Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th February 1891

Fatal Accident At Jacktrees Pit, Cleator Moor

Through a fall of metal at the Carron Company's Pit (Jacktrees Road) on Friday, between the hours of ten and eleven o'clock in the morning, a man named John O'Pray, residing in Ennerdale road, was brought home in an ambulance wagon suffering from a severe shock to the system. Dr. Eaton was speedily in attendance, and announced that no bones were broken. The shock has resulted in death, the man having died about one o'clock in the afternoon. The man was of a very nervous temperament.

At the Public Offices, Cleator Moor, on Monday, Mr. Webster, the coroner for the lordship of Egremont, and a jury over whom Mr. J. McMullen was chosen foreman, held an inquiry relative to the death of John O'Pray. — Mr. E. Atter attended the inquiry on behalf of the relatives of the deceased, and Mr. R. Bennett appeared for the Carron Company. Mr. R. P. W. Oswald, the Government Inspector, was also present at the inquiry. — Robert Thompson, 165, Ennerdale road, Cleator Moor, a miner in the employ of the Glebe Company, gave evidence of identification. The deceased was 42 years of age. He was a labourer in the employment of the Carron Iron Company. — John Holloway deposed: I live at Trumpet Road, Wath Brow, Cleator, and am a miner in employment of the Carron Iron Company. I worked with deceased. On Friday morning last I went to work at six o'clock in No. 4 Pit. The deceased arrived about ten or fifteen minutes after me. I went to my working place, No. 6, in company with the deceased. When I arrived at the pit there were no overmen present. William Walker, the overman, arrived at the working about half past six. I and the deceased had started to work before Walker arrived. As soon as I got into the working place I examined it. — How did you examine it? I sounded it all over with a hammer. — Did you sound the sides and roof? I sounded the roof. — Did you sound the sides? No; they did not require it. — What was the result of your examination? Before I sounded the roof I knew that a portion of it was bad, because a day or two before O'Pray and I had been cautioned about a piece of stone which was bad. — In what way was it bad? It sounded "drummy." — How did you know that O'Pray was cautioned? I was present when Walker cautioned O'Pray. He cautioned us both at the same time. — Is it the duty of the men, when they have been cautioned that a roof is dangerous, not to proceed with their work until it is made safe? Yes. — And it is the duty of the men to do that themselves? Yes. — And knowing that the place was dangerous and having been warned, why did you not take the piece of stone down? We could not do so. We had tried to do that on the morning of the accident, but we could not get it down, and so we left it for a bit. I then took a crowbar and endeavoured to "lever" over a stone that was in the working place, and the deceased helped me with his pick, and as we were in the act of doing this the "drummy" stone from the roof came away and fell on the piece of stone that we were "levering," and I think that the piece of stone bounced of that and hit deceased on the side near his kidneys. It did not knock him over. — Was it a violent blow that he received? No, because if it had been a violent blow it would have knocked him over. — When you sounded the piece of stone that came away in what condition was it? It was bad. — You knew you had it overhead? Yes. — Then why did you move the stone underneath? We had tried to get the stone away from the roof but we could not. The accident occurred about 10.30, and he died about one o'clock. He did not say anything to me about being struck, nor did he blame anyone. We had plenty of timber near the working place. — You could have propped this piece of stone, then? Yes. — And you didn't? No, we thought it didn't require it. — Although it was "drummy"? Yes. — Did the overman say anything about the piece of stone? Yes, he said we had better get it propped, and we told him we had tried to get it away. — By Mr. Atter: The stone that fell would be about a couple of tons weight. The working place is about 14 feet high, and 14 feet or 15 feet wide. All the stone that was bad came away. — What proportion of the roof of the working came away? About a third. We were sounding the roof for about half an hour. Walker also sounded the stone, and told us not to go under it. I thought when we were up on the bench we were clear of the stone. There would be about seven feet on each side for us to be safe. — How long had this stone, to your knowledge, been dangerous? A couple of days. Walker was present when we tried to get the stone down. After Walker left we fired a shot, but it would not loosen the stone, because the shot was in the sole. After Walker left, Stainton, a deputy overman, came into the working, and said we had better get the stone down. Campbell, another deputy overman, also visited the working. He sounded the stone, and said we were to be careful and keep from under the stone. — By Mr. Bennett: I think we were working in a proper manner. I am acquainted with rule 24, which requires the men to prop dangerous working places. Walker told us to prop the stone, but we did not do so. — You wouldn't blame the overman at all, would you? No. — By Mr. Oswald: When Walker told you to put props in, why didn't you do so? Because we wanted to get the stone down. — Did you tell Stainton you had been ordered to put a prop up? Yes. — Did Campbell know, too, that you had been ordered to put a prop up? Yes. — Then how was it that Stainton and Campbell did not send you out of the pit when they found you had disobeyed orders? I was told to put the prop in as soon as possible. It wasn't possible to get a prop in at the time, nor for the two days preceding. — For what reason? To be any benefit to the lump, because by shooting the sole up we would have knocked the prop away. We had been paid on the "make up" system for a month previous. The hole, which we made in the sole was in metal, had been bored two days before, and was immediately under the stone, which fell. — And if that stone had fallen while you were boring it would have killed you? Yes. — And the whole time you were boring you knew that stone was in a dangerous condition? Yes. — The Coroner: Did the overman know it was in a dangerous condition? Yes. — Mr. Oswald: Did the overman know you were boring the hole? Yes; but I don't think they saw us boring it. I did not tell any of the overmen that I was going to fire it. — John Carty, 26, Ennerdale road, Cleator Moor, said he was employed by the Carron Company, and was getting his bait on Friday morning in No. 6 working, when he heard a fall, and on going to the place saw the deceased in Holloway's arms. — By Mr. Oswald: Witness was a labourer for Holloway. He knew there was a bad stone, Holloway told him so, and that it would have to come down to fill up a hole and make a steer road. He told witness not to go under it. The stone had fallen about a yard from the steer bogie. When putting in the steer bogie there were four of them at work, and they were standing on the place where the stone fell. The stone canted off the stoup. — By the foreman: O'Pray did not refuse to go into the working that morning. — Dr. Eaton stated that he was called in to the deceased on Friday morning last, and found him suffering from pain in the region of the left loin and lower part of the back bone. He was conscious, and evidently anxious and hopeless about himself. He died about one o'clock from shock to the system, from injury to the lower part of the spine and bruise of the left loin. A post mortem examination might have revealed internal injuries, but deceased's bladder was not torn, and there was no evidence of any laceration of the lower part of the bowels, for no blood had escaped externally. So far as medical evidence went he seemed to have died from nervous shock.. — William Walker deposed: I live at 6, Princess street, Cleator Moor, and am an overman in the employ of the Carron Iron Company. It is not a rule of the company that the working places be examined before the men go into them. On Friday I went to work about six o'clock, and examined the working places, including No. 6. I was well acquainted with the condition of that working place on the day previous to the accident. It was not dangerous on the 11th to my knowledge. I first became aware of the fact that the working place was dangerous about one o'clock on the day before the accident, when I sounded the roof, and found it was bad. I gave orders to Holloway that the men were not to work under the roof where it was bad. I did not give any other orders. — Quite sure? I don't think so. — Consider it carefully? I don't remember giving any other order. — Could the men get to the place without going under the stone? Yes, they had three feet of space. — But if the stone had fallen and canted it would have struck them if they had been getting ore? They were not required to get metal, and I told them not to get metal. When I inspected the working I saw that a hole had been drilled to fetch metal down. — The Coroner said that was the first they had heard about this hole. — Holloway, recalled, said that on the morning of the 12th he drilled a hole in the metal outside the stone to fetch metal down, and fired it on the 13th. The hole took two hours to bore. The shot brought down two or three bogies of metal, but none of the metal near the stone came down. They thought the shot had affected the stone, and that was why they tried it. — By Mr. Oswald: When boring in the roof we were five or six feet from "drummy" stone. After we blew the metal out of the roof we cast it off the stoup. — You would have to stand under the stone to cast the metal out? No. — How could you possibly throw it out without going on that stoup? For some part we had to go under it, but not the whole. — Practically you were working under the stone the whole time? Yes. — The Coroner: It is self-evident. — William Walker (examination resumed) deposed: I was aware of the hole in the roof, but not of the one in the sole of the working. I did not give any orders except that the men were not to work under the stone. — Did you order that any props should be put in? I ordered that the stone should be taken down or propped. — That is different to what you told me before. What were the orders you gave to Holloway? I said he was either to take it down or prop it. — Did you leave it entirely in his discretion to do either? Yes, he is a practical miner. I knew the stone was "drummy" on the day before the accident, but I don't remember what orders I then gave about it. — When the stone in the roof is "drummy" it is dangerous, is it not? No, I think not — it depends on experience. — Do you say it is not dangerous to stand under a stone that is "drummy?" No, it is not. Miners of experience will tell you that. — I have had too much experience of men being killed in that way, and I am surprised to hear you say that a stone, which is "drummy", is not dangerous. — Witness: There are plenty of men here, scores of men, who will prove it. — The Coroner: The jury knows as well as I do, and better than I do. I have had several sad cases of men who have worked under "drummy" stones, and have been killed. — Witness: They were not experienced men. — The Chairman: Yes, one was an overman. — Witness: Oh, an overman is anything. — The Coroner: I am surprised at your evidence. What does it signify when a stone is "drummy?" It's bad, and wants taking down. — Consequently no man should work under it? No, I don't think that. — When you found on the 12th that the stone was "drummy," why did you not see that it was taken down? I did. — But you have just told me you don't remember what orders you gave on the 12th. Did you tell any man to take this piece of stone down on the 12th? I don't remember. — The Coroner said he would not ask the witness any more questions. — Mr. Atter: You well understand the evidence you have been giving? — Witness: Read it over. — Do you understand the questions and the answers you have made? (No answer.) — Are you giving your evidence soberly and understand what you are saying? Yes. — The Coroner: Have you been in any public houses this morning or had anything to drink? No. — Now, just recollect yourself, you are sworn to tell the truth. Have you had anything to drink this morning? Nothing but one glass of brandy. — Mr. Atter: Do you understand what you have said, and that you are responsible for what you have said? Did you give any orders to the men on the 12th? I told them not to work under the stone. — The Coroner: You said you did not remember what orders you gave. — Mr. Atter: What day of the week is this? I don't know. — The Coroner: I think he has got confused. I am willing to take as correct his statement that he has only had one glass of brandy. (To Witness): You have just told Mr. Atter that on the day before the accident you told the men not to go under the stone, but you told me you don't remember telling them anything. Just try and pull yourself together. — The witness was then further questioned by Mr. Atter, but gave unsatisfactory replies. — The Coroner: I think perhaps it would be as well not to press this man any further. I don't know what the reason of his present condition is, whether from confusion or some other cause. He says he has not been drinking, except one glass of brandy, and that ought not to have made him in that condition. Dr. Eaton says he is a very nervous man. — Witness: I am not nervous. I deny that. I wont have Dr. Eaton say that. — The Coroner: That is not a fault. I am nervous myself under cross-examination, and most men are. I think you had better step down a bit. — Walker then left the witness box. — John Campbell, Queen Street, Cleator Moor, deposed: I am a deputy overman in the employment of the Carron Iron Company. On Friday morning, about nine o'clock, I visited No. 6 working place. I knew the place was getting rather bad, owing to a stone in the roof sounding a little "drummy." I then told Holloway to put a prop under, or fetch it down, as I knew it would get worse by shooting ore underneath. When a stone is "drummy" it is dangerous. On the Friday morning I talked to Holloway about it, and we came to the conclusion that it would be better to fetch it down. The firing of the hole in the sole of the working might have had some effect on the stone. — By Mr. Atter: I did not give any warning to Holloway before Thursday. — By Mr. Oswald: I told the men that if they could not bar the stone down they were to put a hole in and blast it down. — By Mr. Bennett: If I had been in Holloway's place I should have done exactly as he did. — This concluded the evidence. — The Coroner having summed up, the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental Death," and added a rider that in their opinion overmen of mines ought to be more particular in seeing that "drummy" stones were taken down without delay. — The Coroner: I think it is a very proper recommendation. — The inquiry lasted four hours and a half.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Solicitor  
Bennett, R.    Solicitor  
Campbell, John    Deputy Overman  
Carty, John    Miner  
Eaton, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Eaton, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Holloway, John    Miner  
McMullen, J.    Jury Foreman  
O'Pray, John   42 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Stainton, —    Deputy Overman  
Thompson, Robert    Miner  
Walker, William    Overman  
Webster, John    Coroner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Jacktrees (Iron ore)  Jacktrees (Iron ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print