|
29th May 1890 The Late Engine Accident At CleatorThe adjourned inquiry into the cause of death of Tom Graham, aged 21, who resided at 96, Ennerdale-road, Cleator Moor, and was killed on Saturday, May 24th, at No. 6 pit, the property of the Cleator Iron Ore Company, was resumed on Monday morning at the Three Tuns, Cleator. Mr. J. Webster acted as coroner and Mr. T. Briggs as foreman of the jury. The deceased's father was represented by Mr. J. Bell (from Mr. Atter's office), Whitehaven. Mr. J. R. Thompson appeared on behalf of the company. Mr. R. P. Oswald was also present. — The Coroner, in opening the inquiry, read over the evidence given by James Martin, the engineman, at the previous inquiry, which was to the effect that he was present when the deceased man was killed on the 24th ult. Owing to the engine being on the centre, the deceased came in and put his hand on the wheel to assist him to set her off. When he got her off he went round to the engine handles, but before he got there the deceased gave a scream, and on looking round Graham was between the fly-wheel and beam. He then secured the engine and called for assistance. — At this juncture the jury retired and viewed the place where Graham was killed. — On returning, cross-examined by Mr. Bell, witness said that he could get the engine off the centre himself, but sometimes he required assistance. At the time of the accident he could have moved the engine by himself. He never asked the deceased to help him. The door was open, but the deceased came through the window. — By the Coroner: When the deceased was extricated he was on the window side, the side he came in. — John Mourning said that he went to work at six o'clock on the day of the accident. The deceased was keeping the gates. He (witness) was getting some wood when deceased passed him and went in the direction of the engine-house, without saying a word. He shortly afterwards heard a shout proceeding from the engine-house; so Crawford and he, with some others, went to the place, and found Graham flat between the wheel and the side of the pit. They had to shift the wheel by hand to get him. He was about dead. Martin did not assist. He was at the engine. — By Mr. Bell: He did not see whether deceased's clothes were torn. — By Mr. Oswald: Deceased was taken out from the opposite side to which he fell in, to accomplish which they had to take some boards out. — William Crawford stated that he saw deceased examining the ropes between five and six o'clock. He could not say how the accident occurred. The body was lying head towards the pit, and feet towards the engine. He was about mid-way down the pit, and was between the log and the flywheel. He was taken out the side opposite to which he fell in by knocking a few boards away. — By Mr. Bell: He believed deceased had helped to get the engine off the centre before. He (witness) had also often helped. There was not the slightest danger. — By Mr. Moore : If he had known that deceased had gone on the side which he did he would not have allowed it. — By the Coroner: They could not use a crowbar in this particular instance, on account of the brakes on the wheel. — By Mr. Bell: A brake could not be put on the drum instead of the wheel in this particular engine. The deceased could not see the engineman pulling the wheel whilst standing on the surface. — James Martin re-called, and cross-examined by Mr. Bell, said that the deceased could see him pulling at the wheel whilst standing on the surface. He could not see the flywheel, but only him pulling. — Crawford, re-examined, said he wished to correct the former statement. He thought deceased could see the engineman pulling at the wheel, but not the wheel itself. — By Mr. Moore: The engine sometimes got on the centre. It was customary in such cases to get a man. If there was any about to assist. He had himself often assisted in getting the engine off the centre. He considered that there was not the slightest danger. — The Coroner, in summing up, said it appeared that Tom Graham was a banksman at No. 6 pit, the property of the Cleator Iron Ore Company. The deceased went to work on the Saturday morning at six o'clock. Several men had been lowered into the pit. When one or two men were obtaining wood, whilst doing so the engine got on the centre, and the engineman was unable to lower or raise his cages. The man finding that his cages were stuck did his duty in trying to get them free. Whilst doing so the deceased came to the window, doubtless knowing that the engine had got on the centre, and without saying a word he got through the window and stood on a piece of wood, and began to assist the engineman in moving the fly-wheel. They managed to get the flywheel to move, when the engineman left the wheel to go to the handle for the purpose of controlling the wheel. Whilst moving in the direction of the handles he heard a scream. On looking round he saw the deceased had disappeared. He called out for assistance, and went to the handles. Assistance came immediately, and it was found that deceased was in the fly-wheel pit, crushed between the side of the fly-wheel and the timber which lined the side. They had some extraordinary evidence as to the way in which the fly-wheel was moving. If the engineman could be believed, the wheel was moving in such a direction that the deceased would have been carried with it , and jammed between the bar of the fending and the fly-wheel; but Instead of that the man fell down between the wheel and the side of the pit. It might be that the engineman was confused when assisted, so that he could not remember which way the wheel was revolving. He did not think, however, that it would make much difference to the jury in arriving at the verdict. The deceased was entirely a volunteer. He was not asked to give any assistance. If he knew that the engineman required assistance he ought not to have gone into the dangerous place that he did. It must have been a dangerous place because Crawford, the overman said that if he had known deceased to go in that particular spot, he would have told him that he had no business there. It was the duty of the engineman in charge to see that no unauthorised person should be there. But he might have omitted what was his duty, because at the moment deceased came in he had just got the engine working. Rule 35 said, "The engineman must not allow any unauthorised person to go into the engine-house and meddle with the engine." He thought the rule was rather undefined. It would have been better if the words had been somewhat different. Say, "No other persons other than certain other persons or person authorised by the manager, shall enter such house." Continuing he said the rule as it was at present said no unauthorised person should interfere with the engine. The deceased had interfered, and if the jury considered that he was unauthorised, he did what was wrong in entering. — The jury then returned a verdict of "Accidental death".
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||