|
13th September 1894 Fatal Accident At WinderOn Friday last, Mr. J. Webster, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held an adjoined inquest, at the Royal Oak Inn, Frizington, touching the death of Thomas Kirvin, a miner, who was injured by a fall of the roof in Postlethwaite's mines, Winder, on Saturday last. Mr. W. Leck, Government Inspector of metalliferous mines, was present. Mr. T. Brown appeared for Postlethwaite's Eskett Mining Company, the proprietors of the Mines. — Daniel Tracey deposed that he lived at Winder, and was a miner at Postlethwaite's Mines, in the employment of Mr. Harper. On the 1st of the present month witness went to work at six a.m., along with several others. He was going to work in the No. 11 working. He was the first to arrive there, and afterwards Charles Burns, then Thomas Kirvin and last Thomas Wheelan. Witness set to work about half-past six. The first thing he did was to examine the working place himself. He did not think anyone else examined it. He examined the working place with a pick and hammer, sounding the sides and the roof. Burns and Kirvin were there when he examined the place. When he examined it in this way, his suspicions were not a bit aroused. Robert Batey, a deputy over-man had been in the working place before witness that morning; because witness found a spade with his name written with chalk and the date 1st September. After having examined the whole working place, witness and his companions commenced to take out a piece of metal, and then witness commenced to bore a hole, finished and fired it. It did not " get" properly, and witness charged it a second time and fired, and cleaned it down before they got their " bait" which would be about 10.30. After that witness examined where the shot had been fired, and dressed down again. He was working away dressing down, and the deceased was working behind him. — Mr. Wm. Dixon, mining engineer and surveyor, put in a plan and section that he had prepared of the place where deceased was injured; and he explained the plan, and said the piece of metal which fell was 3ft 6in in. length, 9in thick at one end, and 12 inches thick at the other, cigar shaped. — The witness Tracey continued to depose that whilst they were proceeding with their work, a piece of " pagging " and shale mixed fell from the left-hand side, entering the working. It broke in two, and one half of it caught the deceased man. Witness was satisfied with the examination he had made of the working place, and so was the deceased, who also was an experienced man, and he was quite satisfied that they struck and sounded this particular piece of stone. — By the Foreman: As an old experienced miner, witness would not have worked in the place if he had not considered it safe: neither would the deceased, who was an old and experienced miner also. — Charles Burns deposed that he lived at Winder, and was an iron-ore miner in the employ of Postlethwaite's Esskett Co. He worked in company with the last witness and deceased, and corroborated the evidence of the last witness. He never heard the lump fall till deceased fell. The lump fell upon a shovel which was upon deceased's abdomen. Waring Ivy's name 31st August, was in chalk upon a spade in the working place. — Last witness re-called, corrected his statement that Robert Batey's name, and Sep. 1st was upon the spade. He said it was Ivy's name and 31st August. Batey's name was not upon the spade. — Charles Burns said he was an experienced miner, and he considered the place was safe, and he might have been doing the same thing as deceased was. Deceased complained of pain in his abdomen and in his back; from pressure on the shovel on him by the lump, which fell. — Robert Batey deposed that he was one of the deputy-over-men at Postlethwaite's Eskett Mine. It was his duty to examine the working places, and report the result in a book kept for that purpose. He examined No. 11 working place on Saturday morning, sounding the sides of the roof. He saw the piece of pagging after it came away. The ends were thin. If it had been sounded at either end it might have sounded "drummy," but he did not find it so. "Pagging," was always a great deal duller to sound than stone. Witness saw deceased at his house after the accident. Deceased then said he felt first-rate, and smoked his pipe. He did not complain of any pain, and he did not complain of anything having been faulty at the pit, where he met his accident. From the conditions witness found deceased in, he did not expect that death would have resulted. The doctor said deceased died from shock to the system. — By Mr. Brown: The working place had been examined by Ivy on the night before, and then by Batey that morning, as well as by the men themselves. — Waring Ivy, deputy-over-man, said he examined No. 11 working between five and six on Friday evening, after the men had ceased to work, and he left his name and the date. — By Mr. Leck: The working places were examined in the afternoon whether the men were working or not. — Mr. Leck said that was a very careful system. Kirvin, son of the deceased, said his father complained of his back and his heart. The doctor told them to put linseed poultices to his back. He died from the effect of the accident witness was sure. Deceased was 53 years of age. — The coroner, in summing up, said no body appeared to have been to blame. Every care seemed to have been exercised. It was very important that the examination of these working places should be carefully made; for there was no doubt that careful examination prevented many accidents. — The jury returned a verdict of " Accidental Death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||