|
13th July 1893 Fatal Accident At The Hodbarrow MinesOn Monday last a serious accident occurred at the Hodbarrow Mines. John Fitzwilliam, an old and thoroughly practical miner, was working at the mines with his two sons, Frank and Abram, and had charged two holes and made the usual preparations for their safety. One of the holes then exploded, but the other not having gone off, after the expiration of the regulation time, the deceased went to examine the hole, and it just then exploded, knocking the deceased some distance. He must have met the full force of the explosion, as one of his arms was scorched and presented a very blackened appearance. His neck was broken and his skull was fractured, and he received several other injuries. Frank was following his father when the explosion occurred, and was knocked insensible. He, however, seems to have sustained no other injuries beyond some bruises about the face and the severe shock. The deceased was a very inoffensive man, and was very highly respected amongst his fellow workmen and all who knew him. He spent almost the whole of his lifetime, since he was able to work, in mining operations, having been engaged at the Coniston copper mines before he came to reside in Millom. He was a staunch teetotaller, never having tasted a glass of intoxicating drink. When quite young he took the temperance pledge from Father Mathew, the well-known Irish temperance advocate, and he remained true to his pledge to the day of his death. He leaves a widow and a grown up family. His elder brother also met with a fatal accident nearly 40 years ago in America. An inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital on Tuesday morning, before Dr. Stoney, coroner for the Lordship of Millom. Mr. A. E. Bradley was elected foreman of the jury, the following jurymen being also in attendance :— Messers W. Park, W. Darvell, J. Mackereth, H. Waite, J. Singleton, J. Phillipson, W. Watson, T. Floyd, A. Birbeck, J. Mason, and R. Stevens. Captain Rich attended the inquest on behalf of the Hodbarrow Mining Co. A telegram was dispatched to the Inspector of Mines the previous day, intimating the time it was proposed to hold the inquest, but no reply was received. Frank Fitzwilliam, son of the deceased, residing at 2, John-street, stated that his father was 62 years of age, and resided at 2, Queen-street. He was a miner, working at Hodbarrow. On Monday morning witness and his brother Abram were at work at the Hodbarrow mines, and, having bored two holes, charged them at about 8:30. One of the holes missed and they stopped out between 25 minutes and half an hour, as near as the witness could state. Abram and is father went in, and the former said, "Come out father and let the smoke clear." Both then came out and sat down, and deceased went in again very shortly and called to Abram to fetch another fuse. Abram went away and witness went in, when the hole went off, and his father was thrown back in his arms, and he knew no more. [Whilst giving his evidence this witness was very much affected, and had, on one occasion to be removed from the room in a fainting fit.] Abram George Fitzwilliam, also son of deceased, stated that he resided at 5, John-street, and worked at the Hodbarrow Mines. On Monday morning he was working with is father and brother, and had bored two holes around 8:30, and after charging them, came round and sat near some men. He asked them if they had heard both holes go off, and they replied no, only one hole went off. Witness remained out about half-an-hour before he went in again, and he was then followed in by his father. There was smoke in the place, and the hole was smouldering away. He went back, and told his father to do the same, and they went and sat down again. Witness went past the place again to a distance of about 40 fathom, when he heard the shot go off. He then ran back, found his bother lying on the ground groaning, and he stepped over the body and went to his father. The latter was lying on his back, with is head down. One arm was over is chest, the other was stretched out. Witness lifted up his head, and put some cold tea in his mouth, and it ran out again. He then went away. — The Coroner: Is there not some rule about not going back for a certain time? — Witness: Yes; twenty minutes. — The Coroner: Are you sure you stopped out that time? — The Foreman: Can you give any reason why one of the two shots was so much longer in going off than the other? — Witness: I could not give any explanation except that it was the fault of the fuse. — The Foreman: Had you two different types of fuse? Witness: No, they were both the same kind. — Mr. Waite: Was there any attempt to take the charge out? — Witness: It was never touched. — Captain Rich said he should not refute what the witness had said, but it was a very open place, and did not see why there should be all the smoke about. There were ten or twelve levels. — Witness: It was a three-foot raise, and there was a pillar beside. It was like being boxed up. There was not much smoke there. — The Coroner: Did your father send you for anything? — Witness: He told me to go for another fuse. He sat down when I went away. I never knew he had gone in again when I heard the report go off. — The Coroner: Your brother says Abram went in and came our again to let the smoke clear. — Witness: We both came out and sat down. There was a little smoke, but there was not very much then. — Captain Rich produced rules regulating the time for miners to return to their work when two or more holes are charged, and when any of them did not explode, twenty minutes was the time the men had to stop out, any breach of this rule being met with instant dismissal. A caution was also produced signed by a miner named Joseph Redhead, who on March 16th 1893, went into the working before the elapse of the specified time and thereby nearly lost his life. -The Coroner: Is there any further evidence required? -Mr. Darvell: There does not appear to be any breach of the rules. — The Coroner: That is not the question. We want to find out the cause of death. There might be evidence given by Captain Rich about the rule, and some explanation obtained as to why one fuse took longer to go off than the other. — The Foreman: There might be some information got on that point. — Thomas Rich was then sworn, and stated that he resided at Steel Green, and was manager of the Hodbarrow Mines, and had heard the evidence given by the former witness. — The Coroner: Have you ever had any experience of a hole hanging fire for twenty minutes to half-an-hour? — Witness: No. — The Coroner: How long have you been a miner? — Witness: Above 50 years. -The Coroner: Can you account in any way for the hole taking so long. — Witness: My experience is this. When there are two men lighting fuses in different holes, and when a splutter is heard the men will probably run away without being certain that all the fuses are lit. I have seen a hole many a time missed in this way. I believe that in the present instance the first hole fired the second. Mr. Darvell: These men swore they fired both holes. -Captain Rich: They did not say they took. It was not a question of being fired, it was whether they took or not. — Mr. Singleton: Still there was half-an-hour, and the second hole should have gone off before that time. — Mr. Mason: If the fuse had been bad it would not go off at all. — The Coroner: How long does a fuse take to go off as a rule? — Capt. Rich: That depends. A 2ft. 6in. fuse would not take more than four minutes. — The Coroner: If it only took that time the second hole should have gone off before? -Captain Rich: Yes. — The Coroner said that was all the evidence he had to lay before them. If there were any other points the jury would like to have cleared up he had no doubt but he could get other witnesses. It was quite possible that these witnesses were deceived about the length of time. They know how slow time passed when they had to sit waiting for a fuse, and what seemed half-an-hour in the present case might not be so long at all. This would account for any discrepancies with respect to the length of time. — Captain Rich said after twenty minutes he would have no hesitancy in going into the working. He never heard of such a case. — Mr. Watson, being a miner for 30 years, never knew of such a case. — The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death, no blame attached to anyone."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||