|
21st October 1890 Cruelty To A Pit Horse At WhitehavenWhitehaven Police Court. (Before J. R. Bain (in the chair), J. N. Dickinson, J. G. Dees, C. E. Fisher, H. Fox, and J. Dickinson, Esqs.) Cruelty To A Pit Horse At Whitehaven William Patterdale Tubman, 19, driver, Catherine place, West Strand, Whitehaven, was charged by the Whitehaven Colliery Company with cruelty to a horse at Whitehaven, on the 26th July. — Mr. T. Brown appeared for Sir James Bain and Co., and Mr. Atter appeared for the defendant. — Mr. Bain retired from the Bench during the hearing of this case. — Mr. Brown said the defendant had been one of the Colliery Cornpany's servants, and on the 26th July he was at Wellington Pit standing on a bridge or platform, below which there was a horse attached to certain coal waggons. The defendant was seen by two other servants of the Company to throw stones at the horse, which was seen to wag its head from side to side. Immediately afterwards the horse was seen to be bleeding from an eye, and it was then found that the eye was knocked out altogether. The horse keeper (Mr. Jackson), seeing the condition of the horse, went for Mr. Fisher, V.S. It was at first alleged that the horse had met with an accident when it was turning; it was said that it had struck against one of the levers which worked the brakes, but Mr. Fisher was satisfied from the nature of the wound that it was impossible to have been caused in that way. Inquiries were set on foot by the officials, with the result that evidence was obtained against the defendant, who went to Mr. Ramsey (the manager) and to Mr. Bain, and told them he had done this by throwing stones at the horse, and his father said he was willing to pay any damages which might have been incurred. Messrs. Bain, however, found it utterly impossible to deal with cases of this kind in such a way, and it was necessary for them, so much did they suffer from the ill-treatment of their horses, to bring the case before the Bench in order not only to have the man punished, but to show persons in their employ that they could not possibly overlook these offences, and that when they did occur the offenders would be brought before the Bench for punishment. — William Kellett, riddler; John Ewan, riddler; George Jackson horse-keeper; and John Fisher, V.S., having given evidence for the prosecution, Mr. Atter, on behalf of defendant, admitted that he had been guilty of wrong in throwing coal at the horse, but he had no intentions of committing any injury upon the animal. The horse had not been working fast enough, and defendant had no whip or stick, and unfortunately he took up a piece of coal and threw it at the horse. He was extremely sorry for what had occurred. Defendant had been four years in the employ of the Colliery Company, and two years previously had been employed by Mr. Edward Kennaugh in boat-building, and during the whole of his lifetime there had previously been no fault against him. He had a certificate of character from Mr. J. Harvey, of Parton. Defendant had been dismissed from his employ, and he very much regretted the consequences of the accident which had occurred. — The Chairman (Mr. Fox) said the Bench thought the case a very bad one and deserving of severe punishment. Defendant was fined 40s including costs, or one month's imprisonment with hard labour.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||