|
22nd May 1890 The Late Mining Fatalities At CleatorThe adjourned inquiry into the cause of death of John Cullender, aged 58, residing at Roper street, Wath Brow, Cleator Moor, and W. Irving aged 18, residing at 16, Church street, Egremont, who were killed in the Glebe Mines, Cleator, May 12, was resumed on Tuesday afternoon in the Wheat Sheaf Hotel, Egremont, by Mr. H. J. Whiteside, Mr. J. T. Anderson, solicitor appeared on behalf of the widow of Cullender and Mr. Nelson for the Mining Company. Mr. J. Vivian as chairman of the Company was also present. — Henry Pickering, who was the first witness called, said that he was a miner, and worked in the Glebe Pit, but not in the same workings as the deceased. He heard John Cullender shout when the lump fell, but did not hear Irving. He shouted where he expected the deceased lay, but got no answer. He then went for assistance, and got David Bell, a miner to help him. A man named John Jenkinson was first with the deceased. Both Cullender and Irving were dead when extricated. There was a large lump on Cullender, who was in a standing position. Irving was lying with his face downwards. If anybody had been in the working at the time of the accident they could not have rescued them. The piece of stone, which fell upon them, was about four feet long. Assistance was given ten minutes after the first shout. The two men were about one yard apart when extricated. The working place had been inspected that morning by R. Wilkinson. He knew Wilkinson was there by his voice, but he could not make out what was said, as he was about 40 or 50 yards off. He was aware Cullender had been ordered to take the stone down which had killed him. Cullender had told him at "bait" time that "Robert Wilkinson had told him to take the stone down." Those were the exact words, which Cullender said to him. When the men were killed they were not taking the stone down. W. Irving was filling a bogie. He didn't know what Cullender was doing. Cross-examined by Mr. Nelson: he knew that Cullender had fired two shots that morning. He could not say at what time the first one was fired. The second was fired about ten minutes after "bait" time. Ten minutes or a quarter of an hour would elapse between the shot and the fall. The last lime he saw the deceased Cullender was boring a hole. He was boring beneath the very stone, which came down. That was not the proper way to bring it down. He could not bring it down by boring a hole. The second hole was bored after the manager had been round. Wilkinson came round on the morning of the accident just after they had started. He did not know whether Wilkinson had examined their working before he went in. He (Pickering) was in the working where Cullender was killed on the Saturday previous to the accident, when the roof on being tested sounded very bad. In reply to a juryman, witness said that he did not see Cullender from "bait" time until he was killed. He heard him boring. Cullender and Irving had started to work when Wilkinson came in to their working. That was about seven o'clock. — In reply to Mr. Irving, the farther of the deceased lad, witness said that he did not know whether Wilkinson made it a practice of going down the mine before the men commenced work. He was aware that Cullender had asked whether to prop the stone or pull it down. He received instructions to pull it down. He thought the piece could have been taken down without firing a hole. Witness admitted that Cullender had told him that Wilkinson had given him orders not to make a second hole, but to take the stone down right away. Cross-examined by Mr. Oswald: He could not say whether Wilkinson had told Cullender to bore the first hole. Cullender did not tell him. — Cross-examined by Mr. Anderson: He thought that Cullender had always been in the habit of obeying orders. Robert Wilkinson was next examined; he said that he was the overman at Glebe Pit. He had inspected the working that morning at a quarter to seven. He had had some talk with Cullender on Saturday in the working respecting the stone. Cullender said the stone was very bad, and asked whether he should prop it or take it down. He (witness) said, "Take it down by all means. "Cullender, in response, said that he would do so. There was very little said on Saturday. His orders to Cullender were that he should undermine it and shoot it down. He thought that one shot put into the stone would have fetched it down. He passed the place twice that morning, but never spoke to the deceased. He pointed out a hole for Cullender to bore, at a quarter to seven. There had been one fired near there, but he couldn't say where the second was. As far as he knew, the man Cullender had bored the hole where he had told him. He never gave him instructions to fire a second shot. Where they had been found, some ore was lying about; it might have been brought down by a second shot. In reply to Mr. Nelson: The deceased need never have gone under the bad stone. The place he had pointed out was beyond the stone, and if he had gone where he was told he would have been on the backside. If the first shot had not taken effect, he should have gone beyond. He had cautioned Cullender no to allow anyone to go under it, or go under it himself. — In reply to Mr. Anderson: Cullender was just in the act of commencing to work when he went into the working. If he had known that Irving was working in that place he should have considered it no safe. He (witness) had the greatest faith in Cullender being responsible for Irving. — James Marshall said that he was a duty qualified medical practitioner. On the day named he was called by telephone to the Glebe Pit. He got there a little after twelve o'clock. He arrived before the men were brought to the pit top. Cullender's injuries consisted in one of his feet being nearly severed from the leg, and the other was a compound fracture. There was also a slight scratch over the forehead. There were no other external injuries that he could see. He was inclined to think that death was caused owing to being crushed. A weight upon his chest would have prevented him from breathing, or there might have been abdominal injuries. Irving had his skull fractured, and his left thigh was broken. He was quite dead. — In reply to a question, Mr. Wilkinson said that after a shot was fired men went back about five minutes after; but if the smoke bothered them they would stay away perhaps ten or fifteen minutes. — Mr. Oswald: And sometimes they rush in directly the shot is fired, and sometimes before it went off. (Laughter.) — John Jenkinson deposed that he assisted in getting the bodies out. He did not know how the accident occurred. — The Coroner then summed up, remarking that the facts laid in a small compass. They depended entirely upon the evidence, which the foreman, Robert Wilkinson, had given them at the inquiry. His evidence appeared to be straightforward. From the plans it appeared that there was a piece of limestone in the roof. Some conversation took place between the foreman and Cullender, on the Saturday previous to the accident, as to that piece of stone. From the evidence it seemed that Cullender had asked if he had to take it down, and he received the command "to take it down by all means," and they had heard that Wilkinson had warned him to be very particular, and allow no one to be in — "he had to undermine it and shoot it down." It appeared that the deceased man Cullender had gone into the working on Monday morning, and had bored a hole for the purpose of bring it down. That however had not been effective. It seemed clear that a second shot had been fired, and the question arose. Was Cullender doing right in firing that second shot? According to Wilkinson, there was no necessity to fire the second shot. What he ought to have done was what was called dressing the roof. From the geographical position the second shot might have been done in a different way to what had been. If the deceased man had obeyed the orders given him, it was clear the accident would never have happened. — Mr. Anderson said Wilkinson gave no other instructions than about firing of the first shot. — The Coroner said there was no evidence that any orders were given to fire a second shot, and if Cullender had done what Wilkinson had told him — to fire the first shot, and then dress the roof — the accident would not have occurred, but it was clear beyond all doubt Cullender had fired a second shot, and the result of which was that the roof had fallen down and killed the two men. If they thought, under the circumstances, that there was any blame to be attached to Wilkinson for his orders to the men, the jury must say so, but if they thought, on the other hand, that Cullender, without being told, and at his own risk, had fired the second shot, and brought the roof down, they ought in fairness to say that Wilkinson was in no way to blame for the deaths of these two men. Mr. Anderson: There is the defective state of the workings on Saturday. — The Coroner said it did not greatly matter. — After a short deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death".
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||