1st March 1894
Important Trades Union Meeting In Millom
Address By Mr. Marston, Cleator Moor
On Monday afternoon an important and crowded meeting was held in the Co-operative Hall, Millom, in connection with the newly formed Miners' Trades Union. Matters now seem to be in a more satisfactory position, for last week the Hodbarrow Mining Co.
issued a second circular, intimating that they would maintain a neutral position with regard to the formation of the Union, but that they would object to any of their workmen leaving their work and canvassing during working hours.
Mr. Marston, at the commencement of the proceedings, said he felt like the old hero they read about in the scriptures. On one occasion he stood alone, and no man stood with him. In some respects he was like that individual this afternoon, whilst in
other respects he might not be like him. Although it could not be said that there was anyone standing with him on the platform, still be believed the great majority- he might say the entirety- of the meeting was with him in spirit. (Applause.) He
should like to say at the commencement of that meeting that he had taken charge of it himself. He regarded himself to a great extent as responsible for it, and what was more he was responsible for what might be the outcome of it. They would at once see
now in what a very difficult position he would be placed if he should have on the platform several men who might say something perhaps to which he could not fully subscribe. He regarded that meeting as being an important one so far as the future was
concerned. It was only by adhering to the principles of sound judgment and common sense that they could tread what might be termed a safe path during the future. There was
A Remarkable Document
In the form of a manifesto or letter, and he wished to say a word or two on one or two paragraphs, and he would endeavour to treat that manifesto in the best possible spirit. He would treat it without showing a spirit of favouritism on either side. He
found in one of the paragraphs of that circular that there was nothing further from the desires or wishes of the directors of the Company than to attempt to interfere with the liberty of action of anyone employed by the Company. Well, so far they were
perfectly agreed. They did not desire to express themselves in this way for the simple reason that by so doing they would be exceeding their legal right. There was nothing to boast of in that. In not interfering with their workman the Hodbarrow
Company were simply doing their duty, and nothing more than their duty. If they in any way interfered with the liberties or rights of the workmen they would be at once interfering with the law, and would be consequently be doing a criminal act in the
sight of the law. So far he might dismiss that paragraph. Coming down to one just a little more vital, which states that during the past forty years the Company had often times requested to form themselves along with others in what might be termed a
Masters' Union, and that they had always steadfastly refused to do so. Well, he did not know if there were any workman, he dared go a little further, and say that if the Company desired to join a masters' association, he was sure there was no one who
would say that they shall not, or would have the least objection to their so doing. (Applause.) Then there was the great question to be considered by their miners as to whether it would not be to their interest — the interest of themselves and
families — to maintain intact the cordial relations, which have always existed between the Company and themselves. Might he ask them which of their workmen had the least idea of going to undo anything, which would tend to sever the cordial
relationship, which has hitherto existed? No one desires to create any strife or warfare. If things are right all they asked was that they should continue so. If they were not right, then they should be put right in strict accordance with the
principles of justice and truth and of common sense. He found
A Rather Awkward Statement
a little further down. If the miners, as a body, joined the Union they would part with the management of their own affairs. He did not profess to understand every thing, but this was one of the things, which was a mystery to him. He could not tell
what was meant by the statement, "That if the miners, as a body joined the Union, they would at once part with the management of their own affairs." His impression was that if they joined as a body they were just beginning to take an interest
in their own affairs. He was sure the statement was the outcome of a very imperfect understanding about Trades Unionism. Then there were references made as to the philantrophy shown with regard to the sick and hospital arrangements, and the cheapening
of rents, &c. With reference to this, he had only one question to put. They found that 40 years ago the Company commenced operations at Hodbarrow. He dared say the Company now would have a pretty fair idea as to their individual position. Now if
they took their individual or collective position at that day and balance them up with what they were today he wondered how matters would harmonise, and whether the balance sheets for the two dates would show that the Hodbarrow Mining Company were poorer
to-day on account of the hospital and this sick fund, &c., or rather that they, in spite of their philantrophy, were better off, and if they were better off how did they come to be better off? Would it not be the practical outcome of their workmen's
labour at the Hodbarrow mines? (Applause.) He took it for granted that if in Lapstone road he met a poor fellow who solicited an alms, and if he assisted him, and afterwards met him a little later on in the day in some other part of the town, and
taunted him with receiving relief simply because he differed in politics or something else. Would not this fellow think it was a little mean of him to do so, more especially if he had been a workman of his who for several years had contributed to
improve his condition. He regarded this paragraph in the same light. The Company had offered a gift out of their abundance, and that abundance had been procured by the workmen's individual and collective labour. (Applause.) The workmen did not want
charity; they wanted justice that was all. (Applause.) If they will give the workmen a just return for his honest toil, he dared say the working men would be prepared to take the responsibility, but if they did not get this they would ask for some
larger share in the outcome of their labour. There were several other things that perhaps deserved a little attention. One thing he found was the statement with regard to the untruthful and foolish rumours, which had been circulated. He wanted to
disclaim any connection with these. He did not circulate any of these rumours that men had been discharged for taking an active part in connection with the Miners' Union. Well that may be so, he was not going to dispute it. But at the same time he did
not see much difference if a man has to suffer simply because he did not get on well with one of his relations. Putting aside the manifesto, he said that since the issuing of the same other means had been adopted to try if possible to get a correct
understanding as to how they stood. He wanted it to be distinctly understood that any man who worked at Horbarrow had a perfect right and liberty, so far as the Company were concerned, to join as many trades unions as he wished, and that no man would
interfere with him directly or indirectly for so doing. (Applause.) He wanted now to come to what might be termed
The Future.
He thought he might state that as a body of workmen the Hodbarrow miners were practically a united band. (Applause.) There were not so many Hodbarrow miners outside the Miners' Union today, and he might safely say that the time was not far distant when
the number that would be left outside could be counted on their fingers. Now he wanted to say a word or two with the reference to the position of the directors. The Trades Union was recently formed, and he wished to make a short plea in the directors'
behalf. When railways were first instituted, most horses when they saw the puff of a steam engine felt just a little frightened, but after a little time they became reconciled to the changed condition of things, and stood quiet as the express rolled by.
The directors of the Hodbarrow Company were never accustomed to Trade Unionism. So far as the history of Trades Unionism was concerned he believed they had read a good deal of reference to it, but they seemed to remember most about that side which
dealt with strikes, lookouts, and disasters. There were, however.
Two Sides To Trades Unionism,
and he asked the workingman to try and feel for the position, which the Hodbarrow Company found themselves in today. Something new had arisen in their midst, and they could not yet fully grasp or understand what this Trades Unionism meant, and their
whole fear was that there may be commercial disasters as the outcome of this institution in Millom. If the workmen would but unite themselves together, and exercise common sense and patience, they would bring them by-and-bye to see their true position
and the workmen's true position towards their employers. They would then see that the Trades Unionists were not a band of rebels, nor a band ready for revolution. They had no idea of turning the headgear upside down. He felt sure, if they exercised a
little patience, the directorate would soon become coolimatised, and that they would get to understand them. There was one feature that they should not loose sight of in connection with such concerns as Hodbarrow and other places. There was a necessity
for strict discipline on the part of the management and the workmen. The character of the work demanded that there should be someone at the helm- someone there constantly with a practical knowledge and a cool head. Whether there was or not he was not
going to say — such like concerns could not be conducted unless strict disciplines were maintained, but discipline did not mean despotism. So long as the management exercises themselves to this extent in their official duties, and does not exceed
it, he had not a word of fault to find with them, neither would Trades Unionism. He thought they would honour a manager who did his duty in this respect to his employer, but there was dual responsibility, however, resting upon a manager. He had not
only to do his duty to his employers, but he had to realise his duty to the workmen, over whom he had control. If the managers treated their workmen and their employers, and carried out the principles of the second great commandment, "to learn to
love thy neighbour as thyself," they could all get to like them the better. There was a fear of disaster following the establishment of Trades Unions in Millom. There was a need of common sense to guide them and direct them in all things. (hear,
hear.) There was also a latent common sense, a common sense that needed to come into operation and wanted to be exercised by both the workmen and managers alike. There was one thing, which the workmen should learn and apply to themselves, and that was
self-respect. They knew there were a certain class of employers that have been accustomed to look upon working men more as chattels and instruments by which they might accumulate large fortunes and secure luxuries. There were also employer's
conscientious men, who desired to treat their workmen in a righteous spirit. He was sorry for the former, and he thought they were objects, which required their commiseration more than their censure. At the same time, there were workmen who needed to
exercise
A Little More Common Sense
and self-respect. Workingmen should learn that their interests were identical, and that they could not injure one another without injuring themselves. Past history was full of records where workingmen had been the greatest enemies to themselves.
(Applause.) From a political point of view what did they find to day? Take the working class during an election period, and what did they find? They found them caviling amongst themselves as to whether the Conservative or Liberal party were the best.
If they listened to this caviling they would find out that those questions which were most vital to themselves were not paid any attention to. Every workingman should learn to legislate for his own class without any regard to party. What the working
class wanted to learn was this. They should learn to do a little more of their own business than they have done in the past. (Applause.) The working classes have been accustomed to be represented by proxy. Some large landowner was sent to parliament
to represent them, but instead of doing so he represented himself. They should learn to emulate the example of the classes, and study their own interests a little more. The workingmen of to day were beginning to awake and to fully realize their
responsibilities. Their responsibilities were widespread and far-reaching, not only in the realm of politics but also in the realms of social life and commercial subjects, and the sooner they grasped this the better it would be for them. He detested a
backbiter amongst themselves. (Applause.) He hated a backbiter as he did the devil. And backbiters did not always regard the principles of truth. He hated a liar as he did the devil. (Applause.) Depend upon it any man who would stoop to backbite
owing to self-regards for no one, would not stop at lying to obtain his purpose. They would never lose anything by being honest one to another. It was the best policy all round. He would always try whether he succeeded or not by adhering rigidly, in
dealing with working men or employers, to the principles of truth and justice and fairplay. Last time he spoke in that hall he said something about favouritism. He did not like it. It was not honest. He did not say that it was dishonest for a man to
receive a fair return for his labour, but he did say that it was unfair for a man to receive an undue proportion to the disadvantage of his fellow labourers. He wanted to say a word or two
About Intimidation
He did not like to be intimidated, as he would not if he knew it. Whilst he would not allow any one to intimidate him, at the same time he did not like any one to intimidate any one else. Now he had heard — it was a matter of hearsay. He had the
fact communicated to him, that there were workmen at the Hodbarrow mines who, instead of minding their work wandered up and down like a commission agent, endeavouring to intimidate men to become members of the Miners' Union. When he heard a thing he
liked to know if it was the truth. He did no believe it was true, but he would say this. If it was true it ought no to be. (Applause.) If it was not true he would try to correct it. He classed it as a wrong impression floating about in the
atmosphere, which belonged to that class of foolish and untruthful statements. Now he wanted the managers of the Hodbarrows Mines to understand this, and also the workmen of the Hodbarrow Mines to understand it, that nothing of this kind is required at
their hands, and their Trades Union rules did not countenance such like things. There was a great difference between a man working alongside another asking him if he had joined the Union, and telling him he must do so. His policy was the policy of
persuasion. They should try to convert men by honest reasoning and by just persuasion, and if they did not succeed in getting them to become members of the Miners' Union in this way, he would not countenance any act interfering with their fellow-workmen
to try to make them become members. If men had to be taken by the throat and forced into a house they were never good company when they got inside. (Applause.) Men needed to become Trades Unionists by conviction and if they did not feel that Trades
Unions were calculated, if managed wisely, to promote the welfare and benefits of the working class, then he wanted them o remain outside. If they were not converted to their belief then they were better in the other place. (Applause.) What was more
than that he never treated such men knowingly with any but a friendly spirit? He gave them credit for their convictions. There were, however, two sides to this question; they had treated their own side pretty honestly, so far as they could, but,
perhaps there was some little
Fault To Find With The Opposite Side
If he was to believe reports there was miners found ready to intimidate one another, and the officials had also had been intimidating men. If such a thing as intimidation was held to their side of the house, some one else would have to take a fair share
of the responsibility. One of the latest things that came to his knowledge was a matter, which he did not care to say much. He had a profound respect and he said this with all sincerity for the ministers of the various denominations. He did not think
that it was right that they should interfere with the men because they had joined a Trades Union. (Applause.) He did not think it was perfectly fair of these men to do this if they had done so. He wanted them to understand that it was not fair and what
was more he wanted to tell them that if such like things existed he would be bound to tell them very plainly about it. He again said that he respected a minister of any denomination. He did not believe in any minister assuming a position, which his
Master would not assume towards the workingmen. God gave men free will, and he believed He did not intend any minister to interfere with it. He regarded ministers as educated men- men who had opportunities of ascertaining facts and grasping matters and
dealing with subjects in a way which ordinary everyday working men could not do, and it was more their duty to enlighten working men than to keep them in the dark. (Applause.) It was a well-known fact, and he thought there were none who would refute it,
that Trades Unions, with all their disadvantages, or supposed disadvantages, had done a lot to enlighten and elevate workingmen. They had minds of their own, and should exercise them. They had their liberties, which were their sacred right, and no
minister had a right to interfere with them. If their wages were low, or anything was wrong with their income, these ministers would not help to make it up out of theirs. (Applause.) But Trades Unions would in time put that right. He was going to
suppose in connection with the Hodbarrow Mines. He was only going to suppose, as it was very difficult to make definite statements, and he did not like to make definite statements. He was going to suppose that there were certain evils- certain
injustices in existence at these mines. They would agree with him that these things had not grown up like the gourd in Jonah's prophecy in a night. They were not of mushroom growth, but had been growing and developing for some considerable time. If
they existed could they expect that they had but to wave the magic wand of Trades Unionism, and there would be a quick change and they were all gone. They could not do that. They required to treat the disease with a remedy which was in perfect harmony
with the needs of the case. There might be certain conditions existing between workmen and their employers, which had not grown up in a day, and
Would Not Be Put Right In A Day
They wanted to exercise patience — (Applause) — and to arrive at what was right in a constitutional common sense method. (Applause.) He had no intention, and he assured the directorate of Hodbarrow of this, that he had no intention of
bringing the men out on strike. He had never brought out men on strike, but he had sometimes kept them in. (Applause.) He had never advocated a strike, and he thought he never would. He recognized this fact that if at any time there were evils to be
redressed every peaceful and every reasonable effort should be put into operation and allowed a fair trial before they would risk the extremist of all methods, a strike. So far as the workmen of the Hodbarrow Mines were concerned, he would, through the
medium of the press, assure the directors and manager that they were prepared to listen to what was fair, and just, and right, and that there was a desire to keep everything in perfect harmony. All they asked was their rights. (Applause.) There was a
position taken by managers, which was a little comical to his way of thinking. They always referred to him as a third party. He was glad he was not No. 1. They regarded him as an individual who had nothing whatever to do with these matters between
themselves and their workmen. What was a manager, or rather what was he not? [Voice: In most cases.] With exceptional instances. He was now referring not to the directorate or to a manager with an interest in the proprietorship, but to a servant the
same, as they were, who was paid for attending to the interests of their employers. Supposing the workmen, whose labour were their capital, had a mind to form themselves together in a body, and say now that they were united and in a position to protect
their interests, and commission him to look after their interests, and pay him for this work, such a man would be the workmen's paid servant
Just The Same As The Manager
is the servant of the proprietor he represents. (Applause.) He had no regard to assume anything unusual on his part, but he felt himself generally on an equal with these men. (Applause.) He held a position, which brought him on the same level —
on the same platform. He always respected these men so far as their position went. He never went past the manager to the proprietor of the works. If a manager met him it might possibly be settled with him in the first place. If he would not then of
course he had to go to higher authority and be settled there generally. (Applause.) He did not wish to interfere with matters at the mines if nothing goes wrong. He liked to see everything all right, and to see things working evenly, every man getting
his right, and getting a fair share. If they would not do this, but will still resist against right principles, depend upon this, third parties — outside agencies — will crop up. In concluding, Mr. Marston introduced to the notice of those
present the various benefits to be derived from being connected with the Miners' Association.
In proposing a vote of thanks to the speaker, Mr. Phillips alluded to the rumour about men going about canvassing. He had only just joined, and if there were any canvassing it was surprising that no one asked him to do so before. He supposed they
thought he was safe enough to come ultimately. - Mr. T. Rundle seconded the vote, which was carried with acclamation, and Mr. Marston having duly acknowledged the compliment, the meeting was brought to a close.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Marston, D. | | | |
| Rundle, T. | | | |