|
7th August 1890 The Late Mining Fatality At WoodendAn Exhaustive InquiryThe adjourned inquiry into the circumstances of the death of Thomas Coulthard, aged 19, and residing at 62, East road, Egremont, who was killed on July 24th, while following his vocation as a hanger-on, at No. 11 Pit, Woodend, the property of Messrs. James Bain & Co., was held on Friday morning. Mr. J. Webster acted as coroner. Mr. L. T. Helder appeared for Messrs. Bain & Co., and Mr. W. Paisley for William Owens, the engineman at No. 11 Pit. Mr. Oswald (the Government Inspector) was present. — Edward McCourt, the first witness, stated that he resided at No. 6, Birks road, Cleator Moor, and was a labourer at No. 11 Pit, Woodend, the property of Messrs. James Bain & Co. On the 24th of July he was at the top eye of No. 11 Pit, and he had some conversation with the deceased. He observed him putting a full bogie on the cage from the flat sheets. While so doing two of the front wheels got off the cage. He saw him put his right hand out to get hold of the crossbar on the cage, in order to go over the bogie to the north side of the shaft. He (witness) was about six or seven yards off with an empty bogie. He got his empty bogie on the brake bottom, and then he heard the cage lift away up the shaft with the deceased on it. He was at that time in a position lifting the bogie on to the rails. He had his back towards the bogie at the time. He went up the shaft a little way, and then he saw the deceased fall down the pit. He thought the deceased had come in contact with the lip of the eye, which caused him to fall. Shortly after the cage came down the pit, and he pulled the full bogie off. The cage had only gone a short distance up the shaft. He could not say the reason why the cage came down. The top "eye" at which he was standing was well lighted. The cage, when it came down, did not come on to the keps, and Edward Burrows, who came to the eye after the accident occurred, knocked twice, and the cage was then lowered to the keps. He (witness) thereupon pulled the full bogie, which was on it, off. The bogie had been capsized on to its end in the cage towards the south side, at which the deceased had got on. Edward Burrows then knocked three, and was drawn up the shaft. He believed that he told the engineman what had happened. A man named Joyce, on hearing that deceased had fallen down the shaft, ran to the bottom to assist him. There were rules for the guidance of the hanger-on and engineman at No. 11 Pit. There was one at the top eye, and another at the bottom shaft. To raise the bogie required one knock. He did not see or hear the deceased man give the signal to raise the cage. He did not see or hear the deceased man give the signal to raise the cage. He could not have given the signal without him hearing it. The Coroner: If you heard no knock why was the cage raised? I could not say. — Could any one knock at the bottom without you hearing the knock? No. — Cross-examined by Mr. Paisley: He had worked in the employ of the Company between nine and ten years. He was engaged by Mr. Coulthard, who was the contractor, to assist in putting full bogies on the cage. Two men assisted the deceased on the south side of the shaft to bring full bogies from the break bottom. They also took empties back to the brake bottom. He was the only man engaged on the north side. Between 7 and 80 bogies were sent up the shaft in an hour. As soon as the cage came down they put the guards on. The accident occurred at about 1.30 p.m. When he took off an empty bogie he carried it about 14 or 15 yards, and then he returned to within about two or three yards from the shaft for a full bogie. — By Mr. Helder: The signal apparatus was in good condition. There were distinct signals in the engine-house for the bottom and top eyes. — By Mr. Oswald: He was between seven and eight yards from the shaft when the accident occurred. He was much pressed to get their work out, and they had to wait at times for empty bogies. They frequently ran a bogie on the cage with one hand and rapped with the other. He had never known the engineman to raise the cage with out having had a signal. The deceased man who was the contractor, raised at so much a ton. Deceased was also the hanger on at the south side of the shaft. — By the Jury: He was of opinion that whilst deceased was on the cage he could not touch the wire and so give the signal to the engineman, but he might have done so. — By Mr. Oswald: The deceased could not have had time if he touched the signal to have got clear before the cage would commence to lift. — George Hooper stated that he was a mining surveyor and resided at Whitehaven. He prepared the plans produced of the shafts and working of No. 11 Pit, and he would certify that they were correct. — Robert Rickerby of St. Bees; Edward Sanderson Burrows, 70, North road Egremont; John James Joyce, No. 10, Main street, Cleator; John Edgar, St. Bees; and Edward Walters, Smithfield, Egremont, having given evidence, William Owens stated that he resided at No. 23, East-road, Egremont, and was the engineman at No. 11 Pit, Woodend. He remembered the 24th of July. He was in the engine-house about 1.30 p.m. He was winding iron ore from the top eye, and he noticed from the time the trailers made their descent to the top eye to put out iron ore, they began to hang on at a great rate. About 75 bogies an hour were put out as far as he could tell. He noticed their signalling more than anything else. The reason for doing so was because they were taking the full bogies away before he put his cage on the keps at the pit top. From the time of their descent to the time of the accident he noticed three mistakes in their signalling. The first was they signalled the cage away for men. As soon as he took the cage he found it was a bogie of iron ore. He took it to the pithead, and placed it on the keps. The second mistake was they signalled a full bogie away, and had the banker been there to change his bogie undoubtedly there would have been something wrong then. His reason for saying so was that just as the banker ran his empty bogie on to the cage they gave a signal two, to let the cage stand. That was repeated another time up to the time of the accident. When the accident occurred he received the signal in the usual way. He could not just then lift the cage right away, as he had to wait for the banker in order to change the bogie. The time which elapsed between the signal and the raising of the cage would be about eight to ten seconds. He lifted the cage in the usual way, and when he got it raised about four or five fathoms up the shaft he received a signal of two. He thereupon lowered the cage a few inches, in order to see if the cage was in the slides. He not only found the cage in the slides, but a full bogie of iron ore. He let the cage gently down to the eye. When he received a signal of three, he gave the back signal, and one was responded in the usual way. He brought the cage to the surface, and on seeing a man on it, he was out of the engine-house, and asked the man, Edward Burrows, "What was wrong." He said "Tom had gone down the pit." He asked how it had happened, and he, in reply, said, he (witness) had raised the cage when Tom was lifting on his bogie. The next thing he did was to get the ropes changed as quickly as possible. Whilst doing this there was a signal of two from the bottom, which required the cage to be lowered. He did so. When the cage arrived at the bottom, he received a signal of seven. He replied with one, and they responded. He then raised the cage to the surface, and saw the deceased on the cage. — James Mills having given evidence, the Coroner summed up the evidence, and the verdict returned was "Accidental Death." — The inquiry lasted about five hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||