Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

4th September 1890

Stoppage At The Whitehaven Colliery

For some time past the question of the riddling of coal has been the subject of attempted arrangement between the employers and employed at the Whitehaven Colliery. On Friday last, when it became known that orders had been given at William Pit top for the riddling of coal, the men refused to go down to work, and as a consequence the men at the other pits also ceased work. In the case of the latter the occurrence of the Whitehaven sports may have had an effect.

On Saturday the other pits resumed work, William Pit men alone standing. William Pit men went in on Monday morning. On Tuesday, in consequence of a tub of coal sent up from William Pit being confiscated, the men again stopped work; and the men of the other pits came out also to support them. The position so far as we can understand it is thus. At Croft Pit the men have suffered a deduction of a small amount to do away with riddling altogether. At William Pit and Wellington Pit there has been no such reduction and the men have been consequently restricted in the proportion of small coal they are allowed to send up in their tubs. If the quantity of small in a particular tub exceeds a certain allowance, and that particular tub chances to be selected at the pit top for examination by the riddlers paid by the employers, on detection the tub is confiscated — that is, no allowance is made for it; the round coal it contains is not paid for. Some months ago there was a remonstrance made by the William Pit men against the system of riddling and confiscating at the pit top, and the riddling was suspended. Now it has been resumed, and the consequence is the stoppage of the whole colliery. The employers offer to do away with it entirely if Wellington Pit men will accept a reduction of one penny and William Pit men a reduction of a halfpenny. The men have agreed to set to work again this (Thursday) morning, and take a ballot whether the latter offer shall be accepted.

Yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon a meeting was called for the Queen's Arms Assembly Room; but it was obvious that the place was not large enough to hold one quarter of the men who wished to be present, and it was agreed to hold the meeting in the Market Hall at six o'clock. The Market Hall was crowded. Mr. Hugh Davey, the president of the Whitehaven Union, presided, attended by Mr. John Wilson, the secretary. — The CHAIRMAN said when the pits ceased work, it was deemed advisable to wire to Mr. Sharp, and let him know how they stood. Mr. John Wilson, their secretary wired to Mr. Sharp, and Mr. Sharp replied — "Could work be continued until I come home, and meeting held on Monday, when the whole subject could be considered?" Then Mr. Sharp sent this letter that (Wednesday) morning:— "Dear Mr. Wilson, — I have received your telegram, and sent you a reply today. Would it not be best for work to be continued, and when I come home by Saturday you could arrange a meeting for Monday night, or a meeting with the owners on Monday, and the riddling question could be discussed, and the matter referred to the Joint Committee for settlement? If William Pit men are dissatisfied with the standard hewing price, they could put the case "What is a fair price for hewing coal at William Pit? at the same time as the owners claim an adjustment for riddling. I see no difficulties in the way that should have caused a stoppage of work. Disputes from both sides could have been heard at the committee meeting; and alterations of hewing price, where made, could date back from the day that the claim was raised." That was the letter Mr. Sharp sent them from the Conference at Liverpool. It contained the very same advice as he (the chairman) gave to them before the pits were stopped. He then told them that they might as well do away with the Conciliation Board at once, as throw the pits idle. It was now for the men to say what they would do. They need not stop there dilly-dallying about this question. It was for them to say whether they thought Mr. Sharp's advice worth taking or they would take some other course, if other course they had. Mr. H. DUGGAN thought they had outstepped their bounds in stopping work as they had done, ignoring the Conciliation Board and paying no respect to the representatives they had elected and sent to that Board. He wished to inform his fellow workmen that if there was a hundred thousand pounds in the central funds, they would not be entitled to one penny, owing to the action they had taken. He did not see any right or reason why the Whitehaven Colliery should be laid idle as it had been. Why had they not left the thing in the hands of those who had been elected for that purpose, to go before the Conciliation Board for consideration; and then abide by their decision? He said it was a shame, and a great shame, and it was a scandal to the men of the Whitehaven Colliery that they should take the action they had done. He moved that they resume work. The CHAIRMAN, at the request of some who had not heard it, read Mr. Sharp's letter again. He added that at their last meeting they appointed a deputation to see Mr. Ramsay, who made them this reply:— "Dear Sirs, Agreed by me, that riddling is to go on as formerly. Agreed on by G. B. Forster, Esq., that from this date, if the riddling is dispensed with, and the men receive part of the 2d for Wellington Pit and part of the 1½ d for William Pit, they will receive one half of the fines back; and if the men receive all the 2d or the 1½ d, they will get all the fines back, from date to the date of the agreement." That was the answer Mr. Ramsay gave the deputation, and that was nearly word for word the same as the advice Mr. Sharp sent. — Mr. H. DUGGAN asked concerning the amount of metal allowed per tub, was it 35lbs or 30lbs? — The CHAIRMAN said the understanding was that it was to exceed 36lbs before a full tub was stopped off them; and it was to exceed 20lbs before a half-tub was stopped off them. That was the arrangement made between Mr. Simpson, Mr. Ramsay, Mr. Sharp, and himself. — Someone having alluded to the case of Wellington Pit, the CHAIRMAN asked them not to confuse the object of the meeting. He would recommend the Wellington Pit men to take the same advice as Mr. Sharp gave the William Pit men. Let them bring their average to the Conciliation Board, for comparison with the average of the rest of the county. He had not the least doubt that Wellington Pit average would compare favourably as regarded money with any colliery in the county except William Pit. Mr. ROBT. LITTLE said he would like to ask how did this strike occur, considering that two thirds of the men were at work. He thought it took two thirds of the men to agree, to constitute a strike. They had a meeting at three o'clock, and not one third of the men could get in. He would like to know how this occurred. Every man should receive a ballot-paper, and thus have a voice in saying whether there should be a strike or not, and not leave it to a few. Although there had been no riddling at William Pit for about twelve months, the Company never cancelled that obligation. The CHAIRMAN said they did not do so directly; but he was bound to say that they had issued sets of gear and never given a riddle with them, whereas the riddle used to be the first and foremost thing given out, and no man got a set of gear without a riddle. Mr. R. LITTLE said there was a question as regards Croft Pit. — The CHAIRMAN interrupted to appeal that they should not confuse the meeting. It was not a question of Croft Pit, or anything of that. The question was whether they had done right or wrong in stopping the pits. — Mr. R. LITTLE: Well, I consider we have done quite wrong. If we were out on strike, we could not command a fraction from the West Cumberland Union. — The CHAIRMAN: No, we could not get a penny. I have said already that if you throw the pits idle you may as well throw this Conciliation Board over altogether. My advise is to bring the case forward to the Board; and I believe that the average at this colliery will be a long way below the average of this county. Mr. R. LITTLE said the right course with regard to the confiscation of this would be to take a case to the County Court. A man had no right to lose his day's work. — The CHAIRMAN said the riddling had been stopped for about twelve months, and it could not have been stopped without the knowledge of their employers. There had been gear issued to men inside that twelve months, without any riddles; and it was only natural that men would feel a little uncomfortable about this riddling system being enforced after it had been discontinued so long. Mr. R. LITTLE: But if tubs were wrongfully taken off, couldn't it be recovered? — The CHAIRMAN: Well, it is an expensive way to get a remedy, to go to law. Mr. H. DUGGAN: Mr. Chairman, I would let them have the halfpenny: let them take it. I would sooner get rid of it, so far as I am concerned. — The CHAIRMAN said the best way would be to see whether the Wellington men were willing to lose the penny and the William Pit men to lose the halfpenny. If they agreed to suffer the reduction, then they could compare their wages with the county average, and if they were below it, they would have a fair claim to be brought up. But without they got a clear majority it was not the proper way to stop work. — After some further discussion, which became more and more desultory and unruly the longer it continued, the CHAIRMAN had occasion to remonstrate with some for coming there as if only for fun, and so making a farce of their meeting. Immediately afterwards being interrupted when attempting to put a motion that he had already several times failed to put owing to interruption, Mr. Davey left the chair and the room. After some delay, he was persuaded to come back. — Ultimately it was carried by 80 votes against 43 that work should be resumed, but that a ballot be taken of William and Wellington Pit men, whether they will consent to suffer the reduction of a halfpenny and a penny per ton respectively, and do away with the riddling altogether. — The CHAIRMAN said that seeing so few men had voted — only 128 out of a large colliery like this — the sooner that ballot was got over the better. — The following were elected to take the ballot:— John King and James King, William Pit; Simeon Crane and Wm. Walker, Wellington Pit.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Crane, Simeon      
Davey, Hugh      
Duggan, H.      
Forster, G. B.    Arbitrator  
King, James      
King, John      
Little, Robert      
Ramsay, James    Colliery Manager  Whos Who Page
Sharpe, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Simpson, —      
Walker, William      
Wilson, John      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print