|
West Cumberland TimesArticle from the West Cumberland Times, 15th June 1895 Letters to the EditorWest Cumberland Miners' AssociationThe Dispute at Buckhill CollieryDear sir, It is with deep regret that I feel bound to write on this subject, but with the conviction which I have, after careful consideration, I am compelled either to express myself, or stand condemned in my own estimation as acting in a mean and cowardly way. Here we have Great and Little Broughton, with some at Dearham and other places, laid idle through the stoppage of Buckhill Colliery. I am told that by this unfortunate dispute these two Broughtons are rendered as destitute as Dearham was by the stoppage of their colliery. And why this stoppage and destitution? Rather a big question this, but its importance is equal to its size, and therefore it must be faced. In trying to answer it, we will try to state the case as clearly as possible. Mr. Fletcher asks for 10 per cent reduction without which the colliery cannot continue working. The men consent to give him 10 per cent off the 30 per cent leaving 20 per cent on the wages paid. I understand that Mr. Fletcher agrees to accept this at first, but on more careful consideration refuses, and asks for 1½d. per ton. The difference as regards the money value in the method of taking it off is nil. Then if the difference in the money value be nil, or at the most only fractional, there surely must be some vital principle at stake to cause such a deadlock. Well, sir, in the first place let us try to examine the position taken by the owners of the colliery. At the first glance one might think that it could make no difference to Mr. Fletcher whether it came off the per cent or standard, but it must be remembered here that, all the combined representatives of Coalowners Association requested a 10 per cent reduction off percentages, and were refused by the representatives of the Miners at a Conciliation board meeting. That refusal was right inasmuch as every lodge of the Miners' Association had condemned the request, by refusing to authorise their representatives to grant it. About that time a brief, but we think timely epistle, appeared in your issue, pointing out the absurdity of meddling with the percentages in the face of the agreement in Conciliation Board Rules, not to touch these until the Midlands did so. The short letter referred to was by "that Tither Chiel." All these things considered carefully, we would ask, what would have been the position of Mr. Fletcher, had he consented to take 10 per cent off the 30? Well, sir, I for one am glad to think that in this instance Mr. Fletcher had better judgement than to be in the position of the first sheep to run through the gap. I have little doubt but that in taking up this position, I may be looked upon as something of an "Ishmael" but I cannot help it, I must defend what appears to me to be the truth. It is hard to write against the action of my fellowmen, but I think they are wrong. I would be the last to advise the acceptance of a reduction if I thought it uncalled for, and in this case if the men had said to their employer you have cheerfully got what the Conciliation Board awarded you, and we can't submit to any more either off tonnage or percentage, then I would have been glad to say fight like lions. But the case is different. What motive Mr. Fletcher has in refusing to accept the terms offered is immaterial to me. I conclude he has done that which is right and best for his men. Now, sir, let us try to examine the other side. In the first place, I wish to be understood to say that, in my opinion, the position taken by the men of Buckhill Colliery is a wrong position, not so much in what they refuse to grant, as in what they have offered. The offer, however, we think, implies their obligation to accept what they refuse rather than throw the neighbourhood into such a state of poverty and destitution, but the offer of 10 per cent. off the 30 per cent. involves even greater and graver issues than these. We hold again that that offer, if accepted, would so affect the whole district as to make the present confusion worse confounded. Where would our organisation be? It is confused and weak, mainly through confusion, to begins with. We are now trying to govern by a Board of Conciliation, but the Federation has put a claim to protects its own in the rules of that Board, and I hold, sir, that that claim is so well put in that it cannot now be broken without, at the same time, breaking the said Board of Conciliation. Then you have disaster, the natural issue of a lack of policy. Look for a moment at this confusion which we have hinted at. One reason why the offer to submit to 10 per cent. off percentages, and to refuse it off tonnage, is by a large majority, not only of Buckhill men but throughout the district, that the tonnage has suffered too much already. These would give away the percentage, in their simplicity, to save the tonnage from being further reduced. If you have a diseased bone in your left leg you might as reasonably submit to have your right leg cut off to save it. There is competition not only between ourselves and Scotland but among ourselves, and if we give away our percentages at one colliery, the others, who have already got reductions off the tonnage, will follow suit, and have it, too, and the result must inevitably follow that, in the course of a few weeks, Buckhill must either stand, or be working minus 20 per cent. instead of 10. That is 20 instead of 10 as asked for at present. I cannot see how she could be kept going without a reduction equal to what others would then have got. Then the force of competition carries us down its stream, as a mass of confusion, until I am lost to know where we will arrive unless in the ocean of oblivion. Confusion, weakness, lack of system and policy is seen in the fact that while some say the tonnage has suffered too muck, others affirm that it has not yet been touched, alleging to get seams worked. Those who make the latter statement tell us that the 30 per cent is only a shadow. Still it is 6s added to every £1 you make, making it 26s instead of 20s, which we think, you will find to be correct if you try to reckon it. If the percentage only be a shadow, and reality, then what is the standard? I think, by a little careful scrutiny, you will find that the standard is only a shadow of its former self, while the percentage has lost only 10 out of 40. We were able to get, at one time, 73 6d as easily as we can get 4s 6d now, but we have only lost 9d by percentage, consequently the standard has suffered. I must say in conclusion, fellow-workmen, don't cling to the shadow of a standard, at the expense of a real percentage. You have the latter, and can keep it. By giving it away, you cannot hold the other. The standard is fluctuating, the percentage is abiding; and weak as we are we can hold it. The standard is as changeable as the hours of labour, and we suffered 7½ per cent off the standard by the allegation that our hours were shorter than Scotland and others. Then what about the hours at Buckhill now? Are they any longer than when the Commission sat? Rest assured these will shorten, the standard will come back, when trade improves. Therefore, keep your percentages and make a settlement of your present dispute. Thanking you for past favours favours [sic], and begging the insertion of this communication. I remain, yours, &c., SLAVO JURE.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||