Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

16th May 1895

Fatal Mining Accident At Frizington

A fatal accident occurred at High House Mines, Frizington, on Thursday morning. Robert Howell, 26, miner, who lived at No. 1, Moor-street, Frizington, was engaged drilling a hole in the forebreast of a working, when without any warning the forebreast rushed in on him. He was at once overwhelmed and buried. A man named Hayton who was working near, was injured, but was able to be removed to his home. 20 men at once set to work to timber up the forebreast and clear away the debris, but they were engaged for six and a half hours before they recovered Howell's body. It was of course dead, and was found to be fearfully mangled. — An inquest on view of the body was opened by Mr. J. Webster, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, on Friday forenoon last, at the Yeathouse Hotel. It was adjourned till Tuesday, to admit of the attendance of the Government Inspector.

On Tuesday afternoon, Mr. J. Webster resumed the inquiry at the Yeathouse Hotel, Frizington, relative to the death of Robert Howell (26), married, miner, who was killed at the High House Mines, Frizington, on Thursday, by a fall of metal. — Mr. J. Moffat was foreman of the jury. — The inquiry was watched by Mr. W. Leck, inspector of mines. — Joseph. H. Woolcock, engineer of the High House Mine, produced copies of the plan and sections of the mine so far as related to the accident by which the deceased was killed, and explained the plan and section to the jury. — By the Inspector: When the accident happened the men were taking off part of a pillar of ore. — By the Coroner: The work was done under his directions. He was in No. 6 working where the accident happened, the previous day, about one p.m. and made a careful examination of the place. He did not give any orders. The overman, Robert Simpson, was with him. Witness did not see anything unusual; all appeared safe and right. — The Coroner: Was this what you would call a "robbery" of a pillar that was going on? — Witness; Yes I suppose you would call it that. He was acquainted with the old plans of the pit, and had examined them, and knew that by going on excavating in this particular place they would hole into some old workings. — The Coroner :— Were there any extra precautions rendered necessary by that fact? — Yes, special care had to be taken with the timbering. The last headtree was about thirty inches from the forebreast of the working, and the other headtrees had been between three feet and five feet apart. That had been sufficient for the purpose of maintaining the roof. At the time of the accident the men had finished timbering the roof, and were about to get the ore. The men had been putting in spiles which rested at one end of the headtrees, and the other on the ore in the forebreast, the top of the ore having been knocked off to form a resting place for the spiles. Witness had seen the place since the accident. The spile had been broken between the headtree and the face of the working. The place had not been inspected before the men went to work on the morning of the accident. — Why was it not inspected that morning? Because it is not necessary according to the Act. — But is it not a fact that all mines in the district are inspected before the men go to work? I don't know. — Is it not desirable that some officials should inspect the working places before the men go to work? No, I don't think so. — At any rate, you have not made it a requirement in your pit? No. — By the Inspector: When he saw the working place on the 8th inst. all the woodwork shown on the plan had been put in. The men when he was there were at work spiling. The roof was formed of old wood and sill; it was an old working. In front through the pillar, there was a working with some sill in it. The character of the roof of working No. 6 and the one they were holing into were practically the same. In the opinion of witness, the top of the forebreast gave way owing to the top of the ore being thinner than he anticipated. The material that fell mainly consisted of sill. — Replying to Mr. Leck, the witness said the system of official inspection at the High House Mines was as follows: They had one overman (Richard Simpson), whose duty it was to inspect the workings every morning. He had three pits to inspect: they were all connected, and practically one mine. He would have four levels to go through, but the witness could not say how many workings he had to inspect. It would take him three or four hours or more to examine the whole of the working places and drifts. They employed about 90 men underground and they worked one shift per day. — You will be aware that a very considerable proportion of accidents in Metalliferous mines occur from falls of roof and side. Yes. — In fact you would not be surprised to learn that last year the proportion of these accidents in this district was about 37 per cent? I don't know; I have not got the figures. I did not think it would be so much, but was aware it would be heavy. — Do you not think that increased official inspection would have a tendency to lessen that class of accident? No I don't think so. — Do you believe that less official inspection than at present would increase the accidents? No, I don't think so. — Replying to a further question, the witness said he dared say that official inspection tendered to decrease the number of accidents. He had no objection to adopting the system of morning inspection except that it was not in the Act. — The Inspector said the witness might take it that the system of morning inspection had been largely adopted in local Metalliferous mines. — The Coroner: Is there any other reason why you don't consider the morning inspection necessary except that it is not required by the Act? I think a man can examine his own working better than a stranger walking in and out. — Replying further witness said that by stranger he meant inspector. You think it desirable to put the responsibility on the men themselves? A good deal of it. — An argument here ensued between the Coroner and the witness as to the advantage of having a man as inspector whose ears were educated to sound rather than an ordinary working man. The witness said the ordinary workingman sounded his place a good many times a day, and his ear would probably be as well educated as another man's. — The Coroner: Then what is the use of a man being educated? There are various kinds of men, some careful and some careless. Is it desirable to leave it to themselves? I don't know; I think a man knows his own working better than somebody else. — The witness in answer to the inspector said he could not suggest anything that would reduce the percentage of accidents from "falls" - By the Foreman: Witness was appointed manager of the mine in 1892, and was previously well acquainted with it for 12 years. — Richard Simpson, underground manager at High House Mines, said he had been engaged in that capacity for ten years. On the morning of the 9th inst, he was in No. 3 Pit for the purpose of seeing that the working was kept at a certain height and breadth, and that the men put their timber in properly. When he first went into a working place, he looked it over and saw that everything was right, and if otherwise, told the men. He judged by his eye, and nothing else. If there was a place that wanted sounding, he might take a pick and sound it. He did not sound No. 6 working, because he had not been in it. He had seen the place the previous day twice, but did not sound it then, because there was no necessity that he knew of. He could not tell anything by sounding that place. In his humble opinion the accident arose from the metal in the forebreast bursting forward. The working place was as far as he knew sufficiently timbered. Witness was present when the deceased was extricated he had been buried up for eight hours. There were six men altogether in the working two of whom were labourers. — By the Inspector: He gave the men special instructions to have the place timbered up strongly, and to be careful when they broke through. The men had broken through on the previous day, but not the whole way across. There was nobody at the mines who assisted witness in inspection but Mr. Woolcock and Mr. Leck. — Mr. Leck: Then you get some assistance from me (Laughter.) — The witness believed that in some instances his visits round the mine-prevented accidents. — Thomas Hayton, living at 42, Arlecdon Parks Row, a miner employed at the High House Mines, said he was working with the deceased on the 9th inst. They went to work about six o'clock in the morning and the accident occurred between 8.30 and 8.40. Deceased was boring a hole in the forebreast. Witness intended to put in a spile, and bored the hole. They both then left the stage, and fired the hole which witness had bored, and afterwards worked it out and drove spiles into the forebreast. When they had spiled it up they thought it was all solid, and the deceased started to bore a little hole to drive more spiles. Witness could not say what deceased did then, but he himself was knocked down off the stage, and his light was extinguished. While they were boring the holes they were not warned in any way by any peculiar sound. He thought the metal and shale came from the place where it had been spiled. Witness was knocked out, being struck in the back and his head being cut. — By the Inspector: The overman told them to wood up the place very carefully. It was a little dangerous when they were holing through, and the instructions of the overman related to that, and they were carrying them out. — Adam Huddart, miner, of 226, Frizington-road, said he was working with the deceased, and when the accident occurred was about 13 feet from him, boring a hole in a crosscut. Witness saw the place after the shot was fired and saw that a hole had been made just sufficient to allow three of four spiles to be put in. The place did not strike witness as being at all dangerous, except that they were taking extra precautions because of the holing through into the other working. — The Coroner, in summing up referred to the overman's statement that he judged the place by his eye, and said he did not think that was a satisfactory thing to go upon. He (the coroner) had repeatedly urged upon mineowners to insist on a careful examination and inspection of the whole place, and he regretted very much, indeed that the same law which applied to coal mines did not apply to iron ore mines. It was a fact that during the past twelve months 37 per cent of the men injured in the metalliferous mines in this district were injured by falls. This showed the great necessity of official inspection in the most careful way, and that the men themselves should also carry out inspection, especially after the firing of shots. He could not too strongly urge this upon the owners and managers of mines and the men themselves. In this case there did not appear to be any neglect on the part of the officials or the men. The men themselves considered it to be safe, and apparently the officials had made what examinations were necessary by the Act of Parliament. — The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."

Funeral Of Deceased

The victim of the fatal mining accident was interred in St Paul's Churchyard, Frizington, on Sunday. The St. Paul's Brass Band in which deceased was drummer played the "Dead March." The friendly societies with which deceased was connected — the Ennerdale Mechanics and the Frizington Foresters — walked in procession out of respect to their deceased brother. The members of the Frizington Fire Brigade also attended, and carried the corpse to the graveyard. The funeral was a most impressive one, and the largest observed in Frizington for a long while. Many sympathising friends sent wreaths, the coffin being literally covered with them. The insignia of the Mechanics, Foresters, and fire Brigade were carried on the bier. The service was conducted by the Rev. John Fisher, and the service of the Foresters was read by Mr. Robert Douglas.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Douglas, Robert      
Fisher, John, Rev,      
Hayton, Thomas    Miner  Injured
Howell, Robert   26 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Huddart, Adam    Miner  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Moffat, J.    Jury Foreman  
Simpson, Robert    Overman  
Webster, John    Coroner  
Woolcock, Joseph H.    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

High House (Iron Ore)  High House (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print