|
May 1896 Monthly Circular
Gentlemen, Brancepeth Inquiry. There are two events which demand prominent attention in this circular. They are both of importance to us; although affecting us in a different manner. These events are the inquest at Brancepeth and the International Miners' Conference. The former of these was proceeding when the last circular was printed, and the other was held in Aix La Chapelle, and commenced on May 25th. I refrained from making any comments anent the sad calamity, while it was under investigation, but now when the inquiry is finished, there can be no harm in considering it with a view to see what lessons we may learn, and as wise men, profit by them. The sorrows and sacrifices, the mishaps and mistakes, the ignorances and accidents of life are, and should be, schools of preparation and prevention for the future. Misfortune may leave its pangs, and calamities cut short the lives of our fellows, but it is no small calamity when men go on regardless of the teaching. This is the object in view, and the motive which prompts a reference to the Brancepeth accident and inquiry. There is not an approach to fault-finding. The future alone is before us, and not the past, except it be its instruction. The sad affair and its results we know and feel. These will be with us for sometime to come in many forms. Their dark shadows rest on the bereaved hearts and homes. We shall be wise if the lessons are as pointed as the sorrows and regrets are pungent. The inquiry (as all who were there will confess) was not only painstaking, but was clear of reservation. Doubts there might be in men's minds; and differences of opinion on some points; but on the essential there was a more general agreement and less evasion than has been seen in other cases of the same kind. Honour to whom it is due, and credit to whom it belongs. From the very first moment of the fatal occurrence until the finish, the officials on the colliery, without distinction as to grade, acted like true heroes and men. Some of them with the shadow of death resting upon their own home, and their sons among the dead, slacked not in their endeavour to explore, and to save where possible. If their conduct was praiseworthy during the explorations, it was equally so at the inquiry. They spoke as men who had no doubt as to the initial point, and the dangerous element in the cause, and propagation of the explosion. Gas had not been seen for years. A shot had been fired. There are but two known sources of danger, so far as explosions are concerned — gas and coal-dust. If gas was unknown, there was but the other alternative. Perhaps it was not a dusty mine in comparison with some; but once assert that there is no gas, every attempt to minimise the dusty nature of the mine, increases the danger there is in the dust, and hence the greater heed to the lesson before us, and the increasing demand for precautions in the future. This is a sound logical position, and it is one which should not be passed idly by. If there be no gas in a mine, but if the mine be very dry and dusty, and if necessary precautions have not been adopted, then increased care may secure the mine against an explosion. If the mine be not gaseous, and if it be not a dusty mine, and care has been had to watering, is this not a proper conclusion — the danger in coal-dust is greater and more imminent than we have been willing to acknowledge; and has the time not come when science should turn its attention to the invention of an explosive which will not emit flame? If that be outside the possibilities of human knowledge, should the law at least not prevent the use of powder in the mine? There was at the inquiry a general concurrence of opinion as to the firing of a shot. There was doubt as to the person responsible for the firing of that shot; there was none as to the fact. Further, it was a shot in which powder had been used. The makers of the higher explosives may, on the principle of there being nothing like leather, contend their special make is flameless; but where is there a man insane enough to say powder will not emit flame? The amount of flame may be in dispute. Royal Commissions may speak of a blown-out shot as if that was the only occasion when flame can be caused; but as I am not writing for the members of a Royal Commission (many of whom are theorists), but for practical men who have seen flame from powder, when there has not been a blown-out shot, there will be perfect agreement amongst us, at least, that after our experience at Brancepeth, it should not be used. This should meet with the approval of all, and there should be no hesitation as to the use or disuse of it. There can be no choice. Life is too sacred to be risked when the danger is so very clearly demonstrated. But when is there sufficient dust to warrant the mine being classed as dangerous? Has this catastrophe not proved that a very small quantity of dust indeed may be the initial cause of a great loss of life and destruction of property? In the opinion of the management (and all will admit they were conscientious in that opinion), the mine was not a dry and dusty mine. Accepting that opinion as being the harmonious view of all the mining engineers and experts (because there was no admission that the mine was within the dangerous category), does the importance of the calamity not stand out more prominently, and the warning receive greater force than if there had been a universal consensus of opinion as to its dryness, dustiness, and consequent danger? The question presents itself as follows :— Here is a mine considered not to be sufficiently dusty as to be classed as dangerous. That view is honestly held and avowed. The colliery is under good management. If then we are in danger under those conditions, where are we safe, and what amount of dust is required to cause an explosion? There needs no scientific calculation as to the amount required. Let the plain and palpable facts speak for themselves, and let us, as wise and careful men, accept them as our guide in our future operations. A reference to one leading scientist will not be inappropriate at this point, — "It has been stated by Mr. Galloway that one pound of dust to 160 cubic feet of air is necessary in order to form an inflammable mixture. Assuming that, 40 square feet area, then one pound of dust is required for each length of 4 feet, or ¼ lb. for each foot." In haulage roads, along which long "sets" are (and have been for a long time) running, we may soon have an accumulation of a few pounds of dust. In all our collieries that are a long distance "in-bye," the tubs run along at a very swift rate, and against the air-current, which consequently raises a cloud of dust. This imperceptibly, but surely, gathers on the ledges of the stone, or on the timbers, forming a source of danger, the magnitude of which has not been sufficiently realised, nor appreciated, nor provided against. What have we to learn from this sorrowful teaching? Have we not been ignorant of the absolute danger in dust, not merely from its nature, but the quantity required? If we have, why not acknowledge it, and not wait for another repetition of the lesson? Are the precautions taken sufficient? If any explosive that will give off flame be used, what system of watering shall we adopt to prevent an explosion? The dampness of the bottom is not enough. The real danger lies higher up. We have more than one sad instance of an explosion starting where the damp bottom has been thought an ample watering. In the book written by W. N. and J. B. Atkinson, this danger was pointed out some years ago. "If the conclusion as to the origin of the Usworth explosion is correct, it appears that where upper dust exists, the complete absence of bottom dust, owing to permanent dampness of the floor, will not prevent the extension of an explosion by means of coal-dust past the 'wet road.'" To us, as workmen, the serious danger contained in the dust of the mine is no new thing. We may not be able to enter into a scientific or learned disquisition of the subject, but having been brought into close investigation and the results of the initial points, we were convinced that in nearly all the explosions which have happened in this county during the last twenty years, gas played a very small (if any) part in their cause and extension. So far back as Seaham, we tried our best to press the question upon public attention. We and those who thought with us, were met by scorn, and an adhesion to old ideas. In old opinions, men are true conservatives, and in none more than the one we are dealing with. Gas as the only possible cause of an explosion had taken firm hold of many minds, whose opportunities for investigation should have convinced them of the dangerous error. To support the idea, theories wild and absurd, were started, and every effort was made to bend and twist the indications in the mine, to make them fit the theory. It would have been better and safer to have confessed that Nature has secrets in Its vast repository, which our puny and finite knowledge has not found out, and which only comes to us by a rude shock in our experience, and to have accepted the teaching and profited thereby. In the whole series of explosions we have had, there is none more striking than Brancepeth. It is a clear and conclusive proof of the place, and part dust plays in them. Every circumstance is explicit. When the news of the calamity was spread abroad, men doubted the possibility. They said, — "The management was good. The ventilation was all that could be desired. Gas was unknown. It was not an exceptionally dusty mine." After the explorations, it was agreed that a shot had been fired, and the precise spot was located. There was no complication or contradiction. If, then, under these conditions, we are liable to destruction of life and property. If the only danger here lies in coal-dust, what then is demanded of us? Have these calamities to be in vain? Shall we not through these deaths reach greater security and safety to those who remain in, and those who take up the dangerous occupation of the mine? The International Miners' Conference. This conference was held in Aix La Chapelle, and commenced on Monday, May 25th. It is the 7th of a series. The following being the order :— Jolimont, Paris, London, Brussells, Berlin, Paris, and the one just finished. The origin of the conferences was incidental. In the year 1889, Messrs. Burt and Fenwick were sent by Northumberland to Paris as delegates, to what is known as a Possililist Conference. There were attending that meeting, other miners from the mining countries of Europe. Out of intercourse which took place between them there, arose the idea of an International Miners' Conference. Mr. Fenwick was requested to report the desire to the British. This he did, by laying the matter before the Central Board of the Miners' National Union, the result being the holding of the first International Conference. At this last Conference there were 57 delegates in all who credited themselves with representing 1,087,000. It may be a most imposing representation. It is certainly a most delusive one, and a piece of gross self-deception. Nothing can be further from our ideas of representation. When we think of that term, we think of numbers in union. It is not so at these Conferences. The way it is done is to total up the whole of the men and boys employed in and about the mines, and say we represent their views, express their opinions, and can bind them to any and every resolution we carry. To say the least of it, the numbers (so far as being represented is concerned) is as fictitious as the idea, that you can bind those who are not in union by your resolutions is futile. We want to preach more the need of unionism amongst the people, and place the representation on a proper and sure base. We must not think that organisation is so good on the continent, and in many parts of Britain, as it is here. Such is not the case. Districts could be mentioned where the non-unionists preponderate, and yet, even there, every worker was represented and spoke for. There are two or three matters in relation to these Conferences which may be of interest to you. Some of them will be a surprise. Take the speeches. Each of these is to deliver thrice, in the following manner :— Say an Englishman speaks ten minutes. When he sits down, an interpreter gives the same speech in French, which again is by another man turned into German. It will, therefore, be obvious, how slow and somewhat tedious the discussions will go on. Of course, the order is altered in accordance with the nationality of the delegate who speaks; but in every case, be the speech long or short, there is the three-fold delivery of it. Under The Eye Of A Policeman. In Germany, as in the case of this last Conference, a meeting cannot be held except without a special permit from the Authorities, and with a couple or more policemen (in Berlin we had three) on the platform, ready to intervene if anything be done out of order. Before the meeting takes place, an application must be made, and a declaration sent to the chief of the police, setting forth the desire to hold it, the place in which it will be held, and the time of opening and adjourning. It may interest you if I append the form received from the chief of the police in reply to our application. "I herewith acknowledge the receipt of your declaration to hold an International Congress in Aix La Chapelle, at Winandy Hall, 19, Franz Street, at the following times :— May 25, open at 11, a.m., until 4, p.m.; May 26, 27, 28, and 29, open at 8.30, a.m., and at 2, p.m." This was signed by the Police President, and sent to one of the German delegates. There is an hour's margin allowed, and if the meeting was not opened within that time, it could not be held that day. It will be observed that 8.30, a.m., is an early hour for us, although not for them, and we decided to open at 9.29, a.m., which kept us a minute within the prescribed time. This other restriction was imposed :— the meeting could not be opened until two representatives of the State were on the platform, and for the whole of the time the Conference lasted, these gentlemen were in attendance. As illustration of the difference between our laws and those of other countries, let me mention that there are two French representatives — Lamendin and Basly — who would not be allowed to attend a Conference in Belgium, because they have said something at sometime in their places in the French Parliament, condemnatory of the Belgians. At the Berlin Conference in 1894, Defiuseaux, a Belgian, was turned out of Germany, and those who attended that Conference, will know what a difficult task the British section had to keep the continental delegates within lawful bounds, and if it had not been for their determination to recognise and abide by the law of the land, the Conference would have been broke up. At this Conference there was only one delegate from Austria. On the first day, he made, what was considered by the Authorities, an inflammatory speech, and very shortly after he received a hint that he had better leave, and he left. These restrictions and interference are a contrast to our free, social, and political atmosphere; but it is their law, and they do not ask us to go. It reminds us of the days within some of our experiences, when workmen were taken to prison as common malefactors here. We have changed all that. It would have been wrong for a foreigner to have come here and interfered with our laws. If we hold Conferences in those countries, we must recognise the law. We have no more right to object to them, than Dr. Jameson had to march his troops into President Kruger's territory. We hope that the spirit of freedom will compel a better state of things, which end will be assisted by our behaviour and willingness to confirm to the law. This has had its effect already, for at the conclusion of our meeting, the representative of the German Government gave Mr. Pickard his card, upon which were written the words, "with respects to all English gentlemen." The Conference On View. There is another peculiarity worthy of mention, as indicating a striking divergence from what might be called the incidents of our Conferences. There was at the Aix La Chapelle meeting, as at Berlin, a charge for admission to the public. It was, no doubt, on a par with a circus; and an occasion from which profit could be derived. There was no showman describing the various peculiarities of the different nationalities, and inviting the people to "walk up;" but there was a fee. It was in addition an elysium for thirsty souls. At one end of the room there stood a counter tempting and alluring people to come and taste the national beverage, ricebeer, or braunesbeer, and when a delegate was thirsty with either speaking or listening, he had ready access to the counter, but not free. Of What Use Are These Conferences? In my opinion they have been very useful, and will be more so. Their results cannot be tested by a year or two, nor by their influence on one nation. I refer to a few sentences from the opening speech of the President, Mr. Burt, because I think they set forth plainly the benefits. There were unseen benefits accruing from these meetings. These could not be measured. The British had received a knowledge of the continental workmen; while the latter had learnt from us the methods and uses of trades unions, and in a few years these would be put more into practice. We had in part overcome the difficulties arising from our different modes of procedure, manners, and languages. To those of us who have attended the whole of the Conferences, the change in them is marvellous. There is now a spirit of order, where all was chaos, or in a state of susceptibility to confusion and clamour. This final lesson we should learn, that whatever raises the platform of the Continental workmen, increases our safety, and gives a guarantee of permanency to any benefit we may secure here. Britain and the Continent is becoming nearer, and our competition keener every year. Durham. — 1896
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 13 Feb 2023
|
Search |
|
|||