|
30th July 1890 The Morfa Colliery ExplosionTwo reports have been presented to the Secretary of State on the Morfa Colliery explosion, and were yesterday published as a Parliamentary paper. One is drawn up by Mr. Howel Jeffreys, barrister-at-law, and the other by Mr. J. T. Robson, one of her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines. It will be remembered that the explosion at the Morfa Colliery, Port Talbot, occurred on the 10th of March last, and that the 86 persons in the pit at the time lost their lives thereby. Forty-three of the bodies were recovered at once. The rest of the bodies were left in the pit, which had to be flooded. The inquest was opened on some of the bodies on March 12 and then adjourned until April 1. At the adjourned inquest Mr. J. T. Robson, her Majesty's Inspector of Mines for the South Wales district, in which the explosion took place, Mr. Howel Jeffreys, on behalf of the Secretary of State, and several other gentlemen were present. In all the inquiry lasted for seven days, and came to an end on April 25. The jury returned a verdict that death was due to afterdamp and burns caused by an explosion of gas, which explosion probably took place in the face of the No. 8½ range, and they were of the opinion that the explosion was due to shot-firing carried out in accordance with the rules laid down by the Mines Regulation Act, and that it was due to accidental causes. In fact the jury blamed no one, but recommended that firemen should report the presence of gas whenever found. Mr. Howel Jeffreys in his report recites all the known facts of the case. He comes to the conclusion that the explosion occurred in No. 8 or No. 8½ west, probably the former. He says that it is difficult to entertain a doubt that the cause of the explosion was shot-firing. This belief was expressed not only by the jury (as already stated), but by the Coroner, by the four Inspectors of Mines who were present, and by a large proportion of the witnesses. There is not the least reason, he adds, for supposing that a naked light was used that day for any purpose except that of firing a shot. The only other suggestion made, that the explosion might have been caused by a broken lamp, need not be seriously considered. Mr. Jeffreys thinks it a by no means improbable hypothesis that Leyshon, who was acting in place of the day fireman that day, and whose body has not yet been found, fired the shot in the place known as Griffiths's stall. Ignition of gas originated the explosion, which was fed, intensified, and carried along by the coal dust which it whirled up and ignited in its passage. Mr. Jeffreys finds it difficult to believe that there was not a technical breach of one of the rules in the Mines Regulation Act, either in shot-firing too soon after a report being given of the presence of inflammable gas, or else in making no attempt to water the parts where dust was lodged. Further, there was a breach of the rules in the fact that no competent person was appointed to inspect the part found dangerous; and the presence of gas, recorded on Thursday and Friday, was not recorded on Saturday and Monday, the last being the day of the explosion. Mr. Jeffreys finds another breach of the rules in that a deputy fireman's report was made in another person's handwriting, and he thinks that the officials committed an error of judgment in permitting shot-firing in these particular places without providing water-cartridges or the use of water, and in permitting such firing during the shift. He does not recommend any prosecution. He concludes by urging that if shot-firing in fiery mines cannot be avoided — and he does not dissent from the view that it was carried on in accordance with the general rules — he thinks it would be better that such a risk should be confined to the few men actually engaged in the operation rather than that the lives of tens or hundreds of others in different parts of the mine should also be sacrificed. Mr. Robson also comes to the conclusion that, though there was no positive evidence of a shot having been fired at or about the time of the explosion, there can be little doubt that it was a shot which ignited gas, either present within the range of the shot or suddenly given off at the time of the firing. He gives his reasons as follows: — "1. It was a fact that shots were being fired almost daily in three or four places, and the ordinary time for firing was coincident with the time of the explosion. "2. On that morning, Aubrey, the day fireman, had been asked by John Griffiths, one of the colliers working in the place marked B, when he (Aubrey) would be coming in; and on Aubrey replying that he was not coming in, Griffiths said, 'Tell John Morris (the overman) that I want some one to come in.' Aubrey understood this to mean that Griffiths expected to have a shot ready to fire during the shift. "3. Aubrey gave William Leyshon, the man appointed in his place, his safety-lamp and the key for opening it in case he had a shot to fire. "4. Leyshon was not seen on No. 7 that day by any survivor, and, as his body has not yet been found, it is probably in No. 8 or No. 8½ west, where he had been at the time of the explosion. "5. The colliery had been for many years worked with safety-lamps, and the discipline as to their use was such that I do not think any of the workmen would surreptitiously use a naked light, or smoke in the workings. "6. A safety-lamp damaged and left burning, a lamp in an unsafe condition being passed by the examiner on the surface and by the fireman or other examiner at the lamp-station underground, the passage of flame through the gauze of a safety-lamp by an abnormal velocity of current, and a spark from a pick striking some hard, flinty stone, are each possible means of igniting an inflammable mixture of gas and air; but the probability of such a contingency where gas has happened to be present is too remote to be entertained as the cause of this explosion." With reference to the finding of the jury that the explosion was due to accidental causes, Mr. Robson dissents, as shot-firing is a deliberate act regulated and permitted under certain conditions, to be ascertained by previous examination. Whether Leyshon really followed the directions laid down for shot-firing, if he did fire on that day, will never be known. As to the recommendation of the jury on the report of the presence of gas wherever found, Mr. Robson entirely concurs. He concludes by pointing out that the explosion is another warning of the danger of shot firing in mines known to be fiery and dry. It shows in a very forcible manner "the absolute necessity there is for some thoroughly reliable method of keeping all roadways as free from dust as possible, without which the best ventilated collieries may sooner or later become the scene of such calamities as that which occurred at Morfa." The owners of the colliery are Messrs. Vivian and Sons, and the agent and certified manager is Mr. T. Gray, who had held that position for 17 years. Mr. Robson adds to his report a plan and a section which illustrate the general conclusions to which he comes.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||