|
27th February 1890 The Late Mining Accident At Cleator MoorThe Adjourned Inquest ResumedThe adjourned inquiry into the case of the death of John James Oates, which was opened on Monday, February 10th, at Stirling's Hospital, Jacktrees road, was resumed yesterday (Wednesday) morning, Mr. J. Webster acting as coroner. As representing Mr. Stirling, Mr. L. T. Helder was present. Mr. Oswald (mines inspector) was also present. — Mr. Burns wanted to know if it was legal that Mr. Jenkins (manager) and Mr. Johnstone (overman) should stay in the room. — The Coroner thought it was desirable that anyone that might be affected by the evidence ought to have an opportunity of hearing it, in order that he might put any question to the witness, and elicit anything that might be favourable, or might require explanation on his behalf; and if he was put out it would not be fair for him to be treated in that way. As for Mr. Jenkins, I don't think it would be wise to exclude him, as he was the manager, and he would no doubt be anxious to hear the evidence. If there was any reason to keep them out he would order them out. — Mr. Doyle: if they sat down behind the witnesses they would perhaps forget that they were there. (laughter) — E. Watson, re-examined by Mr. Oswald, said that he held the candle for a part of the time, but he went out for about 15 minutes, and gave the light to Oates, who held it afterwards. He did not notice any cracks where they were working. He did not examine for any distance around. On the day before the accident, he saw one of the overmen in the working place. He thought it was Bawden. He could not say whether he saw Bawden examine it. But did not think he did. He thought he saw one of the overmen in the working place on the Tuesday before the accident. He never at any time saw any official go up the ladder and examine the roof of No. 4 working, but he had sounded the roof for both of the overmen, and in the overmen's presence. He could not remember any particular day on which he sounded the roof for the overmen. He thought Johnstone examined the roof by means of a tonite light in the week in which the accident occurred. The ladders were sufficiently long for the roof to be examined, but the footing of the ladder was so steep that there was a difficulty in examining the stone that fell. They were not getting ore on that day by contract. They were working shift work. — Patrick Foy was next examined by Mr. Oswald. He thought if a proper examination had taken place it would have been seen whether the place was safe or not. Bawden, when he examined the roof on the Wednesday, would be 18 or 20 feet from the place where the metal fell. He could not say whether at that distance he could see whether the piece of metal that fell was dangerous. — By Mr. Helder: There had not been any change in the roof since the previous Wednesday until the time that the accident occurred that he was aware of. — John Atkinson was next examined by the Inspector. The piece of metal that fell on the 6th instant was not sounded. The place where they were working was sounded. They sounded all round the place where they were working. The place where the piece of metal fell they could not get a ladder to, because there was a lead footing for the ladder. The piece of metal fell in their working place. — Joseph Johnston was next called, and said he was an overman employed by Mr. John Stirling in No. 5 pit, and resided in Montreal street, Cleator Moor. The special rules then produced applied to Mr. John Stirling's No. 5 pit. The rules where placed on the surface where the men ride down the pit. — Cross-examined by Mr. Helder: He had been overman at No. 5 pit nearly 20 years. He inspected the working places in the pit once a day, either by himself or the deputy, Richard Bawden. He then produced the report book giving the result of his inspection of the working places, and also Bawden's inspection. His last inspection of No. 4 working in No. 5 pit was Tuesday, the 4th February. The following is a copy of his entry which he had entered in the report book:— "I have examined Nos. 5 and 12 pits, and find all the roads and working places safe to work in." On Tuesday he took tonite down the pit for the purpose of taking a special inspection of No. 4 working. He placed several lights, about five, one after another, and he was quite satisfied that the working place was safe on that day. He put the lights in different parts of the working. The roof of the working place was strong ore. There were no sill partings or backs in the roof. There was a fall ten days or a fortnight before. He did not on that occasion use a hammer. He did not consider it necessary always to sound the roof or sides. Rule 2 was here read, and witnesses said it was his usual practice to see that the place was all properly timbered for the men, and likewise to see there was plenty of timber ready for them, examining the roadways to see if they are all safe. He also questioned the men to ascertain from them if the roof was safe, and sometimes asked them to sound it with a hammer. He could see the place from his inspection on Tuesday. If there had been anything wrong on that day with the roof he thought he would have observed it. There were ladders in the workings, sufficiently long to reach the roof. A ladder could not have been put up to the place from where the metal fell, because there was no footing to put the ladder on, and there was nothing to bear it against either. It was five years since a fatal accident occurred in any of the mines under his charge. He had charge of four pits, in which work above 100 men and boys. — By the Inspector: The accident occurred in Oates's working place, but at a considerable distance, where they were getting metal. The men were not getting metal that day. They were on shift work, removing the stones from off the metal. He would not have prevented the deceased man going to the place where the accident occurred. Some times he examined the roof by means of a hammer to satisfy himself that the roofs were sound. He did this when he had any suspicion that the ground was giving way or if it be ground on which a crush is going on in. This plan of sounding was a more reliable plan than by looking at the roof with a candle or light. If an examination had taken place on one day and the place was found sound, he did not consider it necessary to examine it on the following day to ascertain if it was sound by means of hammer, and he would say if the ore was good and sounded he would not sound for perhaps twelve months. He was of opinion that when the deceased was removing the stone on the top of the metal he may have partly displaced the large piece of stone, which was lying against the piece of metal that fell. He also said the piece of metal may have been struck when the large piece of stone fell against it. He thought the piece of stone fell about the 25th of January last. If this was so, had the piece of metal been sounded with a hammer he thought, it would have sounded drummy: but it could not have easily been got out. He knew rule 24 required miners to see the roofs of the working places which were under their care, were safe. — Richard Bawden said he resided at Montreal street, and was an under overman in Mr. Stirling's employ, and had been in this employ for 19 years. It was his duty to daily inspect the working places under his charge. The practice of the overman and himself was to examine each working place on alternative days. He examined the working place, No. 4 working of No. 5 pit, on the Wednesday before the accident to Oates, and he made the following entry: "I have examined No. 5 and 12 pits and found all the roads and working places were safe." He did not use a hammer to the roof. It was impossible to get to the place where the metal fell on to Oates, with a ladder, on account of their being not able to get a place on which to foot the ladder. — Cross-examined by the Inspector: By working with two men for a day and a half a footing might perhaps have been made, but even after that, it might have been a difficult matter to get a heading for the ladder. — A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||