit it would cause cracks? Yes.

Would the cracks extend? For a short time until they felt their feet as they termed it. From a settlement of the foundation he should look for diagonal cracks. He concluded that the cracks were due to mining operations, as he had been told that the houses at the end had suffered injury from mining operations. He had never seen these vertical cracks in houses in localities where there were no mines.

George Williams said he was an iron-ore miner and lived at Trumpet-terrace, Cleator. He had been an iron-ore miner, for 30 years, and had left the Company's employment in 1888. He knew that in No. 2 shaft certain workings ran towards the East-road. He had worked in three workings running towards this road. He worked in the three topmost levels, the roof of which was metal until they got to the far end, where gravel stopped the drift. They came across no limestone in the working. The limestone was lower down. The level fell in, as near as he could guess, 30 fathoms from the shaft.

John Williams, 28, Queen-street, Cleator Moor, stated that he was a miner, and worked for the Wyndham Mining Co. for about eight years. He had worked in the same levels as the last witness. The roof was iron-ore. He saw no limestone in it. At the end of the drift they worked into gravel.

Cross examined: He never looked for limestone. It was possible for limestone to be there without him knowing it, as he was not all over the working.

John Elliott, miner, Senhouse-street, Whitehaven, worked for the Company from 1882 to 1891. He worked in the same levels as the last witnesses, and saw no limestone. The workings gradually settled while they were working them.

His Honour: This evidence is so very unscientific that I am afraid I cannot grasp it properly.

Mr. Langton said he would call Mr. Russell.

Robert Russell, mining engineer, St. Bees, said that for 25 years he had been in the employ of the Government as geological surveyor. He had surveyed all that district. He had been down there working before they collapsed. He was acquainted with the geological formation and the external nature of the country. He had taken the level of East-road, which showed indications of having settled to the south-west. There had been a settlement under the tramway, which as the ground had subsided had been made up. He knew Wyndham-terrace; the cottages there had subsided. He knew the slate fault in the mine. The ore lay alongside the fault. The slope of the slate cheek and the ore was towards the west. Witness had seen the houses, and the cracks were due to the drag caused by the subsidence of the surface. To the best of his knowledge the subsidence was caused by the mining operations, owing to the gravel having fallen into the workings, and the ground having then a tendency to "drag" towards the west. Had the gravel been shallow the distance over which this extended would not have been great, but the gravel been here from 50 to 120 feet in thickness, it would extend over a very considerable distance, and he did not think that the distance was any greater than it might reasonably be expected to extend to.

The Judge: To put it into geological terms, the houses are within the slope of rest.

Witness: They are within the angle of repose.

Mr. Langton: Is there a limestone roof to the one of the workings towards the East Road? There is no limestone roof to the ore lying on that part of the mine, because the iron-ore rises up to the surface under the gravel.

Any plans showing a limestone roof to the workings would be wrong?

His Honour: It would depend where it was.

The Court rose at five, His Honour adjourning the case to the 19th inst.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brockbank, —    Solcitor  
Elliott, John    Miner  
Hartley, —    Land Owner  
Helder, —    Solcitor  
Hewetson, —    Builder  
Jordan, —    Solcitor  
Langton, —    Solcitor  
Moffat, James      
Moffat, William      
Nelson, —    Solcitor  
Preston, Walker      
Renny, —    Architect  
Russell, Robert    Mining Engineer  
Smith, John    Builder  
Thomas, —      
Walker, —      
Wear, Joseph      
Williams, George    Miner  
Williams, John    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Wyndham (Iron Ore)  Wyndham (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print