Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th December 1894

The Flooding Of Birks Mine

Inquest Yesterday

The adjourned inquest touching the death of the three men, Thomas Toye, Daniel Crone, and David Harrison, who met with their death through the flooding of Birks Mine, about a month ago, was held yesterday (Wednesday), at the Rising Sun Inn, Wath Brow, Cleator, before Mr. J. Webster (coroner) and the following jury :— Messrs. Abram Southward, John Carr, Isaac Hunter, Moses Hope, Wm. Fisher, Jackson Casson, James McLaughlin, John Hutchinson, John Wm. Irving, James Pears, George Kirkpatrick, Wm. Steele, George Lobb, Thomas Wood, and John Cleator.

Mr. T. Brown, solicitor, appeared on behalf of the Frizington Mining Company, the proprietors of Birks Mine, Mr. W. Burnyeat being also present; Mr. D. Marston, miners' agent, appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased men; and Mr. J. L. Hedley and Mr. W. Leck, Government Inspectors, were present.

Wm. Peile deposed: I live at Moresby, Whitehaven, and am a mining engineer. I and my partner, Mr. Wm. Edward Walker, are the consulting engineers of the Frizington Mining Company Limited, and have been since the month of May, 1887. We have kept the working plans. We have during that time prepared plans and sections of the pit belonging to our employers, commonly called the Birks Pit. I produce those plans. The working plan produced has been prepared under my instructions and superintendence. Some of the plan has been surveyed, and some portions have been copied from old plans which we got from the Frizington Mining Company when we were appointed consulting engineers. I produce two tracings of plans which I think we would obtain from our predecessor, Mr. Johnston, of Whitehaven, formerly the engineer of the Birks Pit. I also produce seven other plans that we have made on a large scale, to be prepared for this inquiry, and to assist the inquiry. All the plans and sections which we have prepared are correct as to measurements and otherwise.

Mr. Marston stated that the man Thomas Watson, who was seriously injured, was not able to appear today and would not be able to appear for some time.

Owen Kelly: I live at 144, Crossfield-road, Cleator Moor, and am a miners' labourer, in the employment of the Frizington Mining Company. I remember the accident in Birks Mine, on a Saturday last month. I went to my work there about six o'clock in the morning. I worked in company that day with Thomas Watson, David Harrison, and David Crone, in number 18 drift. We were engaged in removing sill and stone from the fore-breast. There was a door in the drift about 12 fathoms from the fore-breast. That door was put up for the purpose of stopping the water which we were driving for; the water that was supposed to be in the old pit. We worked on in the drift until about ten o'clock that morning. We then knocked off to get our "bait." David Crone, Thomas Toye, and I, got our bait at the bottom of the brow in No. 18 drift. Thomas Watson and David Harrison got their bait up near to the door. We had eaten our bait and were sitting, the three of us talking together, when David Crone asked what the noise was. Thomas Toye, the other boy, said "It's a bogie coming down the break." I stepped out on the flatsheets, and our lights then went out. I walked back into the drift from the flatsheets; and I felt a great draught of wind. I then ran onto the other flatsheets, on the bogey siding, and saw the lights of the men who were baiting on the outside of No. 16 working. As soon as I saw their lights I shouted "Water!" and made to them. Joseph Boaden, deputy, came to me then, and asked me what had happened, and I told him that the water was in, and he told the men then what road to go to get out of the pit. Mr. Kitchin, the manager of the pit, had given me directions as to what we were to do in the event of an accident. It might be eight or nine months ago, that he spoke to Thomas Watson and David Harrison and me, when we were together. He said that in the event of any water coming they were to go up this No. 11 road, and they would get to the high ground, and he could come to them in a short time. He said the doors were put up for the purpose of being shut whenever they were firing a shot, so as to close the drift. I don't know that there were any other orders given, as to how we were to conduct ourselves when we were not working. There had been two shots fired in No. 18 drift on the morning of the accident. The doors were not closed before firing the shots. When the shots were fired, I went to the bottom of the brake of No. 18. I was not told to go any particular place when a shot was fired. I don't know why the doors were not closed. The last shot that was fired before we got our bait was about five minutes to ten o'clock, and about twenty or twenty-five minutes before the accident happened. The doors were strong and substantial, and as far as I knew about water, I thought the doors would have withstood a rush of water. I had been told by Richard Nancarvis and Ned Hampson that they had been told that when shots were fired the men working in No. 18 drift had to go into No. 11 drift. I had never adopted that advice when shots were fired. Had the men working in No. 18 drift when the accident happened, all gone into No. 11 drift, they would all have been safe. The men Nancarvis and Hampson are both working in the district now, and are both present at this inquiry.

By Mr. Hedley: I don't know why the boys Crone and Toye remained at the bottom of the brake, except that they thought it was a bogie coming, and they were in a manhole, and they remained there. That is the place where their bodies were afterwards found. I had no instructions where we were to go to when getting our bait; but I heard the men say so. Hampson and Nancarvis told me the men in No. 18 were to go into No. 18 when a shot was fired or when they were getting their bait. I did not hear that the door was to be closed when we went to our bait.

By Mr. Leck: What Nancarvis and Hampson told me was all after the accident. Mr. Kitchin's instructions were given before the drift was re-started. The dam was also put up before it was re-started.

By Mr. Brown: I am paid by the company working the drift. It was not at the bottom of the drift, but at the bottom of the incline where we got our bait: that is a bit from the bottom of the drift. It was not usual to fire a shot immediately before going to bait: it was just as it happened.

By the Jury: The water came, I think, from the side of the working, about three yards from the face. The doors were not closed when the shots were fired. It was my duty, on being instructed by the men, to make the doors ready to drop after the men had come through. I did not make them ready on the day of the accident, because I got no instructions. Before the shots were fired I noticed there was a little dampness on the left-hand side of No.8, about four or five yards from the fore-breast. I did not call the attention of anybody else to that, except that Crone, the little lad, and I talked about it.

By Mr. Marston: I never heard Crone or Toye say that they had received any instructions such as I received from Mr. Kitchin, eight or nine months ago. The deputy overman Boaden, was in No. 18 drift that morning before the accident. At the time of the accident he was sitting in No. 16, getting his bait. I don't suppose he knew then that we were sitting in the manhole at the bottom of the incline. - Did he know where you would get your bait? - The Coroner thought the witness could not tell what was in Boaden's mind. The question had better be put to Boaden himself. - Mr. Marston said the witness knew very well; but he would put the question again: he would get it answered by some one. - Witness said there was dampness all along the sides of No. 18. There was nothing exceptional about it.

James Bateman Kitchin deposed: I live at Birks, Cleator Moor. I am mine manager of the Birks Pit, and have been mine manager there for nine years and a half. I know the drift No. 18. It goes by the name of Hetherington's drift. It is an incline. Six men were employed in driving that incline, — Thomas Watson, David Harrison, Edward Hampson, Richard Nancarvis, John Tallen, and Lawrence McGrath. The day was divided into three shifts of eight hours each. The drift was commenced in June, 1891, and continued as a cross measure drift. It was driven continuously from that time till December, 1893; there was more worked on the way, but it was still kept in view. Deceased worked on it until October, 1894. We were aware that there was danger in making this incline, when nearing the point where we would intersect some old workings, in which we knew there was water. Precautions were taken to prevent the water bursting in upon the men. The first thing we did, in October, 1894, was to take care to employ men upon the work who were working there before, in December, 1893. When they started work in October, 1894, I met the men and told them in the drift that it was intended to extend the incline, and that they were to continue the lead holes in advance of them 6ft., and that no holes were to be fired on the morning shift, that being the shift from six a.m, to two p.m. I told them that in all cases, on firing and blasting, they were to carry out the rules that were in force previous to December, 1893; and I repeated these rules. They were also informed that if they saw any water in any part of the drift, they were to close the door and retire to No. 11 road, at which point they were to remain, and not upon any grounds whatever to leave that place, and that I would know at once by the water balance at the shaft, that the water had come in, and in a very few minutes I would come to where they were. These men went back in October on exactly the same conditions as they went out in December. I cannot say that I repeated all the conditions, but I repeated what I have stated. From October, 1894, to the time of the accident, I inspected and examined the incline, and I saw that the leading holes had been put in a proper manner. The holes were put in the fore - breast. No side holes were put in after October, but holes were put in the roof. On the morning of the accident I was in No. 18, at nine o'clock. I carefully examined it. I noticed in particular the left side of the level. I saw nothing unusual. I noticed there was a sweating on the left side; there was a moisture on it; but that was the usual thing in the place. It did not indicate to me that there was a pressure of water there. It seemed to me as if it was water finding its way through the strata. I expected to find the body of water in the right hand side of the incline, if we came across it. Seeing that we had passed the point where the water was expected to be found, we had to keep a guard on all sides of the drift. I have been in the drift since the accident, and I found that the water came in from the left side. My conclusion was made from the plan: it was shown so on the plan - that if we cut it all it would be on the right side. Previous to 1893 we were driving this drift in order to cut through the water: but by December, 1893, we had arrived at a point at which the water should have been reached. In Oct, 1894, we were driving for some ore that had been proved by boring. - But you still had the idea that water might be cut? We did not know where the water was. - But you still continued your precaution? Yes. - In 1893 had you put in holes in the side of the drift? Yes, all the way. - Why did you cease to put holes in the sides in October, 1894? Because we thought we had passed the point where the water should have been met with. - Did you ever take any means of ascertaining whether the plans on which you were working were correct? I had no means of ascertaining that. The pit we were driving to was standing full of water, and we could not get in. - Did you during October and November see whether the regulations you had laid down for the working of this place were carried out? I never watched them, but I expected they would be. I had every confidence that the men who were placed there would carry out the instructions I had given them. - Had the men carried out your instructions would they have been safe? If they had obeyed my instructions and retired to No. 11 to get their luncheon, they would have been safe, and no lives would have been lost.

By Mr. Hedley: No. 4 Pit was stopped previous to my time. The tracing shows that it was stopped in 1883. I had nothing to do with the making of the plans, but working plans were given to me to work on, and I had every confidence in the correctness of the plans; I never found them otherwise. I had been with the gentleman who checked the plans by measurements, and knew that they had been checked repeatedly and found correct: there was not an inch wrong. We had put bore-holes into the sides and the roof up till December 1893, when we passed the place where we expected we would intersect the old working. I believed that the old company had come down with a limestone roof, and on the top of the same shale in which we were driving, which was 17 feet thick. Our drift was 8 feet in height, from the sole. We went on the understanding all along that the water was above us. The side holes were close to the roof - as near to the roof as we could get them, as shown on the plan. The ground led us to think we had passed the place where we would intersect the old drift. We put in two bore-holes in the roof, and in the fore-breast, because were not sure. We put the holes in the fore-breast to make sure there was no water before us. It did not occur to me that if it was necessary to put in the roof-holes, it was just as necessary to put in flank-holes. I assumed that as the old drift was not where we expected; if we were still going to come upon it, it would be right ahead of us. I assumed that the length of the old drift as given on the plan would be correct; and its inclination one way or the other would either make it that we would not reach it, or we would meet it right ahead. I therefore told the men they need not continue the side borings. In August 1893, we decided to take out all the water from No. 1 Pit, so that it might reduce, as far as possible, the water in No. 4 Pit. We took 180 feet off the level of No. 4. That is 180 feet of head, which would be equivalent to a pressure of 90lbs to the square inch. When we had got within 33 feet of the water we expected to reach, and after the water had been reduced as far as possible in October, 1893, we commenced to put in a dam, of which a correct sketch is produced. On each side of No. 18 drift the shale was cut in to the depth of 3 feet, and after the ground was cleared out, we commenced to put in Swedish timber as shown on the plan, two in thickness, each 5 inches in thickness. Afterwards they were lined behind with 3-inch spruce deals. Then the cavities in the sides are all filled up with wood and wedges, making the ground solid to the breadth of the drift; after which four strong larch timbers, two of them 11 inches in diameter and two six inches were cut about a foot into the limestone in the sole, and into the hard grit in the roof about the same distance. To support the perpendiculars in the roof, a strong larch timber, 8 inches in diameter, was cut into the solid sides and brought right in front of the top part of the round larch timbers. A falling door was made in the centre of the dam, made small in order as far as possible to reduce the pressure against it. It was about 3 feet square, and the door was hung on the inside of the dam. There was also a valve put in the dam, so as to regulate the flow of water from it, in the event of our tapping it. - Was this the usual course to follow in tapping for water? I don't know, I am sure, but it was what I considered was the best under the circumstances. If the door had been on the "trig" when the water came away, the water would have closed it. I said if the water came in, the men would retire to No. 11. They could not have left the pit as easily. We did not expect such a body of water as would reach No. 16. We had a pretty good idea of the quantity of water we would have to contend with; and I have not found that there was more water than we anticipated. The moisture that I saw on the left side of the drift on the morning of the accident was at the very place where the water afterwards came through, but it was not to the same extent or lower down the drift, where we expected to have cut the water. That moisture I had seen every morning for about a week. On Saturday morning I noticed that there was a drop of water on a projecting piece of hard sandy shale; and I fancied that this drop was an indication that there was more than there had been. I accordingly sounded the ground over, and found it perfectly sound, and arranged to put in a bore-hole 9 feet in depth - a flat hole, bored horizontally into the actual place where the moisture was showing. The head of water that broke in was 124 feet. - How do you explain why the dam was smashed? I consider that the dam was broken away owing to two cast - iron pipes, which had been broken from a set of pumps in the dip, coming against the dam. - Of your own knowledge, can you say whether the dam would have been able to withstand the water if the door had been shut? It did stand. It took fifteen minutes before it gave way. - But if it took fifteen minutes, how is it that these men were drowned? The men were brought away with the rush of water through the door. There is no doubt Watson was down at the place where we found him five minutes before we found him. He was brought away with the first rush of water. The men in their excitement had gone from where they were baiting, and were up 18 road, at a level 60 feet higher up, at the time the dam gave way. You will have witnesses to prove that. - Witness, further questioned by Mr. Hedley: After the accident, I found that a hole had been made about 4 feet in diameter on the left side, about 9 feet from the fore-breast. That is 37 feet beyond the place where we expected to cut the water. This hole was about 3 feet 6 inches from the level of our sole; and the roofs of the old working and No. 18 were nearly one. If we had continued the boring of the flank holes, I do not think I would have found the water; the position of them would have been above the level of the water.

By Mr. Brown: The side of the drift where there was moisture was 9ft from the fore-breast, so that it must have been exposed for ten or twelve days - it would be really a fortnight before it gave way; a fortnight or more. I had kept my eye on this place, not with any special expectation of danger, but with the ordinary precaution of a manager, as it might have developed. If I had expected any heavy pressure of water immediately behind where I saw the moisture, I would have expected it weeping through the beds. On the Saturday morning I noticed there was a drop. Watson observed that it was sufficient to damp his clay if he stuck it in it; so that you may guess there wasn't much. Watson said there was no fear about the dropping. I however, determined to test it; and I took a pick and marked the place where a hole had to be bored; and it would have been begun then had there not been boys travelling on the roads in the drift. I gave directions that the hole should be driven on the Monday. Had that hole been put in, I think somebody else would be here to tell the tale. There was only 18 inches between me and the water, and the accident would have happened at once. If the door of the dam had been closed, the pipes which I think broke the dam away could not have reached the dam at all; and the fact that they did get there proves that the door must have been open. - Was there ever any stint of any possible expense, in order to protect the lives of your men? I was never interfered with, and had full power to do everything that was needful for the protection of the men who were working in the drift. The men employed in the drift were good and experienced miners - good, reliable men. The No. 11 road into which I told the men to retire immediately rose them 60 feet above the level of the drift. They perfectly understood where they were to go. If they had gone down No. 18 drift they would have got to a lower level, to which the water was bound to travel, and would thus have increased the danger.

By Mr. Marston: Though the dam was not built to control the water coming in at the point that it did, yet I think it was strong enough to resist the water coming from the point 37 feet from the dam where it burst in. - Could not all the water have been pumped out? Yes, provided plant had been put down for that purpose. Though it could have been done, it was considered by me at the time quite unnecessary to do it. If the working had been correct, we could certainly have connected the water without danger to life. I assume that these old plans were not correct; they must be wrong.

At this point the inquiry was adjourned in consequence of the absence of an important witness, Mr. Watson, the man who was badly injured by the accident. It was therefore decided to adjourn the inquiry until Wednesday, January 2nd, at the Greyhound Inn, Wath Brow.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Boaden, Joseph    Deputy  
Brown, T.    Solicitor  
Burnyeat, W.      
Carr, John    Juror  
Casson, Jackson    Juror  
Cleator, John    Juror  
Crone, David   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Fisher, William    Juror  
Hampson, Edward    Miner  
Harrison, David   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hedley, John Laidler    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hope, Moses    Juror  
Hunter, Isaac    Juror  
Hutchinson, John    Juror  
Irving, John William    Juror  
Johnston, Andrew    Mining Engineer  
Kelly, Owen    Miners' Labourer  
Kirkpatrick, George    Juror  
Kitchin, James Bateman    Manager  Whos Who Page
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lobb, George    Juror  
Marston, Daniel    Miners' Agent  
McGrath, Lawrence    Miner  
McLaughlin, James    Juror  
Nancarvis, Richard    Miner  
Pears, James    Juror  
Peile, William    Mining Engineer  
Southward, Abram    Juror  
Steele, William    Juror  
Tallen, John    Miner  
Toy, Thomas   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Walker, William Edward    Mining Engineer  
Watson, Thomas    Miner  Injured
Webster, John    Coroner  
Wood, Thomas    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Birks (Iron Ore)  Birks (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
20 Nov 1894  Flooding Of A Mine (The Times)
22 Nov 1894  Disastrous Flood At Birks Pit, Loss Of Three Lives (Whitehaven News)
13 Dec 1894  The Flooding Of Birks Mine, Inquest Yesterday (Whitehaven News)
03 Jan 1895  The Flooding Of Birks Mine, Adjourned Inquest, Yesterday (Whitehaven News)
10 Jan 1895  The Flooding Of Birks Pit, Inquest On 2nd January 1895 (Whitehaven News)
03 Jun 1937  Cleator Moor And District Notes (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Birks, No. 7 Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print