|
17th September 1891 The Fatal Mining Accident At JacktreesOn Friday last, Mr. J. Webster, the coroner for the lordship of Egremont, resumed his inquiry at the Albert Inn, Brookside, Cleator, into the cause of the death of Joseph Woods, Trumpet Terrace, who died on Saturday evening last from the effect of injuries received whilst at work that morning in the Carron Company's pit at Jacktrees. The jury consisted of the following: Messers. Thomas Bell, retired miner (foreman); Thomas Bell, publican; Matthew Burns, miner; James Currie, miner; Robert Kerr, grocer; William Raven, labourer; Matthew Knowles, miner; Henry Rigg, tailor; Charles Lamb, fitter; Samuel Fearon, publican; Jonathan Holmes, borer; William Ray, deputy over-man with Mr. Stirling; Thos. Hodgson, publican. Mr. W. H. Atkinson appeared for the Carron Company; Mr. E. Atter appeared for the relatives of the deceased; and there were also present Mr. Oswald, deputy inspector of mines, and Mr. Marston, miners' agent. Dr. Speirs deposed that he was called in to see deceased on Saturday, at Trumpet terrace. He found him suffering from collapse. There was a star shaped wound over the parental bone on the left side of the scalp, a wound over the right cheek bone with severe contusion of the eyelids, and a wound over the left eyebrow. He presented symptoms of severe concussion of the brain. Death was due to extreme extravasations of blood on the brain. There was very little bleeding from the wounds. He was of opinion that the injuries to the head were caused by a blow from some hard substance. The injuries on the face were due to deceased having fallen as the result of the blow on the head. There was no fracture of the skull externally visible. He was of opinion that the stone or hard substance which had caused the wound had came from the roof above deceased's head. He observed slight scratches on deceased's left ear, as if the substance had broken on the man's head and part of the fragments had caused wounds, or as if other fragments had fallen at the same time. Thomas Doran, 27, High street, Cleator Moor, deposed that he was a labourer in the Carron Company's No. 4 Pit, and worked in company with the deceased, John Higgins, and John Smith in No. 4 working. On Saturday, the 5th September, between half-past eleven and twelve in the forenoon, he was engaged filling metal into a bogie. John Smith was not with them at the time. About a fortnight ago a quantity of metal had been got by blasting out of the forebreast and roof of No. 4 working, and some which fell without blasting from the roof — plenty to keep them going with a fortnight's filling, perhaps more. Witness went to work at six a.m. on the 5th inst. When he went into the working place he found Wood and Higgins there already. Witness immediately commenced to fill metal. Higgins was taking metal away from him in a bogie. Woods was in another place in the working shifting stone. They continued thus for two or three hours. Witness then went to where Woods was working, and started to work with him, helping to move stones. They then all three commenced to put out metal. After dinner they started in the same place to fill and remove metal. They had got one bogie filled and away. Higgins brought in the second bogie, and Higgins and witness started to fill the bogie. Woods was picking the bogie. The bogie was about half-full when a lump came flying past then and struck Woods. Witness has just got turned, when the lump came between witness and Higgins. Saw Woods fall, and shouted to Higgins to catch him. They both jumped down and took Woods to Brake Top. Witness left Woods and came back to get some water for him. Passing where the lump was lying that had fallen on deceased, observed three pieces of metal. Witness returned to the Brake Top and helped to take Woods up the pit and home. Woods was not sensible. No. 4 working had a high roof. There was no timber in the working. It was 20 or 30 feet wide, and the sole consisted of stone. Had worked twice in this working — this last time for six or seven months. The roof above the platform was stone and metal. He thought the roof up to the working place would be stone. There might be a shell of metal on the roof. Had not seen it for a good bit. Never examined the roof. The overman (William Walker) and the deputy (John Campbell) were persons who should examine the roof, sides, and working places. John Smith and Joseph Woods were the men over the working and in charge of them. Witness was not aware that anyone examined the roof, sides, and forebreast that morning; but a person could have examined the working without his having observed him or heard him, where he was working. He had occasionally seen Woods examining No. 4 working — on the last occasion, about a month previous to the accident. Had seen John Smith examining No. 4 working. Had also seen William Walker examine it, about five or six weeks ago. Also John Campbell and William Graham. Saw Campbell examining the working on Friday, the day before the accident. Woods was up with him. Woods told witness that was a piece of bad cill up in the roof. Campbell was not present at the time of this conversation. The piece of bad cill were not taken down, that witness saw, before he went to work on the Saturday morning. It would have been Wood's duty to have taken down the cill. By Mr. Atkinson: The sole of the working place in No. 4 is nearly level, and we have to cart the metal down the slope to the platform, from which we fill it into the bogies. The stage, when full, will hold nine or ten bogies. The rest of the ore was lying on the slope and on the sole of the working. On the morning of the accident Woods had been working at the bottom of the slope, casting metal on the platform. I cannot say where the metal which struck deceased came from, but it was from the direction of No. 4 working. I cannot say it came from the place where Woods had been working that morning, but I am satisfied it did not come from the roof above his head. The piece which came past me would not be ½ cwt. Woods was looking in the bogie at the time of the accident occurred. There would be about 500 or 600 bogie loads on the slope and in the workings of No. 4. After the conversation with Woods about the bad cill in the roof, saw Campbell on the bottom road. He asked me if all was quiet up there, and I answered "Yes." Have not worked at No. 4 since the accident, but have heard that stone work has been put in from stage to roof. That will be an additional means of security to workmen. A great quantity of stone and metal on the slope may have fallen from the roof of the working. Could not have got the metal out if there had been a battery. Do not think it would have been desirable to have had a battery to prevent the ore rolling down on the platform. Re-examined by Mr. Oswald: About four or five weeks ago I rolled lumps down the slope. Some went on to the stage, and some on to the road where the bogie was. There was metal rolled down, could hear them bounding from one place to another. Did not hear this piece of metal bounding. By the jury: The metal rushes down the slope. Neil Wilkie, M.E., in the service of the Carron Company, produced a plan of No. 4 Pit. The gradient of the slope was 1 in 2, he was of opinion that ore which had been blasted in No. 4 working would come down the slope without assistance from the miners, until the ground got choked up. He thought a piece of metal rolling down the slope with such force as to kill a man would have been heard. He did not think that if a stone fell from the roof at No. 4 working place, and if there had been between 400 and 500 bogie loads on the slope, it would have prevented the stone rolling down on to the man at the bottom. It might have been better to have had a barrier across the slope for the purpose of preventing stones or metal from rushing down and so on to workmen at the bottom. He did not think the working was dangerous. John Higgins, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, deposed that he was a labourer in the employ of the Carron Company, and worked with woods and Doran. Sometimes pieces of metal fell down the slope, and they could hear them coming down, and stepped aside to get clear of them. Anything put across the slope to stop pieces rolling down would have prevented them filling the bogie. By the Inspector: Heard that a security had been put up to protect those who were passing at the bottom of the slope. Witness could not tell where the metal came from that struck deceased — whether from the roof direct or down the slope, or from the roof and on to the slope. By Mr. Atter: Saw Campbell that morning, but Campbell gave them no warning. Wm. Graham, of Wath Brow, deputy overman in the employ of the Carron Company, said he was in No. 4 working on Friday, the day before the accident, and examined the ground. Saw Woods and Smith at the bottom of the slope. Did not speak to them. Examined the roof with a pole. Could not find anything different from the day before. There were no marks of the ground giving way. He spent ten minutes or a quarter of an hour in his examination. Metal sometimes rolled down the slope as to be dangerous to anyone working underneath. It was safe on Saturday, by reason of the way in which the men were working the metal: they were close down to the platform — say some six feet. There might be 6ft. in depth of ore on the slope. It was not dangerous if they had taken the metal off the top instead of underneath. He was at No. 4 working on Saturday, and Walker, Campbell, and he examined the working place and the slope leading to it. They examined the roof with two long poles. Could not sound the roof with the poles — they merely looked at it. About a month ago he examined the roof with a ladder, when Smith and Woods were there. Examined the roof with pick, hammer, and bar, about three fathoms distant from where a robbing of a pillar was going on. There were no pieces of bad cill in the roof. Cross-examined by Mr. Atkinson: There is no ore in the roof of No. 4 working place — and therefore it if was a piece of iron that killed deceased it must have come from the loose stuff on the broken ground. By Mr. Atter: Cannot say that the roof of the slope was safe within the month. A wall has been put up since Wednesday, to prevent stuff rolling down, thus closing up the working. John Campbell, Queen street, Cleator Moor, deputy overman at No. 4 Pit of the Carron Company, deposed that it was his duty to examine No. 4 working. He examined it on Saturday, at seven o'clock in the morning. Graham, Walker, and he had two poles: one held a light, the other had an iron ferrule on the top for the purpose of sounding. Sounded the roof, and sounded six or seven yards down the slope. Found the roof all right — that is not drummy. The roof of the slope was all stone. Wm. Walker, the overman of No. 4 pit, deposed that he had told Woods he should have a sleeper across to avoid a rush of ore down the slope. Deceased said he thought there was no use in doing so. Witness said, "Very well, if you keep the bank even." The jury found that the deceased was killed by a piece of stone or metal which fell on to his head, but there was no evidence to prove from whence the said stone or metal fell. The inquiry lasted several hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||