Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th December 1890

Fatal Mining Accident At Cleator Moor

At the Queen's Arms hotel, Cleator Moor, on the Friday afternoon, the inquest upon the body of Michael Ash, 50, miner, who was killed at the Carron Company's No. 2 Pit, Cleator Moor, on the 12th inst., by a fall of stone from the roof, was resumed by Mr. H. J. Whiteside (deputy-coroner) and a jury over whom Mr. T. Richardson presided. Mr. R. P. Oswald, Government Inspector, was present at the inquiry. Mr. Atter appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased, and Mr. Bennett appeared on behalf of the Carron Company. John McMannis said he went to work with the deceased on the 12th of this month. They went down the pit about six o'clock, and began to work about half past. About three ton of stone came down about eight o'clock and killed deceased. It was a solid stone, and struck him on the breast and right leg. A quantity of sill fell about the deceased, who was crushed against a wall. Witness helped the deceased out. Deceased was insensible and could not speak. They got him out of the pit in fifteen minutes. The stone would fall a distance of about thirty feet on to deceased. A projecting slab stopped part of the stone in its descent. Deceased was working under part of the stone, and was only about three feet away from where witness was working. No one had been in to see if the place was safe that morning. He could not say when the place was last inspected. When they went into the place in the morning witness sounded the stone, and considered it safe. He did not sound the whole of the stone. The deceased was standing under him when he was sounding it. No conversation passed between witness and deceased then about the stone. About an hour afterwards, when witness had been out with a tub, the deceased told witness that a piece of sill had fallen, but it was only a small piece. Deceased did not ask witness whether the stone was safe or not. The roof from where the stone came was not roofed with wood. Witness considered the roof to be safe. He had been a practical miner for about fourteen years. There was no difficulty in getting to the stone in order to sound it. The deceased had not been taken out when the deputy overman (Campbell) came in. It was about his time for coming in to examine the working when the accident took place. Walker, the other overman, came in when the man was being carried up the pit. — By Mr. Bennett: He had worked four years in the Carron Mine. He did not see anything wrong with the working. Witness shouted to deceased to get out of the road, and he was of opinion that he had plenty of time to do so. — By Mr. Atter: This was the fifth fatal accident since he had been in the employ of the Carron Company. — Do you know any man who has been dismissed by the Company after giving evidence in former inquests? — No, I have not sir. — The Coroner objected to the question. — Mr. Atter said his object was to see whether it was correct that persons could not be got to appear before the Coroner and tell the real facts in consequence of what happened after giving evidence. — Mr. Bennett: I submit that we are met to consider how this man met his death. — Mr. Atter: And further whether this man's death was caused by the negligence of your clients. We know what caused his death; but we want to see by whose fault. — The Coroner held that Mr. Atter's question could not be put to the witness. — Witness, continuing, said he was of the opinion that the place was too high for a man to work in. It did not take him long to sound the stone, because he did not sound it properly. It was witness's duty to sound the stone to ensure the safety of himself, and it was the deceased's duty to do the same. — If you had sounded it properly you would have detected it? I might have done. No one had worked in the place since the accident. I have been in the working since, and dressed a bit of bad ground. It was after the Government Inspector had been down. Alterations were made in it before the inspector examined it. — Would you be prepared to work in that place now? Yes; I would work in it only for one thing, and that is, I would not care much about working in it because a man has been killed beside me. — Cross examined by Mr. Oswald: Do you remember telling me that you did not give deceased any warning? I said about as far as I know a bit of stuff fell on the slab didn't I. — You are not answering my question. Don't you remember telling me that you did not give deceased any warning? I have said that, I think. — You told me distinctly that you did not give him any warning, and now you say you did give him warning? — The Coroner: Which is true? — Witness: I say this is true that I have told you. — The Coroner: Why did you tell a lie? I did not tell a lie. — The Coroner: Clearly you have. — Mr. Oswald: Certainly oh yes, you have told me a deliberate lie. — Witness continuing, said he admitted not having examined the working properly. Campbell generally looked at the roof, and any place he could sound. Walker also sounded the place that he could not reach by means of a ladder, if the ladder was near hand. If he could not reach it he walked through, and if he knew there was anything bad he would make witness put up a ladder up. The deputy knew if there was a bad place by looking at it with his light. — Mr. Oswald: Well may he have met his death. If this stone had been properly examined could you have told whether it was bad or not. If you had got a hammer, could you, from your knowledge, have told whether it was bad or not. Well, I believe we could. — It was not a flat stone, was it? — No. It was really a flag, with a feather head, that fell? Yes. — By a Juryman: The working was about twenty feet wide, from pillar to pillar. — Bernard Heeland said he was working about twenty yards away from the deceased when the accident took place. He did not hear McMannis shout out before the accident happened. — In reply to Mr. Atter, witness expressed the opinion that the working place was too high and too broad. — By the Foreman: It was only possible to examine the centre of the roof with a candle on a pole. — John Campbell, deputy overman, said he examined the working place the morning before the accident and considered it quite safe. He sounded it with a hammer. On the morning in question witness arrived in the place after the accident took place. Up to the time of the accident he had been engaged inspecting other working places in the pit. Walker, the other deputy, was examining working places as well that morning. Witness examined the stone with a hammer on the Thursday morning by standing on the slab. He could not examine the whole of the roof by standing on the slab. A good deal of the stone could not be reached. — It is a dangerous working this, isn't it? No, sir, I should not think so. I have been inspecting this place over eighteen months. — By Mr. Bennett: He would not have had any hesitation in working in the place. The parts of the working were only examined where the men were employed. — By Mr. Atter: It took him about five minutes to sound the stone on the morning previous to the accident. He could not give any reason why men had not worked in the place since. Were there the same precautions taken in this working as the other workings? Yes, or other places similar to it. It was no more dangerous to work in than any other. — Do you mean to say this place was examined equally careful as any other portion of the mine? — Yes. It took you five minutes to examine this working, how long did it take you to examine the others? Did any other place take you longer? Yes. — Why did you not give this place more than five minutes? I couldn't reach it any further. — By Mr. Oswald: A portion of the roof over the roadway fell, but I can't say that was examined. I don't sound all the high places. It takes me about two hours and a half to examine the places. — If you can't examine all your places, as you say you do, in two hours and a half, you can't say that you make a thorough examination of them, can you. I quite think so. Stones get bad from shift to shift. William Walker, deputy-overman, also gave evidence. The Deputy-Coroner, in summing up remarked that the means adopted for the examination of the pit were very poor. To make any person criminally guilty however, very strong evidence of neglect and default must be advanced, and he did not think any such defence had been given. — The jury returned a verdict that deceased was accidentally killed by a fall of stone from the roof, and they recommended that the pit should be more carefully worked generally and especially that the width of the working should be materially narrowed.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ash, Michael   50 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Atter, Edward    Solicitor  
Bennett, —    Solicitor  
Campbell, John    Deputy Overman  
Heeland, Bernard    Miner  
McMannis, John    Miner  
Oswald, Ralph Patterson William    H.M. Deputy Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Richardson, Thomas    Jury Foreman  
Walker, William    Deputy Overman  
Whiteside, Henry J.    Deputy Coroner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Jacktrees (Iron ore)  Jacktrees (Iron ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print