|
25th February 1892 Local Law CaseWoods V. The Carron Iron CompanyOn Monday the Court of Appeal, consisting of the Master of the Rolls and Lords Justices Fry and Lopes, gave judgment in this appeal of the defendants from an order of Mr. Justice Lawrance and Mr. Justice Wright refusing a motion for judgment or a new trial of an action heard in the Whitehaven County Court before Judge Steavenson and a jury. The plaintiff was the widow and administratrix of the personal effects of her husband, the late Joseph Woods, of Cleator Moor, and she sued the Carron Iron Company on behalf of herself and her three children to recover £255 as compensation for his death, which occurred on the 5th September, 1891, in consequence of personal injuries while in the employment of the defendant company. Woods was engaged in No. 4 working of the Jacktrees and Crowgarth Iron Ore Mines when he received the injuries by a piece of stone or metal falling upon him while he and two men named Doran and Higgins were engaged in blasting operations. The sole question was whether on the facts of the case the defendant Company was liable under the provisions of the Employers' Liability Act. The question was had there been negligence on the part of the Company, and at the trial the jury found that there had been negligence on the part of the Company, and found for the total claim of £255, with costs. This judgement was upheld in the Divisional Court, and Mr. Crump, Q.C., and Mr. Sharpe now appealed (instructed by Messrs Atkinson & Bennett) — Mr. Crump, in the course of his argument, submitted that there was no evidence of negligence to go to the jury. The drift and the roof of the seam in which the deceased was working with two other men in blasting operations had been inspected on the morning of the fatal occurrence, and everything was found to be in a safe condition. The inference was that the injuries had been caused by the negligence of the deceased and his fellow workmen while in engaged in blasting operations. Mr. Crump was about to read the rules under which the mines were worked, providing that men were forbidden to remain at work whenever it was unsafe to continue to do so, — when the Master of the Rolls said these rules were not referred to in the Court Below. They could not now be used for the purposes of the appellant's case. — Mr. Crump argued that the evidence was not sufficient to justify the verdict, and that no negligence had been established. — The Master of the Rolls proceeded to give judgment without calling upon Mr. Gully, Q.C., M.P., and Mr. Henry (instructed by Mr. E. Atter) for the respondent. He said this was a case in which all the essential facts were place before the jury, and they had found a verdict upon them, which seemed reasonable enough. He saw no reason for disturbing the verdict of the jury, who evidently believed that negligence had been brought home to defendants. The appeal would therefore be dismissed, with costs. — Lord Justices Fry and Lopes concurred.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||