Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th April 1894

The Recent Mining Fatality At Moor Row

Adjourned Inquest Yesterday

An adjourned inquest was held yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon, at the Infirmary, Whitehaven, before Mr. Gordon Falcon, coroner, touching the death of James Fisher, aged 55 years, who was injured at the Postlethwaite Mines, Eskett, on the 2nd March, and who died from the injuries so received, on the afternoon of April 2nd, at the Infirmary. - Mr. Hedley and Mr. Oswald, Government Inspectors, were present at the inquest; and Mr. J. D. Kendall as representing Mr. Postlethwaite.

William James said he was the manager of Postlethwaite's Moor Row mine, which belonged to Mr. Miles Postlethwaite. The deceased James Fisher was a miner, and was working in No. 16 working-place, along with another man. He would go on at six o'clock in the morning. They get the ore by shot firing there. The accident occurred about 8.30. He was working with Archie Murphy. Murphy was boring a hole, preparing for a shot, and the deceased was working underneath. We have the places inspected every morning before the men go down, by a deputy-overman, James Nichol. He is here to day. I would have been in if the accident had not happened so soon. The fall took place 18 feet or 20 feet back. We don't at all times timber the roof, but we do so when we think it is necessary. There is wood supplied for that purpose. These places are inspected every morning before the men go in. While the men are working there is no practice of visiting every part of the mine; but I go wherever I think it necessary, and visit the greater part of the mine. - By the jury: The deceased was a practical miner, who knew his work. There had been a shot fired at the place the day before. The fall consisted of sandstone and partly of metal. I don't the fall was caused by the concussion of the shot of the previous day. It was a slippery "parting," but it could not have been detected by the inspector in the morning. The concussion in making the borehole might have helped to loosen the lump that fell. - By Mr. Hedley: Nichol had no other occupation than to examine the workings in the morning and during the day. He goes into some places two or three times if he considers it necessary; but this was considered a very safe place. There was no rule that Nichol should inspect every working place during the shift, though he had to into every working place in the mine before the men went in in the morning. Nichol would take a hammer and test the roof. If the roof was high he would have a ladder or a stage. In this particular working in which the accident occurred there was a stage. I was not in the working previous to the accident since the Wednesday, and the accident was on the Friday. There was no timber set in the place. In case timber was required, it was the duty of the men themselves to put in what timber was necessary, and it was Nichols duty if he thought any timber was wanted to be set, to tell the men to do it. The timber is provided at the pit top, and the men take it down when they want it. He thought it was useless taking timber down where it was not wanted. He could not say that that would be an inducement to the men to go on working without timber even although they did run a little risk. - Mr. Kendall said there was a rule requiring men to take down timber and set it up wherever they thought it necessary. - Witness, examined by Mr. Kendall, said Nichol had not reported the working as being unsafe. It had been regarded as a safe working for a long while. - By the jury: The deceased made reference to the "slape back" as the cause of the accident, but did not say anyone was to blame.

James Nichol, 65, Dalzell-street, Moor Row, deposed: I am an inspector at Postlethwaites pit, Moor Row. It was my duty to inspect the workings before the shift started in the morning. I inspected the working in which this accident occurred at about a quarter to six. I examined the workings with a single hand hammer. I remember pounding the particular lump that came away, getting up on a board for that purpose. The sound was in no way drummy, and I went away thoroughly satisfied that all was perfectly sound. I was not in this working place afterwards before the accident. I was in another pit, which is distant about five minutes' walk. I go between these two pits during the day. I could not account for the accident except by a little bit of a slip, which came up the roof; but I saw no signs of such a thing in the morning. - By a Juryman: I examined No. 5 pit, the one in which the accident took place, at from four till six o'clock. I consider two hours is enough time to examine the 16 working places, which are many of them as close together as pigeonholes. I examined No. 3 pit afterwards, but the men there are by that time going into the workings, and if I am not ready there is another man to take my place. - By Mr. Hedley: The reason of the difference made in the inspection of the two pits is because No. 3 is much easier gone through. There was more dressing down required in No. 5 pit. This is the first slip of this kind that I have seen in No. 5 pit. I examined the stone after the accident, and the place where the stone fell from. There was a kind of dampness, but I did not see any water. A stone with a damp slip might be examined by sounding and appear to be solid and yet not be. - Don't you think it would be better in such cases to order propping? Well, this was the first slip of that kind I had seen there. I would not have hesitated to work there myself, for it appeared to be quite safe, the stuff that had come down was mostly small, with the exception of the one piece that caused the accident. - By the jury: If he had found anything wrong with the place, he would have dressed it down, or ordered the miners to fetch wood down and do it; and he would have entered that in his report book. — By Mr. Oswald: No. 5 was considered a "troubled" pit. The strata was very irregular, and the metal in No. 16 working was "drafty," and required dressing down every day. It was not a treacherous place. It was only thin shale that they dressed down: nothing like half a ton. When it was dressed down the roof was good. They had to dress it down every day, or they could not work. Arthur Murphy, Ennerdale-road, Cleator Moor, deposed: I worked with James Fisher in No. 16 working. I had worked with him for two years. We had this particular working to ourselves - nobody else ever worked in it besides us. We had not fired a shot that day nor brought down any metal. I was on the staging drilling at the time, when a fall of stone took place. I had sounded that stone when I went in in the morning. I have always made a practice of sounding a work place before starting in it. I sounded it with a single-handed hammer. It sounded good, and I could detect nothing. Nothing came away but one piece of sandstone and metal - about five or six bogies full. A little dampness of water had come in on the Tuesday. Always previously the working was very dry. With the exception of the dampness I cannot say what may have caused the accident. I did not at the time consider the dampness was dangerous. The fall came away from what was called a cleat or a slip in the ground, which deceived us all, and as far as I know no one was to blame. When Nichol found anything wrong with the place, he told us, and expected we as practical men would look after it ourselves. - By a Juryman: There was no chance of seeing the slip before the stone came down. - By Mr. Oswald: They had constantly to be dressing down No. 16 working - the thickness of half-a-crown; never to the extent of half a bogie. They had to go over it perhaps once a week, except there was bad ground. There was bad ground perhaps twice a week, not oftener. - By Mr. Kendall: No. 16 was a safe enough working. It did not require timber. We are constantly firing shots, and we always dress after firing a shot. We are always dressing down. The working was not in the slightest degree an unsafe working.

James Berryman deposed: I live at Moor Row. I work in No. 1 working. On the day of the accident I assisted to bring Fisher here. The Doctor said, "It's a dynamite case again, I suppose." I said "No, it's a fall of the roof."

Dr. Tawse asked if anyone was to blame, and deceased in my present said "No, that there was no blame to anyone." Dr. Tawse said deceased was admitted on the 2nd March. He lived until the 2nd April. He suffered from a fracture of the right thigh, dislocation of the left hip, and a scalp wound. The immediate cause of death was congestion of the lungs, but that was caused by his injuries. Deceased said that the accident occurred from a fall of roof. He did not exonerate anybody from blame that I can recollect. Witness would not take much notice of the questions, except from a medical point of view. Deceased was delirious for nearly a month, and during that time took off his splints, threw his poultices at the nurse, and all sorts of things. He even got out of bed, sitting on the edge of the bed, with a fractured thigh and dislocated hip.

The Coroner, in summing up, remarked that in all his experience of inquests in coal-mining cases he never yet met a miner who had ever seen a report book. The report book was bound to be there, but he never yet met a miner who ever saw it. - Mr. Hedley: And I don't think you ever will. - The Coroner said the evidence in this case was straight forward, and the jury would have no difficulty in coming to a verdict. - The jury at once returned a verdict that the deceased met his death accidentally, casually, and by misfortune.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Berryman, James    Miner  
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Fisher, James   55 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hedley, John Laidler    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
James, William    Manager  
Kendall, John Dixon      Whos Who Page
Murphy, Arthur    Miner  
Nichol, James    Inspector  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Postlethwaite, Miles    Mine Owner  
Tawse, George Watson, Dr.    House Surgeon  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Postlethwaite's Eskett (Iron Ore)  Postlethwaite's Eskett (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print