|
31st August 1893 Fatality At Crossfield MinesAt the Crossfield Mine, Cleator Moor, on Friday last, a painful accident occurred, resulting in the death of a promising young man, John Richardson, aged 19, residing with his father, Mr. Wesley Richardson, at Moor Row. The company in which young Richardson was engaged was employed in drifting and filling in the debris from the drift into an old working. The deceased was in the act of unloading his bogie when a large stone slipped from the roof or side and instantaneously crushed him to death. Deceased was a fine young fellow, and great sympathy is felt throughout the district for his sorrowing relatives. A inquest was opened on Friday by Mr. J. Webster, at the Station Hotel, Moor Row. Evidence of identification was given by Ann Fee, of 14 Scalegill Road, Moor Row, and the inquiry was then adjourned till yesterday (Wednesday) for the attendance of the Inspector of Mines. At the adjourned inquest yesterday (Wednesday), Mr. G. F. Bell, the Government Inspector of Mines; Mr. J. M. Main, manager of Messers. Mackenzie's pits; and Mr. R. Robertson and Mr. Richardson (father of the deceased) were present. — The first witness called was Mark Millican, who deposed: I live at No. 10, James Street, Cleator Moor. I am a labourer in the employment of the Crossfield Iron Ore Company. On Friday, the 25th of the present month, I was at work at No. 3 pit. I started work about seven o'clock in the morning. I worked with Richard Waters, Thomas Howlet, James Cowan, Thomas Cavannagh, and the deceased, in No. 88 working, I think. Before we started work, Richard Waters examined the working place. I saw him sound the ground with a hammer. (A plan to scale was put in and sworn to be correct by Mr. Robertson, the sub-manager). He sounded the roof where this piece of stone eventually fell. There was no wood to support the roof. He did not say it was not safe. He said the ground seemed to be all right, it sound well. He then made a hole in the roof, to be bored, so as to bring away the piece of the roof which afterwards killed the deceased. That was in order to make the roof level, and some of the roof was metal. After he bored the hole he fired it. It would be I think about 10 o'clock when he fired the hole. The shot brought away two or three bogies of stone and metal. After the shot was fired John Richardson, dressed the place where the hole had been fired. Waters was then in the drift boring another hole in the face of the working. I was coming out of the drift with my bogie of sill, and after I had taken my bogie I brought it back to where John Richardson was dressing down the hole. I sat down and had a bit of a crack with him, and he also sat down on the contrary side to me. I was sitting on the left side of the working place, looking in, and he was sitting on the right side. While we were talking I heard some ground giving an awful tear, and I shouted "Run Jack." I made for the face where Richard Waters was working, and deceased was making in the same direction, and as he got under the centre of the lump it fell upon the head and shoulders of the deceased. My light was knocked out then, and I turned round and shouted of him, but he did not reply. I then met Richard Waters coming towards me, and I told him what had happened. We went to the place where the accident had occurred, and we found deceased lying dead. When the shot was fired Waters went to the place where it had gone off, and examined the ground. He examined it with a candle and hammer, and sounded the ground which the shot had not got. He said it seemed as if it would stand for a long time; it sounded as well as ever; and he told the deceased to dress it down. — By a juryman: John Richardson bored the hole that was fired. — By the Inspector: I think that Waters had been told to put the hole in the roof. — By the father of the deceased: The shot did not bring all the roof down; part of it came away, and then while we were having a crack the rest came down. — Richard Waters deposed: I live at No. 26, Church Street, Moor Row, and I am a miner in No. 3 Pit, the property of Mackenzie & Co. I got to my work at six a.m., on the 25th. John Richardson was a labourer working with me. There were six men working with me, and I had the management of the party. The first thing I did when I went into the working place, No. 52, was to begin to bore in the forebreast; and the first thing Richardson did was to get out some road plates, some of the other men assisting Richardson to do that. As soon as I got the road plates, and before finishing my boring, I went back, and we made preparations to put down some road plates. Then there were some loose pieces of stone, and I dressed them down. We then started to put the road down, and finished it. I then directed some of them to clear the "muck" away, and I returned to the forebreast. I heard nothing more until after the accident. I am quite certain I heard nothing more; and I have stated now all that I did and all that I ordered. The Coroner: Was there a shot fired that morning. — Witness: Oh, yes. — The Coroner: Now will you try to recollect yourself. Here is a most material thing that you have omitted. — Witness continues: I forgot that. On the previous day I observed a lump in the roof that required removing. On the morning of the accident I tried to get this lump down with a pick, and failed to do so. I told Richardson to put a hole in it, and he put a hole in it of about a foot, and charged it in my presence, and it was afterwards fired. After the hole went off we met again at the same place. I then cleaned down the loose stone near the place where the shot had been fired. I also examined the roof and found it sound. I saw the piece of stone that afterwards came away. I did not sound the piece that came down. The other young man sounded it, while I put my hand to it to feel it. That was the piece that came down. It was about 20ft. long and 2ft. thick. The young man sounded it with a hammer. It sounded well and safe. I had not been ordered to take that stone down. The overman thought like me that the stone was perfectly safe. — By the father of the deceased: The hole that was bored was not over the lump of stone that fell and killed your son. — By Mr. Harrison (foreman of the jury): I cannot say what was the width of the roof where the accident occurred. — By the Inspector: I did not examine the working place when I first went into the drift. I consider that is the duty of the overman; but I don't know whether the overman examined the working place before we started. — The Inspector: Don't you think there was the more need for you to examine it if you did not know that the overman had done so? — The Coroner: It is not compulsory that he should do so. — The Inspector: I know it isn't, but he might have done it for his own safety. — The Coroner: It is compulsory in coal mines, but not iron ore mines, but I hope before long it will be. — Witness said he saw the overman the previous morning, and it was arranged that the piece of stone should be brought down. They tried dynamite. The piece brought down by the shot was eight or nine feet in length. I examined the roof after the stone had fallen which killed deceased. It had a slate back all round. — The Inspector: And that sort of stone might come down at any time without warning? — Witness: Well when we sound with a hammer and fell it, if it sounds solid and feels firm we conclude it's all right. — The Inspector said they might easily be deceived in such cases. — Owen Macartney deposed: I live in Duke street, Cleator Moor. I am the overman at No. 3 pit. I went to the pit on the morning of the 25th at half-past five. I examined the working places — all of them. I went into No. 2. I went into No.52 about ten minutes past six. The man had not then gone in. I sounded the roof with a hammer. I told Dick Waters that there was a piece in the roof that should come down because it ran up to a feather edge, and I was afraid it might come down. With that exception I thought the roof was safe. I sound the piece of roof that afterwards killed the deceased, and it appeared sound. — By a jury man: The lump that fell and killed the deceased had no connection with the piece we brought down. — By the Inspector: I am quite certain that it was the same day and not the previous day that I told Waters to bring down the stone. — The witness Waters, re-called, said the overman did not speak to him that morning. — Thomas Howlet deposed: I was working with the deceased, but I was not present at the time of accident. — Robert Robertson, sub-manager, deposed that the width of the roof, at the place where the stone fell which killed the deceased, would be 6ft. 6in. — By the foreman: Wherever the roof was sound we did not put in props; but where we thought it is necessary there we put props. The working place was being filled up with shale out of the drift. This was all the evidence. The Coroner, summoning up the jury, said he would have thought a man of the experience if Waters would not have started to work, as he did, without first examining the working place. It appeared that there was behind all this roof what was called a "slape" back. When the loose stone was very thick it was not as easy to ascertain that it, was loose by sounding. The stone that fell was found by measurement to have been 3ft. 6in. thick. Therefore, it did not appear that in this case there had been any criminal negligence such as would make anyone responsible for manslaughter. If there was any mistake made in not proving, that would be an error of judgement; and it was simply a matter of judgement by experience whether it was required or not. With regard to the contradiction by Waters and the foreman as to the time when the direction was given to bring down the material, there must be some mistake, but that was not material, because that was with reference to the stone, that was brought down by the shot, and not the stone that fell and killed the deceased. — The jury returned a unanimous verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||