14th September 1893
Delegates' Meeting At Workington
On Monday a meeting of the representatives of the West Cumberland Miners was held at Dent Hall, Workington. Mr. Andrew Sharp presided, and there was a full attendance of delegates. Reports were given by the delegates respecting the lodge meetings held
to consider the proposal for an advance equal to the amount lost by the Coal Commission. It appeared that the majority of the lodge had left the matter in the hands of the delegates to decide what action should be taken after hearing the coal owners'
statement. Some of the delegates complained that the managers had not carried out the pledge they gave when the men agreed to accept a 10 per cent., reduction, to enable some of the coal owners to carry on their collieries during the summer to the
effect that all their old hands should be reinstated before any fresh men were set on. As that had not been done in all cases the meeting recommended that steps be taken at those places to enforce a policy of restriction so more hands would be wanted.
Joint Meeting Of Delegates And Coalowners - A Further Advance Of Wages Refused.
A joint meeting of delegates and coal owners was afterwards held at the Commercial Hotel. Mr. J. D. Bain presided. Mr. Sharp represented the men, and stated that their claim for an advance was on the ground that the Scotch miners had been advanced two
shillings per day, and that the coal owners during the Commission contended that they were obliged to reduce the wages in consequence of the Scotch miners wages having gone down, and consequently, they were unable to compete with Scotch coal owners in
the Irish market. Trade, Mr. Sharp submitted, had got back to that point at which Cumberland coal owners should be able to pay wages in proportion to the wages being paid to the Scotch miners. - The Chairman said the coal trade had not advanced anything
like what the men contemplated, and that it was reported that the Scotch coal owners would be recalling the last advance they had given to their men in consequence of the low price of coal in the Irish market. Should trade revive they would have no
objection to meet the men at any time and consider the matter further.
After the coal owners adjourned the delegates held a meeting and decided to recommend the Cumberland men to continue working at present.
Meeting Of The Whitehaven Colliers
On Monday morning it was announced by bellman that a meeting of the colliers would be held in the Circus that evening at six o'clock. It was understood that the meeting would be to receive the report of the delegates who had attended the meeting at
Workington. These delegates, however, did not get back in time for a meeting at six o'clock, and the meeting was consequently postponed till eight. The Circus was packed, and yet a great number of men and boys were not present, but remained standing in
the Market place to hear the result. Mr. Batty presided. Reporters were in attendance, and they were admitted. - The Chairman said this meeting had been specially arranged to hear the delegates report from the district meeting that day. - A Voice:
Well, Mr. Chairman, will you allow me to speak a minute! I hope these reporters will give a thorough explanation of what they hear, and not deviate one from another, same as they have been. (Cheers.) And I expect that the reporter gives it right, as it
should be. - Another Voice: Or else not let them in. - Another: Or else they will get in nea mair. (Cheers and laughter.) - The Chairman: you mean for instance, that if a man states the workmen's case you hope the reporters will put it all in, and not
cut it up. - A Voice: A full report. - Another: I expect that Advertiser man will make his statement different from what it was last week. (Laughter) - Another: He will get his money on Saturday if he doesn't. (Laughter) The Chairman: Well, order, men.
The first business of this meeting to night is to report to you what has been done as regards supporting Whitehaven men. You will all be aware that there isn't a great amount of money in the Association - not as much as we would have liked to have in;
but I may tell you this - every delegate at the Workington meeting to-day did everything in his power, and I think every one of them had a wish to support Whitehaven men, and see and get them out of this difficulty. Well, they propose to pay to-morrow
3s per member and 6d a head for children; and with the funds that we have collected, and our check-weighmen's money, we can pay another shilling; so that will be 4s per member and 6d per child that will be paid to-morrow at half-past one. (Cheers.)
Now I was very glad, and I think there isn't a man in this Circus but would have been glad, if they had heard the delegates of Cumberland expressing themselves so favourably with regard to Whitehaven; in fact I did not think we would have been met on
such terms as we were met; and I think if we don't get a settlement soon there will be some special arrangement made altogether as regards supporting us. I may tell you that there has been arrangements made to day with the delegates from each pit for a
man to be sent up to each pit on Friday and Saturday, and there will be men appointed with them to stand and collect there. I may tell you that each delegate gave his report in, but we had to meet the masters at half-past three. Well, this question of
the claim that we put in for 7½ per cent., I am very sorry to tell you that our employers would not hear of it at all, on any account. They said that the position of Cumberland scarcely warranted the 10 per cent. that had been paid; that merchants
would not buy coal from them, saying that it was only a spurt from the Midlands counties being out, and they had supplies in that would last a month or two, and they thought they could keep clear of paying a high price for coal. I need not - in fact I
could not - tell you all that was said and done then; but I may tell you the main part of it, and that is that they could not see their way clear at present to refund this Commission back; and more than that, they argued that whatever state trade was in,
or whatever prices they could get, they would not be justified in paying the reduction that was taken off by the Commission. They say that it just put us on a level with competing countries as regards our standard, as regards our wages; that that
reduction was got simply because Cumberland worked eight hours and competing districts were working nine hours. Well, I may tell you that after meeting our employers we had a meeting to consider the case, and they thought, under the circumstances, it
was best for Cumberland to work on, pending a settlement of Whitehaven dispute; and I am very glad to tell you that as far as I could gather from the tone of the delegates representing Cumberland, that they are determined to see Whitehaven get an
honourable settlement. (Cheers.) Our agent Mr. Sharp, during that coal owners' meeting - I forgot that, just as the time - brought this Whitehaven case up, and Mr. Bain, who presided over the joint meeting, said that it wasn't a question to be
considered at that meeting, but that he would meet the delegates along with Mr. Sharp at any time. So there was a meeting arranged for eleven o'clock to-morrow - for three Whitehaven delegates and Mr. Sharp to meet the employers. I scarcely need tell
you, because you will all know that, that there will be nothing done definitely till you do it; - anything that is offered will be brought before you at the meeting to-morrow night at six o'clock, and you will decide upon it. We could not reasonably
refuse meeting them; at least, I can't see how we could refuse. - A Voice: Well, Mr. Chairman, I propose if they give us 10 per cent., same as Cumberland we will go in, but if they won't we won't go in. - The Chairman: That can be dealt with afterwards,
when we know the result of the meeting. - Another Voice: What about that letter of Mr. James's that was in the Free Press? - Another: Yes, I expect that will be gone into. — The Chairman: I have it here. The Chairman read the letter of Mr. James
contradicting the statement that the Colliery Company were offering 10 per cent. less than was being paid in other parts of the district, and stating that if the Company's offer was accepted the men (both hewers and shiftmen) would be working on the same
terms as at other collieries in the district. - A Voice: And are we? - The Chairman: You need not ask that. Don't we all know we are not? - The Voice: Then it's your place to prove it. - The Chairman: If the present terms they are offering us are as
high as what the other part of Cumberland is working under, how is it that the Whitehaven Colliery Company offers us 10 per cent! Is there a man here imagines they are going to throw 10 percent away, or that they are 10 per cent bigger and better than
any other place in the county? I can't see it; and I think when Mr. James or when any man puts a letter in the paper saying a certain thing, he should put proofs in to show how Whitehaven Colliery is on a level with the rest of the county. (Cheers.) I
may tell you that I can't deal with this letter as it stands, because for my part I can't see how it is possible for us to be on a level with Cumberland, seeing that Cumberland with the exception of Whitehaven has got ten per cent. and we haven't. How
is it possible? To-morrow when the delegates meet Mr. James we will be under more favourable circumstances to argue this letter out, when they give us their reason for saying that Whitehaven colliers are on a level with other colliers in Cumberland.
Well there is a good lot more in the Free Press and other papers, but I think that perhaps Mr. Lamb would wish to address you a bit, I think he will be more fit to deal with that question than I am. (Cheers.) But I do say this, that for my life I can't
see why policemen should have been drafted out of all parts of Cumberland into Whitehaven, and the soldiers; without it is that the men's out of health and they have sent them for a change of air. (Laughter) - A Voice: They want to make a riot - Another:
put that in't paper. - The Chairman: You know it should be a healthy spot, Whitehaven - it's pretty near the sea, and it is just possible these men's health has been failing, and they have sent them here to improve them. - A Voice: They have got a touch
a'that cholera. (Laughter) - The Chairman: Then this Free Press goes on to say "Scandalous and Wanton Outrage." Why, God bless my life, men, you all know that that night that them outrages were committed there were maybe a hundred school lads
and a lot of snuffery lasses. (Cheers and laughter.) And what were they doing? I never saw them do a thing except go round the streets singing "Whoa kilt Cock Robin." (Laughter and cheers) You all know that at the last general election
there was twice as much excitement - there was twice as much rowdyism in Whitehaven as there was this last week, and there wasn't one word in the Free Press when it returned Mr. Little; but if it hadn't, it would have very likely called the Whitehaven
colliers; but seeing it returned Mr. Little to Parliament then they were everybody; but now they have done a thing to cause them soldiers and military and policemen, it's something awful. It's blazing all round the country. You would actually think it
had been the siege of Plevna, or something like that. (Laughter and cheers) Now I would ask these gentlemen here when they are reporting a thing to be careful. There has been a good bit been made about the Dales down there on the Quay. But you know I
was down there. If you recollect we were deputed to see these men - William Pit delegates and me - and we went down, and without hesitation these men said they would not go to work any more, and they would have scorned the idea, but it was hunger and
starvation that drove them to work. Other reports where spread that there were men running up the passage, and that it would have been a bad job for the Dales if they had been caught. I don't think there is a man would have touched the Dales; it was
simply a few school lads, and, as you all know snuffery lasses. (Laughter and cheers)
Mr. Lamb, a herbalist, who said he was "a retired collier," said he saw this terrible row, and there was not one engaged in it over 18 years of age. Further than that he would stand in defence of the Whitehaven colliers as a whole, that there
was no desire on their part to break the peace. They regretted to a certain extent that the inexperienced youth should be led away for about five and twenty minutes to create a little bit of excitement, which of course led the officials entrusted with
the peace of the community to lose their heads and suppose that something serious was going to follow. To a certain extent he sympathised with those who were entrusted with the peace and good government of the town, but he was somewhat amused at their
excited indignation at the rowdyism of a class of men who never were found in the streets with any desire to kick up a row at all. He did not blame the policemen, rank and file; but he blamed someone for creating too much excitement. Dealing with the
Free Press, he said they were told that men had a perfect right to work if they would. He did not deny that, and he would not touch a hair of their heads, but he would leave them severely alone - he would boycott them, to use an Irish phrase. (Cheers.)
He would hold up to contempt the slyness, the want of manly fortitude, and of the thoroughly robust material that go to make honest men, in servile wretches who would crawl at the feet of the bloated capitalists. (Cheers.) - In reply to a vote of thanks
for his address, Mr. Lamb, said the best thanks they could give him would be to quietly walk away from this meeting in twos and threes, and don't give the authorities the slightest chance of charging them with rowdyism. (Cheers.) - At this point the
reporters were requested to withdraw, the remainder of the proceedings of the meeting being private.
The Police Break Up The Crowd, Clearing The Streets.
When the reporters left the Circus they came out into the Market place to find it greatly crowded. There was a large number of colliers there who had never been in at the meeting, just as there were considerable number present at the meeting who were
not colliers. In a few minutes the meeting in the Circus terminated, and those who came out moved through the market in the direction of King Street. The movement became general in this direction, and there was a slight manifestation of a desire to
"sky lark" among the younger men. The crowd passed up King Street and into Tangier Street. Here it was found that the police were preventing the passage of the crowd and driving them back. Repeated charges were made by the police, with drawn
batons, to clear the street, and then they were drawn across Duke Street and Tangier Street to stand at ease. A very few stones were thrown, and one of these went through the top of a dray's lamp; but the police had no difficulty in breaking the crowd,
which was in no way angry nor inclined to resistance. A large number of the people in the crowd were not colliers at all, but persons whom curiosity led out to see what was going on. Some of these protested against the proceedings of the police as
unnecessary, and as calculated to rather make a riot than to prevent one. On the other hand it was soon perceived that the intention of the police was simply to show that a mob could not be allowed to parade the streets that at any moment might indulge
in lawlessness, and that it was firmly intended to put a stop to this kind of licence; and that if peaceable people were among the crowd through curiosity they must take all the risks and inconveniences incidental to the gratification of that curiosity.
Every time there was any disposition to crowd in at the junction of Tangier Street, Duke Street, and King Street, the police kept sallying out and scattering the people. A number of young men and lads came up from the direction of the Wet Dock, and a
few of the police drove them away and followed them. The runaways got behind the wagons on the docks, and under cover of darkness began to throw stones; but the officers managed to catch some of them and changed their tune. Before long it was evident
that there would be no further disturbance. By eleven o'clock the streets were pretty well cleared of all but the police and a few young men who seemed to be making for home. The Chief Constable, Mr. Dunne, was present, and superintended and directed
the whole operations of the police. One of the magistrates accompanied Mr. Dunne.
The Interview Between Employers And Delegates
On Tuesday the delegates, along with Mr. Sharp, had an interview with the employers, as previously arranged and announced. The Colliery Company said they could not now concede the 10 per cent. advance previously offered. So far as we are able to gather,
the position of the company is this - that when the 10 per cent. offer was made there was a prospect of securing some trade, owing to the general strike, and the absence of the competition of Lancashire; and that although when the strike ceased there
would probably be a drop in prices and it might be necessary to have the 10 per cent., off again, and there might be some difficulty in getting it off, yet it was worth while running the risk; but when the men changed their minds, and said they would
accept the 10 per cent., they at first refused , the chance had passed, the markets were lost, and it was no longer worth while running the risk of another strike latter on , if it was necessary to take the 10 per cent., off again. Mr. Sharp, on behalf
of the men, suggested that it would be possible to give the 10 per cent. at all events until after the general strike is concluded, and then see how the position stood. The Company stood firm to their contention that it was no longer worth their while
to risk the men coming out again on strike if they proposed to take back the 10 per cent., - that they had lost their markets, and that a fall of prices would be inevitable when the general strike terminated. The interview, therefore, terminated without
any change in the situation.
Meeting Of The Men.
Mr. Sharp States The Men's Case:
Those Who "Pay The Piper" Are Asked To Chose The Tune; Pressure Of Public Opion Invoked.
On Tuesday evening, at six o'clock, a meeting of the men was held in the Circus, to hear the report of Mr. Sharp and the delegates. Before the hour of the meeting it was pretty generally known that there was nothing favourable to report as a result of
the interview, and the meeting, though a large one, was not nearly so large as on the previous evening. - Mr. Batty presided. He said after arguing the case out for somewhere about an hour and a half, they could not make any impression whatever upon
their employers. Their employers said that as regards shiftmen - that is offhand labour - if they were paying less in Whitehaven than was being paid in other parts of the county, they were quite willing to remunerate their men to the same extent as
other collieries do; but to the hewers they absolutely refused to give this 10 per cent. (Some applause) They claimed that they had lost their chance of establishing a trade, and getting back the trade they had lost in the past times. - A Voice: It was
their own fault that they lost that. ("Order") Mr. Sharp and the delegates argued it out from every possible point of view, but there was no impression whatever could be made on the employers. They naturally thought that the Whitehaven
Colliery Company had still a chance of getting trade: they thought the Colliery Company could demand a trade, provided they gave the men this 10 per cent., and let them go in to work. Mr. Sharp would be prepared to explain.
Their Position From Beginning To End.
Mr. Sharp said they had great expectation that it would have been possible, after the interview on Monday with the coalowners, and after having the opinion of the remainder of their district - they were in great hopes that it might have been possible to
have got an amicable and satisfactory settlement of this question. Unfortunately the Whitehaven Colliery Company were, he must say, almost immovable. They held that, as the men did not resume work on the 11th they were justified in their course. He
was sorry to say this strike, so far as it was a strike between capital and labour, had ceased, and it was now a personal strike. It was now a question of whether the men should continue to work with the same satisfaction as other parts of the district
or
Whether The Colliery Company Shall Rule The Roost.
(Hear, hear.) That was really what it had drifted to. There was not now a little bit of capital and labour in the question. He wished the Press and the public to take notice of it; because it had reached a point when their case should be put to the
public. He used all the arguments he possibly could, and he thought he could work out figures as to a prospect as well as most men; but he could not get the Colliery Company to adopt his view. So far as shiftmen were concerned, they might possibly have
obtained an amicable settlement, because the Company said they were willing to pay the same as others taking into consideration hours of work, if investigation showed that such rectification was necessary. He had very little fear from the statements
made of reduction and alterations, and taking into account the hours worked here as compared with other parts, that at all events some reduction could have been got on that class of labour proportionate to what other people have. With regards to hewers,
he asked the Company, very carefully, to let things stand as they stood previous to the 11th - that was, to give the hewers 1¼d per ton, and if they would do so he would do his uttermost to prevail upon the men to-night to accept work. (Hear, hear.)
He pointed out to the Company, and he was sorry to say that as commercial men the Company could not stand upon the question, that all the men were asking was 1¼d per ton; and he was prepared to say here that there was STILL A CHANGE IN THE MARKET
OF A SHILLING PER TON on selling prices, over and above what those prices were when the men came out. That was taking prices all round. Now, there was no commercial man in Whitehaven, nor in the whole of this county, who would attempt to lose 10¾d
for the sake of 1¼d. That was about the sum and substance of how this dispute stood. He showed them that they had the winter season coming on as well. It was quite possible higher prices might be obtained; that the struggle in some counties might
go on for months; that there was every hope of the Company obtaining a standing, and a good standing, in the market, the same as others in the district were doing; and a great profit for the Company on simply a small outlay. Because he wanted the public
to know this. It is sometimes cried out, when the workmen get 10 per cent., advance, what an enormous amount of money it is. But this 10 per cent., is simply, all told, 1¼d per ton, and that would only mean 1½d per ton on the purchaser,
supposing the "offal" coal were sold for nothing. Now, the public at large must know that that was the whole dispute; and he said if the public at large sympathised with commercial men who would carry on a gigantic war like this whereby, the
ratepayers would have to pay for regiments of soldiers and no end of policemen to protect the place, then it was time that
The Public At Large, Who Pay The Piper, Should Speak Out
about this question. (Cheers.) He quite admitted that the public at large and the law had a perfect right to protect every individual; and he wished to say there that at the present time it was the duty of them all, everyone, to be law abiding, because
they could not live without law and order: they could not have this meeting without law and order - (hear, hear) - therefore it was necessary that they should be law abiding as far as they possibly could. But the public at large ought to understand this
- it was a question whether people had a right to be put to this expense on this dispute, when the dispute had not the merit of warranting the payment of such a large expense for the piper. When a person was soft in the head or a lunatic, they put him
in Garlands Asylum, for his own and the public safety; and he thought the public would do well in a case like this to speak out fairly, and say that where the employer could settle a dispute with an actual profit, but because of personal considerations
would not settle it.
The Public Were Justified In Taking Charge Of Him,
and ought not to be made responsible for the spending of a large amount of money to keep law and order when people disturbed law and order. (Cheers.) He did not think any employer should be forced to pay what he could not pay; but when they could show a
shilling - and he believed it was admitted by everybody that there were ships in the harbour to-day, and boats ready to come, and any amount of people wanting coal, who would not object at the present time to pay a shilling more for coal than what they
were paying three months since - why should a strike prevail when there were probably 1,500 adults and no end of children and wives affected by it - why should it go on, when it can be clearly seen, commercially speaking, that work can be resumed at a
profit to the owner and only a very small remuneration to the men? (Cheers.) This was the position at the present time, and he expected that the public would see and understand it. Now, it would be a pity if this had to be fought out to the bitter end;
but it appeared that it either was a question of their being starved in, or they accepted the employers' terms, or the matter was
Fought Out To The Bitter End, Whatever The Consequence Might Be.
Whoever was responsible for this, when the employers and the public had, after a statement like this, a full knowledge of what could not be done, the public as large could not judge the men harshly, as unfair in this question. (Hear, hear.) In some
cases in the Midlands the employers contended that they could not afford to pay the rate of wages asked for, at the price of coal. But that could not be one of the arguments in this county at the present time. He could not say that if the strike in the
Midlands was settled things might not come back again; but for the time being there was no justification on the part of the employers that this strike should be continued another day - no justification whatever. Mr. James, as secretary of their
employers, had attempted to show that they were paying
40 Per Cent Above The Wages Paid 1880,
and that they were at present paying as much as anybody else. It was as well that a word or two should be said upon this. They all knew, and they did not deny, that some local advances were given the Whitehaven Colliery, but he did not know that more
was given by them than was given at other collieries. A few years since 2½d per ton was given because the rate at the Whitehaven Colliery was not up to what it was in other places, for an average wage. He could point to places in the district
where they had given three times as much as that, because their work was not equal to other people's. A man would not work at a place where there was not a living wage. If a colliery would not pay at a fair wages, the same as was paid at other
collieries, the workmen had no right to be made responsible for the losses or blunders or mismanagement of persons over whom they had no control. The collier was responsible only for getting and loading the coal; and when a ton of coal for which they
were getting 1s 10d would sell for 10s or 12s, he thought there was some where a great expense that ought to be investigated, and that the men had no power to investigate. The employers would tell them it did not pay, and would run up a cost of
something like 6s or 7s a ton. He did not dispute that in some cases that was true; but he had no hesitation in saying if that colliery was his it would not be true, because if he could not get a ton of coal for less than 6s 6d when the hewer had done
his part for 1s 10d he would give up the coal business. (Cheers.) Now the Whitehaven Colliery Company contended they were giving
As Much As Anybody Else.
They gave them 2½d a ton to make the work equal. Then they got 1¼d per ton back by the Commission. They took another 1¼d last year. What the men were asking for was that they should have one of those penny-farthings returned to them,
which was equivalent to about 10 per cent. That was all the men were asking for. If every other employer in the county were to say "I had 2½d or, 3d to give four or five years ago because our wages were not up to the mark." and he
included that in his averages, they would have every colliery in the county on strike, as well as Whitehaven. (Cheers.) They were paid what was considered fair in 1891. Since that there had been the Commission reductions, which applied to everybody.
Since that there had been what might be termed local reductions. There was 1¼d taken at Whitehaven. There was 10 per cent. or 2d it might be in some cases (bet it was equivalent to about 10 per cent.), taken off all other parts of the district.
The resolution passed and handed to him by the coalowners' meeting was that they would give back the whole of the reduction taken on these grounds. Therefore that was
No Justification For The Whitehaven Colliery Company Withholding That Reduction,
and not giving it back. (Cheers.) The justification the Colliery Company offered at the present time was that they agreed to pay the same as the rest of the district, and it was not accepted at the time. But was that wise or sensible. There might have
been some error on the part of the men, but there was also some error on the part of the Company. There was error on both sides. Bygones did not justify the continuation of the struggle. At the present time the Whitehaven Colliery, in all fairness, so
far as the hewers were concerned, was
10 Per Cent Below The District.
(Cheers.) He hoped that if public opinion was expressed forcibly, as it ought to be on this matter, it might be the means of bring some pressure to bear with a view to trying to settle this question; because no doubt, this was entailing a great amount
of cost on the people of Whitehaven and a great amount of cost on the county of Cumberland. (Cheers) Mr. Sharp proceeded to say that there might have been some bitter feeling on account of blacklegs, but he had heard of nothing of any importance at
Whitehaven to warrant anything like importing soldiers or such an overdraft of policemen. While the Chief Constable and the authorities were responsible for law and order, they were also bound to do nothing themselves to cause disorder. (Cheers.) If a
group of men happened to be standing quietly together, it was most inhuman, most disgraceful, and there were no words strong enough to denounce it, for anybody else to go and hit somebody on the head
Because They Are Standing Talking Quietly And Civilly Together.
(Cheers.) If they went to protect people, they must protect them with as little force as possible, and they were bound on no consideration to try to aggravate the assault and cause any disturbance. So far as the police and soldiers in Whitehaven were
concerned, it appeared to him that they would be here for a few months now - (laughter and cheers) - but however long they might have to stay, he hoped they would treat the colliers just as respectfully as other people; because they had good civil
colliers, who could stand civilly on the street as well as anybody else. He did not know their justification for
Going Round That Evening To Tell The People To Close Their Shops
at six o'clock. (Cheers.) There might be some law for it. But there was one thing they should remember. These guardians of the peace were appointed by persons the working classes had the power of electing. (Hear, hear.) The County Council at the
present time had a great share in the supervision of the police, and the sooner they called upon their County Councillors in Whitehaven to investigate this matter, as was done in the Millom case, the better, if anything like the statements made as to how
the police charged on the crowd when they were doing nothing was true. (Cheers.) They were ratepayers, and if they were civil they had a right to be treated civilly. If any of them committed any depredations they must take the consequences. They all
knew, and they had always got that advice from him and everybody else, that in these disputes everyone was individually responsible for his own actions if he attempted any depredations; every tub, in such a case, must stand on its own bottom. (Hear,
hear.) Mr. Sharp advised the men to control their feelings with regard to "black-legs." No pit could pay with a few men working; the cost was enormous. The employers could not hope to destroy their organisation in that way. It had been
tried many times before, and the employers had been forced to give it up as ruinous. Let workmen have the liberty to organise if they liked; if they did not want to organise, nobody had a right to force them. If this case came to the worst, they would
have to try in the county to render all the assistance they could. (Cheers.) At the same time, if the outside public could bring any pressure to bear on the employers, they would always be ready and willing to make a reasonable settlement. - The
Chairman said he would ask the men to do everything in their power to keep as quiet as they possibly could. He knew, and they knew how they were aggravated last night - A Voice: They tried to make a riot. - The Chairman: They want to make a riot, and
throw discredit upon you, and I really believe they would do anything to force you into a riot. As regard those few men who are working at William Pit, I would advise you to leave them by themselves; but when this dispute is settled, I would advise you
then to boycott them in every manner and every shape you possibly can. (Cheers.) If you don't let these gentlemen, who have been imported into Whitehaven force you into a riot, we have every possible chance, after the public has heard our case as Mr.
Sharp has stated it, of getting support; and I may tell you that we all will do everything in our power to help you to get support to fight this case out. I ask you whatever is the end to fight it out quietly and peaceably, but determinedly; and if we
are starved in, well we will have to submit. - A Voice: We can fight them again. (Cheers.) - The Chairman: If we are starved in, we will have our Association left, and we will still be able to put money in to put us in a position to let us fight the
Whitehaven Colliery Company at some more opportune time. (Cheers.) - A resolution was proposed and seconded and carried by a show of hands in the dark (the reporters could by this time scarcely see what they were writing) in favour of standing idle until
the Colliery Company conceded the 10 per cent. now in dispute. The meeting then dispersed.
The Streets On Tuesday Evening.
On Tuesday evening, after the distribution of the small amount due to each man and child, there was some appearance of drink among the colliers, and the police being aware that there would be no settlement at the night meeting, deemed it prudent to
advise the shopkeepers in the principal thoroughfare that they had better put their shutters up as early as convenient. As there was nothing doing in the way of business, a good many followed this advice. Others, as though by way of protest against
what they treated as groundless fears, kept open a good deal longer than usual, and reaped the reward of advertisement to the vast number of people who were on the streets. The police were again out in force, and the usual places - Marine terrace and
William Pit - continued to be specially guarded, with the soldiers at the Grand Hotel; but there was no appearance whatever of disorder. No attempt was made to proceed in a compact and united crowd, as on the previous night, and so long as this was the
case the police interfered with nobody. A magistrate was again on duty, as on Saturday and Monday nights. There were very few cases of drunkenness, and these cases, and any disposition to play with the police, seemed to meet the grave and decided
discountenance of the great mass of the men who were walking about the streets up till bedtime.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bain, J. D. | | Mine Owner | |
| Batty, — | | | |
| Dunne, — | | Chief Constable | |
| James, — | | | |
| Lamb, — | | | |
| Little, — | | | |
| Sharp, Andrew | | | |