|
2nd February 1893 The Mining Fatality At St. Helens PitOn Monday afternoon Mr. Gordon Falcon, coroner for West Cumberland, and a jury of which Mr. R. Jackson was foreman, held the adjourned inquest at the Workington Police-station, to inquire into the circumstances touching the death of Joseph Minnican, who was killed at St. Helens Pit on the Monday previous by a fall of coal. The St. Helens Company was represented by Mr. Gilchrist, manager. Mr. Oswald, inspector of mines was also present. Peter Welsh, coal miner, No. 3, Norman-terrace, repeated his evidence, showing that he was working mates with the deceased when the fall of coal occurred. He saw the deputy, Lawson Clapperton, on the top of the pit before they went down. He told them he had examined the working before they entered it. No one worked in the place during other shifts. The shot was fired a week last Friday, by Clapperton. They worked on the following Saturday. All the coal had been got down where the shot was fired excepting the one piece. When the accident occurred they were not together. Witness was holing underneath. There was a break in the cannel surrounding the last wedge of coal. Deceased was getting the cannel out when the top coal fell upon him. It did not follow that they always heard when a piece of coal like this was giving way. Deceased was rather hard of hearing, and it might have been that he (witness) was making a noise at the time. There were fifteen inches of coal overhanging but they considered it safe. About 15 cwt. of coal fell. They had all the appliances required. They did their own timbering. They had not been visited during the shift of four hours by the deputy, but they had made arrangements for him to come at eleven o'clock to fire another shot. The accident occurred at ten o'clock. There was a fault in the coal which made it come away. They couldn't get any sound from it. Minnican had worked with witness for over two years. He (witness) was a practical miner. Nobody could foresee the accident! The Inspector: Did you think he was taking the coal down in a proper manner? Yes. Lawson Clapperton, deputy, St. Helens, deposed he examined the working before the two men entered it at about four o clock in the morning. He considered the working quite safe. He understood they would be ready for the firing of the shot at ten o'clock, but he hadn't visited the working just previous to the accident occurring. By the Inspector: The coal that fell was a clean slip. It was next to the fault. The piece that fell on Minnican was from the forebreast where there was no fault. — Had the piece been broken by the shot tired on Friday? By the Coroner: He didn't know the cause of the coal coming away excepting by the man working at it. The Inspector: But he was working at the wedge away from it. — Mr. Gilchrist said he visited the working shortly after the accident. The coal came away because of it containing a clean — a fresh — fracture. It was not caused by the tiring of the shot. The Coroner: What would cause the fracture ? I think it would be the weight of the strata above. It was the top part of the coal that fell. The roof was formed of coal, and was one of the very best they could have. By Mr. McAleer: Does it often occur that coal comes away like this? It is very unusual. It wasn't caused by his wedging. It must have been from the weight above. He should have heard the noise of the coal coming away, but perhaps being hard of hearing would account for that. The Coroner, in summing up, said it seemed to be one of those unforeseen accidents which nobody could foresee in a coal mine. In all probability Mr. Gilchrist's theory was the correct one, because if the slip had been caused by the firing of the shot the result would have been apparent in the coal. On the other hand it was evident here that the fracture was a fresh one. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental Death," the Foreman congratulating Welsh on the straightforward manner in which he had given his evidence.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||