|
28th January 1892 Local Law CaseAppeal In A Mining Compensation CaseThe case of Woods v. the Carron Iron-ore Company owning mines in West Cumberland, came up on Monday before a Divisional Court in the Queen's Bench Division, composed of Mr. Justice Lawrence and Mr. Justice Wright. Mr. Crump, Q.C., and Mr. Sharpe (instructed by Messrs Atkinson and Bennett) appeared for the defendant Company, and Mr. Henry (instructed by Mr. E. Atter) for the plaintiff. Mr. Crump, Q.C. said the facts of the case were as follows :— Some time ago an accident occurred in the mines belonging to the defendants Company by which a large piece of stone was by some means broken off the rocks and flying along the workings struck a man named Woods and killed him. An action was brought against the Carron Iron-Ore Company in the Whitehaven County Court, and the jury awarded the widow a sum of about £280 on the ground of negligence on the part of the defendants. He now had to appeal from that verdict and ask it to be set-aside on the ground that there was no evidence of neglect. It appeared from the evidence that no one could say where the piece of stone came from that struck the deceased, though it was supposed that it came from the roof of the mine. Mr. Justice Wright said that he thought the jury might say that they had evidence from which they could draw an inference. Mr. Crump said he held that it was not sufficient for them to do that. Mr. Justice Wright said that it appeared that a witness close to whom the stone had passed said that in his opinion it came from the roof. Mr. Crump said that he thought the jury ought to have some evidence from which they could be satisfied there was a defect in the works or negligence. Mr. Justice Wright said the mine inspector also said he thought it came from the roof, and there was also clear evidence from which they could find the examination of the roof was insufficient. Mr. Crump said the jury could only find that the overmen had not examined the roof as they ought to have done. Mr. Justice Wright said if there was a loose stone in the roof that would be a defect, and that would go to the question of negligence. Mr. Crump said the jury had almost nothing to go upon except a piece of ore which is said to have done the damage, and was not connected with any spot in the roof, and it was absurd to say that because of this the mine owner was to be afflicted with serious liability. Mr. Henry said it was stated quite clearly at the trial that if a proper examination of the roof had been made the loose stone would have been detected. Mr. Oswald stated that if the roof had been properly examined in the way he directed the bad piece of stone would have been found out, and the accident most probably prevented, the object of the examiner being to test the soundness of the roofs of the workings. Mr. Justice Wright said he might have said so, but the judge's note was not very clear. Mr. Henry said his memory was quite clear. Mr. Oswald, who was an inspector, said if the roof had been properly tested as he directed the accident would not have occurred. Mr. Justice Lawrence said his opinion was that the appeal must be dismissed. The point was whether there was any evidence, on which the jury could act, and the view he took was extremely near to the line, and though he thought the appeal should be dismissed he did not say so without considerable doubt. Mr. Justice Wright said he concurred with his brother. He thought the case came within the scope of sub-section 1 of the Employer's Liability Act, and probably also within sub-section 2. He thought the existence of a stone liable to fall from the roof of one of the galleries of the mine such as that one was a "defect in the ways or works connected with or used in the business of the employer," and that the "defect had not been discovered or remedied owing to the negligence of persons in the service of the employer, and entrusted by him with the duty of seeing to them." Therefore he thought the jury were warranted in finding that the stone did come from the roof, and that there was no proper examination of the roof. The real question was whether it was reasonable to infer that the roof was defective, and the defect had not been discovered owing to the negligence of the overmen, or, in other words, could not the jury infer that the accident would not have happened if the roof had been properly timbered or a proper examination made? He though they could. He also thought there was no contributory negligence show. — The appeal would, therefore be dismissed with costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||