|
23rd May 1891, Page: 8, Column: 4 The Boiler Explosion At UsworthThe adjourned inquiry into the deaths of the four men who were killed in the boiler explosion at Usworth Colliery was resumed yesterday morning in the School Room, Usworth Colliery, before Mr. John Graham, coroner. There were present Mr. Thos. Bell, Inspector of Mines, Mr. G. F. Bell, Assistant Inspector of Mines, Mr. Cooper, Newcastle, appeared on behalf of the owners, and Mr. H. Forrest on behalf of the workmen, assisted by Mr. W. H. Lambton, secretary of the Durham County Enginemen's Association. A number of the colliery officials were present, and there was a large attendance of miners, who took considerable interest in the inquiry. Mr. Bell stated that he had received a letter from Messrs Fowler and Co. of Leeds, the makers of the boiler, stating that they had not sent a representative to the last inquiry as they were preparing a statement for the Board of Trade inquiry. Thomas Smith, boilersmith, said he examined the boiler (No. 2) about two o'clock on the morning of the explosion. There was nothing the matter with the boiler that he was aware of. He handed the slate containing the record to the engineer. He did not think there was any danger. Mr. Chas. Wilson Stokoe, certificated manager at Usworth Colliery, said he had been so engaged for nearly two years. The duties of the engineer and foreman enginewright were set forth by the Mines Regulation Act, and he (witness) only acted on their reports. No complaints were ever made to him that the boiler was in a dangerous state. Mr. Elwin in his report stated that the boiler would go for several years yet. The boiler was six years old. W. Daniel, engineer, representing Messrs. Fowler and Co. of Leeds, described the boilers supplied by that firm, and thought it would be quite safe to work the boiler at 90lbs pressure. He had not seen the plates, and could not therefore give any opinion as to the cause of the explosion. If the engineer had made a careful examination, he thought he could have seen the deterioration. Mr. George Hauxwell, engineer, Durham, had had great experience in making and repairing boilers. He had examined the boilers at Usworth Colliery, and found in No. 2 boiler that the plates on the right hand side had been completely eaten away. Ten feet on three plates of the boiler was deteriorated. The width or the corrosion was ten inches, and was rather worse below the water-level than above. Had Elwin or Wraith examined the boiler carefully a fortnight before the explosion they would have been able to tell that there was great deterioration. He believed the cause of the explosion was sheer weakness and nothing to resist the pressure. The cause of the corrosion was the acid in the water, and the chemical action which took place, in his opinion, caused the explosion. William Daniels, recalled, described the plates of the boiler which he had just examined. The plates were very much corroded. If the plates were in the same condition as they were now Mr. Elwin must have seen it, but the action of the water on the plates might have had an effect without actually thinning the plates. John Stephenson, fireman and boiler minder, had noticed that No. 2 boiler was eaten away, and had told Simpson about it. The boiler was in a bad condition, and he had frequently complained to Elwin and Wraith about the leakage. The boilers were always repaired. This was the whole of the evidence. The Coroner in summing up defined the Mines' Regulation Act as it affected the matter they were called upon to consider, and stated that the rules clearly defined the duties of the men appointed to look after boilers. The question was, did these officials, or each of them, perform their duty in respect to the particular boiler which had unfortunately exploded. So far as the manager of the colliery (Mr. Stokoe) was concerned, be had provided a full staff of men to perform the duties repaired. It was an important point that Mr. Stokoe had been told by Mr. Elwin that the boiler would last several years, as that related to Mr. Stokoe's responsibility. Having carefully reviewed the evidence, the coroner said it was for the jury to say whether there had been culpable negligence on the part of one or both (the engineer and the foreman enginewright), or was it an error of judgment. The Verdict. The Jury, after as absence of an hour and a half, returned the following verdict — "That the whole of the deceased had died from scalds and other injuries caused by the explosion of a boiler at Usworth Colliery on April 11th; and, with respect to the whole, that, such boiler having been wasted by water containing corrosive acid, was rendered unfit to use, and, if properly inspected, should have been laid off for repairs." In addition the jury make the following presentment :— We are of opinion that the water being of such corrosive nature that the boiler needed more than ordinary attention, when it was first found by the engineer and the enginewright that the boiler had deteriorated to such an extent, we consider that this condition ought to have rendered more necessary and more careful inspection; but when the second examination was made, and it was found that the plate had further deteriorated, proper means ought to have been taken to ascertain the thickness of the plate remaining which was not done, and the boiler should have been laid off for repairs at once. We consider the engineer and the enginewright are equally culpable, inasmuch as they did not ascertain and report to the manager the true condition of the boiler, which must, in our opinion, have been unsafe at the time of the last examination. We further consider that Mr. Stokoe, the manager, is not to blame, and that George Elwin, engineer, and Robert Wraith, enginewright, although not guilty of criminal culpability, have exhibited great want of judgment and care, and we further state that we do not consider that there is any blame attributable to Wm. Bell, the deceased boiler-minder, as there was no want of water as the time of the accident. The inquiry then terminated.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||