Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

25th January 1894

The Hodbarrow Miners

Trade Union Meeting

On Saturday afternoon Mr. D. Marston gave an address in the Co-operative Hall, Millom, on the advantage of Trades Union Combination. At five o'clock, the time which the meeting was announced, there were not very many in the hall, but men soon began to flock in, and by the time the proceedings commenced the room was well filled, the numbers being further augmented as the meeting proceeded, and very soon the building was crowded. It was evident that a great change had taken place since the last effort was made to start a branch of the Union in Millom. Several meetings have been at one time or another held in the town with the object of inducing the miners to identify themselves with trade organisations, but such efforts met with very little success, the meetings being generally very meagrely attended. On the present occasion, however, the miners appear to have taken up the idea with a good deal of ardour. The remarks of Mr. Marston's on the advantages of trades unions were carefully listened to, and it was evident that his recommendations for the men organise were appreciated. At the conclusion of his speech, Mr. Marston was the recipient of quite an ovation from the crowded audience.

Mr. Richards, an old trades unionist, occupied the chair, and in opening the meeting expressed his pleasure at seeing such a large and crowded meeting. It was evident that something was in the wind, and that they meant business. After giving a very good account of Mr. Marston, whom he said he had known for years, he alluded to the work that had been done in connection with trade organisations since he was first connected to them some 23 years ago. If they identified themselves with the Miners Association, there was no doubt that if they wished Mr. Marston would represent them, and Give the same satisfaction as he had given at Cleator Moor. He then called Mr. Marston to address the meeting.

Mr. Marston said the object for which the meeting was called, was for the purpose of discussing trades unionism. He had on previous occasions spoken to the workingmen of Millom and endeavoured so far he was able to point the advantages of combination. The men of Millom he believed had never disputed for one moment that there were advantages in combination, but up to that they had not felt it necessary to give practical expression to their ideas. However, they had now come to the conclusion that combination was not only a good thing, but they were not bent upon carrying that idea into practice (Applause.) There were still mistaken ideas with reference to the object of the trades union of to day. It was said by some that their motto was defiance, but he distinctly contradicted this. (Applause.) The motto of trades unions was defence not defiance. They had men in all parts of the country organised into workmen's associations. Was it that they might defy their employers? Not at all? It was that by combination they might obtain for themselves that which it was their just right to receive. They combined themselves together for the protection of their individual and collective interests. That is why and what they combine themselves together for. One of the leading features of trades unions — it might be one of the chief objects of trades unions, but it was not the sole object - was to keep up wages. Some people make a great deal or fuss about working men combining for this purpose, but if workmen did not receive wages what had they to live upon. Consequently wages was a vital question and men had a perfect right to organise for this purpose. (Applause.) Working men realised by hard and bitter experience that they did not receive the same rate of wages through being disorganised as they could by combining and presenting a united front to the capitalist. As wages was an all-important question to a workingman if by combination he could secure better wages then he had a perfect right to combine for that purpose. (Applause.) There was another side to this question. Wages was the one thing, but not everything. Workingmen in some places have had fair wages paid, but there was something else. There were employers who paid fair wages, and who got a sort of idea that the workman sold himself for what was paid him. Another thing, therefore, that men combined for was to secure to themselves and their class fair treatment. (Applause.) Workingmen were men, not mare machines. He had not read anywhere in his Bible, and he was not ashamed to state that he read it frequently, that God created a certain class of human beings that they might be mechanics, and that they might procure luxuries and riches for another class. (Applause.) Whether they cared to acknowledge it as a fact or not they were all brethren. It mattered not what might be their condition or status in society they were brethren, and their interests were identical. And the sooner this was realised the sooner would good times come for them all. Another object of trade's unionists was to pay attention to the interests of members in the time accidents. They knew what a dangerous calling mining was. They had only to glance down and inspect the reports year after year to see the record of accidental deaths. Every year they found that some noble and useful lives had been cut down by the dangerous mines. In years gone by the men were taken out of the mine and buried by their friends. There was a little more humanity in the society of to day. Now if every effort is not made to secure the men's safety the companies are asked to pay compensation to the relatives. They would know, however, that it was utterly impossible for 90 per cent. of the working men to take up the question of compensation on their own bottom, and fight it through the law courts. To day the trade's union societies do this for them, and in the Cleator Moor district £400 had been secured as compensation without costing the relatives one farthing, and it only cost the society something like £13 or £14. Then there was another reason why the men should be organised. There was an important feature, to be taken into consideration, particularly in connection with the wage question. It was a question that was often over-looked, though he had to combat it when occasion called for it — in vague disputes. The first thing they heard from the employer's side was that the place was not paying, and they were compelled to make this reduction. It always struck him as rather strange that the employers never looked to the official side for relief, but always to the poor workingman. If a person meant to be inquisitive, and had the means to satisfy their inquisitiveness, he would find in connection with some of the employments the works did not pay principally on account of the high wages and salaries paid to the officials. It is well enough to talk about paid agitators but he did not know one single official who got less - the great majority of them got a great deal more for his officialdom than he got for this paid agitation. If those who spoke in this manner but knew the amount of work that had to be done in connection with his position it would probably make a change in their opinion. If his own advice were accepted he would say to some of the employers dispense with the superfluous incompetent officialdom, and it would be found that the works would pay better and the employers would also be in a position to pay their men better. (Applause.) What were the results of combination? Some would say strikes and disaster. Trades organisations did not manufacture strikes. In the great majority of cases where strikes did occur, if the employers of labour would listen to reason and submit to what was fair and just, a strike would never have happened. (Applause.) Coming to some of the results of combination he said he might place in the category of these results the Mines Acts, the Factory Acts; the advancement made in the Eight Hours Question the Employers Liability Bill &c. Did they ever hear anything about any of these measures before combination came into existence? (No) What about the Mines Acts? Read the history of the mining community and what did they find? They found, at one time men were worked like mere machines or slaves without any regard being paid to their personal safety. Time rolled on and, began to realize that they were men, and they got men into the House of Commons in sympathy with the working classes; and the Mines Acts and other measures were thereby made reality to-day, and every employer was now held responsible for the safety of his workmen. For this advancement they had to look to such men as Tommy Burt, Crawford, McDonald, Fenwick, John Wilson, &c. Did they hear anything of these men before combination becomes a reality? Combination gave advantages some of their fellow-men, which educated them and raised them a little higher in the social scale, through these men would not say that they were say higher socially than their fellow — toilers in whose interests they laboured in the House of Commons. It was to combination they had to look for the advantages working men enjoy to day. Look back to the history of the Manchester Factories and those of other places of the kind. What did they find recorded in the pages of this history? Children were imported, in some cases, from workhouses, and were obliged to work twelve hours in the factories. They were taken from their work and put into beds, which had never been cold — kept warm by those who had to go to take their places. They were worked like little slaves day and night. Now the factory laws were a reality, and the remedy to this sort of thing was due to combination and the assistance of such friends as Shaftesbury, who advocated the interests of the toiling masses. The Eight Hours Bill had passed the second reading. He wished it had passed the third. They had to thank to a great extent combination for the advancement made in this direction (Applause.) With regard to the Employers Liability Bill, the House of Lords were now trying to tamper with it. It was a noble institution was the House of Lords. (Laughter.) The Lords did not represent anybody but themselves. After quoting the Chamberlain's scathing criticism on the House of Lords, which the Unionist leader delivered in 1881, Mr. Marston went on to state that if the Bill passed as it was brought into the House of Commons by the Home Secretary, it would be a great boon to the working classes. The Bill was directly or indirectly the outcome of combination. John Burns — (applause) - a man who deserved every honour from his class, during the 12 months he had been in the House of Commons, had done, he ( the speaker) believed, more than any other in the advancement of labour reforms. Such progress had never been made, and he believed that it was to John Burns chiefly that they owed what they had got from the Government recently, viz, the establishment of an eight hours day in some of its departments. Take the late coal strike. He saw that in Millom they discussed it, and if he did not make a mistake they had done something for those who were suffering in consequence of that strike. The strike showed, whatever capitalists might say, that the men won the victory. It showed the power of combination. It had, he believed established what was never recognised in England before, "a living wage." Now the platform and the pulpit were vying with each other telling humanity at large what is man's duty to man. And to crown all they the action of the Government and of Lord Rosebery. (Applause.) Did not all these thing show them that combination was necessary for the interests of the working class? Combination had beneficial results, but some men might urge the suffering that had been undergone as an argument against it. Take what phase of life they would, whether political freedom or religious freedom, which of them were procured without bloodshed and suffering? Men had to suffer for their principles, and depend upon it they would not secure for themselves all that they were rightfully entitled without having to suffer more yet. Mr. Marston then dealt with the hindrances, which sometimes kept combination back. It was, he said, to the advantage of the capitalists and employers to keep up the bickering and quarrelling amongst working men. Sometimes men's political and religious opinions are utilised for this object. He (the speaker) had no objection to a man holding a contrary opinion to himself. If a man had a mind to be a Roman Catholic, or to belong to the Episcopalian Church, or the Wesleyans, or Primitives, or any other section of the Church, it was a matter of perfect indifference, from a certain point of view. Perhaps he might wish and desire in his heart that the man might think otherwise. If they held different opinions in these things; if they did not see eye to eye in maters of this kind still let them not fall out about it, but agree to differ. How often had political opinions interfered with working men's combination? Men would not join because trade organisation was said to be Liberal or Conservative. It was nothing of the kind. If employers got them fighting amongst them selves it was an easy matter for their employers then to beat the whole of them. (Applause.) They had interests in common. He did not agree with those men who thought their employers should be used as tools. He had no such opinion and he believed that working men would do what was just and right to their employer. (Applause.) He would be the last man in the world knowingly countenance injustice on the part of any man, but at the same time he asked the same thing from the employers to do justly towards him. (Applause.) Working men had a living to earn, they had to labour for their wages, and by uniting together they were in a position to protect their interests and secure for themselves better conditions without neglecting the interests of their employers; then it was their duty to another and to their families to do so. (Applause.) The sooner workingmen recognise the fact the better it will be for themselves and for their employers. There was another thing, which interfered with the progress of organisations amongst working men, viz., certain kinds of favouritism in works. He was sorry to have to say that there were workingmen, who, for the sake of a selfish advantage over their fellow-workers, pay no regard to their common interests. Some short time ago he was speaking to a number of workingmen. The average wage paid at the works where the men were engaged was very low. These men sent for him to ascertain if he would decide that they should come out on strike. He advised them not to do so but to keep in work. This was six months ago, and the men were working yet. He told them that they could not expect that the Association to which he belonged would allow him to transact their business, and endeavour to better their condition without they were part of that organisation. He informed them that he had no desire to coerce them in any way, but he thought it would be to their interest to join the Association. They were welcome to his advice, but he could not undertake to transact their business unless they were members of the association. A man who was sitting in the front row said, "Well I wish to know what you came here for. For the last 20 years no one outside interfered with us before, and I think we are quite capable of managing our own business yet." He afterwards ascertained that this individual got a considerably higher rate of wages than the rest of the men. He did not object to a workingman getting good wages, but he certainly did protest against such a person interfering with others - who were not getting perhaps half as much — and trying to prevent them from taking some means to benefit them selves. They might depend upon it wherever this favouritism was in existence it was used as a tool in the employers hands, and what was more than that, as soon as such a person served the employers purpose he might then go where he liked. Combination used wisely conferred many advantages in the working class. He had before said from that platform that it would not be a disadvantage in any form, but rather an advantage to be an honest and fair-minded employer. He could give instances from his own district if time permitted. If by organising here in Millom they could improve their condition and protect their interests better than what had been the case in the recent past, then he advised them by all means to organise. He might say this was entirely a matter of opinion and advice. For anything he knew there might be someone on the opposite side at that meeting — some on the employers side. That was a matter of no consequence to him. He liked them to here these opinions as well as the workmen. His advice to the workmen was to organize. At the same time let their organisation be based upon justice and right. They had to be disappointed if the organisation did not secure 50 per cent. Advance in their wages in the first six weeks. See to it that their organisation was firmly based on that which was honest and true and just, then when any differences arose, whether it affected an individual or the whole general body, they had to calmly deliberate and wisely rule their proceedings. There's an old proverb, which says, "Make haste slowly." This was very good advice to give to workingmen generally. His belief was that if they formed a thorough organisation in Millom strikes would not be the outcome of that organisation. If the employers were willing to recognise that organisation of their workers it would tend to create and develop a good feeling between the two parties, which usually worked out to the benefit of employer and employed alike. He was pleased to see others besides miners at the meeting. He believed it was the business of ministers of religion and others to come to their meetings and hear what they had to say upon the labour question, and thereby become better acquainted with their difficulties and their interests. They would then learn to have more sympathy with them, and understand them better than they profess to do at present. (Applause.)

Mr. Richards said he considered that they had received some sound sensible advice; the next thing to do was to carry it into practice. He combated the idea that Trades Unions led to strikes and disturbances, and he strongly advised them to organise in Millom.

A vote of thanks to the Chairman and speaker brought a very enthusiastic meeting to a close.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Burns, John      
Burt, Thomas      Whos Who Page
Crawford, William      Whos Who Page
Fenwick, —      
Marston, D.      
McDonald, —      
Richards, —      
Rosebery, Lord      
Wilson, John      Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print