Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

28th December 1893

Fatal Accident At Croft Pit, Whitehaven

The adjourned inquest on view of the body of Henry Haig, who was crushed against the side of the road in Croft Pit, near Whitehaven, was held at the infirmary, on Friday afternoon last, before Mr. Gordon Falcon (Coroner for West Cumberland), and a jury, of whom Mr. John Waugh was foreman. Mr. T. H. Brockbank appeared to watch the interests of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and Mr. J. Webster was in attendance on behalf of deceased's relatives. Mr. A. Sharp, secretary to the West Cumberland Miners Association, was in attendance, as was also Mr. R. W. P. Oswald, Deputy Inspector of Mines; and Mr. W. Redshaw (Manager of Croft Pit), Mr. Joseph Haig (Brother of deceased), and Mr. John Stafford (brother-in-law of the deceased).

Richard Donald, 21, Newtown, miner, engaged at Croft Pit, under the Whitehaven colliery company, said he was working there on Friday night last as a hewer. Witness was a practical miner, but he could not mind ever seeing Haig before. Witness was coming up the incline between six and seven o'clock at night. He was coming off the back shift. He was walking up with the deceased. They heard when the set was put over the top. When they got past the manhole he said, "Here's a set coming." They stepped on to the full road. He heard it was coming faster than usual. He said "the sets amain. Lets get out of the road as sharp as we can." When he turned he saw a manhole on the left-hand side, the contrary side. They made for it, and witness threw himself on his hand and dived into the manhole. Deceased was following as sharp as he could. The set came down the side of the manhole. They thought they would be safer in a manhole. There is no spare room to stand when the tubs pass. The only place of safety was the manholes. The tubs worked by the endless rope system, bringing them down and up at the same time. The manhole they passed, and this one they got into were at a distance of 17 yards apart. There was nothing to distinguish the manholes. Some of the manholes would hold four and others six persons. Deceased tried to follow witness into this manhole, and was caught at the edge of the manhole, catching deceased's right-hand side. The bogies were going so fast that he could not count them. Witness had never seen bogies going amain before this, and he had worked at Croft Pit near two years. Witness could not say of his own knowledge how the bogies got set away. The bogies got off the way below where the accident occurred. They would have come 70 or 80 yards before Haig was struck.

By Mr. Oswald: They would be five or six yards off the manhole when they heard the tubs coming down.

By Mr. Webster: the road was only sufficient for the bogies to pass. The manholes were on the left-hand side. Deceased was before witness. When the sets got away they could not depend on it keeping on the rails. He did not know what the distance between the manholes should be. He had heard that the distance between the manholes should be ten yards.

Mr. Webster read the section of the act bearing on this question, which provided for manholes at intervals not exceeding 20 yards.

By Mr. Webster: This was an endless rope. The manhole was 4ft. 2in. wide and 2ft. 10in. high. They had been making no alterations at the road that he was aware of.

George Hooper (Mining Engineer) put in the plan, adding that the deceased, he was told, was killed at the middle manhole. The holes were measured by witness. The plans were made from his measurements.

Examinations of Donald continued: he did not know that the manhole had been whitewashed. If the manhole had been the same height as the travelling way he thought deceased could have thrown himself in. Witness saw the clutch bogie on the incline, when he went up. It had gone down three yards, and witness's son stopped it. Witness unfastened it, and spragged the wheel. It was the duty of a man named smith to fasten the tubs to the clutch bogie.

Mr. Webster asked if the Coroner would help the friends of the deceased by allowing their representatives to examine the manhole? - Mr. Brockbank said that had nothing to do with this inquiry, but they would be prepared to consider any reasonable request. - Mr. Webster said that he made the request now. - Mr. Brockbank said if they had a formal request before them they would consider it. If there was anything the Coroner required for the purpose of the inquiry it should have immediate attention. - The Coroner did not think it would be required. - Mr. Oswald said he had examined the place, and probably his evidence would do.

Mr. Hooper recalled, said the manholes were the height of the rail below the manholes. The manhole was 3ft 11in high, and four feet wide. The centre manhole was 56¾ ft between that one and the bottom one, and from the top one 61½ ft. The roof was 6ft high at this place. The height of the manhole from the top of the rail was 3ft 7in. As far as he knew there was no alteration in the manhole since the accident. He prepared the plan on Saturday last. He had not heard of any alteration to the manhole.

George Smith, living at Kells, said he put on the sets at Croft Pit, and was working there at a quarter to seven o'clock that night. His duty was to fasten the tubs on and put the sets off. There were ten tubs in the set, and the clutch bogie. They were all coupled together, and this particular set was coupled with a link and a drop into it. It was a shackle bolt with a pin. The rope was going slow. Tom Wilson put the rope in the shackle, and witness screwed the set. As soon as it got over the brow the pin jumped out. He could not say whether the jerk of the rope did it or the pulley. He had seen a jerk of the rope do it before. Witness at once knocked; and stopped the rope. They were working the same bogie regularly. The pin was quite in good working order - the same as others. The pin was about eight inches long. As soon as they got over the brow top he found the tubs had gone, and jumped and knocked hold. Sets had gone off before, but this was the first set that had ever got away from him. It was not a common thing for sets to get away - they might get away once a month. He did not know that a man was injured a short while ago by the set getting away.

By Mr. Oswald: He could not tell if he was at the brow top if a set got away a mile below. It would have to fasten itself before they knew. Witness was quite sure he had the pin in before the set started.

By Mr. Webster: Wilson was assisting witness that day at the brow top. Witness was pushing the clutch bogie. There was no one present but witness and Wilson. As soon as the tubs got on the incline they gave a clinch. The tubs stretched the rope. Witness did not see the pin come out. He asked several people as to the pin, and witness ultimately found it near the "T" pulley, aside of the brow top. The pin was attached by a lump of wire to the clutch bogie. Witness said he had not got the fastenings here for the jury to view. It was a quarter or half-an-hour after this occurrence that he found the pin. The pin had opened the wire out and broken it off the clutch bogie chain, after the pin came out. If they had a lock for the pin it might have saved it. The pin could be knocked out by the rope or the jerk. Witness never saw a set get away but this one. - Mr. Webster: Is it not a fact that repeatedly these things get away? - Witness: Not so often. He did not know that men were being fined for letting tubs get away. They had not fined him. He thought the weight of the tubs might be 5 or 6 cwt. The chain was in no way injured. There was no mark on the draw bar. Fothergill, the pit top gaffer, examined the tackle and such like. The pin was not bent. The rope might hit the pin at any time, and there was nothing to prevent it. He had known this to be done before. It could not have come away if it had been locked. Witness had the sole charge and set them off.

By Mr. Sharp: He clutched the bogies 50 yards off. The drag bar goes below the tubs. He saw the men coming up, and stopped the set. He asked the men if they were coming up and they said no. The pin went straight down. If the shackle was put into the nipple it would be better. This manhole where the accident occurred was in the arches. He did not remember whether the arch had sleepers in.

By the Coroner: It was not possible that the pin was not put in.

Thomas Wilson, Hanger-on at the pit bottom, said he was present when the set was set away. Witness saw Smith put the pin on the set, being three or four yards away. The rope was going slow, and they gave no further signal when the set was got right. The clutch bogie got over two or three yards. Directly the sets own weight got over they went away. Witness pushed them to the top. He did not know whether the weight of the tubs would not help to keep the pin in. The pin was not attached to the clutch bogie when it was found. They just put the pin in without catch or screw. Witness had not seen the particular bogie working that struck down the deceased.

By Mr. Oswald: the chain was lying in the middle of the road in front of the clutch bogie. As soon as the set got their own weight they went right away.

By Mr. Webster: Wilson was there when the pin was found near the brow top, aside the pulley. When the chain was slack the pulley would knock the pin out be knocking the point, or it might be by the rope. The incline rope did surge. Witness had been in the pits for five or six years. He had never heard of a set getting sway, but he had heard of tow or three tubs getting sway, by being uncoupled. There was no provision for screwing the pin on.

By Mr. Sharp: Smith had no assistance at the top. Witness gave him a help, volunteering to do so, to get the set away sharper. He had no authority to do so. They did that to get it quicker sway than it should have been away. Immediately the tubs started witness went back to his own place. When he came back he bound the clutch bogie three yards down the incline. He could not account for the chain lying out. This was not a theory he had got from somebody else. He saw it for himself.

Smith (re-called): The first time the clutch bogie was stopped it was done by witness. When it was first stopped the chain was underneath the waggon. - By Mr. Brockbank: Wilson took the full ones and he took the empties.

Mr. William Redshaw, manager of Croft Pit, said he was a first-class certificated manager, in full charge of Croft Pit. He had seen clutch bogie No. 9, and it took the same set in after the accident. The Jaws of the shackle of the bogie had opened a little, and had been closed to its proper position by the top manager. The witness explained, by pencilling on the plan, his idea of what had happened. - The Coroner said it appeared to him that the chief danger was that of having no travelling road, so as to do away with the men travelling on that road. According to his theory the pin had been in. The pins were firmly put on and would not be likely to jump off. - The Coroner: Why don't they make these manholes higher that they do? - Witness said it was a question whether they ought to be made higher: There was a greater source of danger from making them too big. Only last week Mr. Hooper and the manager got into a refuge hole and the set ran off, and ran into the hole. If the hole had not been too large it could not have got in. The height of the hole referred to in connection with the accident about which they were now enquiring was 2ft. 11in., 4ft wide and 5ft deep. (Mr. Hooper explained that he was mistaken in saying that the manhole was 3ft. 11in., but the plan was wrong in that respect, it should be 2ft. 11in.) Others were 5ft, and 6ft high. He heard the witness say if the hole had been bigger he might have got in; but he thought that if the first man had not stumbled they would both have got in. No doubt it would take longer to stoop to get in with a height of 2ft 11in. than it would if the hole had been 6ft high. - By Mr. Webster: He said that the pin was knocked out by the chain having caught in the "T" pulley. He had never known that happen before. It was possible that the pin had not been put in; but so far as he could make out it seemed to have been in, and that was the cause of it coming out. - By Mr. Sharp: do you believe it is a safe system to allow a set of tubs to run down an incline with a smash on a 5ft chain? - Witness: Practically, it is. - Mr. Webster: With the liability of the pin to being knocked out? - Witness: There are always liabilities, sir, to everything.

Thomas Parker deposed that he was under-manager at Croft Pit. He say the shackle at the end of the chain, on Friday morning. It was all right then. He made his report in the report book that all was right. He did not see the shackling afterwards until sometime after the accident. He came straight away to the Infirmary with the deceased. - By the Inspector: When he examined the shackling the bogie was running past at four miles and hour. - By the Inspector: You would not examine it properly, moving at that rate. - By Mr. Webster: From his inspection of the bogies passing at four miles an hour he was prepared to swear that all was right. He could hear the wheels running and could see the shackle. - By Mr. Sharp: It is very seldom there is a loose plate; but he thought he could tell by the sound whether it was the wheels or the plate that was wrong.

Smith (re-called said he did not notice that the clutch was rather wide. He did not notice that it was wider. It was just about the same as the other. It was the same immediately after the accident at it was before. - By Mr. Oswald: They sent the bogies in-bye after they got them on the road, using the same pin and tackle. - By Mr. Brockbank: He would not know if the tackle was taken to the blacksmith's shop in the morning. They tot another set out the same night with the same bogie.

Mr. Redshaw said the engineer, Fothergill, told how he adjusted the tackle in the morning as it was too wide. He still adhered to the theory he had given to the jury, that the pin struck against the pulley and widened the tackle.

John Ashbridge, shiftman, said he was working at Croft Pit when the set got away. He was at the man-hole higher up when he heard the sets get away. Witness was working on the brow. The siding was full of full tubs. He heard the set coming harder than they should have done. He shouted to the men below that there was a set a-main. After this occurred, he shouted were they all right, and Donald said, "No, there was a man hurt." He afterwards examined the tackle, and found the moth rather open, and the in was lying between the rope and the roller. He did not think the tackle was open wider that it should have been. He was certain that it had not been opened - he was not aware of it. - By Mr. Webster: He knew the manhole were these men were at. Witness had plenty of time to get into the manhole, and had had frequently to get into the one where the deceased was killed. - By Mr. Sharp: He had been two or three months at this job. He had heard of three or four tubs getting away before.

Dr. George Watson Tawse, house surgeon at the Infirmary, said deceased died at ten minutes to seven on Saturday morning.

The Coroner summed up the evidence, pointing out that the manhole compiled with the Act, although if it had been a little higher probable the men could have got in. The set got way, but he could not say how it got away a-main. It would remain a mystery. But for the sworn testimony of the two men he would have hesitated to say that the pin had been put in.

The jury were left to themselves, and the verdict they returned was that the deceased was "Accidentally killed by the running way of the set, but they could not agree as to whether the pin was ever in or not." - Some conversation ensued as to this verdict, Mr. Webster holding that that was the gist of the whole affair. - The Coroner said that they would accept the verdict as given. It was the jury's verdict. - A juryman said as long as men were allowed to travel where sets were there would be accidents. It should not be allowed. - Mr. Oswald said they would have to get a new coalfield and new pits in that case.

The inquiry lasted from three o'clock until half-past six o'clock.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ashbridge, John    Shiftman  
Brockbank, T. H.    Solicitor  
Donald, Richard    Miner  
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Fothergill, —    Engineer  
Haigh, Henry   29 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Haigh, Joseph      Brother
Hooper, George    Mining Engineer  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Parker, Thomas    Under Manager  
Redshaw, William    Manager  
Sharp, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Smith, George    Miner  
Stafford, John      Brother-in-Law
Tawse, George Watson, Dr.    House Surgeon  
Waugh, —    Jury Foreman  
Webster, J.    Solicitor  
Wilson, Thomas    Hanger on  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print