




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
2nd January 1890
Fatal Accident In The Ginns
On Monday afternoon, an inquest was held by Mr. Falcon, the coroner for West Cumberland, at Mr. Peter Kelly's, Miners' Arms, Ginns, touching the death of Patrick Welsh, miner, Newhouses. Mr. Dobson was chosen foreman of the
jury. — Rose Ann Welsh said she was a daughter of the deceased, and resided at 47, Backrow, Newhouses. The deceased was 58 years of age. She had been living with him, and worked for him. He had been in poor health, and had been unable to
work for about four years. He had rheumatics and weakness. Dr. Irwin had been attending him off and on during that period. Witness remembered the day before Christmas Day. Witness went down the street about eight o'clock at night, and left her
father in the kitchen. She came in again at eleven o'clock. Her father was then abed, in the kitchen. She saw him. He was asleep, and she did not bother him. Matthew Welsh, the man who lived with them, was in the kitchen. He had been at work and
was perfectly sober — he had never touched drink. He was sitting at the fire. Witness spoke to Welsh, who said her father was in bed. He didn't say anything further about him. He said he had been out and had been brought to the door, but be didn't
think he was any worse. Witness did not look to see whether there was anything wrong with her father. She slept in the same room with her father. She sat by the fire for about half-an-hour before she went to bed. She went and looked at him, and she
thought he was unconscious from the injury he had received. She spoke to him, but he made no reply. She went to bed. At four o'clock in the morning she was wakened by hearing her father fall on the floor. There was only one bed in the room. Witness was
in the same bed with her father, who laid on the side next the fireplace. He had moved over to try to get out of bed, and had fallen. He did not speak. Witness got out of bed and picked him up. His head had struck a little fender in front of the
fire-grate. Witness shouted upstairs to Matthew Welsh to come and help her to lift him into bed. The two of them lifted him in. He was cut on the right side of his head, and was bleeding. Witness looked at him, and did not think he was so bad, and so
they left him till morning. Witness went for the doctor the first time between ten and eleven o'clock in the morning, to the best of her belief. The doctor was out, and she went for Dr. Harris. She went a second time for Dr. Irwin, when it would
be getting on to twelve o'clock. When Dr. Harris got to their house, Dr. Irwin had been there and left. Dr. Irwin left word that a powder had to be sent for to the surgery, but she was so much put out of the way that she forgot about it. She was not told
about the powder until it was too late, about four o'clock. She did not go for that powder at all. She thought the powder would do another day. She thought a powder was a queer medicine for an old man. She was not told about the powder until between
eight and nine o'clock, when it was too late to go to the surgery; and the reason she did go for it was because she thought it was too late at night. She never went for the powder at all, she was that much put about. Dr. Irwin was not there on Thursday,
and witness did not go to the surgery. The doctor came on the Friday, about half-past nine on the Friday night, her father died. He left word then that a powder was to be sent for, and a neighbour woman went for it. Her, father was a sober man, who was
not in the habit of coming in the worse of liquor. That did not make her think on the Christmas Eve that his condition was extraordinary. He was very feeble on his feet. — John McClurry, 49, Middle Row, Newhouses, collier, said he had known
the deceased for 40 years. On Tuesday night, about nine o'clock, he was coming to the Miners' Arms, and saw the deceased lying snoring on the middle of the street, not five yards from the door of the Miners' Arms. Two other men came up. Witness lifted
deceased up into a sitting position. He was bleeding from a wound on the left side of the head. Could not say whether it was a big wound. Deceased never spoke. He was not very smart at best: he was doating. The other two men helped witness to take
deceased to his house. The old missus was the only one in. Matthew Welsh, the nephew, came in from work just after they had got to the door, and helped them to take him in, and they put him on the settle. Witness told Matthew the condition he had
found him in. Witness then left. Deceased had a milk tin which had rolled away. Witness had never seen deceased drunk. Could not tell whether deceased had any drink in him at the time. Did not know how long the man had lain there. It was a busy
thoroughfare, and be could not have lain long without somebody seeing him. — Wm. Smith said he lived on Middle Row, Newhouses. He came up when the last witness found the deceased, and helped to carry him home. He corroborated the last
witness. — Annie McNeil said she kept the Dog and Gun Inn, Preston Street. Patrick Welsh was in her house about nine o'clock on Tuesday night. He was a relation of witness's. He asked for a glass of port wine, and she gave him it, and
also gave him 3d and told him to send for a pint of stout with it next day. He was a very feeble man. He was perfectly sober. Witness left the house at a quarter past nine, and deceased had not left then. — Matthew Welsh, collier, who lived
with the deceased, said he came in from work just as the deceased was being brought in, and he helped to put him to bed. That would be about half-past nine. McClurry did not say where he found him, except that he found him. He was not washed that night
by anyone. There was no wound and no blood about his head or face. He could not speak; he was unconscious. After witness got himself washed be put deceased to bed. He undressed him, and put him to bed without any assistance. Witness went to bed about an
hour afterwards. Before he went to bed, Rose Ann Welsh came in, and witness told her that deceased had been brought in by two men. Did not notice anything about his forehead. When witness was called up at four o'clock in the morning there was blood on
the floor and blood on the deceased's forehead. The blood on his forehead wan clotted, and not fresh. When the doctor came next day he left word that a powder should be sent for. Witness told someone, but he did not know who, to go for it. He went to bed
about four o'clock, and did not get up till seven, when it was too late to go. Rose Ann was in when he told them. When he got up at seven o'clock, he inquired whether the powder had been sent for, but they did not tell him. Rose Ann Welsh was in the room
when he asked at seven o'clock whether the powder had been sent for. Dr. Harris's assistant bandaged the deceased's head up. Witness did not think of going for the powder next day, although the man remained unconscious. Witness reported the death to the
police. He did not say a single word about the deceased having been brought home by two men. He told the police that he thought the deceased had taken a stroke when he got out of bed, and fell on the fender. He did not think there was any occasion to
mention what took place on the previous night, though he now believed that deceased died from the injury he received by the fall on Christmas Eve. He would swear that the old man was put to bed, and that he fell on the fender. — Jas. Ross
Irwin, medical officer for the Whitehaven and Preston Quarter district of the Whitehaven Poor Law Union, said be received a message on returning from the Workhouse, and without waiting for dinner he at once hurried up to see the deceased. He was
perfectly unconscious. Found a wound on the left side of the head. It was about an inch in length, but a very contused wound. Witness could not tell whether the skull was fractured. Had heard the evidence of previous witnesses. There was only one wound.
It might have been inflicted by a fall or a blunt instrument. The fender in the house was part of a round wheel. Witness was never told about the man having been brought in unconscious. Witness ordered a powder, and as they did not come for it, he
supposed that the man might be dead. He expected that he would die. The powder was to give him any chance there was of relieving the congestion of the brain. It was probable that he would have died even if the powder had been administered at once. The
man was so completely struck down that witness thought the powder would not have saved him. — Inspector Hope said he received a report of this death at mid-day on Saturday, from Matthew Welsh, who said he had taken a stroke and fell against the
fender. He said not a word about the man having been carried home. It was only by accident that witness ascertained that the deceased was taken home on Christmas Eve. Welsh, when taxed with the latter fact, appeared to say he had forgotten to mention it.
Witness had made every inquiry, and there was no reason to suspect any foul play. — The Coroner, in summing up, said he could not account for the suppression by Rose Ann Welsh and Matthew Welsh of the fact of the deceased having received injury on
Christmas Eve and being brought home insensible, unless they thought that by simply telling of the fall in the house they might escape an inquest. He commented strongly on the neglect that had been shown by these persons in getting medical assistance and
in following the instructions of the doctor after he had attended on the man. There was the grossest neglect on the part of these people; but he could not advise the jury that there was such neglect as to render them criminally liable, for, as the doctor
said, it was highly improbable, indeed it was quite impossible, that any assistance could have saved the man's life. — The jury returned a verdict of accidental death, being of opinion that death resulted from the injury received by the fall in the
street; and they thought Rose Ann and Matthew Welsh should be censured for their careless conduct. — The Coroner had these two persons called into the room, and strongly censured them for their gross neglect.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dobson, — | | Jury Foreman | |
| Falcon, Gordon | | Coroner | |
| Harris, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Irwin, James Ross, Dr. | | Medical Officer | |
| Kelly, Peter | | Innkeeper | |
| McClurry, John | | Miner | |
| McNeil, Annie | | Innkeeper | |
| Smith, William | | | |
| Welsh, Matthew | | Miner | Nephew |
| Welsh, Patrick | 58 | Miner | |
| Welsh, Rose Ann | | | Daughter |
|
|