|
20th February 1890 The Late Mining Fatality At Cleator MoorThe adjourned inquiry into the cause or causes of the death of John James Oates was resumed at Stirling's Hospital in Jacktrees road, Cleator Moor, last Tuesday morning, Mr. J. Webster acting as coroner. The first witness called was Edward Watson, who said: I am a miner in the employ of Mr. J Sterling. I went to work at six o'clock in No. 4 working in No. 5 pit on Thursday, the 6th of February. The deceased went into the working with me. The deceased commenced to take down some loose stone off some metal, which had been shot down before. I was standing looking at him until he got the stone down, when apiece of metal fell from the roof and struck Oates. Johnston and Bawden were the overmen in the pit. I have never seen the rules of the pit. There were rules placed in the working, but I never read them. I could not say whether they were any at the pithead. I could not say if any overman had examined the working before I went into work. I think not. I had been working in it for four weeks before the accident occurred. I can't say whether it was the practice of the overmen to examine No. 4 working before I went to work. I was always on the day shift, but have seen them in No. 4 examining, one or other of them every day. We used to hold lights for them to examine. Here witness corrected his first statement and said the first thing they did when they went into the workings was to examine it with a light and nothing more. We were using dynamite, but I don't think we fired any shots on the 4th or 5th of February. There is only a morning shift. There were five people in the top working, J. J. Oates, Patrick Foy, John Atkinson, F. Corkhill, and myself. On the previous day we were taking out some loose stones. We were getting paid for it by the day, and not by quantity. We didn't make any use of dynamite on the 5th nor the 4th. We had not used it since the Monday previous. The weight of metal that came away was six or seven hundredweight, and if they had examined it properly they would have found it "drummy," and if I had known it to be "drummy" I would not have worked there, and I would have tried to prevent deceased from working there. I think if it had been carefully examined by the overman it would have been found to be "drummy." I am quite aware that the working places in mines are liable to alter, and therefore it was necessary that a careful supervision should be exercised. The inspection by the overman and deputy-overman generally took place after the men commenced work. It would be from 7 to 8.30 that the examination by the overman took place. It was either Tuesday or Wednesday morning that they held a light for Johnstone, who stood at the bottom and looked on but did not sound the roof. The roof was sounded on the Monday before the accident by Oates, Foy, and myself. We examined it by placing ladders and sounding with hammers. When the metal fell from the roof it hit Oates it seems on the arm, and knocked him down. We went and picked him up and got him up the pit. He was sensible all the time. He only complained of his injuries, the pain, and he did not find fault with anyone. I never knew of any metal to fall from that spot before. Patrick Foy was next examined and said: I am a miner in the employ of Mr. J. Stirling. I went to work on Thursday, the 6th of February, with the deceased and some others. We went into the working and we examined it with lighting poles, and I sounded the roof with a hammer very nearly all over in the presence of the last witness. Witness here corrected this statement and said: I now say- I can't say whether Watson was present when I sounded the roof. I know John Oates was present, for he was holding the light. I am a practical miner of 15 years' experience. I could detect a piece of metal when it was "drummy." I don't think I sounded that piece of metal. The metal was a piece of blue metal weighing about 4 or 5 hundredweight. If I sounded it with a hammer I think I would have found it to be "drummy." Johnstone and Bawden were the overmen and were experienced men, and had even more experience than myself. I did not see them that morning. The last time I saw them was the day before the accident. I saw Bawden in No. 4 he was examining and taking time, and he asked if the working was all right. That is all he did to my recollection. Johnstone was in on the Tuesday previous to the accident. He examined No.4 by viewing it all over, but he did not sound with a hammer. I can't say who was there on the Monday, but one was there every day. I think Bowden was there on the Monday. He examined the same as they do every day. They looked round the place and asked if it was safe, and if they reported that it was safe they did nothing more. During the Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday preceding the accident they did not go up the ladder to sound the roof to my knowledge. We were not using dynamite for some time back. He never heard deceased complain. He was conscious to the last. Cross examined by Mr. Johstone: I can't say whether it was the Monday before the accident or the Monday before that, that Mr. Johnstone examined No. 4 working place all over. He lit two lights and examined the roof all over. I can't say whether he sounded it with a hammer. I can't recollect. — John Atkinson said: I am a miner in Mr. Stirling's employ. I went to work on the 6th of February in No. 4 working of No. 5 pit. The first thing they did was examine it with a pole and a light on the end of it. Edward Watson held the pole, and Watson afterwards gave it to Oates to hold, and Foy sounded the roof with the hammer. The overman never examined or sounded it with a hammer. I am of opinion if it had been sounded it would have been found "dummy." The metal came from the stone and had a "smit back". Fredrick Corkhill said: I arrived about ten minutes before the other men in the working place, but I saw one of the men put a candle on to the stick for the purpose of examining the working place. The roof was examined by means of this candle. I was in the working place from the time when the candle was fixed until the accident occurred, and I did not see Foy make any sounding. If he had done so I think I would have seen him, but he was in the working before me. In any case it would take half an hour to examine the working place. The Coroner then said, as the evidence evidently did not tally one with another he would move another adjournment to hear what the Government Inspector had to say. The inquiry was accordingly adjourned to Wednesday, the 26th inst.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||