Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd January 1895

The Flooding Of Birks Mine

Adjourned Inquest, Yesterday

The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the men who perished at the flooding of Birks Pit, Frizington, was held at the Hare and Hounds Inn, Wath Brow, yesterday (Wednesday). Mr. Hedley and Mr. Leck (Government Inspectors) were present; Mr. T. Brown appeared for the Frizington Mining Company; and Mr. W. Paisley and Mr. D. Marston for the relatives of the deceased.

Mr. J. Webster (the coroner) read over the depositions taken at last sitting. Mr. Peile (mining engineer) corrected his deposition so far as regarded the description of the plans he produced. He previously described them as being partly surveyed, with some portions "copied from old plans;" and he corrected the word "plans" by the substitution of the word "tracings." He previously said that he also produced two tracings which he thought he obtained from Mr. Johnstone. He now explained that he did not get them directly from Mr. Johnstone, but that they would be left at the office at the mine.

Thomas Watson, the next witness, deposed: I live at Greystone-terrace, Wath Brow, Cleator Moor. I am a miner, and recently worked for the Frizington Mining Company. I remember the accident on the 17th November last. On that day I went to my work at the Birks Pit at six o'clock. I was engaged in driving No. 18 drift. David Harrison and I each bored a hole in the fore-breast, or nearly in the fore-breast. We completed those holes about ten o'clock in the morning. We then charged them with dynamite, and at bait-time we fired them. We retired from No. 18 at about ten o'clock. We went through the dam and just down the brake a little bit. We waited till the holes went off, and then we went back to the dam and got our bait. About half-an-hour from firing, the water broke through and came through the door of the dam. The water hit me, and I know of very little what took place after that. I had instructions as to how we were to conduct these boring operations. I had instructions from Mr. Kitchin, the manager of the mine, who was daily in attendance and gave us directions from time to time, and who had also given us general instructions. Our instructions were to do the same as we were told in 1893, that in case we saw any danger of water if we got to No. 11 we would be perfectly safe; and that we were always to close down the door in the dam before we fired. At the time of the accident the door was really not closed. We really did not think it was necessary, owing to the position in which we had our holes. We had also instructions to keep the door of the dam on the "trig," in case of the water breaking through; and that when we were out of the working place we were to keep the door on the "trig." When we left the place on the morning of the accident, and fired the shots, the door was neither closed nor on the trig. We did not think it necessary, from the position in which we had our holes. By Mr. Hedley: We followed the night shift men; and I was the first man on the day shift. I met Nancarvis, one of the drift night shift men, that morning as I was going to my work. We had a conversation as to what had been done, but he made no suggestion respecting the work in No. 18. When we first went in, there was a leading hole, but we did not do anything to it. The men on the day shift generally attended the leading hole. I looked at it that morning, but did nothing to it. I don't know what depth it was. We were supposed to keep it five feet six to six feet in hand, but I did not measure it. I had no instructions not to go on with the leading hole. We had other work that we wanted to square up to that breast; that was the reason we did nothing to the leading hole. Josiah Boden was in the working at about eight o'clock. I was boring at the time. He just looked round, to see that all was safe as far as he knew. He did not look at the leading borehole; and I don't remember that anything was said about it. Our manager, Mr. Kitchin, came in about nine o'clock. I had that morning discovered a slow dropping of water from a piece of rock on the left-hand side, back from the fore-breast. I had previously noticed it was moist, but that was the first time I noticed a drop. I drew Mr. Kitchin's attention to it. Mr. Kitchin gave me instructions about it, and marked out where a hole was to be bored on the following Monday morning. That meant that on Monday morning there would be no working in the fore-breast until that was bored. The hole was to be bored to prove this dampness to see if there was any water behind it. I agreed with Mr. Kitchin that it was desirable to do this. I was not at all afraid that any water would come in at that point. After lighting the shot we went through the dam and five or six fathoms down the brake, and afterwards returned close to the dam to get our bait. Harrison and I have baited there since we went back to this work. In 1893 we used to get our bait at the foot of the incline. - Was that according to instructions? Well, I don't remember anything about where we were to get our bait. It was a more suitable place to get our bait. - If it was suitable in 1893, it would be suitable in 1894, would it not? Yes, just the same, except it was further to walk. - But, it would be the same in 1893? Yes. We went to the foot of the incline to be further away in case of anything occurring. We were told by Mr. Kitchin that in the case of anything occurring, we were to make for No. 11 drift, which was about seven or eight fathoms from the foot of the incline. We got our bait in No. 11 when we first started the drift, in 1893. We continued getting our bait at the brake foot, or in No. 11, until the work stopped in 1893, when we thought we had got past where the water was. When we started in 1894 we had instructions to carry out the same rules; but we did not go to bait at the bottom of the incline or into No. 11, because we thought it was too far to go. As we thought we had got past where the water was, we did not think the danger was so great, and we had got a bit hardened: we thought ourselves more secure. Mr. Kitchin, Mr. Boden, and Mr. Murphy were coming in at all times of the day. I don't remember them having been in at any time while we were getting our bait. It is possible they may not have known that we were baiting up at the dam. - You say your instructions were always to keep the door on the trigger. Are you correct in saying you were to keep it on the trigger when men were inside boring holes? Is that not a mistake? - Well, it may be a mistake; but they told us that. - You did keep it on the trigger when you were working? Yes, very often. - The Coroner: Then why hadn't you the door on the trig that morning, when you were boring? - Because the bogeys were then passing in and out. - Mr. Hedley: But the bogeys were not passing in and out when you fired the shot? - No. - And the only reason you give for not putting the door on the trig then was the position of the holes? - Yes; they were back from the breast. They were not leading holes; and we did not anticipate any danger. - But you have told us your instructions were to place the door on the trig when you left the place any time, and why didn't you do it? Well, just that we did not anticipate any danger. We always looked to have it down when we fired leading shots, into the breast. - That was the reason why I asked you whether you had any conversation with the men of the previous shift. Were there any indications of a shot having been fired in the leading hole that morning? No; not in the leading hole. - Have there been any flank holes bored since you started this last time in October? Yes; I think so, but there have been none recently on the left-hand side. I don't know why they are left off. We were ordered to let the flank holes be, and just bore this hole in front. I myself was satisfied with those directions at the time. It was some time before the accident happened that we were told to leave the flank holes. We have on other occasions left the door open when we were firing small holes, back from the breast. I cannot remember that on any of those occasions any of the officials of the pit were present when such shots were fired. I don't know whether they would know or not.

By Mr. Paisley: The top of the sweating was better than half-way up the side of the drift, on the left hand side, and extended down to the sole. I put my hand on it several times, and I also sounded that part of the drift. I found it damp, but not a great lot. I have worked as a miner for 20 years and more. - Can you tell me how many shots would be fired between the place where you saw the drop and the forebreast? I could not say. On my shifts four or five shots a day would be fired; and we would have been working for about a week after passing that place. I have said that I don't remember anything having been said at any time as to where we were to get our bait. That is true. The instruction to go into No. 11 was not given to me particularly, but to us all. - When? Oh, on different occasions.

By the Coroner: The sweating that I noticed was not unusual, and did not surprise me. It did not indicate to me any danger when I found my hand moist.

By a juryman (Mr. McLaughlin): Is there anything in the Metalliferous Mines Act about these side borings? - Mr. Hedley: No, there is not. - Mr. McLaughlin: Well, it is a pity. It ought to be. - Mr. Hedley: It is a pity. - Mr. McLaughlin: It seems there is no compulsion? - Mr. Hedley: No, not under the Metalliferous Act.

Josiah Boden deposed: I live in James's-street, Cleator Moor. I am a miner, in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company; and am deputy-overman at Birks pit. On the 17th November last, I went on duty at Birks Pit at a quarter to six in the morning. I went to No. 18 incline at between eight and nine o'clock. I examined the working place. I found it safe, as far as my judgment led me. Mr. Watson, the last witness, who was present while I was in the drift, sounded the working while I was there, and I was quite satisfied with it. My attention was not that morning called to anything in particular. I saw that the left hand side of the drift was damp; I saw that myself without my attention being called to it. I also saw that there was water dropping from a piece of stone projecting from the side. It was dropping a drop every "moment." I did not think there was any danger from the dropping. On 16th, the day before, I had also noticed the water dropping; I could not say that it was dropping more rapidly on the 17th than the 16th. I did not make any suggestion, on seeing the water dropping. On the 17th I met our manager, Mr. Kitchin, and told him what I had seen. He said he would go, up and have a look at it. - Are you aware whether there were any rules and regulations for the working of this particular place? Yes. - Were you present when they were given? No. - Then how do you know? - I asked some of the workmen. I asked John Tallon. - How long ago? I believe it would be about five weeks before the accident occurred. - What did he tell you? He told me what directions had been given to him and a man named Larry McGrath respecting the carrying on of the work in No. 18. He told me that there was to be a leading hole put in the breast, to be bored six feet in front. - Anything more? No; I don't think so. - Was there nothing about the dam or the door? Oh, yes before that. - Well, when and where, and who told you, and who was present? Well, I really cannot say as to any particular man. - Do you know whether any directions were given? Yes, there was directions given. The other deputy tells me - No, no. Were you ever told yourself by the manager? I can't remember that I was. - Do you remember any of the directions? Yes; the men in No. 18 had to come down from the working place when they fired holes. Also, they had to shut the door when firing, and not to get their bait at the top of the brake. - Do you know that the door of the dam was sometimes kept on the trig? Yes, they had to set the trig. - Do you mean that the door was to be on the trig or perfectly closed when shots were fired? My instructions were that the door was to be put on the trig when shots were fired. There were no directions that I am aware of as to where the men were to get their bait. - Do you know where they get their bait? Well, I have seen them get their bait at the bottom of the brake. - Since when? Since the door was put in. - When was the door put in; in 1893? I cannot say from memory; — Before the door was put in where used they to get their bait? At the bottom of the brake. That was about 15 fathoms from No. 11 road. I was not present when the bodies of the three men were found. I was present when the body of David Harrison was found. It was found just below No. 11 flatsheets. I formed no idea of how he had come by his death - whether he had been drowned or what. The body would be covered by about six inches of water. There was a fearful cut over the eye, I saw. I don't know whether the skull was fractured. I would think the wound was sufficient to cause death. The body was completely naked, the clothes having been torn off by the force of the water.

By Mr. Hedley: What are the duties of an overman. Is he a workman or an official? Well, I can only tell you what I do myself. I go through the workings in the morning and examine them, to see whether they are safe for the men to work in. - And what else do you do? If I find bad ground and they want timber I order the men to take timber down. After examining the places, I go into a working and work the greater part of the day getting ore. - Oh, then you are not doing overman's duty the whole of the day? No; only in the absence of the manager, when he comes down my duty ceases. On the 17th my duty would cease when I met Mr. Kitchin on the road, as I was coming from No.18 working, about nine o'clock. - Is it your duty to see that any instructions given to the men are carried out. For instance, if you found that the men were firing shots without the door being on the trig, was it your duty to call their attention to it? Yes, sir. - Are you supposed to be superior to them in that respect, so that they would have to abide by your orders? Yes, sir. - Then are we to take it from you that these men get instructions of which you have no knowledge until they tell you themselves? No, sir. - Well, you have told us so? I will give you my reasons. The day I got instructions from Tallon and McGrath the morning shift men would get the instructions, and we were on the afternoon shift. Where were you when he told you? In the working. - And what time of day do you say it was? About four o'clock. - And were you acting as an overman at that time? Yes. - And you tell us you went down to act as an overman without knowing what instructions had been given about this dam or anything else. Did you get any instructions from Mr. Kitchin, or did you get all your instructions from the men? I have told you I got my instructions from Tallon and McGrath. - Did you get any from Mr. Kitchin? I don't remember. - Is that the only way you get instructions, from the men? Oh, no; but at other times I have received instructions from Mr. Kitchin through the men. - Yes, about trifling things, but about a matter which concerned the safety of the whole pit, did Mr. Kitchin not himself give you any instructions? I can't say that he did. - Did you ever take steps to see whether the men put the door on the trig or got their bait at the bottom of the incline? No. - Why didn't you, when you knew it was your duty? Well, I naturally thought the men would carry out their instructions. - Well, in that case what's the good of an overman. You have already told us it was your duty to see that the rules were carried out. Were you paid by the day? Paid by the day. So that you were not interested in the amount of ore you got? No. - How long have you been acting in this capacity as overman? I really could not say from memory, but I have been acting for years. I was acting as overman in 1893. I knew the directions given to the workmen in driving the incline; but I cannot say which of the men it was who told me what the directions were. In 1894 when the drift started again, I know that those same instructions were in force. - How did you know that? Because Tallon told me. - But didn't you know from your own knowledge that those instructions were in force when the drift started? Yes; but the instructions I got from Tallon were simply as to the firing of the holes. - Now about this water that you noticed. You say you didn't notice any difference between the 16th and the 17th. Why didn't you tell Mr. Kitchin about it on 16th, then? I told Mr. Kitchin on the 17th that there was very little difference in the place. - What made you mention the water? I don't know what induced me to mention it. I did not anticipate anything from it. - You did not make a special point of telling him that? Not at all; I had no idea that the water was at that point. I was in No. 11 when the water broke in. I heard a boy shouting "Water, men! Water!" I jumped up and ran to the place where the voice was. The water had not reached No. 11 at that time. From the time I heard the cry it would be ten minutes before the water was in No. 11. - Could you see whether the water was going down the drift, passing No. 11? No, but I could hear it passing. - How soon after you heard the cry of water was that? Well, not many minutes. - A large body of water would pass before the water got into No. 11? It was only after the brake door gave way that the water got into No. 11. - How do you know the brake door gave way? Well, from the crashing sound nearly ten minutes after I heard the cry. Possibly Harrison may have been sheltering behind the dam until it gave way.

By Mr. Leck: I have never seen any of these men baiting at the top of the brake. I have seen them baiting at the bottom.

By Mr. Brown: When the brake drum came down, the water would carry it over No. 11 flat sheets. Then the dip on the left-hand side, and No. 11 on the right-hand side, there was not sufficient water to take the drum down the main drift; and the debris getting on top of the drum diverted the water into No. 11. In my opinion, the crashing noise that I heard was the breaking up of the dam.

By Mr. Paisley: There are printed rules and regulations. I have read them. Murphy was an overman; he was on the second shift, on the day of the accident. He got ore in the same way as me, when he was not acting as overman. - Did you take no steps to find out whether what Tallon and McGrath told me was correct?

John Tallon deposed: I live at No.13, Ennerdale-road, Cleator Moor, and am a miner, in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company. I was not at work on the 17th November. I last worked there on the 16th. I commenced working there in October, 1893. My instructions were that we were to bore flank holes. I was always with my mate, Lawrence McGrath, on the first shift, from six a.m to two p.m. We did not fire any shots on that shift; we had orders to that effect. We were ordered to bore these holes for the other men, and then leave them standing. We got orders from the overman, William Murphy, in case there was any water we were to go to No.11 road. We also got orders to shut the door of the dam, in case we saw any water. We never had any orders to shut the door when we went to our bait. There were orders to put the door on the trig when firing; but we were never in the place when shots were fired. In October, 1894, when the work was re-started, my mates, Thomas Watson and David Harrison, told me there was only one hole to be bored, that was in the forebreast, and that was to be kept six feet forward. Then I and my mate were authorised to fire shots. There were not special directions how we were to conduct ourselves. Watson and Harrison told us they did not go to the bottom of the brake when they fired. They said that they got their bait at the door. The door was always shut when shots were fired: I never fired a shot without shutting the door. - By Mr. Brown: In 1894, since taking our round of shifts, we divided our pay equally among the six men. The other men thought it was a waste of time to go down to the bottom of the brake when firing shots. That would prevent them making as much as they might otherwise do; but I never heard that given as a reason for not going to the bottom. When we were firing and baiting at the same time, we went to the bottom of the drift.

By Mr. Paisley: I never had any instructions from the manager about this drift, or from any overman, excepting what I got from Murphy. I never told Boden what the directions were as to working in this drift. I noticed the dampness on the left side of the drift on the 15th, two days before the accident: it was not dropping, but you could notice that it was wet.

Wm. Murphy deposed: I am a miner, and live at Birks, Cleator Moor. I am a deputy overman in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company. I have been a deputy overman for 8½ years. I remember the starting of this No. 18 incline about two years since. When the dam was put in, in October, 1893, Mr. Kitchin took me to the office, and showed me the plans, and told me what was intended to be done, how these trail holes had to be bored. Next morning I went up to No. 18, and directed the men according to what he had told me. The men were John Tallon and Lawrence McGrath. I told them they were to start a flanking hole, and that it was to go six feet. I told them if they touched water or saw any signs of if they were to go away, and shut the door, and go down the brake. When the men were working inside, the dam door was to be on the crook; but when they were going to fire it was to be put on the trig. I am sure I told the men that. I did not tell it to any other men except Tallon and McGrath. They showed me how they did it, when I asked them. I did not tell them to put the door on the trig when they were going to their bait. After the accident I went and assisted in recovering the bodies. The bodies were found in the refuge hole at the bottom of the brake. They were not in water when I found them; the water was all gone. In my opinion they had been drowned. Their clothing was wet.

By Mr. Leck: I don't know that there was any special instructions given as to where the men were to get their bait.

By Mr. Paisley: I know that we were driving this drift for ore.

Richard Nancurvis deposed: I am a miner in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company, and live at Red Beck, Eskett. I was working at the Birks Pit, in No. 18 incline, on the night shift previous to the accident. I had worked there for about two months, and previous to October, 1893. I had also worked there. At the latter time I got instructions from Mr. Kitchin, the manager, how the work was to be carried on - how the holes were to be bored, and in the event of water being found that we were to retire into No.11 road. At that time the dam had been put up, and we were told that the door of the dam was to be closed when we were firing. I don't remember hearing any instruction that whenever we left the working place the door was to be left on the trig; but we often enough did this. I was not in the place when the accident happened.

By Mr. Hedley: On the morning of the 17th, my mate and I would fire about six shots. One hole was about a yard, and the other from 20 inches to a foot. We had a charge in the leading hole, thinking that if the water was there we would see some signs of it. When we fired those shots on each occasion we shut the door and retired back into the rise, about 10 to 14 fathoms away. There was no excessive quantity of water on the morning of the 17th, at the place where the water afterwards broke in; not half as much as there was further back into the rise. There was more water nearer to the dam than at the place where the water eventually broke out at. There was nothing in the water I saw at the side to cause me any apprehension of danger.

By Mr. Brown: I was never caught taking bait at the dam. Boden once found us in the rise when we were firing. He told us he did not think it was safe to be there. I thought we were equally as safe as retiring to No. 11, because we would have to come back and face the same thing, and lift up the door to let the smoke out. - Mr. Brown: But there would have been no danger with the door shut; but it would have taken up a great deal of your time.

Edward Hampson deposed: I live at No.7, Mill-street, Frizington, and am a miner in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company, and worked in No. 18 drift in the Birks Pit. I have worked in the drift ever since it commenced two years ago. I remember the dam being put up. I can't remember any directions that I received as to the working of the place in the event of water being found. I know that the door had always to be closed when we were firing. The manager told me that - that the door was always to be closed when shots were fired. Nothing was said about the door being put on the trig, but we adopted that plan ourselves; when we were preparing to fire, we kept the door on the trig. I was working on the night shift on the day of the accident. I and my mate always closed the door as directed, excepting on one occasion, nearly three weeks before the accident; on that occasion we did not close the door because they were only very small holes we were firing, and we did not think it was necessary.

By Mr. Brown: I remember Mr. Leck being in the drift about a fortnight before the accident. I heard Mr. Kitchin reply to Mr. Leck that the men always went into No. 11 road when they fired shots; not when they got their bait? - I did not hear him ask that. Nancarvis, Kelly, and David Crone were present at the same time, and were within 12ft or 16ft, and might have heard had they been so minded. I said to my mate afterwards, "Mr. Kitchin evidently thinks we are going into No. 11 road." We had instructions when we started from the level to go into No. 11 road, and those instructions were never withdrawn. It would not be necessary to withdraw them. That was about two years ago. - Mr. Brown: I put it to you that you had instructions from Mr. Kitchin to go into No. 11 road when baiting? - Witness: I don't remember it. - Have you never said to anyone lately that you had such instructions? No, sir; I never said I had any instructions where to go when baiting.

William Peile, managing engineer, re-called, deposed: No. 18 drift was commenced on the 13th July 1891, and was carried on continuously until about December 1893. The dam was put in about October, 1893. The Frizington Mining Company got possession of the Birks royalty about the year 1884. Previous to that it had been in the occupation of Messrs. Woods. - Can you say whether you got the plans from Messrs. Woods? I can only say that the old plans that we have used to put on this plan were, as far as I know, left at the offices, and we obtained them there. Mr. Andrew Johnstone was, I believe, the engineer of the Frizington Mining Company when it started. In 1887 Messrs. Walker & Peile were appointed engineers, and when we took office we had access to plans and tracings belonging to our predecessor, at the office of the Mining Company. - Did you at any time take steps to verify the plans you found? At the time we took office there were three pits in the royalty closed, — No's. 1, 2, and 4. No. 7 pit was the only pit working; and the working plans of No. 7 pit are made from surveys under the supervision of Mr. Walker and myself. The person who made the surveys, principally was Mr. Nichol, and they have been continued by Mr. Atkinson. I am prepared to say those surveys were correct. We have checked the plans of No. 7 pit, repeatedly, and they are correct. No's. 3 and 5 pits had, I think, been sunk in Mr. Fearon's time. They had been abandoned for several years before we took office. No's 1 and 4 had been abandoned during Mr. Johnstone's time. I was aware that the abandoned pits, No's 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 were full of water. They were not in any way connected with No. 7 pit. After proving the extent of a strip of ore underlying the inclined drift, No. 18, we set that drift away to win that ore. We found that the drift was going in the direction of the old working in No. 4 pit. In consequence of that, we commenced to pump the water out of No. 1 and No. 4 pits. That would be in August, 1893, and we got all the water that we could in March, 1894. We expected by pumping at No. 1 pit we would take out all the water in No. 4 pit, except what would be down the dip drift. We also put in a dam in No. 18 drift, as a further protection for the men. I have frequently seen that dam, and it was properly and efficiently made.

By Mr. Hedley: The object of the dam was to control the water when we got it into No. 18 drift from the dip working of No. 4. We knew that the old dip was somewhere in front of us. We had nothing to guide us as to its position except the old tracing showing its position in plan, but there were no levels, and of course being full of water, we were unable to survey it. - So that whatever the plans were you were obliged to take them as your guide? Yes. No's 1 and 4 were on a separate plan, but we have put them on the same plan as No. 7. Mr. Nicholl made the plan when all the pits were represented on one plan. - Do you know what steps he took to get them accurately on the plan? It is impossible for me to give you that information now. I think he must have used the old tracing of No's 1 and 4 to make the complete plan of 1, 4, and 7. - Do you know whether he took any steps to check that by surveys? Well, he must have connected No. 7 pit with No.1, probably No. 2 or No. 4. This would be four years ago; and I am not certain. We believed Mr. Nicholl's plan to be correct, up to the time we stopped, in October, 1893, after we passed the position where we expected to have met the old working in No. 4. - What was your reason for stopping the drift then? We took the men away at that time to commence another drift. - It was not in connection with the water? It was not. - Did it occur to you that your plan of No. 7 might not be correct? No; I knew that our plans of No. 7 pit were correct, because of actual surveys, and by reason of staple pits and tie lines which proved them correct between one point and another. We have made an independent survey since the accident, and found that our own survey workings are correct. When we found we had not tapped the water where we expected, we made inquiries, and those inquiries led us to doubt the accuracy of the position of the dip drift of No. 4, and we could get no information about the level of it. When we started again in October last, the feeling was that we had either passed it or it would be right in front of us. That was the reason that the flank boreholes were discontinued; though as a matter of fact I did not know myself that the flank boreholes were being discontinued. I have been down the pit since and seen what occurred. We have made surveys, both at the surface and underground; and I have found that the old tracing of No. 4 pit contains two errors: The dip drift is not so long by 14 feet as it is shown on the plan; another drift west is about 12 feet or 14 feet further extended than shown on the tracing; whilst the No. 4 pit should be further to the east than is shown on the old tracing and on our plan complied from the tracing; and that brings the position of the old dip from No. 4 pit to the place where it broke in. - Well, now in making this survey, the surface and underground surveys practically checked each other. We have surveyed now from No. 1 to No. 7, and from No. 7 to No. 4. On one of the old tracings we have No's 1 and 4, and on another No. 7; and now we have these on one plan. (Witness described on the plans what had been done.) I should say the error in the old tracing is owing to No. 4 shaft being shown about 14 feet south - west of its proper position. - I think you say the actual survey proves that the correct position of the old dip should be where it has been found, thus proving the survey? Yes. - You have been going on the assumption that this water was above No. 18 drift? That was my opinion. - Do you think that was a fair assumption? I think it was; because the bed of shale that we were driving No. 18 in, and the drift from No. 4 pit was in the same shale, and that shale was 17 feet thick. No. 18 was on the bottom, and we concluded that the dip drift would naturally be driven along the top of the limestone roof; so that there would be solid shale between the top of one drift and the sole of the other, of about 5ft or 6ft. As a matter of fact, there was not a single flank hole that would have cut into this drift, even if they had been continued. It never once occurred to me to check the position of No. 4 Pit, before the accident. The plans had come to us through the hands of several engineers before coming to Mr. Johnstone.

By Mr. Marston: I knew for some time previous to the accident that there were several fathoms of water in No. 4 shaft. I knew that there were nine fathoms, just below the eye in No. 4 pit. - Could not all the water have been pumped out of No. 4 pit? If plant had been put down, all the water could have been taken out of No. 4 pit; yes, it could have been done. Never had in my mind a proposal to put down pumping plant. If we had done so, and got all the water out we would have been in a position to make an actual survey, and ascertained the position of the old pit.

This was all the evidence, and the Coroner addressed the jury, and said the question of how the deceased men came by their death would require their serious consideration. He reviewed the evidence, observing that they would no doubt place considerable reliance on the evidence of Mr. Kitchin, the manager. Repeating the substance of Mr. Peile's evidence last given, he said he did not see that much blame could be thrown on the engineers in consequence of the error in the plan prepared by Messrs. Walker & Peile. The jury would have to consider whether anyone had been to blame, and if there had been any neglect. So far as the evidence went, the officials seemed to have gone into the working place and viewed and examined it, saw the condition it was in, and heard what the men had to say; and they could only act according to the best of their judgment. If their judgment failed, they were not to be blamed because of an error of judgment. They might be liable in some other way; but they were not liable in this Court. What the jury had to consider was whether anyone was criminally liable.

The jury were left to consider their verdict, and found that the men met their death by drowning, adding that they considered the engineers were to blame in not pumping the water out of No. 4 Pit immediately they became aware of its whereabouts.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —    Surveyor  
Boden, Josiah    Deputy  
Brown, T.    Solicitor  
Crone, David   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Fearon, —      
Hampson, Edward    Miner  
Harrison, David   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hedley, John Laidler    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Johnstone, Andrew    Mining Engineer  
Kitchin, James Bateman    Manager  Whos Who Page
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Marston, Daniel    Miners' Agent  
McGrath, Lawrence    Miner  
McLaughlin, James    Juror  
Murphy, William    Overman  
Nancurvis, Richard    Miner  
Nichol, —    Surveyor  
Paisley, W.      
Peile, William    Mining Engineer  
Tallon, John    Miner  
Toy, Thomas   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Walker, William Edward    Mining Engineer  
Watson, Thomas    Miner  
Webster, John    Coroner  
Woods, —    Mine Owner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Birks (Iron Ore)  Birks (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
20 Nov 1894  Flooding Of A Mine (The Times)
22 Nov 1894  Disastrous Flood At Birks Pit, Loss Of Three Lives (Whitehaven News)
13 Dec 1894  The Flooding Of Birks Mine, Inquest Yesterday (Whitehaven News)
03 Jan 1895  The Flooding Of Birks Mine, Adjourned Inquest, Yesterday (Whitehaven News)
10 Jan 1895  The Flooding Of Birks Pit, Inquest On 2nd January 1895 (Whitehaven News)
03 Jun 1937  Cleator Moor And District Notes (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Birks, No. 7 Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print