18th March 1890
Federation of Colliery Owners
A meeting of the Federation of Colliery Owners was held yesterday at the Westminster Palace Hotel, representing the district attacked or menaced by the miners' strike, and, after a discussion extending over three hours, a resolution was adopted refusing
the demand of the men for an immediate advance in wages of 5 per cent. and a further advance to the same amount from the 1st of July. At the same time the owners expressed their willingness to enter into negotiations with the representatives of the men
on strike if any compromise could be suggested, or if any other method for the regulation of disputes about wages could be arrived at in the future. It is impossible to say how far these conciliatory overtures will be met by the miners, but, at present,
the attitude of the men holds out little hope of peace ; and, as individual employers in various parts of the country have yielded to the pressure brought to bear upon them, the struggle may be prolonged and doubtful in the result. In any ordinary case
of industrial conflict the public might possibly look on with lore or less tranquil indifference, but the action of the coal-miners is affecting, and must continue to affect, the whole community, producers as well as consumers. Happily, so far as the
latter are concerned, the winter is over, and the poor will not suffer as much — though they must in any case suffer severely — as if the strike had begun in November or December. The rise in the price of house coal, however, though it will
pinch thousands of poor families throughout the United Kingdom, is a trifle compared with the effect produced upon our national industries by a sudden stoppage of the supply of one of the indispensable elements of production, or, accepting the
alternative hypothetically, by a sudden rise in its price. Already, though the cessation of work ordered by the organizers of the strike has not yet been fully carried into effect, and though large stocks of coal have been accumulated by manufacturers
and merchants, business has met with a sharp check in some of the most important centres of industry. In East and South-East Lancashire many factories have suspended work, and in Sheffield rolling mills and steel works have been closed after a vain
effort to carry on by burning house-coal. If the miners are right in assuming, as they do, that they have only to starve out the community in order to get what terms they please, they are, no doubt, exulting in the immediate prospect of a complete
victory.
The question, however, is not one that can be settled by the triumph of the miners over the coal-owners. Whatever course the latter may adopt the outlook is dismal enough for British industry, which, after years of stagnation, had at last begun to hope
for a real revival of business. If the coal-owners persist in their refusal to accede to the demands of the men, the stoppage of supplies must not only bring to a standstill cotton-mills, steel factories, and all the other great manufacturers of the
country, but will seriously cripple the ordinary operations of the railway companies and the gas companies. If, on the other hand, the owners are compelled to yield to what they regard as unjust exactions, which has, in fact, happened in the case of a
good many small proprietors without the means of standing their ground, there must follow inevitably a large and probably a permanent increase in the price of coal. To the mass of the consumers throughout the country this increase in price, which
possibly would be equal to an addition to the income-tax heavy enough to overturn the Government that should impose it except at a grave national crisis, would be burdensome, but not crushing. It is far otherwise with the industries which have struggled
on during a succession of disastrous or barren years, and have at length seen some hope of returning activity and prosperity. A large increase in the price of coal would mean for the manufacturers of this country a burden as grievous as any to which they
could be subjected by the most unenlightened system of taxation. The difficulties of contending with foreign competition are acknowledged to be great, and every nation in Europe is on the watch, at the first sight of a revival in trade, to assist their
local industries in underselling and cutting out the English. No doubt, if trade were now advancing by "leaps and bounds," as it was when Mr. Gladstone gathered up his big surpluses, employers might find their account for the time in
yielding to any demands, however unreasonable. It is not, however, the fact that British industry has once more attained such an ascendancy over all rivals that it can bear the burden which the coal-miners, apparently with the direct or tacit sanction of
the workmen in other branches of business, would put upon it. The problem is one, we admit, which can only be conclusively solved by the method of experiment. Yet it would be a poor consolation to the working men, if they were to drive away the whole or
a large part of the reviving business of the world from England, to know that their action had settled a moot question in economic science. A strike in the coal-producing industry practically amounts to a general strike with which the community was
threatened a few months ago, and the menace of which was withdrawn in deference to a very energetic and decided manifestation of public opinion. We know not whether the same remedy can be applied in the present case, but we are quite convinced that there
is not less need of applying it.
Whether or not the strike of the coal-miners has been organized and is being urged on by those who contemplated, announced, and, in the end, recoiled from the direct enforcement of a general strike a few months ago, we do not take it upon us to say. The
condition of the men does not appear to be such as to afford any legitimate pretext for the application of an extreme and desperate remedy, which threatens to inflict ruin on the whole of the industrial population of the kingdom. The miners are not
striking against excessive hours of labour or inhuman conditions of toil. Their pay is good compared with the other trades, though coal-winning is certainly exhausting and repulsive, and a great number of them, by their own choice, work only four days in
the week. Many of them, we are assured, are reluctant to enter upon a struggle of which the issue, from their own selfish point of view, is doubtful, and of which the consequences, in any event, must cause much suffering to their fellows in other trades.
Unfortunately, the miners are no more their own masters than were the gas-stokers in South London and Manchester who were driven to give up well-paid and permanent employment at the command of professional agitators. Moderate concessions might be made to
moderate demands without any calamitous disturbance of the market, though not, perhaps, without a serious addition to the price of coal. But a strike covering so large an area as that now involved, not to speak of the districts which, though threatened,
have not yet been invaded, is much less likely than a mere local dispute to be used for urging a moderate demand. At all events, the outlook is a very grave one for all classes in the community, whether the miners succeed in their immediate aim or not.
In any case, British industry must now be heavily handicapped just at the moment when it was necessary to strain every nerve in order to climb up on the crest of the wave of reviving trade. Other strikes, which seem to have been organized in concert with
that of the coal-miners, are comparatively insignificant, and, indeed, may even bring a certain amount of temporary relief to employers while the difficulties in the coal trade continue. But the question whether the whole industrial system of the country
should be left at the mercy of interested persons able to sway the action of some two hundred thousand coal-miners is well worthy of the thoughtful consideration of Englishmen, and, we may add, is much more practical and pressing than any of those which
are likely to be debated, not to say settled, at the Berlin Labour Conference.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Gladstone, — | | | |