|
19th November 1891 Whitehaven County CourtTuesday, November 17th(Before Judge D. F. Stevenson.) Barristers and solicitors present:— Messrs A. Henry, J. Sharpe (North Circuit Bar), K. Atter, R. Bennet, J. T. Anderson, W. Paisley, and W. H. Chapman. Employers' Liability Act Isabella Woods v. Carron Company. — In this case Isabella Woods administratrix of the personal effects of her husband, the late Joseph Woods, 72 Trumpet Terrace, Cleator Moor, sued the Carron Company on behalf of herself and three children to recover £255 as compensation for the death of the deceased, which occurred on September 5, 1891. The death of the deceased was alleged to have been occasioned by Woods being struck and injured by a piece of stone or metal falling upon him in the No. 4 working of the Jacktrees and Crowgarth Iron-ore Mine, from which injuries he subsequently died. — Mr. Henry (instructed by Mr. Atter) appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. J. Sharpe (Instructed by Messrs Atkinson & Bennett) represented the defendants. — The jury empanelled consisted of Messrs. J. Cant, T. Kitchin, D. Benson, J. H. Watson, and W. Holloway. — Mr. Henry said the measure of damage was not disputed. At the time of the accident two men named Doran and Higgins were blasting, and were filling the ore into a bogey. Deceased at the time was standing at the bogey picking out pieces of metal and throwing them aside, when a stone fell from the roof and struck him. Deceased was carried to the hospital and died. The question for the jury was — was the company liable? This pit had a high, jagged bad roof at the spot where the accident occurred. The height was either ten or twelve or fifteen feet. The roof was not tempered or protected in any way. It was the duty of the Company to have the roof carefully inspected daily, in support of which Mr. Henry read the special rules under the Act. He would call before them the Government Inspector to prove that the roof hadn't been properly inspected. At the inquest it was admitted by the overman that they hadn't inspected the roof for weeks, and that when they did make the examinations it was only by means of a pole. Mr. Oswald, the Government Inspector, examined the roof the day after the accident and found it bad right in the spot under which the deceased was killed. — Isabella Woods was then examined. She said her husband died on the day of the accident. His wages were £3 10s per fortnight from about last Christmas. Previously they were £2 8s. She had three children — all boys — aged respectively 18 months, 3 years, and 4 years. — By Mr. Sharpe: Her husband might have earned more than £3 10s per fortnight. She wasn't aware at the time of the accident that her husband was working by the ton. — Thomas Doran, a labourer, employed in No. 4 working of the Jacktree Pit, deposed that the deceased was working with him on the day of the accident. He was picking pieces of stone from behind the bogey on the roadway. Higgins and witness were filling the bogey when apiece of iron-ore; he believed, fell from the roof and struck deceased. It knocked him down, and he died afterwards. Witness hadn't seen the roof examined that morning. — By Mr. Sharpe: Deceased was not standing on the roadway. The piece of iron-ore whizzed past between them and bounced from the "Stope." He had not been told by Campbell and Walker not to work from the bottom of the "Stope." He had never told Woods to loosen the metal under the "Stope." They were not told not to undermine for fear of accident. Witness was a miner's labourer, and had worked in the pit for five years. Woods was a skilled miner and had charge of the working. On the morning of the accident two or three of the overmen were in the working, but he didn't know whether they examined the roof. They had to take the metal from the bottom: they couldn't take it from the top. (Laughter.) This was the way they had to work. It was not a question of tonnage. They had to take the metal as it came. — Cross-examined by Mr. Henry: He had known stones to come down the "Stope." — Dr. Speirs testified he was called in to see the deceased. He found him suffering from collapse, and he had a star-shaped wound on the left side of the head, over the left paritial bone. He presented symptoms of concussions of brain. The wound on the left side of the skull caused his death. There was a wound on the left ear, caused evidently by a piece of stone passing it. His opinion was that the wound on the left side was caused by a direct stone, and the wound on the right eyebrow by deceased falling against something. His further opinion was with regard to the evidence that the wound on the left side of the head was caused by a downward blow from the roof. — By Mr. Sharpe: It might come from an angle. — Daniel Marston, residing at Cleator Moor, agent of the Miners Association, disposed that he attended the inquest held on the deceased, and heard the evidence given. Graham, the deputy-overman, then said that there had been no examination of the roof of No. 4 working for some time prior to the accident. — Mr. Sharpe objected to this statement as evidence. — His Honour: You should have objected at the moment. I must take it now. — Witness, continuing, said he heard Graham say he had not sounded the roof for about a month before the accident: that he didn't always obey the rules: and that they would have to carry ladders on their backs if they made a proper examination daily of the workings. Mr. Sharpe proceeded to seek admissions from his own witnesses, but His Honour objected, saying that the depositions of the coroner hade better be procured. — Mr. R. W. Oswald, Government Mining Inspector for this district, said he attended on subpoenas. He had given no evidence to the gentleman who instructed Mr. Atter. Witness attended the inquest of the deceased. William Walker, William Graham, and John Campbell admitted that they were the overmen and the persons responsible for the state of the workings of the pit. — Mr. Sharpe said there was only evidence with regard to Graham. — Examined by Mr. Attar, witness said he examined the place of the accident on Tuesday following. He found the roof to be a high one. Where the accident occurred it was not timbered. Places not timbered required more careful examination than those, which were timbered. According to rule the inspection should be daily. Even if there were no rule it should be daily. The proper mode of examining this roof should be by means of a hammer or bar. At this spot they would require a ladder, because it was so high that it could not be reached by a bar or hammer. On the occasion he inspected it, Graham produced a ladder. Witness saw the particular part of the roof above the place of the accident examined. The manager, Mr. Watson, Walker, Campbell and Graham were present. They found a short distance from the exact spot where the deceased was killed several pieces of bad stone. One piece measured eleven inches square by three inches thick. If the examination had been made previously, the bad stone would have been detected. Campbell said he had made an examination that morning, and he also informed him that he merely looked at it. Graham said he had examined the stones by looking at them. They evidently didn't know of the dummy pieces. He (witness) was under the impression that they hadn't been examined. — His Honour: You musn't tell us that. — Witness said in his opinion the piece of stone that struck deceased fell from the roof. — By Mr. Sharpe: It was the roof of the roadway, which he examined. It was twelve feet away from where the man was killed. The roof was stone. The man was killed by a piece of iron-ore. He didn't go up to No. 4 working, because the man was not killed there. He was killed on the trail road at the bottom of the "slope" of No. 4 working. If the man undermined at the foot of the "stope" it would tend to make ore, and "slope" plumb. A "stope" was in a line to the working face. — Mr. Sharpe: It has been said that this piece of ore whizzed past the two men, Doran and Higgins, who were standing on the platform, and came between them and went on past the platform, hitting Woods. I ask you, under those circumstances, might it not come from the plumb face of the ore in the "stope?" It is impossible. It hadn't sufficient fall for it. A good examination of a roof could not be mad with a pole long enough to reach it and a man holding a light. If it were usual, it was improper. When necessary, he required timbering to be done to stone roof s where men were working. — This was the case for the plaintiffs. — Mr. Sharpe, replying, contended that the accident was due sole to Wood's negligence. He was a miner of skill, and had sole charge of the working. Did he in fact satisfy himself or not of the safety of the working? Was there any evidence to show that he made any such examination, or satisfied himself according to the rules by which he was bound: or that he made any report to his superiors. If there was no evidence of that kind before the jury, it was their duty to find a verdict for the defence. The only part of the roof which was bad was now, upon their own admission, stated to be twelve feet away from the place of the accident, and therefore the accident didn't happen in the way related. These men undermined the working contrary to orders, and in consequence this piece of ore came bounding down from the "stope" and hit the deceased. After reviewing the evidence. Mr. Sharpe called Wm. Walker, overman of Jacktrees No 4 pit. He had been 29 years engaged in mining. The deceased had charge of the working, and with him there were two miners' labourers, Doran and Higgins. Witness inspected the working on the day previous and on the morning of the accident. Campbell and Graham were with him. On the Friday they examined it with two poles, one with a candle and the other with an iron ferral, and found it all correct. On the Saturday they examined it again with poles. It was then all good. The ore was "stoped" down on the Saturday, but on the previous day it was not "stoped." He told Woods they must stope it on Friday, and if he didn't he would cause him to put in timber. He replied he would stope it if he was supplied with the timber. Three hours after the accident witness found the ore in the "stope" almost plumb up. The men had been undermining. In his opinion the accident was caused by a piece of ore coming from the bank on to the "stope." — Could such a stone have come down if the ore had been "stoped" as you directed? No. — By Mr. Benson: As regards the loose ore; what depth on the stope was it, and what distance was it off? — Witness: The height of the bank was about eight feet plumb up, and about 32 feet from the platform up the inclines. — Cross-examined by Mr. Henry: Four men had been killed in their pits during the last three years. — Has not there been eight? I am confident there has not been that number. I can't, however, remember their names. He and Campbell and Graham were cautioned by the coroner at the inquest that if greater care were not taken in the pit in compliance with the rules there might be a charge of manslaughter. He hadn't protected the "stope" with timber. There was no other way. It was not usual to protect a "stope" of this kind by wood. It was Woods duty to timber the "stope" if he didn't keep it dressed. Since the accident they had built a wall on the "stope" to keep the stone slipping down, for the protection of people passing on the tramway. They inspected all over the top of the workings on the Friday and Saturday. If Graham said at the inquest that they merely looked at the top of the working. It was not true; neither was it true that he hadn't examined the workings for a month. One pole was twenty feet long. They had two candles on one pole. They didn't see the bad piece of roof, which the Government Inspector discovered on the Tuesday. They saw it when they made a proper inspection. The stone might not have been drummy. If it had been, he admitted they would have found it on the Saturday or Friday, under proper examinations. There was no work from the Saturday until the Tuesday. — If the plumbness was the cause of the accident, why didn't you call Mr. Oswald's attention to it? I didn't think it was my duty to call Mr. Oswald's attention to anything. — Mr. Benson: Is there anything wrong, or is it usual for three overmen to examine a place in the workings? (Laughter.) We would meet in the road, but we had no reason for doing so. — John Campbell, deputy-overman, said he had been engaged in mining for twenty years. He found the roof safe on the Friday. The "stope" was standing almost plumb. Undermining, in his opinion, was an unsafe method of working. — By Mr. Henry: What was the cause of the accident? On account of the metal rolling off the stope. On the morning of the accident he told the deceased to take the "stope" down. He, too, was cautioned by the coroner at the inquest. — Did you tell the coroner one word about your examination of this place shortly before the accident? I simply answered what I was asked. — William Graham, deputy-overman, deposed he didn't say at the inquest that the workings hadn't been examined for a month. He meant the solid stone check. He examined the roof every morning. — By Mr. Henry: He said before the coroner that he didn't examine the roof. He wouldn't swear that he said that he never sounded the roof. He must have said that he had examined the roof off a ladder. He didn't say at the inquest that he ever disobeyed the rules. He admitted saying about carrying ladders. — Mr. McClellan, mining engineer and inspector of the mines, said he concurred with the evidence of Walker. He attributed the accident to the stone falling down from the top of the bank. If the bank of ore had been "stoped" the accident would not have occurred. He considered the working perfectly safe. — By Mr. Henry: Do you suggest that the miners should examine these workings? Yes, as well as our officials. — How? With lights. — When there are specially appointed persons to make these examinations, it is also the duty of the miners? Yes. — This was all the evidence. Mr. Sharpe: submitted there was no case for the jury. — His honour: I think there is not the slightest doubt about there being a case for a jury. — In addressing the jury, Mr. Sharpe contended that Wood elected to undermine, which was a dangerous method. In order to make more money, and that from first to last he knew the great risk he was running. — Mr. Henry submitted that if an order of the kind mentioned was given to Wood, it was extraordinary that they had not corroborated it by calling evidence. If there was any undermining, which he didn't think occurred, it was done by Higgins and Doran, and not by Woods. If they listened to the defence in this case, it was evident that the accident couldn't happen at all. It was a terrible thing that there should be such a mine in this district, and that it should be so recklessly worked. Negligence was proved by their own witnesses, and out of the mouth of the Government Inspector. — His Honour then summed up. He said there was evidence that the three men named had superintendence of the mine, and there was nothing to contradict it. Now the only witness who was there when this man was killed that has been called was Doran, and one would suppose, if he were speaking the truth, that his evidence was the best to guide them to their verdict. He said, "I believe the stone fell from the roof; I am not prepared to say it actually came from there, but I believe it did." Then the evidence of the government Inspector was worthy of the greatest weight because he was entirely impartial. He said the stone could not have come from the plumb face of the stone. There was not sufficient fall. If his opinion was correct why then the defendants really had not given a sufficient answer to this case. — The jury retired to consider their verdict. — After an absence of five minutes the jury returned into court. They found for the plaintiff in the full amount of claim with costs, leaving the question of apportionment to His Honour with regard to the children. — His Honour said he would order that £75 be paid to the widow, and that the balance of £180 be invested for the benefit of the children. — Mr. Sharpe asked that the money be paid into court pending an appeal. — Mr. Henry held there was no appeal from the County Court. — His Honour: He can do as he likes. — After further conversations His Honour said he refused to grant an appeal.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||